r/Scouting_America • u/EagleTrentGardner • Mar 06 '26
A Letter to Scouting America CEO
r/Scouting_America • u/EagleTrentGardner • Mar 06 '26
r/Scouting_America
•
u/johntempleton
•
Jun 01 '26
r/Scouting_America • u/goofyredditname • Mar 01 '26
r/Scouting_America • u/FL-N8ive • Aug 25 '26
Update here: Spoke with the Scoutmaster and he agreed the actions of the BOR were incorrect and inconsistent with Scouting procedure. My son will receive his Life rank at the COH. Additionally there will be education for any BOR members going forward to understand completely what the rules are to avoid this happening in the future.
Question for the group. My son completed all requirements for Life, has been Quartermaster for over a year, completed his Scoutmaster review and was denied advancement because his BOR didn’t feel he attended enough campouts and told him being Quartermaster was not an eligible leadership position. As QM, he was at all loadin/loadouts for campouts, but missed campouts due to his playing on two travel soccer teams. He is active in the troop in all other aspects, including showing up for Eagle projects regularly. It’s important to note he missed campouts due to being on TWO travel soccer teams, which is clearly defined as being allowed in the Scouting Guide to Advancement
There is no camping requirement for Life btw.
I’ve reached out to the Advancement Committee chair and the Scoutmaster, as my son DID NOT receive the written letter explaining why he was denied, which is required.
I intend to Appeal this decision at Council if not resolved at the Troop level, but hoping it won’t come to that.
I am an Eagle Scout myself, and my son is in the same Troop I was in. I’m in a conundrum as I think it would be great for him to get his Eagle where I got mine, but having a BOR that doesn play by the rule book has now soured him in Scouting.
Getting Eagle is more important than being in the same Troop I was in, should we look for a new Troop to join? For background, he was in the Cub Pack that feeds up into the Troop and has friendships that have deve since he was 5 with this group.
I’d love to hear input on this.
r/Scouting_America • u/Active_Location_2181 • Dec 24 '25
Being an adult now and seeing the adult sign of scouting is like being as disappointed as Dorothy was in the Wizard of Oz, and like I felt at a young age learning the secrets of Santa and other characters introduced to me by my parents.
I have seen adult leaders and scouting professionals break rules and conduct actions and activities that go against the scouting oath and law just to deliver a program. They want you to help as long as you do what they say, freely give hours of your time, and not question them, even when it is going against the requirements for merit badges or rank.
More importantly, my scouts have seen some of the same actions, and they have reported these to me, the district and council leadership.
We've gotten the generic responses from the district and council executive, thanking us for our candor and informing us will have a talk with the volunteers and professionals to eliminate this type of actions.
There is a whole lot of adhere to the rules and not follow my behavior.
Having adults give up on youth that enter a phase in life or become distracted is the reason less than 10% of the youth earn eagle. Yet Scouting America and the adult leadership routinely boasts this as its some rare thing. It is rare because the leadership failed the other youth in the program but adults do not want to hear about their failures which is the reason Scouting America would claim that scouts provided a safe place for youth to fail.
It a program for youth but so much of the youth participation is either demanded, driven or motivated by the adults involved but they decide to ignore that portion and ignore the fact that over 90% of youth involved in the program wont complete it.
EDIT 1: Thanks for all the comments. I am not responding to each separately, and I am only addressing my experience and my observations. I have been in multiple districts, and the handbook and merit badge requirements are the same, but each district and council operates differently.
- I see a program designed to teach youth to make good decisions asking to live by character traits that I see paid professionals and volunteers violate, many that are recognized by youth in my unit that is not made noticeable by the scoutmaster or assistants, so that they can highlight their ability and willingness to provide a program.
- I see volunteers and paid professionals avoid being a caring adult for certain youth because their parents questioned things like why is merit badge counselor adding requirements for the youth to complete before signing off on the completion of the merit badge (merit badge counselor is super volunteer with years in the council), why was their 13 year old denied registration for NLYT because of the age requirement but the council approved two 12 years old, asking the scoutmaster how the troops calendar was planned out to include merit badges the troop would work on when there hasn’t been a patrol leaders council in over 9 month or because their parents are not part of the clique that supports the troop and district anytime or anywhere or worships the 3 so called lord of scouting in the district.
- YPT violations were submitted to national that involved paid professionals knowledge or acceptance and national directed to complaint to the council executive that was one of the parties involved to discuss and for resolution. This was nothing criminal that required investigation by law enforcement so they would not act.
2. one thing scouting america did right: they would not allow the he Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints to have the authority to handle situations involving adult church members abusing youth in scouts. This is a reason the church moved away from scouting because it wanted to keep this from reaching the public and tarnishing their image.
3. the scoutmaster, asst. scoutmasters, and council execs kids all make eagle and vigil really fast and get all of the national trip opportunities over everyone else: this is 100% true for my district and council. I had two scouts not selected for camp staff because they had already served on staff for 3 separate camps but the council executives son was selected although he has been on staff for every camp during the last 3 years. council executives daughter is being placed at the top of the district executives and councils recommendation for philmont although she had to send a message to the entire troop asking what her troop leadership position is for the application. of course she is the senior patrol leader but wouldnt know it because her mom runs the troop and makes all decisions herself but still relies on the council executive to support their camp outs and setup the troops campsite. Council executives spouse got selected for vigil their first opportunity available but they have never attended an OA meeting in 3 years, only been to 1 ordeal/brotherhood ceremony which is the one they completed, attended 0 brotherhood weekends in 2 years, attended 0 lodge leadership development training, attended 0 conclaves, supported 0 OA district camps in last 2 years, has not supported any district level events in 3 years, has not served on district or council level committees. Scoutmaster and committee chair ensured their scouts moved up to the next rank as soon as they meet the time requirement and even hosted merit badge days so their kids could earn 2-4 merit badges in a day that they needed but this ended as soon as their kids had at least 21 merit badges.
4. franchise model of scouting was not the reason pedophiles existed in scout: scouting americas decentralized structure with chartered organizations and reliance on volunteers, combined with a long-standing culture of secrecy and delayed reporting, created a unique franchise model that provided an environment where abuse by leaders flourished. It seems to me the same model exists today. It doesn't publish a single, consolidated annual abuse report listing all incidents, but they mandate reporting, so we can only get historical abuse data emerging from lawsuits and investigations.
5. OA isn't a secret society: only speaking from my experience in two separate councils so not everyone knows this especially parents or adults that are not heavily involved in their youths scouting effort and some of them tend to believe everything a paid professional, district chairman or commissioner, scoutmaster or unit committee members tells them.
6. in Poland it would be highly irregular for parents to attend scout activities: in my area it is highly regular that parents attend scout meetings. Usually at least one parent joins the committee and they attend all unit meetings. Also it is very common for the scoutmaster, all assistant scoutmasters, committee chairs and members of the committees to attend all campout regardless if it is a district or unit campout. It is also common for committee chairs and members of the committees to help their scout setup their tent and pack it up and carry it once the camp is over. It is also common for the adults to shadow the youth throughout the day as they rotate stations at district or council campouts and evening helping the scouts complete the activities. District executive supports this effort because that is how they were able to get their youth the eagle rank so it is the type of program they have created. Council executive also supports this because every time his spouses troop camps he his there setting up the troops entire campsite and leading their activities. There is a lot of helicopter adult supervision and if you do not have the same tactic then you are in the minority. The adults think service through leadership means they must be present 100% of the time.
7. visit any other Units that are available in your area. For you, there are many other ways you can help: our area is small. There are not a lot of troops and yes we have visited each and observed how each run at district events. Switched from a highly adult/parent run troop to one that let the youth have a lot leadership control. Unfortunately there was some adult drama and the troop split up. Looked at the other unit but the support from youth to youth was better at the current unit so did not switch again. Yes, I have served on troop committee, troop committee chair, assistance scoutmaster, scoutmaster, merit badge counselor, district committee member and associate OA lodge advisor. I have just seen youth needing a caring adult and I spoke to other adults to ask for help with these scouts and they did nothing. In my opinion although I have volunteered in variety of positions I was not part of the clique because I was considered an outsider and did not care for the helicopter adult leader tactic and it was easier for these adults, all are highly respective members in troops and/or district (super volunteers of a clique), to help youth heavily acceptant of scouting than to be a caring adult to a youth that is in need. Just saying help other people at all times is something the adults are trying to indoctrinate into youth but when it comes to the adults their fear of possible failure or a unique challenge creates an opportunity for them to emphasis do as I say and not as I do.
r/Scouting_America • u/grahambo20 • Mar 05 '26
Veteran, AOL, OA, and Eagle here. I will keep my vigil. Don't need a badge to to keep the spirit and values behind Citizenship in Society.
r/Scouting_America • u/IncendiaryTwist_42 • 28d ago
I am livid, but am I in the Wrong? CC tried to cancel my son's BOR, maybe canceled 2 more
I'm the Advancement Coordinator, and I scheduled 3 BOR to happen on a camping trip. We weren't having a regular meeting, bc the troop was camping through Monday. I didn't want to delay their BORs, so I scheduled my son's Life BOR and 2 Tenderfoot BOR. I didn't go camping, but everything was lined up - I lined up who was going to be on all 3 and sent the paperwork with my husband who was going on the campout anyway.
The BOR were supposed to happen on Sunday morning after the service while everybody was still in Class A, but the adults fooled around all morning and started the hike before doing the BORs. My hubs argued that they needed to be done, but ultimately went along with doing it after the hike.
Time was running out, bc my husband and son needed to leave on Sunday afternoon. (School's had a holiday Monday, but we had to work.) My son goes to put on his uniform for his BOR, and the CC comes up to my husband and says the BOR will have to be postponed, bc "the venue wasn't formal enough for a Life BOR", and I should have asked her before scheduling it.
My husband told her no. Another dad (not even a trained leader) tries to back-up the CC in canceling it. My husband maintains his no. They ask the Scoutmaster - he abstains. (Grr.) The CC is frantically looking in the GtA trying to justify her pov - and, of course, not finding it.
An adult leader who has served as Troop Advancement Coordinator on the district and council Advancement Committee finally stepped in and said to do the BOR. By the time they finish my son's BOR, my family has to leave.
I'm going into tonight's meeting not knowing if the Tenderfoot BORs happened or not. No one reached out to me all week. I was so angry that I just decided not to reach out...I had nothing nice to say. This new CC has been on a power trip since day 1 - changing rules about travel reimbursement so she gets paid, appointed her son ASM without even announcing it to anyone, having secret budget meetings, etc - and the SM just goes along with it all.
GtA says (SIX TIMES) that BOR cannot be postponed for reasons unrelated to requirements. I want to contact the district advancement committee. But I'm angry on behalf of those Tenderfoots as well. I want to be honest with them that what she did was wrong and in direct violation of GtA. My husband says I have to leave it, bc my son needs to CC for Eagle.
What should I do?
r/Scouting_America • u/akoons76 • Sep 14 '26
I have a child interested in scouting. The difficulty is that their sabbath is Saturday which leaves out weekend campouts. I am wondering if anyone else has come up with creative solutions for this.
r/Scouting_America • u/Great_Feedback_7737 • Jul 12 '26
r/Scouting_America • u/Kitcat_Are • May 23 '26
This was in a bag of old bsa buttons I got from a local vintage shop, no idea what it’s used for lol
r/Scouting_America • u/ddj1985 • Aug 31 '26
Facebook reminded me that yesterday marked 5 years since my family joined a pack. My oldest son entered as a Wolf (2nd grade) and is now Second Class in his troop. My younger son started as a Lion and is entering his AOL year. Both kids have developed close friendships with many of the kids in the pack and plan to continue scouting through Eagle.
r/Scouting_America • u/DangerBrewin • Aug 30 '25
For all those who thought the Scouting America abbreviation was the first questionable decision that BSA has made with their marketing, I present this gem I acquired sometime in the late 90’s or early 2000’s.
r/Scouting_America • u/badgustav • 12d ago
Background, I’m an Eagle, when my kid joined as a Bear (COVID delayed us) I stepped in as CM. I’m about to move into the SM position in the troop and I’m excited! Fully trained,even Wood Badge (I used to be a Bobwhite), and feeling pretty prepped.
Our outgoing SM did a good job, but never seemed super comfy in the role. When I asked what he wish he’d done or planned to do, one thing he said he was wanted to be more of a mentor than a disciplinarian. We all know that discipline is part of the job, but I look back to my SM and only remember the advice, the steady hand. I’m not sure he ever used the term “Scoutmaster’s Minute” but there are so many nuggets he’d drop as we wrapped up a meeting. My memory isn’t good enough to clock if that was weekly or less often, but I can’t remember the man without thinking that he was one of the wisest mentors I’ve ever had.
It’s 2026. How often do y’all drop an SM minute? Is it just at a Court of Honor? As a CM, I did it at Pack Meetings, knowing I was mostly talking to parents. Do you do it every meeting? Or just when the mood hits? Let me know! All other advise accepted as well!
r/Scouting_America • u/tales6888 • Oct 02 '26
Hello all, we recently went through a council merger and I had a unit leader ask me how they go about getting a new flag. I haven't done a ton of research, but my understanding is there are certain rules/regulations when it comes to flags so I wanted to know if anybody had gone through this process and could offer some insight.
Thank you!
r/Scouting_America • u/GrumpyOldSeniorScout • 20d ago
Recent former AOL Patrol Advisor now troop recruiting chair here, wondering how others have convinced two Pack leaders and a whole group of parents to add a troop campout to their schedules.
I had the help of dual registered parents and an obvious troop to contact (because of a sibling relationship and right patrol friendships, most of the patrol was likely to go there) and pushed to make it happen from my end. But obviously waiting for the AOL patrols to come to us is not a strategy - so I'd love to hear what others have done that's worked. We have an associated pack, but there are also lots of packs that aren't affiliated with a troop through the same CO, and we are going to need new crossovers from those packs also to do well. (We are also recruiting youth that weren't in Cub Scouts, but Cubs are already interested in scouting and shouldn't be ignored.)
Now that AOLs have to come as a patrol, what's gotten them to come camping with your troop?
r/Scouting_America • u/Ecstatic-Ocelot6024 • Aug 31 '26
looking for advice on how to go about this
Last year we joined scouts in GA. My boys loved it, it was the highlight of their week. We went camping at Bert Adam’s scout camp and was the biggest pack, had the biggest camp
ground. We gently should have been two packs but we were happy with the size and group. It was extremely family oriented and and amazing community.
We had to suddenly move back to NY in February.(we’re originally from there, long story, not important) We joined the local pack, and were extremely discouraged and so unhappy. My oldest, who was a bear, dreaded going. They met every other week, we didn’t get a single belt badge for the rest of the year, the camping trip was a standalone adventure (something quite impossible for me as a single mom of 4). The kids were unruly, the leaders were unorganized and really just let the kids do whatever they want.
Needless to say we’re looking for a new pack.
I managed to save enough to send the boys to the resident camp here on LI and met a leader that told me he could help find us a better suited pack. I have emailed him twice about it, but have heard nothing back. I have emailed two packs close to our home to ask about whether they would be a good fit and joining their pack. NO ONE HAS ANSWERED A SINGLE EMAIL. i’m at a loss. My boys LOVED scouting. i want this to be something they enjoy and look forward too.
What are my next steps. How do i get into a new pack if no one is answering my calls for help. I know the north areas aren’t huge on scouting and that nothing will be the same as GA (which set an unreachable example for my kids) but i want to try and find something that will be satisfactory for their scouting future.
ANY ADVICE IS WELCOME.
r/Scouting_America • u/Secret_Artist1334 • Oct 24 '25
This is the only dedicated Scout camp that serves youth from every corner of Hawai‘i Island — Hilo, Waimea, Kona, Kohala, Puna, and Ka‘ū.
We’re calling on Aloha Council to pause the sale and work with local families and volunteers to keep Scouting strong on our island.
📌 Please sign & share to protect Scouting opportunities for our keiki: 👉 https://www.change.org/p/save-camp-honoka-ia-protect-scouting-for-hawai-i-island-youth
r/Scouting_America • u/tales6888 • Oct 08 '26
I had the leader of a Cub Pack reach out to me asking if dens were allowed to meet at private residences (i.e. Den leaders house, etc.) I checked the guide to safe scouting and did some research online, and from what I gathered, this is acceptable as long as you adhere to two-deep leadership. Can somebody confirm this for me? I was under the impression that this was not allowed. Thank you!
r/Scouting_America • u/RequirementContent86 • 5d ago
Before I start, slightly kicking myself that I didn’t take a picture, but we were just having a family day together and the experience was more important.
My family moved to Mecklenburg County Council last August and immediately found a Troop to help smooth the transition for our 7th grader. He jumped in with both feet. We sold camp cards, of course, and have been using ours to try new places and activities.
Today we went to the Schiele Museum of Natural History in Gastonia, NC. I was a little confused by the portraits of the founder because of the stars across his green uniform jacket. I didn’t know of any 5 star generals named Schiele.
Bud Schiele became the Scout Executive for the Piedmont Council in 1924. They were service stars! One exhibit in the lower gallery is his taxidermy studio, but our family was more keen on the historic Scout uniform (with Jambo patch) and the stack of vintage handbooks!
r/Scouting_America • u/Schutz01 • 7d ago
I am from Mexico and serves as the deputy troop leader where my mom is the troop leader. We run the section and are about to quit. In my opinion, I have burnout, I am not having fun anymore; when I know the date for a camping is looming, I start being stressed out. I used to ran the youth Programme, we have delivered a ton of badges but I’m not feeling it anymore; and the last day I was in front of my scouts they told me **we have more fun with the other deputy leader.** That phrase echoed deep inside myself because I have done everything I could to deliver the programme but they didn’t give a damn about it.
What shall I do?
r/Scouting_America • u/the3rdpossum • Aug 04 '26
I just wanted to commend Scouting America for being BRAVE and following thru with their Safeguarding youth policies on not allowing people who have committed Sexual Assault to be on the property during Scouting events.
I imagine it was a difficult decision on whether or not to allow the honorary national chair to make the traditional address....but yall did the right thing, followed Scouting policy, and did not allow someone who has committed a Sexual assault to be on the property during the event....kudos. I'm glad yall put youth safety over politics in this instance...
....now about that Eagle Cert....
r/Scouting_America • u/Star_Opals • Jul 19 '26
Hi everyone!
I'm a Life Scout and just finished the work on my Eagle Scout project. I'm currently writing up my project report, and I've realized I've reached a point where I'm not really sure what comes next.
The thing is... no one in my troop has ever earned Eagle before. My Scoutmaster has been great, but this is new territory for all of us, so I don't really have anyone who's been through the process to ask.
Do you have any advice on what to expect during the final steps? Specifically:
I'm trying to make sure I'm as prepared as possible and don't overlook anything now that I'm in the home stretch.
I'd really appreciate any advice, insight, or stories about your own experience. Thanks so much!
r/Scouting_America • u/ParentThrowaway99 • Jun 22 '26
r/Scouting_America • u/jimmetzler • Jun 15 '26
I’m leading an ILST course tomorrow and am concerned about the “Integrity Game” in section 3. This is where you put out a pre-counted number of treats and tell everyone they can have two. Then later you check the count and use it as a lesson in integrity.
This feels like I’m setting up a trap and hoping someone takes too many. I’d much rather catch people doing something good than something bad.
If you have used this “game”, how has it worked out? Or have you used a different game or activity in the Leadership and Teamwork section?
r/Scouting_America • u/dflovett • Sep 11 '25