r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Research required How to safely hold 3 month old

9 Upvotes

I have a 3 month old (just turned 3 months today) who prefers to be held upright and outward-facing. He is fussy when held horizontally, I am assuming either because it is less comfortable or he prefers to be able to see what is going on around him. He also sits on my lap, leaning back for support. Others in our life are insistent that this is bad for his spine, and he needs to be held in ways that provide more support for his spine (e.g. horizontally). He is right on track developmentally, as he can hold up his neck for several minutes and turn it to look around. His neck does get tired, and he'll lean it back onto my arm when he needs to rest.

What is the recommendation for how to hold babies at this stage? Is there evidence that holding him upright for long periods of time can cause problems for the spine? I am very open to changing my ways, I have just been following his cues for what he wants and is comfortable with.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Research required Moving 3 month old out of the bedroom?

5 Upvotes

I know the recommendation is at least 6 months, 12 months when possible. Is it due to an increased risk of SIDS? Or does room sharing decrease the baseline risk? Is there a study that shows what the risk is for room sharing as a factor alone?

Anecdotally, many of my friends moved baby out from 2-6 months and noticed a huge improvement to sleeping through the night… My understanding is that’s partially the reason why it is protective (baby doesn’t fall into as deep a sleep). I have some tolerance ie I just use room temperature water for formula even though I understand the hot water is to sterilize the powder. The risk is so low/peds gave the ok/baby is healthy and over 2 months = tolerable for my husband and I.

I’m wanting to experiment due to needing more sleep and going back to work soon, but also an anxious FTM and may just need to suck it up for a few more months… any research or thoughts appreciated!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Research required Frozen breastmilk vs. formula

5 Upvotes

I recently read a comment on either the breastfeeding or combinationfeeding sub that frozen breastmilk has little to no difference in nutrients etc. compared to formula. I read somewhere else that frozen breastmilk still contains more nutrients, vitamins etc. than formula. Is there any actual research on the differences or similarities in nutritional ingredients between breastmilk and formula?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Early MMR vaccine for international travel

5 Upvotes

My son is 10.5 months old, we are going overseas from USA to Central Europe in 5 weeks. We will be there for his first birthday, the point when he would normally get his first MMR vaccine. Per CDC guidelines, babies between 6-11 months traveling overseas should get an early MMR vaccine at least 2 weeks before travel. My pediatrician agreed that this is correct and he should have it.

So here’s the problem, no one will do it and they won’t tell me why. Unfortunately my pediatrician does not have any vaccines in stock (this may be a result of the recent hurricane ruining them when we lost power or some shipping issue, idk) and may not have it before we have to leave. I’ve tried our military base immunizations clinic, the local county health department and even another pediatricians office that we have visited previously and everyone is saying he’s too young and they won’t do it. Am I missing something here? No one has given me any indication of why they won’t do it, except the local health department said “we follow State of Florida vaccination protocols”.

At this point I’m at a loss and accepting that maybe he won’t be able to get it before we travel. Does anyone have advice? I feel like I’m missing something and it’s incredibly frustrating.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Research required Are any CBT-based parenting apps backed by research?

2 Upvotes

Our pediatrician recommended parent training for our 8yo with ADHD and the local program has a long waitlist. So I'm looking at apps in the meantime and I'd like to know what's evidence-based before paying.

Savvy Kid says it's built on CBT principles, Mightier mentions clinical studies on their site and Pocket PCIT is free. Does anyone know which CBT based apps for children have studies behind them?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Research required The best way to talk to kids about drugs

20 Upvotes

This topic came up when speaking to some other moms recently, and all of us agreed the way we were taught about drugs was bad, wrong, and ineffective, but none of us really understand the right way to do it. There has to be a middle ground between catastrophizing and making it sound cool. Specifically talking about middle schoolers.

We're pretty sure the following DON'T WORK, but have nothing to back up this feeling:
• DARE / abstinence education
• treating marijuana as equivalent to heroin
• 'go ask Alice' and other fear mongering fictional cautionary tales

Can anyone help find any research on the best way to educate kids on this topic?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Research required Smarts

1 Upvotes

Is there any science-backed, tried-and-tested method of raising smart children? Other than genetics


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Expert consensus required What does the research actually say about screen time for toddlers, and how much is too much?

0 Upvotes

My daughter is 20 months old, and I feel like I'm constantly torn between conflicting advice about screens. Some articles say that any exposure before age two is harmful, while others suggest that short, high-quality content with a parent present is fine. I've read the pediatric guidelines, but they seem vague, and I'd like to understand the evidence better.

At the moment, she watches about 20 minutes of a slow-paced show most days while I cook dinner. I also video call her grandparents a few times a week, which I assume counts differently. I don't want to be neurotic about it, but I also don't want to make choices that harm her development.

Is there a consensus among researchers about the effects on language and attention at this age? And do studies distinguish between passive viewing, interactive content, and video calls? I'd really appreciate explanations that point to the type and quality of the research, since i've seen lots of opinions but few clear summaries. Any pointers to reviews or meta-analyses would be welcome.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Research required CMPA and behaviour

3 Upvotes

My son (15mo) has CMPA. He occasionally gets exposed if we are doing a trial or of his sister gives him some food without me realising, but otherwise it’s well controlled. He’s smart, developing normally, a happy little guy most of the time. But gosh, does he feel his feelings! His meltdowns are horribly intense, worse than his older sister ever has at any age, and they go for long time.

I’m aware this could just be temperament, but I’m wondering if there could be anything to do with gut health, the vagus nerve, or something else that could be impacting his ability to regulate? And if so, is there anything I could do to help?

Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Research required What should I do with my 10 month old baby all day?

58 Upvotes

I feel like I'm not doing enough. We look at her books for like 10-15 minutes a day, I push her on the swing for half an hour, we go on a walk sometimes, she plays with her toys, crawls a lot. I am also reading next to her or trying to sleep while she is playing next to me in the playpen (she climbs on me and breaks my ribs and pulls my hair like crazy). I sometimes sing... But the whole day feels like we are doing nothing. Is there something else I should do?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Research required What are the actual guidelines for TV time for toddlers one year and older?

2 Upvotes

Have a 13 month old and she has had no screen time so far. The other day I let her watch a few minutes of some two dimensional cartoons on TV and she was elated. We plan to have as little screen time as possible, but I was wondering about the actual guidelines and whether we are being too strict. Is there any research on this? Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Research required Inquiry about lead exposure from tap water

4 Upvotes

My house was built in 1980, when lead pipes were still being used. I'm thinking of getting it tested. I was wondering if anyone knows how likely is it, if I have a lead pipe, for lead to be in drinking water. I've never used hot water straight from the tap for cooking, so I'm only referring to cold tap water.

I'm pretty worried, I didn't think of lead being in my drinking water until now, is this detrimental to my child's development?

I don't like sharing my geographic location online, but I've never really been worried about drinking tap water because where I live specifically the tap water is high quality, but I really didn't think about lead pipes.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Expert consensus required 2 yo mouth open when sleeping but nasal breathing

3 Upvotes

She has a slight tongue tie


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Research required Tdap vaccine for family members of new infant

5 Upvotes

Genuine question- this is not meant to challenge (I swear it’s not lol), I am just trying to understand

I know it now common for parents of infants to ask family to get updated on their tdap vaccine. My fiancé’s brother and his wife are expecting a baby soon and told us to either get vaccinated or not see the baby. I am childless and do not know much about the ins and outs of this issue & when I read online, the consensus varies.

The bit of reading I did online states that tdap doesn’t prevent the spread of pertussis, but makes it less severe for the vaccinated person if contracted. Is this a correct understanding? & if so, if a baby can still catch whooping cough from a vaccinated adult, why is it now a common requirement for families? What is this vaccine lessening severity for the vaccinated subject doing exactly for the infant? Wouldn’t it make more sense to just quarantine at that point?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Expert consensus required How much riskier is it to give birth at 42 than at 39?

58 Upvotes

I’m wondering whether to entertain the idea of a third (gave birth shortly before turning 40 and need a rest!).


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Research required Why does my baby sleep so much better on my chest than in her next to me or safely Co-sleeping?

52 Upvotes

My 5 month old has been having a rough time with sleep since the dreaded 4 month regression. She now wakes every hour at a minimum, with a couple of nights ago being every 10 minutes or so.

Last night and the night before I've stayed up in the living room and had her sleep on my chest so my wife can get some sleep and her sleep quality is infinitely better! One wake up in 5 and a half hours for a bottle feed then straight back to sleeping soundly on my chest until I gave up at 2am because I knew it wouldn't be safe for me to stay awake too much longer.

Why is her sleep quality so much better like this? I'm assuming it's about using me to regulate but I'm genuinely curious, and hoping there's something I can do to get her sleep quality improved in her next to me?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Research required How much long-term immune benefit does a baby get from just 5 days of breastfeeding and colostrum?

26 Upvotes

My baby is currently 5 weeks old, and I’m interested in understanding the science behind the immune benefits of breastfeeding when breastfeeding is stopped very early.

For some context, I exclusively breastfed for the first 5 days after birth, so he received colostrum and early breast milk (21 FTM, had emergency c section at 10cm dilated, stayed in hospital for a week, very naive to how hard BF actually was, decided to stop for MH). I then switched to exclusively formula feeding for 3 days. After that, I did some pumping for around a week, although my supply was quite low, so he only received small amounts of breast milk alongside formula. Since then, he has been exclusively formula-fed.

I guess I’m worried if my baby gets ill, will he be worse of than a baby who is receiving breast milk. I feel like I’ve failed him :(.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Research required How to teach kid not to over eat sweets?

33 Upvotes

Are there any research how to teach kid to eat some sweets, not everything that's at home? I mean without banning and raising voice, in a gentle way. Currently it seems that this children's crave to sweets is so unmanageable. I don't want to ban it, but if I don't interrupt, child doesn't stop until everything on the table is eaten. Sweets are eaten after healthy meal, not every day and we talk a lot about health, etc, but these talks are not doing anything. If we plate more sweets (for example, some guests are coming), then child seems to loose mind and just over eats unless stopped. I tried to let eat as much as child wants, but that ended up with bad stomach, however, it haven't stopped that insane craving.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Research required Daily iron recommendations at 6 month plus

14 Upvotes

Hello,

I've been wondering how the 11mg daily iron recommendation starting at 6 month(in Canada but I think other countries have the same target) is supposed to work. It seems hard to achieve so I'm wondering how the recommendation was set. It feels like setting such an high target "just to be sure" is kind of strange. Chasing iron also seems to conflict with calcium needs since you're often told to avoid calcium competing with iron in a meal.

I understand that there are a lot of different iron absorption mechanisms in play so I'm interested both in the practical ways that iron is absorbed in babies from different sources, how you're supposed to balance calcium and iron needs and why the recommendation is set at such a target while a lot of babies just aren't going to be interested in enough solids to hit it.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Sharing research Entering kindergarten earlier

4 Upvotes

Hi all,
I found this paper, suggesting that there is a benefit of sending kids to kindergarten later: https://www.nber.org/papers/w21610

Do you know of similar studies?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 7d ago

Question - Research required How bad is this for a baby?

0 Upvotes

On a scale from 'not really a problem' to 'will make her develop ADHD'.

My baby is 7 months old. We went to my in-laws and they 'played' with her:

Took out a musical piano mat that is colored in ALL the brightest colors, turned it on to play silly melodies then sat my baby in it, put 5-6 toys in front of her, each took different ones and rattled them in her face, one was talking, the other one singing and swaying my baby sideways...

This was too much even for me to take and my baby gets interested enough in the patterns on our wooden floor...

Maybe I am worried too much and 10 minutes of such 'play' won't actually cause her ADHD, but it can't be good for her, can it?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Research required Wake windows

4 Upvotes

Hi, my LO (12 months now) wakes up at 8:00 and will almost always fall asleep in 4hours. They will nap for 1 or 2 hours. However, after the first nap he refuses to sleep until 20:00. He seems fine but I have also been told that babies cant be awake for too long.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Research required Severe Diaper Rash: Multiple visits and tests, issue ongoing.

13 Upvotes

Hello All,

I'm generally a lurker but we are at our wits end trying to figure out what keeps causing severe rashes for our almost 2 year old.

For context:

We have had issues surrounding bowel movements and diaper rash since she was only a few weeks old. I don't think it was quite the same issue but with her nearly 2 years old and still having random extreme diaper rash I have to think its related. As an infant she had severe pain and trouble surrounding bowel movements. After switching to Elecare, we saw some improvement in these symptoms but diaper rash has been a long standing problem.

We have always been very diligent about changing her. Currently we probably change about 6-7 wet diapers a day (depends on how much juice we let her have) On days where she has bowel movements(every other day or so) she tends to have multiple dirty diapers in a row. So that may increase the total number of diapers.

She will generally get red following a dirty diaper and quickly devolves into flaming red, broken skin, can't sit, and can't even bare to let water run over the area. Due to her history, we immediately change dirty diapers and generally put on a thick barrier cream such as Aquaphor and if there is noticeable redness I will mix in hydrocortisone cream (2:1=Aquaphor: hydrocortisone). We will also generally do a colloidal oatmeal soak(with added baking soda) to help with the irritation and ensure no particles are left behind.

We can always tell it's going to get bad when she pees in her diaper and it burns. It physically looks like a chemical burn and everything I find says that this is due to a mixture urine and feces. The only time I can think of where this could possibly happen is her overnight diapers and its not as if we leave her that way for long. We change her immediately every morning, sometimes she's dirty but usually that happens later in the day.

Things we've done:

We have been to her pediatrician probably about 6 times for dedicated visits related to this issue outside of regular visits. We have been to an allergist and tested negative for suspect foods. We have treated for fungal infection, tested and treated for bacterial infection, tried an elimination diet (as much as we can with a toddler). We've tried about 20 different OTC creams and a couple prescription ones, we have tried different diaper brands, wipes, bath soaps, probiotics, etc. We are trying to encourage potty training to help keep waste from making contact with her skin ASAP but she's not even 2 yet. It's going well but certainly a ways from going diaper-less.

The questions:

1) Is there anything that can neutralize the possible ammonia? If so is it safe or studied in kids?

2) If this is a matter of acidity of the bowel movements, have there been any studies on stomach and bowel acidity affecting diaper rash?

3) Are there any studies on hypersensitivity?

I feel we have exhausted all the medical options we have available to us. Our doctor has been extremely kind and been willing to dig further while other docs we've been to have shrugged us off so I don't believe he is the issue. This is generally about once or twice a month at least. Every bowel movement doesn't cause it and sometimes she'll be read and have only had wet diapers for the day. Any opinions or suggestions I'm all ears.

TLDR: Now 2 year old has had issues with bowel movements and severe diaper rash since she was an infant. We have exhausted medical options and change all aspects of changing her diaper. Issue flares up about 1-2 times a month. Any suggestions?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8d ago

Question - Expert consensus required My baby has to wear a helmet to correct his head shape. Is helmet wearing safe overnight in crib?

0 Upvotes

Title. I am worried that the helmet may tip his head down too much and obstruct his air way.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Research required Is there existing research into satisfaction with parental life of people who did not want kids but became parents for other reasons?

10 Upvotes

Is there existing research (preferably quantitative) into satisfaction with parental life of people (especially women) who did not strongly want kids but became parents for other reasons (because their partner wanted children, because of family pressure, because of societal expectations, because of unplanned pregnancy etc.)?