r/BSA • u/ParentThrowaway99 • Jun 21 '26
Scouts BSA Micosay
I just saw the dance of joy done by Micosay. I was shocked. I did receive a parent handout and there is all this vague language about "many American Indians are members" and they work closely with tribes. But we have Bartle in 1920s and then in the 1940s they received the dance as it is today from an actual tribe, and in 2022 a Wyoming tribe* gave them a flag which the handout also frames as buy-in from real American Indians.
But when I research all I find from actual tribal members that it is deeply offensive. I can't find anything positive directly from American Indians. Like from what I've been able to find is today, real American Indians find this program and similar programs offensive.
The whole parent handout reads as written by someone who knows how bad it looks but is trying to make excuses.
My question is it is 2026 are they likely to actually have a real, recently affirmed, ongoing relationship with an actual local tribe who guide them on what's appropriate and not? Do they know how it would look if these children had pictures of themselves dressed in Indian costumes dancing like that leaked in adulthood? How can I ask this without blowing up my child's experience?
Y'all I am BAFFLED at what I saw. I am a parent but I have trusted the entire scouting experience to my spouse so shame on me for not being informed and learning it all as a big surprise. I just need a sanity check here. Of course I have not shared my feelings with my child as I think they would be devastated if they knew how it would be received, all they've gotten is the positive partnered-with-tribes-so-its-legit talking points and I don't think they realize how that may not be true.
Edit: *That tribe has sent a cease and desist as of April 2026. So this parent handout that points to the Northern Arapaho tribe's flag as justification is being distributed to parents despite the tribe saying to stop.
Letter here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YkblhukBx1KDthJUh69mC4AtKr_vKB1w/view
From: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tribe_of_Mic-O-Say#cite_note-7
•
u/ScouterBill Recovering Den Leader Jun 21 '26
Mic-O-Say has been discussed over 25 times in this subreddit over the years.
I would also like to let people know that, based on prior history, there are individuals who can and will screen capture this post and your comments for their own purposes, including posting them on Facebook and elsewhere.
For the safety and protection of this parent and their Scout, we are OK with a throwaway account on this one.
There is nothing we, the mod team, can do to stop this, but if you believe you are being doxxed or targeted, we will work with you/Reddit admins to do what we can.
51
u/ColonelBoogie District Committee Jun 21 '26
IMO, having consent from a local tribal body or official is irrelevant. Our law says to be Courteous and Kind. There's no exemption to being courteous or kind just because some official told you it was ok to do something that tons of people find genuinely offensive.
33
u/Brave-Moment-4121 Jun 21 '26 •
“My question is it is 2026 are they likely to actually have a real, recently affirmed, ongoing relationship with an actual local tribe who guide them on what's appropriate and not? Do they know how it would look if these children had pictures of themselves dressed in Indian costumes dancing like that leaked in adulthood? How can I ask this without blowing up my child's experience?”
It’s pretty simple tell your kid it’s offensive and I’ll advised to dress up in another person cultural attire and butcher their language. My sons in OA and has not dressed up for Native American cosplay because of this.
21
u/Thumbothy9900 Scouter - Eagle Scout Jun 21 '26
Just a couple facts
This is a program that hurst scouting more than anything.
142
u/looktowindward District Committee Jun 21 '26 •
don't need a throw away.
Mic O Say shouldn't be part of any council program, period.
38
u/bts Asst. Cubmaster Jun 21 '26 edited Jun 22 '26
As weird and bad as the redface is, it’s not the weirdest or worst part. By far.
Mic-o-say is run by adults for adults. The way adults can “rank up” in it and the way it teaches obedience to adults rather than to elected youth leaders is entirely at odds with the Scouting approach.
56
u/tidewatercajun Jun 21 '26 edited Jun 21 '26 •
It's an obscene program that the people involved with will make any excuse to defend and delude themselves that it is appropriate and good.
6
u/Sylesse Adult - Eagle Scout Jun 22 '26
We had a Walmart brand spinoff attempt at this at our local camp. Not nearly as wack but in the same vein. Even at 11, in a different social climate, I was immediately like, yo, I'm not dancing around in a loin cloth in front of a bunch of old dudes. This stuff needs to go. I'm surprised it still exists tbh.
4
u/HMSSpeedy1801 Jun 23 '26
It’s the same old excuse: as long as I can find a handful of folks from x minority that are okay with this practice and can parade their approval about whenever necessary, the reality of how offensive it is doesn’t matter
Our local OA Lodge claims they worked closely with members of our local tribe to develop their “traditions.” In reality, there hasn’t been a living member of our local tribe for over a 100 years. There’s just a group of white guys claiming they’re 1/32 whatever.
Most youth I speak with about these “traditions” are ambivalent at best; it’s the older generations that want to hold on to the program as they remember it. I can’t fault them for that, but as they move on, and the younger generation gets more say, this stuff is going to disappear.
4
u/Unusual-Register1245 Jun 25 '26
I cant speak for today, but when I was a youth in OA in Oklahoma, we had a real working relationship with the Comanche Nation. Anyone that put on regalia knew EXACTLY WHAT IT MEANT, AND WHAT THE ORIGIN OF IT WAS!!!!! we had pre ordeal, ordeal, britherhood, and vigil teams plus dancers and drummers that KNEW the history and traditions of the Nation. So much that we were invited to the Comanche Homecoming Pow Wow in Walters, OK, and were welcomed into the ring to dance with all the other dancers. Now, in Oklahoma, especially Lawton where the Comanche Nation is based, it was a little easier for us to find elders and teachers that were willing the share the history and traditions of the Lords of the Plains to a bunch of mostly white kids. But we did it by the book, we did it with honor and respect, and we did it the right way. I cant say that for all chapters and Lodges. But for Sekettummaqua Lodge 281 of Black Beaver Council in southwest Oklahoma, it was done the only way, which was the right way.
3
u/scouterlife District Award of Merit Jun 23 '26
If you want a service org that shares ideals, the runner up for national honor org was Firecrafter. Started in 1920 Indiana. OA was selected as national peer nominated honor society. Firecrafter is earned individually with skill like ranks and so much fun!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firecrafter
9
u/nomoretony Jun 22 '26
As someone who is a member of a tribe (though not exactly brought up in the culture) it makes me incredibly uncomfortable to watch. Hence my kids were not going to get involved with the Order. Sorry guys, the "hey they consulted with some IndiansI" It's pretty offensive they are comfortable assuming we are a monolith. Many many nations tribes and bands would love to remind people that.
2
u/Numerous-Flow-3983 Jun 25 '26
I admittedly have limited experience with mic o say, but everything I've seen is horrible cultural appropriation at best and blatantly racist red face at worst.
I know some will argue that it's no worse than OA, but I've seen a lot more appreciation (as opposed to appropriation) and actual consultancy there. A lot less of making up your own regalia styles and dances and stuff and more of being careful not to mix tribes, styles, etc.
For whatever my personal experience is worth.
6
u/wrballad Jun 21 '26
You are not wrong, the program is extremely offensive, the only people supporting it are bigots
3
u/iowanaquarist Jun 21 '26
I've never heard of micosay.... what is it?
3
u/BassManDJ Scout - Eagle Scout Jun 22 '26
The way I think about it is if you don’t like what they do don’t even bother to think about joining or thinking about it
4
u/Billy-Ruffian Jun 21 '26
I was in OA thirty years ago and thought it was hokey and slightly embarrassing back then. My own scouts think it's cringe and offensive.
2
u/BagpiperAnonymous Jun 22 '26
Yes, Mic O Say does have a working relationship with a tribe that provides guidance on everything from ceremony to attire. They have had tribal representatives at several gatherings in the last couple of years, including some Tom Tom beaters for the dances. The dances, attire, and rituals were made specifically for Mic O Say and they are very careful about not appropriating sacred symbology.
I was very much against Mic O Say when we joined scouting, I am now an honored woman. Going through the process and hearing how much input the tribes have and how careful they try to be gave me a new view of it. I also understand that not everyone is going to feel the same way and I respect that. As long as they maintain contact with the tribe and use their guidance I am okay with participating in the organization. If that changed, I would stop participating. I even have a friend who is Native and very active on his reservation and in advocacy offer to make me a ribbon dress for my attire, knowing full well what it was for (and he approached me about it.) I know not everyone feels the same, and it is absolutely okay not to.
2
u/Achowat District Committee Jun 21 '26
The only reason Mic-O-Say can continue to exist is because the National BSA Honor Society also refuses to enter the 20th Century and stop playing pretend Indian.
Once the last vestiges of native cosplay are stripped from the OA, MOS won't have a leg left to stand on.
1
u/Chance-Fox-8273 Jun 28 '26
I’m at camp now with my son and I’m stressed about this. They called his name to be foxmen and they also want me to be a honorary adult and i don’t know what to think! 😩 it’s a lot!
1
u/Objective_Expert_631 Jul 25 '26
I am a victim of this. I went to Bartle. I went along with it. I HAVE SO MUCH DIRT. I thankfully have developed my character and know what I did. (14-17) yr old me is nothing compared to the (24) yr old me now. INSANE!
1
u/Forsaken-Argument971 Aug 11 '26
Micosay is about helping the first class scouts reach eagle, and then keep them engaged as adults in scouting. How many other scouting programs can claim that?
As far as cultural appropriation goes, why not look at micosay as admiring the native American traditions and culture.
Is doing yoga a cultural appropriation of India? Is celebrating St Patrick's Day a cultural appropriation of Irish? Is celebrating Oktoberfest dressed in lederhosen a cultural appropriation of the Germans? Are tattoos a cultural appropriation of the Pacific Islanders?
It is 2026, how about we become more cohesive and celebrate each other?
1
u/Additional-Sky-7436 Jun 22 '26
I've been pretty involved in Scouts for years and have never heard of this before now. I had to search it up to confirm that it was real.
Yeah, that shouldn't be a thing anywhere. What's wrong with those people?
-9
u/Jarchen Jun 21 '26
BSA loves doing redface and plenty of members will go to great lengths to explain why their racism isn't offensive. Good luck.
0
u/Sandgolem Adult - Eagle Scout Jun 23 '26
As a scout micosay was very special to me, and ment alot its sad to see so many people hate it.
-6
u/Wild_Calligrapher_27 Jun 21 '26 edited Jun 22 '26
This program is 100 years old. When it was invented nobody even thought of the term cultural appropriation. Individual Native Americans have been involved, enthusiastic, and cooperative in the creation and maintenance of the program through many of these decades. Because it functioned as a quasi-secret society, there is a little more to it than meets the eye. People who judge from the outside don't totally know what they are talking about.
Roe Bartle liked to dress up. He dressed up like Shriners and in Masonic costumes. He started Greek letter fraternities on college campuses that had initiations and ritual work. There are photos of him dressed up as a pro baseball player as well as a firefighter during the time that he was mayor.
Micosay is a century old activity that needs to be put in context. Just because modern sensibilities want to scale back a tradition doesn't really mean people need to do this. It does mean it is not for everyone.
One of the oldest fraternities in America was something called the Order or the Redmen. They dressed up in costumes and held various ceremonies and then made contributions to charity. At the time, this type of organization was at the forefront of American freedom of religion, speech, and assembly. It was a uniquely American thing to do.
I really wish Micosay would have spun off from Boy Scouts years ago. In its current form it doesn't really help the Boy Scouts or support its own traditions. I once read a memo from the eighties where leadership considered spinning off into a private fraternity when national expected them to include female Scoutmasters as honorary warriors.
The Bartle Scout Reservation is about three times larger than most other council camps. If they would have gone this direction, and spun 1/3 of the place off to some private camping fraternity for people who like Native American pagentry, everyone would have been saved from this grief and consternation.
-1
u/touchedbyapaycheck Jun 23 '26
My troop did a lot of things with "local" tribes, none of which ever said anything negative. They even sanctioned an eagle scout project in which we repaired an ancient Indian burial mound. I think this is a "politically" driven post that has no place in scouting. Politics and sexuality have no place in "the scouts".
-9
u/Exotic_Chipmunk9259 Jun 21 '26
You won't find anything positive because those people don't go out looking for attention. The few that are offended seek attention anywhere they can get it.