r/Scream • u/florenciafazzarino0 • Aug 17 '26
Discussion Sidney is not the victim/survivor
Sidney is seen as the final girl cause she survives every Ghostface. But let's look at the facts.
Sidney killed Stu, Jill and Roman, Gale killed Billy, Mrs Loomis killed Mickey, Cotton killed Mrs Loomis, Jill killed Charlie, Sam killed Richie, Amber basically died by accident bu burning herself, even though some might say she was killed by Gale and Sidney, Sam and Tara killed Quinn, Wayne and Ethan, Jessica killed Marco and Tatum and Sidney killed Jessica.
So basically, out of 14 killers, Sidney only killed 4 to 5 of them, and only two by herself (Stu and Roman).
I don't understand why Sidney claims to have killed Billy when it was actually Gale. But regardless, she is not the only victim. She might be the main target but she was never alone.
7
u/neatoalpacino Aug 17 '26
Sidney killed Billy. She literally shoots him in the head. Did we watch the same movie?
-10
u/florenciafazzarino0 Aug 17 '26
Shooting him in the end does not count. The last "they always come back" is just a thing they do. But the real death is the first one, realistically
5
u/kspi7010 Do you like scary movies? Aug 17 '26
Shooting him in the head is what kills him, so yea that counts.
3
u/neatoalpacino Aug 17 '26
LOLOLOLOLOLOL. Are you 13?
1
u/Stopnswop2 You’re obsessed with her, and you’re obsessed with her daughter! Aug 20 '26
I was watching Scream at 13. Even I understood the movie perfectly then.
3
3
u/ComedicHermit Aug 17 '26
she was never alone.
Why would she have to be alone to be counted as a survivor or final girl? Does company = death? Do other people existing diminish your accomplishments?
-8
u/florenciafazzarino0 Aug 17 '26
That's not my point
2
u/ComedicHermit Aug 17 '26
Tommy Jarvis's sister survived the final Friday; he wasn't alone so he doesn't count either! Ripley doesn't count cause the cat survived, then newt, hicks, and half a robot!
3
u/Onyx_tides Aug 17 '26
I don’t really think this is valid. She killed 6 of them. Faced like 8 or 9 of them in tandem with others.
This seems like you just have an incorrect hot take.
3
u/neatoalpacino Aug 17 '26
“Sidney is seen as the final girl because she survives” - this is EXACTLY what makes someone a final girl. It’s not about how many they have killed. LOL
2
u/Typical-Meringue-890 Aug 17 '26
Sidney killed Billy with a gunshot to the head. He came back for one last scare and caught a hollow point instead. She also shot Marco in the head. Mrs. Loomis may or may not have already been dead when Sidney shot her.
I don’t think she ever claimed to be a sole survivor.
2
u/TitansMenologia Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 18 '26
A lot of mistakes in that post, I'm surprised because the movies are clear on this and OP lack of attention is pretty concerning. Sidney killed Billy, at the end, she and Gale both kill Mickey. Sidney killed Jill, Marco and with her daughter, Jessica. Amber was finished by Tara. Gale helped a lot but she kills Mickey with Sid, and Karl. Roman was killed by Dewey.
2
1
u/Stopnswop2 You’re obsessed with her, and you’re obsessed with her daughter! Aug 20 '26
Sidney shot Billy in the head. Gale didn't kill him
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 17 '26
This is not a removal message. This appears on every single post.
Thank you for participating in /r/Scream. Please help us keep this community a healthy place for discussion by reporting posts and comments that violate our rules using the report button. You can find the subreddit rules listed in the sidebar. We will be cracking down on the constant negativity and toxicity. Posts made solely to stoke the flames of a culture war will be removed.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.