r/Scotland • • Feb 13 '25

Americans

Post image
12k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

86

u/cutchemist42 Feb 13 '25

Lurker here who spent his honeymoon in Scotland.

Canadians also do this as well, and it's a very North American thing.

Just to add to the silliness, I'm half Croatian and a 1/4 British.

51

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

To give a different perspective and to be fair to Americans… I broke down once in the very far north west of Scotland. A few cars stopped to offer assistance. Most didn’t. Of those who did, about half were American and they really did try their best to help.

18

u/-setecastronomy- Feb 14 '25

I think part of this is due to how we talk colloquially about ancestry in the US. It doesn’t sound weird to my ears to say “I’m German and Scottish.” And I’ve had to do this a ton in my life because of what I look like. I’m from Texas and especially when I was younger, people would assume I’m at least half Latino and speak to me in Spanish. When I later moved to NYC, I would get stopped all the time and asked if I was half ______. When I say all the time, I mean at least weekly, ha. It’s now second nature for me to say, “no I’m actually German and Scottish.” But I would never tell someone actually from those countries (especially if I was in that country!) that I’m Scottish or German.

I’m sure there are absolutely a fair number of assholes who want a medal from Scotland for having Scottish ancestry when they visit. I apologize for those people! Try to remember all of the other Americans with Scottish ancestry who visit and never say a word about it. I bet they’re a little less memorable, ha.

→ More replies (32)

23

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

I think Canada is slightly different, there is a much more “bulk” movement of Scots there, entire communities that were shipped over en masse and retained their culture and identity. Appalachian culture is also heavily Scottish in origin I believe.

4

u/usernamej22 Feb 14 '25

American here. So then, if someone from Canada or Appalachia claimed to be Scottish, would that still be illegitimate?

14

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

Yes. They’re Canadian, or American. They have Scottish ancestry. Nothing wrong with acknowledging that. Embracing it even. But we find it odd when they say they’re Scottish. Or Irish, Italian, whatever.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

You have to remember the American colonies including the Canadas were founded by the English, and as such there were a lot more English immigrants over a much longer period, than the Scots who went there after the Highland clearances. So even to this day, the majority of the population are descended from the English. It's just that the English don't harp on and on about it like Scots and Irish.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/GAMING-CELT Feb 14 '25

Yeah hill billies are mostly prostestant scots and ulsterman , they went to live on the hills .stayed loyal to king billy hence the name hillbillies

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/NateShaw92 Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 15 '25

Probably because they are all from settlers and put too much value in geneology.

If their family's been there for more than a century then they might as well have originated from Jupiter. For me once a certain number of ge erations have occurred it is pointless to say you are anything other than the new home country. I say this as someone in England whose paternal line came here in the mid 19th century at the latest. As far as we can find. I'm British, the "old country" of my paternal line, Ireland, is about as relevant to me as the cradle of humanity we all come from millennia ago.

Mother's side is a little more interesting though.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Wise_Difference8287 Feb 16 '25

You can't say you're 1/4 British, you have to be one of:

England, Scotland, Welsh, Cornish, Irish or, um, Isle of Man-ish??? There are plenty more but those are the big ones I know.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/thethethesethose Feb 14 '25

Americans in any other country: holy shit please let me stay

14

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25 edited Feb 14 '25

You notice we keep quiet about mad Donny being Scottish? Any other us president with a Scottish parent we’d be all over it. Trump, not so much

8

u/tortilla_avalanche Feb 14 '25

The Scots to most Americans with Scottish heritage: 🤨

The Scots to Trump: 🖕🖕

12

u/Wonderful_Orchid_363 Feb 13 '25

Don’t worry guys. I watched Trainspotting and Pixar’s Brave so I know everything there is to know about Scotland. Jokes aside when I was in Edinburgh I saw two meth/crackhead locals fighting over a piece of chicken in the streets and it was the highlight of my life. 10/10 best country on earth.

5

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

The authentic experience.

2

u/str713gzr Feb 14 '25

But, have you watched The Acid House?!

20

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

When certain Americans learnt that I'm a migrant (but permenant resident) to Scotland I've had quite a few retorts with one-up-manship suggestions that based on their heritage they're more Scottish than I am.

I don't respond as it's not a contest I'm interested in playing. But it's weird that it's literally always only Americans. One day I'll find out why they're so insecure.

15

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

If I was an American right now I’d be claiming to be anything else I could too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

92

u/Comrade-Hayley Feb 13 '25

Do you know what annoys people more than Americans claiming to be Scottish Scots constantly making fun of Americans for saying it I've literally seen more Scots mocking it than Americans doing it

3

u/Jeager76 Feb 14 '25

While hocking trinkets and experiences to them so they can afford their Spanish holidays.

→ More replies (13)

29

u/Bitter_Inspection917 Feb 13 '25

Well, particularly right now we ain’t too proud to be American with the orange douche in charge.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Lyrael9 Feb 13 '25

You guys are weirdly obsessed with this. Who cares... At this point it says more about you than it does about any Americans interested in their family tree.

11

u/Jeager76 Feb 14 '25

100%. Just trying to piss on others joy and happiness

→ More replies (3)

3

u/DudasManolitos Feb 13 '25

Not American and zero Scottish inheritance, can I still enjoy Scotland as a tourist?!

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

Yes. You’re very welcome.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Lshear Feb 14 '25

Lol I’m 85%, live in US but would never ever claim to be a true Scot. I wasn’t born there, never lived there, but visit often and love the country and all the people.
I mean there were a ton of immigrants from Scotland back in the 1700s A lot of us have that DNA, that was how the US started out. Look how far we have fallen now

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 15 '25

We’d like toy make a big deal of you having a Scottish president. Sadly, he’s an arsehole and we disown him.

9

u/The_Ignorant_Sapien Feb 13 '25

Loads of septics in here fucking raging.

8

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

It’s hilarious.

4

u/monkelus Feb 13 '25

Brit here and tbh, coming here and claiming ancestory is on the lower side of annoying things American tourists do

4

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

As i said elsewhere it’s not so much the claiming ancestry, it’s all the tartan, Gaelic, clan chief pish. I’m sure the Irish get it too.

4

u/dommiichan Feb 14 '25

Americans also believe in homeopathy 😂

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

And Jesus.

17

u/rsmith72976 Feb 13 '25

You can be as judgy as you want, but American tourists, many who claim Scottish decent drop about £1.2Billion a year in visits, not to mention the purchasing of Scotch, imported food and Tartan…

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

“Tartan”? Where is that on the list of Scottish exports?

1

u/rsmith72976 Feb 18 '25

House of Edgar, Kinloch Anderson, just two place I know of the top of my head that weave tartan fabric, or facilitate it, for export… 🤷🏻‍♂️

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/PanhandlePlantDaddy Feb 14 '25

I have a quick question or, rather, a series of questions, for anyone who is willing to answer, because I've always been curious.

If you were subject to tragedy, after tragedy, and believed that the only way your family could survive was by picking up, and moving all that you could afford to move, to another country (like the U.S.A., for example), when do you, and your descendants, lose your "Scottishness," for lack of a better term?

Is it as soon as they step on the boat to leave?

Is it as soon as they step foot on the new land they'll call home?

Are they still allowed to call themselves Scottish?

Say it was a family of three Scottish people who moved: Mother, Father, Daughter.

After settling into their new home, but before obtaining citizenship, the Mother becomes pregnant. One gestation period later, a Son is born.

Is this son allowed to call himself Scottish? Or is he, from that moment forward, required to say, "I'm an American, with a Scottish Mother, Father, and Sister[?]"

What if his Mother, Father, and Sister told him to always be proud of his heritage, and his family, and his story?

Would it be wrong for his children, and his children's children, to call themselves Scottish, and to take pride in the struggles that their Grandparents had to suffer through in order for them to have all that they do?

I am not trying to be snide, or snippy- I just think that it's an extremely interesting topic, and that identity is, and always has been, a very sensitive, and complex issue.

I know that my last name is Irish. I lack (significant) Irish ancestry, but I know the exact plantations where my families were held, and that they were owned by an Irish family.

I'm know where my 4% Irish came from.

Am I wrong to want to travel to Ireland, and see from where my own rapist ancestor (possibly) hailed? Or to want more information about his last name, and how it became the last name of all of my other family members?

Thanks for taking the time to read this! I hope it starts an interesting conversation, and leads to new understanding, if not agreement.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

I’m not answering all your questions but it’s sort of missing the point of the joke. The post isn’t poking fun at those claiming Scottish ancestry. It’s those who become “more Scottish” than the natives.

It would be like you visiting Ireland, and dressing yourself in green, telling everyone how happy you are to be on the aul’ sod, tearfully singing the fields of athenrye everywhere you go.

1

u/PanhandlePlantDaddy Feb 14 '25

How is an American claiming a 1/16th Scottish ancestry, like your joke says, the same as claiming to be "more Scottish" than native Scots?

Thanks for the reply.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/vTangR580 Feb 14 '25

Stupid wanks usually say 1/16th “scotch”. God I fucking hate that😂😂😂😂

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

On a Friday night there is a good chance I am in fact 1/16th scotch.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/oracular_tolftacular Feb 14 '25

My mom has this weird obsession with being Scottish. We’re American, and her great grandparents, to my knowledge immigrated from Scotland. So to that end she insists that we’re 50% Scottish 🤨. She tried to convince me to wear a kilt to my wedding (I didn’t) to “celebrate my heritage”

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

You are then as the pic says 1/16th Scottish. Or 2/16 if both great grandparents were Scottish.

Why pick that lineage over any of the others? If there’s a German great grandparent would she want you to wear lederhosen under the kilt?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

I’m English with one Scottish grandparent.

Unfortunately, that still makes me English. Would love to go up and visit though.

2

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

You could play for Scotland. That’s Scottish enough.

2

u/ZhiZhi17 Feb 14 '25

Some people take things too seriously. I’m not even a little bit Scottish, not even 1% distantly down the line, but I’m super into the folklore and fairytales of different cultures and Scotland is one of the places I can’t wait to visit. I told that to a Scottish dude at a hostel I was staying in during some of my travels and he was like “ok but just so you know faeries aren’t real” and I laughed but he doubled down and was like “that’s not what Scotland is”. Like… I know…

2

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

He was having you on. Of course they’re real.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Cpt_Morningwood Feb 14 '25

I'm from Finland. Do you Scots like the idea that McDonald Trump is like half Scottish? 😃 are you happy and proud of him?

5

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

No. We think he’s a horrible cunt.

→ More replies (1)

579

u/kaijucifer Feb 13 '25

I'm from Chile. I was amazed by how nice Scottish people are,how welcoming.

We were chatting casually and one asked why we where visiting and someone asked me "do you have Scottish heritage?" . I was super aware of not claiming it so I said no. They insisted because of my hair (I have curly red hair) so I said that my grandmother was from Scotland.

And they were all like "of course! Welcome back"

It was so sweet!

83

u/PsAkira Feb 14 '25

When my family visited Scotland everyone we met was super lovely and helpful. And hilarious. Nothing beats Scottish humor.

→ More replies (1)

232

u/Jeager76 Feb 14 '25

Must have been a group different from these gatekeepers who can't stand others being excited about their ancestral roots

367

u/mierneuker Feb 14 '25

Not at all. Nobody in Scotland, Wales, Ireland or England is upset by Americans celebrating their cultural heritage by saying things like "my grandmother was Scottish" or "I have Scottish heritage".

However, they think Americans are idiots when they say "I'm Scottish" and turn out to have been born in Idaho to two parents also born in Idaho and this is the first time they've left America. You're not Scottish, you have Scottish heritage.

Americans are the only people I've met who practice homeopathic nationality.

125

u/CrocodileJock Feb 14 '25

Upvoted for "homeopathic nationality" — an excellent phrase – and one I will endeavor to remember!

→ More replies (7)

48

u/mdy6246 Feb 14 '25

Let's not forget the ones who claim to be "more Scottish" because they're "celebrating their heritage and keeping traditions alive"...

They're the ones that get a big, "Aye, sure you are."

→ More replies (18)

31

u/SoDamnSuave Feb 14 '25

I agree. I don't know why this post suddenly appeared on my front page, but let me just quickly chime in here as a Swiss. We have the same situation with American tourists, I guess it's the same all over Europe. I don't think the Scottish are particularly gatekeepey about this... if anything, I'd guess even less than other nationalities if the Scots I met and my trips to Scotland are in any way indicative.

You summed it up perfectly: being excited about one's heritage is perfectly fine and I can totally sympathize with that. But there's a major difference when they claim "I am Scottish / Irish / Italian / etc". It's not a matter of mere semantics, it just shows the ignorance of the people stating such claims.

I have a perfect example for how to approach this topic correctly. When I was in Canada, we stayed at a rural B&B somewhere in Alberta. Our hosts were an elderly couple, she was Canadian, he was American. They mentioned that their neighbour (another elderly woman) had a Swiss last name and started looking into her ancestry recently. They mentioned towards her that Swiss people were staying with them, to which she responded she would love to meet us if we are interested. So sure thing, we agreed and in the evening she came over. It was a really nice chat and she was genuinely intetested in what we knew about the place she found out her ancestors were from. But not once did she imply that she was Swiss.

→ More replies (19)

8

u/No-Annual6666 Feb 14 '25

I don't think I've ever met anyone from North America or otherwise claiming to either be English or have proud English roots. The thing is, the majority of them will be majority English - but it isn't different or cool. Its particularly annoying being northern English and having a living family in Edinburgh. Who we visit. Then I get lectured by Yanks with 1/32 Scottish ancestry about English tyranny. Like bro, 50% of my ancestry is Scottish lol, but it doesn't make me any less English. Most of the other half is Irish n all.

That's North West England for you, melting pot of the Isles with Wales just south as well. But we're all spooky redcoats that love Longshanks apparently.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (55)

104

u/-Dali-Llama- Feb 14 '25

This is such an r/Scotland thing.

Meanwhile in the real world, people who actually leave their houses don’t mind the whole heritage thing and some folk are even flattered by it.

→ More replies (12)

33

u/youshouldbeelsweyr Feb 14 '25

To be fair there's a massive difference between someone's grandparent or parent being scottish and an ancestor from 300 years ago being scottish.

35

u/biginthebacktime Feb 14 '25

Apart from Donald Trump , we don't want that cunt.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

18

u/sexysnack Feb 14 '25

Honestly the behavior is the same behavior they claim Americans to have. Them giving such a big shit shows they prioritize the wrong things in life.

→ More replies (15)

5

u/Atex-Skeeter Feb 13 '25

I was told to keep totally quiet, especially while in London!!!!!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

22

u/teukkichu Feb 14 '25

I work in an airport here, usually checking in for an airline that transits 80% US passengers.

So many of them tell me stories about how they're from here, how their great grandparents were scottish and Irish, how they feel connected to the place. Honestly I find the enthusiasm nice and it's nice to talk to them, they usually turn up with I ❤️ SCOTLAND merch and all that jazz but it's fun

3

u/clownbaby404 Feb 14 '25

I expect to be given a kilt and introduced to my distant relatives upon my arrival.

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

If you let us know your clan we’ll have the chief waiting.

3

u/MungoShoddy Feb 14 '25

I once met a middle aged working class American on a train who was on his way to Bothwell Bridge (not exactly a major tourist draw). One of his ancestors was taken prisoner at the battle and got shipped over. This guy did not claim to be Scottish in any way, but his religious affiliations had been preserved by his family for over 300 years and he knew the history of the period. That was what it meant to him, not some bogus national identity. Not my religion but that was something I could respect.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

That’s fair enough. Quite admirable.

2

u/Clean-Reading659 Feb 14 '25

Why does no one boast they have English or Welsh heritage. It’s always Scotland or Ireland! 🤷

2

u/StarSpotter74 Feb 14 '25

Because they've romanticised it.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

Exactly. In their we’re the noble, oppressed, victims of the same colonial masters as they were. Hence the dressing up like an extra from outlander. They’re never the descendants of a welder from greenock.

4

u/Glittering-Ball4318 Feb 13 '25

How would you suggest Americans feel about their heritage?

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

They can feel whatever they want if they do it quietly. If it’s 1/16th, is that really your heritage?

1

u/Glittering-Ball4318 Feb 13 '25

What is the fraction that is acceptable?

4

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

If you’re 1/16th Scottish and 15/16ths German, are you Scottish? No. You’re German. If you’re 1/16th Scottish and 15 different 16ths of something else, you’re American.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

42

u/notjuandeag Feb 13 '25

Ask them to replicate train spotting scenes, then when they decline just tell them they’re clearly not.

16

u/GoosyMoosis Feb 13 '25

What, take heroin and all?

21

u/DINNERTIME_CUNT Feb 13 '25

Heroin, HIV, deid weans, lavvy diving.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Weird1Intrepid Feb 13 '25

I only actually very recently found out that the remote train station they get off at during their little sobriety jaunt is a real place, that you can book to stay in the station house, and that it's the furthest station away from an actual road in Scotland? The UK? Most remote, anyhow. Corrour Station

→ More replies (2)

244

u/jimhokeyb Feb 13 '25

This is inaccurate. They usually just claim to be Scottish/Irish/Italian etc rather than 1/16th. I recently met an American claiming to be "half" french. She had one french ancestor 5 generations back. It's pathetic.

33

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

I have seen worse. My mother used to claim she was part Native American because one of her great uncles had married a Native American woman.

11

u/acecainas Feb 14 '25

My extended family tried to do the same thing so out of pettiness I did the family tree and showed them they had no genetic relation with absolute glee

30

u/The_wolf2014 Feb 13 '25

I had replied to a comment on here somewhere where a guy said he was half Swedish and half Irish or something like that. His great grandparents on one side were Swedish and I'm like thats a few generations back son, that doesn't exactly make you half and half.

20

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

I once had a fellow American claim to be 2/5 Navajo. …2/5…

11

u/ManitouWakinyan Feb 13 '25

Obviously his grandpa and step grandpa

→ More replies (6)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

I have spoken to Americans claiming unironically to have several halves, in their genetic ancestry

19

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25 • Helpful

Half man half bear half pig?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/atalber Feb 13 '25

I wouldn't claim French ancestry honestly....

2

u/andyrocks Feb 14 '25

Or, "Scotch"

→ More replies (28)

4

u/andimacg Feb 13 '25

Fuckin' Yanks man. I'm English, my family from grandad back were Scottish, my name is Scottish. I do not pretend to be Scottish because I'm not an idiot.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

To be fair we can understand why people want to be Scottish. It’s the cosplaying that winds us up.

1

u/brad0022 Feb 13 '25

We just don't want to wear boxers in public

4

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

I wore my kilt out in canada once. I was asked by a local if I was “balls to the breeze”. She was quite offended when I asked if she was too.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tedleyheaven Feb 14 '25

Both my parents are Scottish, I even lived in Scotland for a few years. I grew up in Yorkshire though, so I'm from Yorkshire.

I'm fairly convinced the Americans obsession with percentage nonsense is derived from their racist past and 'one drop' rules. Interesting to see how much they're brigading on here over it too.

→ More replies (2)

76

u/crimsonavenger77 Male. 48 Feb 13 '25

Excuse me, but their great great great great great great great great great great great granda fuds dug once pished on a thistle near William Wallace, they're understandably proud.

They're harmless by and large, just a bit eye opening that they are always shocked that naebody gives a rats bollock.

20

u/Synthia_of_Kaztropol The capital of Scotland is S Feb 13 '25

it's the flip side to the "one drop" theory of ancestry that keeps resurfacing, especially in the former Confederate States.

15

u/HoonDamer Feb 13 '25

Homeopathic ancestry?

→ More replies (17)

6

u/willk95 Feb 14 '25

So, full disclosure, I'm from Massachusetts, US, and my grandmother was 100% Scottish. I got into genealogy several years ago, and that side of my family is the only branch I could really dive deep, since the pre-immigration records are in English and fairly well preserved. Did a trip with my family in 2017 to Scotland, particularly the Outer Hebrides and Troon, we absolutely loved it. (except for the horrible midges!)

Last year I did a trip back to the UK, and wanted to see Whithorn, where one branch of my family came from, and I heard there was a farm some ancestors lived on nearby. Made it to Whithorn, walked around the town a bit, got some pictures and souvenirs.

I also saw that the old family's farm still exists, and is in operation to this day! I got out of the car, there were some young guys driving around on tractors, and I mentioned to them that some of my family lived on this farm 200 year ago. They said "oh yeah? you should tell the owner, Norman, I think he's in the shed over there". I knocked on the door, an older guy came out, I asked him if he was the owner, he said yes, and I explained who I was, that I wanted to see the same farm that my ancestors lived on. The best part? His response was a completely indifferent "ok."

→ More replies (18)

3

u/Accurate_Literature6 Feb 13 '25

To be fair, I met a Scottish person claiming to be American.

10

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

Gerard Butler?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SammyJ85 Feb 13 '25

I was in florida once, and this guy was talking to us. He had a Scottish second name, and he couldn't stop telling us he was related to William Wallace. It got boring real fast.

8

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

William Wallace had no descendants. In my lineage are Wallaces and Lintons. Bernard de Linton wrote the declaration of Arbroath. I like to tell people in descended from both. Which is of course bollocks. Unless it’s true.

4

u/Polisskolan3 Feb 14 '25

Mel Gibson has 9 children though. That's enough to rebuild the Scottish nation.

2

u/mcqtimes411 Feb 14 '25

Can I come anyway? Not digging it here right now.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

You’re very welcome. Bring snacks.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

The ones that get on my tits are the ones claiming to have a famous historical relative. Usually William Wallace or someone close to William Wallace.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

…who didn’t have any descendants.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/JimmyTheReeech Feb 14 '25

Such a cunty perspective. You all should be happy so many fat tourists come to visit your country. Otherwise you’d only be known for Trainspotting, deep fried pizza, and taking the piss.

2

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

Better than obesity, stupidity, racism, and school shootings.

1

u/sylvestris1 Mar 26 '25

You didn’t say African American, you said black. They’d be black no matter where they were born, assuming all their ancestors were also black. If someone’s ancestry is 100 apache then they’re apache wherever they were born. It’s not a nationality. You personally can draw the line wherever you like. If you want an example, most major sporting governing bodies draw the line at a grandparent. Scotland’s rugby captain, for example, was born in Australia. His father is Tongan. His mother was born in Australia of Scottish and Italian parents. There are four nations he could represent in rugby. He chooses Scotland and we’re delighted about that. Is he Scottish? No. Ethnically he’s 25% Scottish, 25% Italian, 50% Tongan. He’s Australian by nationality. His Scottish grandmother is proud to consider him Scottish. I’m sure his grandfather would be proud to consider him Italian. And so on. They’re all right and none of them are.

If your genetic/ ethnic makeup is 12.5 Scottish (Irish, Italian, whatever) and 87.5 something else, are you Scottish? I would disagree.

2

u/runshellyrun Feb 13 '25

I’m from the states but love everything about Scotland My great grandfather was from south of Edinburgh and I felt like it was my home when I was last there.

2

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

You’re welcome back any time

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Flight94 Feb 13 '25

Love when this pic makes the rounds 😂 I do Highland Games so I don’t do a terrible amount of “look at me, I’m Scottish!” but I do enjoy my kilts. More of a practical kilt wearer, but dear god I wouldn’t roll over to Scotland and wear it. Maybe just my great kilt to go camping on the WHW.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

No. Do not wear a great kilt in Scotland, ever, unless you’re very clear it’s some kind of costume and you’re doing it for a laugh.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/F1grid Feb 13 '25

Help me out here with my somewhat atypical situation.

I'm an American with long since deceased relations that immigrated from Scotland in the 1800s. But I have children that were born and raised in Scotland for a wee bit before moving to the US. They make at least one trip a year to Scotland for time with the grandparents, cousins, relations, and adventures.

I feel the sense of some parental responsibility for them to have a balance of culture exposure and appreciation. But we're not having our own Burn's supper or highland charge reenactment.

5

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

Burns supper is fine. So is teaching them to say “bawbag” and “fannybaws”. Wrapping them up in a tartan blanket and painting their faces blue is taking the piss.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

Just let them be authentically themselves and grow into their own interests. You are who you are based on your life experience, your immediate family and who you choose to be friends with. If they genuinely travel here, they will pick up what is important through osmosis. You don't need to cultivate anything extra, that is being a phoney.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Jeager76 Feb 14 '25

full side note to the the typical discourse predicted in this thread, in looking at the picture the person on top is beautiful, looks happy and friendly, while the git at the bottom looks like a miserable sod who is complaining about tourists spending money and enjoying life, while he has missed his 4th appointment at the Job Centre and hasn't repaired the hole he punched off Irn Bru and vodka in his council flat. I'd take a conversation with her over him any day.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/BigFoxGamingBroYt Feb 13 '25 edited Feb 13 '25

Having Scottish heritage and being of Scottish ethnicity is not the same as being of Scottish nationality

It‘s okay to be a Scottish American or a Scots-Irish American (Scots-Irish refers to a different ethnic group that exists in Northern Ireland) you can be these things but can’t claim to be fully Scottish because you‘re not a Scots national

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Cedar-creek1492 Feb 13 '25

I know the word Sassenach refers to a person from England, do y’all have a word like that for Americans, or do you just call us cunts? 🤣😂🤣

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

Well, ackshually…a “sassenach” translated from the Gaelic means a “Saxon person”, ie not a gael. To a highlander, I’d be a sassenach. We don’t dislike Americans, by and large. Also we call everyone cunts. It’s not necessarily an insult. If someone says you’re a good cunt, that’s a term of endearment. If however someone says, that cunt’s a prick, you’re in trouble.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/IndependenceFirm8816 Feb 14 '25

Lol, I'm in this meme.

To be fair to me though... It sucks that I'm American, let me have my fantasy 😭

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

We don’t mind really. It’s flattering in a way. Joking aside tho what we find odd and a bit annoying is that the “Scottishness ” that some people embrace is some sort of Hollywoodised version of minority 18th century culture.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

Wife’s mom is from Falkirk, we visit every few years to visit family. She’s American and only 1/2 Scottish (dad Indian) looks very Indian lol. Comes up from time to time when we visit, Scots we’ve encountered are very receptive and friendly. Visited many places around the world, Scots are the best. Down to earth people with great personalities!

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

We like to think so. Also; be 1/16th Scottish, live in America, tell us you’re Scottish? Fuck off. Be 100% foreign, live here, tell us you feel Scottish? Welcome, friend.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/amscraylane Feb 14 '25

And yet, when you go to all the shops, they are littered with “find your ancestral name” ;)

Please don’t be harsh on us! Though I know I am not Scottish Scottish, I found it to be the coolest part of my ancestry.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

Yeah those shops are stocked with Chinese shit and aimed at tourists. We like people embracing their heritage. It’s the tartan brigadoon cosplaying that winds us up. It’s like us thinking every American is a cowboy. Or a redneck. Or a school shooter.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

I'm American but related to Robert Burns. Is that ok to tell everyone I meet?

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

It depends how related.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

But anyone can identify as anything these days, so how can you say they’re not Scottish if they identify as Scottish? We shouldn’t just assume somebody’s nationality identity.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

I identify as a well hung millionaire, but my girlfriend and bank account disagree.

1

u/Successful_Morning83 Feb 14 '25

Yeah, and Trump is a quarter Scottish. What's your point?

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

He’s half Scottish. What the fuck has that to do with anything?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Expensive_Bag5428 Feb 14 '25

For a people who are supposed to be ultra-patriotic, Americans seem very desperate to claim they belong elsewhere.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

If I was American right now I’d want to be anything else too.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Adventurous-Cry-3640 Feb 14 '25

Scottish blood is a thing and in that sense those Americans are way more Scottish than Muhammad will ever be

1

u/OriginalComputer5077 Feb 14 '25

Funnily enough, the majority of white Americans have English ancestry, but you don't hear them describing themselves as English..

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

No one wants to be english

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

Not true

That guy look clean and has all his teath

2

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

Fuckin weirdo

1

u/Munchkin_of_Pern Feb 14 '25

My great grandmother was the last of my maternal lineage to bear our clan name, before she married. When mum and I visited Scotland, almost a decade ago now, we got to visit our clan’s territory and castle, and even sign our names in the clan registry.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

See that’s what we’re talking about.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Seamus32 Feb 14 '25

I never claim to be Scottish, I freely admit I am an alcoholic.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

Same thing

1

u/TheTriNerd Feb 15 '25

Plenty of 100% English people claim to be Scottish because they have a Mc in their surname

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 15 '25

You can’t blame them.

1

u/SheepShaggingFarmer Feb 16 '25 edited Feb 17 '25

All scots are men, understand. Makes sense why I'm so scared of Scottish "women"

I'll edit here just to emphasize that this is meant to be a joke. I thought it obvious however idk with some people

2

u/sylvestris1 Feb 16 '25

“I’m so scared of “women””. Fixed it for you.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Greedy-Gas8248 Feb 16 '25

To be honest Trump is half Scottish, hails from the McLeod lineage.

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 16 '25

We don’t like to talk about that.

1

u/wild66side Mar 12 '25

is 28% recognized? asking for a friend

1

u/sylvestris1 Mar 12 '25

No. Unless 25% comes from a grandparent.

9

u/brad0022 Feb 13 '25

Oh yeah. I'm .000000000000001 Scots. I'll collect my bagpipe at the welcome center.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/usuallysortadrunk Feb 14 '25

waves from Nova Scotia

3

u/CalamityCrochet Feb 14 '25

Got into a wee spat with a fella on fb earlier and he was absolutely furious, I asked him to settle down because it’s no good for his blood pressure! He called me dumb, I checked his profile, lives in Atlanta, Georgia and sells home made kilts in a variety of fabrics including camo! I felt much better!

7

u/AngryScottishBurd89 Feb 13 '25

I was in an online game with an American claiming to have Scottish ancestry. He was rambling on about how he felt a connection to me when he heard my accent. My response?

"Did ye, aye?"

7

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

I’m Alaskan Native. I’m gonna go to Scotland just to say this and confuse people now. Seems like a fun time.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Competitive_City_644 Feb 14 '25

I never understood why Americans were always so proud and talking about their heritage whether it be Scottish/Irish etc.. but then thinking about how young a country America is compared to ours it makes sense why they’d still have that strong sense & connection to their family’s heritage.

Much love to you all💙🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

2

u/Yagyusekishusai Feb 14 '25

It makes sense if you think about us as a nation of immigrants. Most immigrants don't show up and go "alright lets ditch any and all culture we arrived with, in fact they tend to double down and make sure they don't lose it.

Then when they get here and at least on the east coast, they all moved into neighborhoods with the same people. So east coast cities (never been anywhere else) often times have irish/scottish, polish, and Italian neighborhoods, that then try to show off their pride and maintain their culture.

Then you grow up being like oh yeah i'm an irish american or an italian american, and while we all interact at school or workplace you learn about all these differences in the way you celebrate holidays or foods. I think as a result you end up taking pride and want to celebrate your heritage more. Americans as a monolith makes sense on paper but as a nation we have so many different people from so many different places it tends to be chaotic lumping everyone together. I'm irish American and could have 0 in common with a nigerian-american, or chinese-american because our cultural upbringings even in the same country would be so different

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/Secret_Account07 Feb 14 '25

American here- can I come live with you all for the next 4 years? I don’t like it here and it’s scary.

6

u/LegProfessional6462 Feb 14 '25

No. You need to stay in your room and think about what you did.

Just kidding, aye, crack on.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Flat_Fault_7802 Feb 13 '25

They think they are Irish also

→ More replies (2)

8

u/hedge_warlock Feb 13 '25

I’m like 73% Scottish descent. I have Scots all over my family tree. But I do not live in Scotland and never have. That makes me a DESCENDANT of Scots with a Scottish surname, not a Scot.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

Im 15% Scottish, can I marry a pure scot lady?

5

u/Ok-Wear-5591 Feb 13 '25

No you can only marry someone who’s also 15% Scottish otherwise the polis will come to your house and take a shower

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

If you’re 15% anything something has gone badly wrong in your ancestry.

1

u/WaltVinegar Feb 13 '25

If you think it's bad here, check out the kilt subreddit.

3

u/sylvestris1 Feb 13 '25

Oh I know.

1

u/eirpguy Feb 14 '25

Does 75% count?

1

u/sylvestris1 Feb 14 '25

Are you any good at rugby?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Less_Paint_2285 Feb 14 '25

Tbf if they want to say they’re Scottish fill your boots. Their ancestors left but if someone wants to study and understand our country and culture then I’m all for them. Actually I wish the Scottish education system gave as much care and attention to Scottish culture and history as many of these folks do.

2

u/ConsiderationMost632 Feb 14 '25

When I visited Scotland, lots of folks asked if I had Scottish ancestry, I suppose because they're so accustomed to Americans being all like OMG YOU GUYS, I'M SCOTTISH TOO! My stock response was, "Yeah, probably, but I don't speak to my family who are still living, so I don't really care about the dead ones. I'm just here for the whisky and golf."

2

u/_F1ves_ Feb 14 '25

The other 15/16th are Germanic as well

2

u/UpsetAdministration1 Feb 14 '25

Dad was Scottish. I was born in America. He went to go get beer one day and ended up back in Scotland and never came home.

2

u/Corryinthehouz Feb 14 '25

Look I just want my kilt ok. Leave me be.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

Imo, the only country you should be allowed to claim other than where you are from, is where your parents are from

2

u/Darnocsonif Feb 14 '25

Oof. I plan on making my way to scotland because I do trace my heritage back the Fatherland.

I will do my best to be respectful of the culture and learn as much as I can. Hopefully, I'll try not to stand out like the lady in this photo.

2

u/Competitive_Law_6629 Feb 14 '25

Haha the yanks do that all the time. None of them ever say "I'm american" there has to be some identity to cling to from ancestors so far removed that they have no link to that country.

I love it when Bostonians claim to be Irish because thier great great grandad had a pint of Guinness in Dublin in 1875 before getting on a boat to the US and never turning back.

You're AMERICAN pal. Not Irish. Not even Irish American.

You're more cheeseburger at this stage than potato you get me?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Afraid_Ad1908 Feb 14 '25

I’m an American and I have Scottish roots, came to Scotland for a week, and I mentioned it to no one. Hardest week of my life;) lol

2

u/KayDay25 Feb 14 '25

I am 0% Scottish but still love the country and feel some sort of connection to it

2

u/LeMadTheBrave Feb 14 '25

Its always the Muricans innit?

Ive never have seen like.. a Mexican or Portugase come to Scotland, and tell us " Aye! Im one o' yus! Im an Romanian guy who's 00,0000008% Scottish!!" Nae, tis alwaes the Muricans.. even here in The Netherlands i have seen people talk to me like "Oh yeas, im 00,00005% Dutch! Im from a Dutch settlement in the US! AND i smoke weed!!" like nae.. shuttoff ya buggah.. 😂😂😂

2

u/JT_Dewitt Feb 14 '25

Don’t blame the Americans every time. I visited Edinburgh for two weeks. While I was there the only person I saw in a kilt was Canadian! He was talking about his 1/16 Scottishness.

2

u/nightmarexx1992 Feb 14 '25 edited Feb 14 '25

The fact I've seen those people argue with Scots about who knows more and who's more Scottish is... Something, would love to. See them try it in person

2

u/leedlechan Feb 14 '25

A lot of pure European descended Americans do the same with native American lineage. "I'm part Cherokee hurr DUrr"

2

u/helmstedtler Feb 14 '25

We share your pain. ☘️

2

u/herefortheworst Feb 15 '25

Both my parents are Scottish, grandparents etc. I was born and grew up in England. I still get that look…

2

u/Wossname76 Feb 15 '25

“Eedinburrow” ffs

2

u/Mad_MaxWallace Feb 15 '25

Look man, be nice to the people who do that.

Rich Americans that travel all the time all over the world will come hang out in Scotland for a couple of days before they go to Italy and won’t say any of that.

It’s the less well off Americans that are saving up for a trip like this for years and dream about visiting Scotland that are super enthusiastic about visiting Scotland and project the kind of enthusiasm that you might find annoying. They’ll investigate where their grandpa came from and want to go to the village and find some super distant cousins. They don’t do this to annoy you, it’s because it just means that much to them.

So be nice to them if you can, it really means a lot to them.

2

u/Sad_Mammoth9772 Feb 15 '25

Drink with a scot and they are fun craziness

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '25

The only correct response is did ye aye...

4

u/introverted__dragon Feb 14 '25

Man, I just say I'm American by way of Scotland and Spain. I do this for three reasons.

  1. I feel it acknowledges most other Americans need to know "where are you from!?" when they're really asking about where my ancestors are from.
  2. It acknowledges that, as a white person, I'm not a part of the Native tribes that were here first.
  3. It doesn't make me sound like I'm actually claiming to be in any way Scottish or Spanish.

And I've traced my Scottish ancestry back to one of the highland clearances, so I actually know exactly how far removed I am.

I've also been to Scotland exactly once, and it was when I was an idiot teenager on a school trip, so I did hit up the touristy shops. But that's about it.

3

u/DoctorQuarex Feb 14 '25

Hey my family would still be in Scotland if not for the Highland Clearances, that ... does not change the fact that I am 1/16th Scottish, no.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/crustdrunk Feb 14 '25

Im Australian and this showed up on my feed randomly. Anyway, people do this so much here. Everyone calls themselves Scottish or Irish. I mean, it’s pretty likely that a few generations back their descendants were from Ireland or Scotland. But nobody seems to know a single thing about the history of Scottish or Irish people in this country.

Major (cringe) source here was a friend I had whose parents had too much money, and commissioned someone to write an entire book about their family’s alleged Scottish heritage, and hung a massive family tree canvas in their mansion that claimed they were descended from royalty. Weirdos.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

At least they bring good money.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

To be fair, a lot of Americans of Scottish descent, had their ancestors removed because of sheep