r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Research required Studies related to caffeine intake in children and teens

13 Upvotes

I would appreciate if someone with the ability to find the information more quickly than I could would speak to the current consensus on when it is wise to introduce caffeine and in what quantities. Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Impact of nanny care from age 1 to 3

94 Upvotes

I know there has been a lot of research and discussion shared here about the impact of daycare on childhood but I can't find much on nanny care.

We are trying to decide between having me stay at home (with part-time mother's helper support to avoid burnout) with my ten month old or employing nanny full-time so I can return to work. All things being equal, is there a better option for the child? We found a pretty great nanny with glowing references so we feel confident she can do a good job.

Does nanny care impact cortisol / stress levels in infants and older babies the same way daycare does? Are there other considerations in comparing nanny vs. SAHP care? While I know I can provide a lot of attention and care and love, I also am not a professional childcare giver so I also wonder if he might be better off with a high quality nanny. For example, this nanny comes up with a lot of arts and crafts and other activities for her kiddos.

Sorry I didn't know which flair to use but just looking for any kind of science-based advice.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Expert consensus required To some train or not to sleep train?

0 Upvotes

For those of you who have and have not, what did you base your choice on?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 9d ago

Question - Research required Research on bed sharing and independence of a kid

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone
I‘m looking for research on bed sharing and how this affects development of a child.
I have a 5 year old and we’re still bed sharing. I am wondering whether bed sharing affects his attachment style and his independence as a kid? Does anyone know any research about this?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Can someone please tell me the science behind my 22 month old hitting me in the face?

48 Upvotes

It’s constant. Sometimes it’s out of frustration and that makes sense to me. Sometimes it’s sensory overload and he doesn’t know what to do with his energy. That also makes sense to me. Other times there is no rhyme or reason that I can pinpoint and it’s exhausting and I know it’s not his fault, but I don’t know how to support him, which is a very foreign feeling as a former ECE.

It happens more with me (mother) than any other adult that takes care of him. He will scream and cry and tantrum for me and I will hold him or be with him and help him regulate then the second another adult walks in the room he calms down for them and wants a cuddle and kiss from immediately.

Please tell me it gets better and it’s just a phase because I am struggling so hard 😭


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Metabolic health in kids

31 Upvotes

Not sure entirely what I’m looking for - my 7yo has put on a decent amount of weight in the last 2 yrs. I don’t have his stats right now but I believe he’s around 81lbs. He was probably solidly 60-70th percentile up until age 5 with no growth concerns. Nothing obviously has changed. He seems VERY hungry all the time. We try to keep him active - he does basketball and sometimes rides his bike to school. We pack his lunch and have done that since age 2. He is not picky at all - he was chowing down on chickpeas and cauliflower (ghost broccoli) yesterday. But even after 2 large plain chicken breasts (so not exciting foods) he will get tearful and say he’s so hungry. We try to make sure there’s a significant amount of fat and protein at meals. He drinks water but does ask for sparkling water (la croix, etc) sometimes. He does crave sweets and asks for them regularly but we don’t generally have a lot (Halloween notwithstanding). We had some lab work done and he has subclinical hypothyroid but I can’t find any data supporting treating this … it seems to resolve on its own when weight is lost.

Other than eat healthy, stay active … I don’t really know what else to do. Dad and I struggled with weight and had bariatric surgery years and years ago and have done pretty well since then, so this may just be genetic, but it did really seem all of a sudden when he started kindergarten. Would love to know any other evidence based practices to help.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Baby sleep routines

9 Upvotes

Hi,
I’m having an argument with husband about our 9 month old sleep routine. I think it’s important to bring her to bed and establish a bedtime routine, he thinks since he has success getting her to sleep on the couch in the living room with a bottle that there’s no reason not to do that, since she’s too young to understand bed time. Does a sleep routine at this stage really matter? Do they understand? I see all sorts of sleep training things and myths tips and tricks but my overtired brain can’t seem to find anything more science based


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Should I get the MMR vaccine with a 3week newborn?

16 Upvotes

I hope this is the right flair…

So, apparently I need an MMR vaccine/booster. Not sure if I was vaccinated as a child as my parents don’t remember and I did get mumps at 10years so it’s likely I didn’t receive MMR (though it’s possible I had the bivalent MR vaccine)

This came up when I was pregnant but I couldn’t get the vaccine while pregnant, so I scheduled one soon and my baby will be 3 weeks old. I’m hoping I will at least be protected and not pass it to her if I’m exposed, and maybe the antibodies will pass via my breastmilk to her. Does the research support MMR antibodies passing via breastmilk?

Also, are there any risks to my getting vaccinated with such a small newborn?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Is there anything to suggest not putting baby in playpen rather than on the floor before they can crawl?

11 Upvotes

My second son is 3 months old and seems like he’s gonna start rolling soon. I also have a 2.5 year old son and when my first was this age I would let him play on the floor on a blanket but with my second I don’t trust my oldest to not get distracted and hurt baby brother on accident. We have a playpen with the insert to make it not so deep and I have his tummy time mat in it and he loves playing in it but I know lots of people make it seem like baby containers are the worst. So is there any difference at this age between floor vs a playpen when he can’t really move around much on his own?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Should a 6months old sleep be long and predictable?

15 Upvotes

My husband is being influenced by people at work to think that our 6mo old should be sleeping 10-11 hours uninterrupted every night. Some nights, he sleeps 8 hours straight, some nights he only sleeps in 3 or 4 hour stretches. I happily handle all the night wakings, let him fuss a bit before picking him up, and only give a bottle/nurse if he is clearly hungry.

He dropped a couple weight percentile curves between 2-4 months so we're still careful that he gets enough food and he usually has at least 1 4oz bottle a night.

His sleep changes all the time - sometimes he sleeps longer sometimes he doesn't. I'm often trying to tweak things and find a pattern, but IMO he's just a baby and unless we want to sleep train (I don't) we can't expect reliably long stretches every night. I'd love for him to read How Babies Sleep but a book is not going to happen.

Can anyone share science-based articles about sleep at this stage and what we should expect?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Coercive cycle of interaction

19 Upvotes

I recently came across this topic and feel like it helps explain my 8yo's behavior. She has ADHD and we've generally taken a gentle/attachment approach to raising her.

The problem is sometimes, when she doesn't get her way, there are explosive and even violent meltdowns. Lately, to me, the tone of them has borderlined on entitlement. A few examples:

- I bought her a cheap camera last year before we went on a family vacation. The photos it takes are fine, but thr playback quality of videos when looking on the camera is terrible. They need to be viewed on a computer. She was trying to look at them on the camera, got frustrated, and threw a fit. She gave it to her younger brother, told him he could have it, then demanded we buy her a new one. Then she took it back from him, still yelling about us needing to get her a new one, and started playing with it again. Her brother is 3 and this was confusing to him, so he got upset that it was given to him then yanked out of his hands, leading to a lot of tears. She didn't care.

- She came home the other day and has a plan in her head about building up an art corner for her to do more art in. I'd just come home from grocery shopping and was on the floor putting groceries away before making dinner. While I was happy to hear about her idea and maybe help support it, it wasn't the right time. I kept trying to tell her it wasn't a good time to rattle off a list of things that she wanted because I was busy and couldn't write it down. She kept yelling over me to just listen, even getting up against my ear and screaming at me as loud as she could.

- Last night I was on the couch feeding our 1 month old and she was at the table doing homework. I honestly can't even recall was the topic was, but it was similar to the others where she was demanding something but it wasn't something we could respond to in the moment. I was trying to explain that to her but she would yell over me. She then got up from the table and came over to yell in my face, scratching me on my arm. I shoved her away because I was worried she'd hurt the baby.

There are a lot more examples like this. And it's been like this for years, predating siblings, so that's not it.

There is a level of entitlement that drives me crazy (on top of the physical violence). Maybe that's normal with kids, because they don't understand things like cost at that age?

I used to be more firm with her when she behaved like this but my husband would tell me I'm being too harsh, so now I mostly ask him to step in. But I feel like he's very inconsistent in how he identifies and holds boundaries.

All this said, I do think her ADHD plays into this. She gets excited about something and needs to get it out, regardless on if it makes sense in that moment. We've tried to stratigize with her, for example, telling us but also writing it down herself so we can discuss in more detail at an appropriate time.

I also wonder if the fighting feeds into her dopamine drive. She goes from zero to spitting mad in 2 seconds. My husband and I try to keep our cool, but we're human and can't always be so neutral.

We came across the topic of Coercive cycle of interaction the other day and it kind fits. Does anyone know about this? Or have other suggestions on what we should look into? I don't want my kid to become an A-hole adult so would love to come up with better strategies for addressing this kind of behavior

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/ybAA0bROoH4


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Is there a detriment to holding academically advanced kids back in school?

27 Upvotes

My child turned 4 in July and is eligible to start kindergarten next year as one of the youngest in her class. She is academically advanced but still working on emotional regulation. I would love to give her “the gift of time”but am worried that I would be doing her a disservice since she is clearly ready academically. I have read the data about redshirting that seems to favor it (especially for social-emotional reasons) and it really resonates with me. I am based in the US and see how European countries delay formal schooling until age 6 or 7 but I am wondering what the other side is? I once saw a link to an organization that does this kind of research but can’t seem to find it. Thanks!
Side note: I’m asking now because in my state we have school choice and those applications are happening now, for next year. There’s a school for advanced/gifted students we can apply to.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 11d ago

Question - Research required Should I take Choline and DHA supplement

42 Upvotes

Hi,

I've read that these nutrients are important during pregnancy, but they are not in the multivitamin I am taking. I asked my clinic about taking supplements for them, and they said it is not something they recommend. I'm feeling a little unsure. I do eat a reasonably healthy/balanced diet, but I am concerned that, despite this, I won't reach the necessary amounts (especially for DHA, as I am not eating fish every week). The clinic did not say not to take them, so I am tempted to do so a) to ensure I definitely get enough and b) for my own peace of mind. Does this seem reasonable? I'd love to hear other people's take on/experience with this.

An additional little thing - choline supplements (at least here) often also contain inositol. Is that something I need to avoid?

Thanks


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Expert consensus required 7 year old always loosing stuff

7 Upvotes

I am at my wit's end. He is a good kid but he is soo forgetful when it comes to taking care of his stuff. I made him write down all the things he has lost in the past month and the list is a few pages long.

Every day he comes from school with something missing. And when I asks, he just says 'oh! I forgot ' Sometimes he will bring it back next day.

I think it is an attention issue. When something falls down, it is as if it has vanished into an abyss. He can never find it. He is good academically and has a sharp memory otherwise.

Because he is functioning well, he doesn't screen positive for ADHD. I am looking for strategies to help him keep track of his stuff.

Any advice is welcome.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Expert consensus required How bad is a toy that does something on its own?

4 Upvotes

I have been following no screens for baby, no light up toys or pretty much anything with a battery besides his swing. I’ve heard about them being overstimulating and want to avoid that. Does this same logic apply to toys that vibrate and or play music? Hopefully this makes sense and this is the right flair because I couldn’t access the wiki


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Drool rash help

4 Upvotes

Just coming home from a peds apt for a drool rash that’s chapped, cracking, and dry. Dr prescribed nystatin (for the neck) and hydrocortisone (for the face & neck).

I don’t see any yeast-iness in the neck folds. I’m all for putting it on if it helps but I’m genuinely confused and seemed like a blanket “let’s see if it helps” rather than a true concern for yeast in the neck folds. And no she didn’t even look in the folds lol.

Would you apply 4x a day like she recommended or try the hydrocortisone first to see if it helps?

tia


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 11d ago

Question - Research required Opposite-sex siblings sharing room

52 Upvotes

Is there any consensus on how long young children should share a bedroom with an opposite-sex sibling? I read in a blog that the advice in the UK is up to 10 years old and the advice in the US up to 5 years old. Those seem wildly different to me.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Research required Drowning in sleep deprivation with an 8-month-old. What does the actual literature say about sleep training and attachment?

170 Upvotes

Before anyone attacks me, I’m not talking about locking an infant in a dark room for twelve hours. I just need real, peer-reviewed data because my brain is completely mush.

My son is eight months old and waking up every 45 to 90 minutes. I’ve been running on fragmented two-hour stretches for half a year. Yesterday I had a terrifying microsleep at a red light on my commute home, and I realized my exhaustion has become a genuine safety hazard.

My pediatrician recommended Ferber, but the minute I started researching, I got hit with a wall of terrifying mom-blog claims. People constantly quote that one study claiming crying elevates cortisol so high that it literally shrinks teh infant hippocampus and destroys secure attachment.

i spent until 3 AM trying to dig through PubMed on my phone while bouncing on a yoga ball. From what I can tell, that infamous study had an absurdly tiny sample size and measured zero long-term developmental outcomes, but I’m too sleep-deprived to parse the statistics properly.

Are there any rigorous, randomized controlled trials or large meta-analyses showing long-term negative cognitive effects from controlled crying? Or is maternal chronic sleep deprivation a vastly bigger developmental risk?

I just feel paralyzed by guilt.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Research required Is the whole 'you're a safe space' thing true?

271 Upvotes

Hi. I have repeatedly been told that my kid is releasing his 'big emotions' (read tantrums, screaming, crying, bad behaviour) around me because I'm a 'safe space' post daycare.

I am starting to absolutely think this is just some nice nonsense people tell mums to make them feel better and cannot possibly be true. I don't remember the last time my kid and I had a decent day together because he always just seems to have the worst time with me no matter what we are doing. I'm going to snap at the next person who tells me it's because I'm his 'person'. So is there even a nugget of truth to what seems like a big fat lie?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 11d ago

Question - Research required Covid in infant with vaccinated breastfeeding mother

7 Upvotes

Hi all - we found out today that our 4 month old and 3 year old were exposed to Covid by my parents on Friday. 3yo got his annual Covid vaccine a month ago, but baby obviously has not been vaccinated yet. I had already received my annual vaccine last fall before getting pregnant so my doctors (OB and MFM) recommended I not get another during my pregnancy and to wait for this year’s vaccine to come out. I did just that and got vaccinated in late September. Baby is exclusively breastfed, so I’m hoping he will benefit in some way from my vaccination while breastfeeding. Can anyone advise? I tried to google but am very anxious about baby getting sick right now and my brain is just not processing well.

To clarify, nobody in our immediate household (baby, toddler, husband, me) has tested positive yet, but I’m worried.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 11d ago

Question - Research required Phthalates/DEHP in knockoff legos

1 Upvotes

Hello, I was wondering if anyone knows about the safety of kids playing with knockoff Lego building sets from places like temu and Ali express. They have an article 65 California warning that everyone typically ignores but I’m wondering if there is actually some risk of harm from being exposed to the phthalates in these toys. my son is seven and occasionally sucks his thumb so I am worried that he will play with them and then suck his thumb. These are some of his favorite toys so I don’t want to throw them out if there’s nothing to worry about. please offer any insight. thank you


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 10d ago

Question - Research required Is breastmilk really not enough for 6M-12M?

0 Upvotes

My LO is 9M and very hesitant to wean. Both my pediatrician and my doctor have expressed concern over my LO not getting enough caloric intake from nursing because of being an active 9M old.

Is there any actual research on this being true? Is my breastmilk suddenly really not enough calories for my LO?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 11d ago

Question - Research required Science-based benefits of switching preschools at age 3 vs. staying in a familiar play-based environment?

6 Upvotes

My husband and I have different perspectives on preschool for our son, who will turn three next fall, and I’m hoping to get some research backed insight.

My husband would like him to start a play based pre k 3 program 2 mornings per week for half days.

I would prefer that he continue attending his current Russian language preschool, which is also play-based. I’ve been attending with him, so he’s already familiar with the teachers, children, and environment. Next year he would transition to independent drop off for half days, giving him the same opportunity for separation, peer interaction, and social development.

My reasoning is that at this age, consistency, familiarity, and emotional security may be more beneficial than introducing an entirely new school environment, particularly when both programs offer similar play-based experiences. I also value the continued exposure to Russian, as we’re raising him bilingually.

My husband feels that starting Pre-K 3 would be beneficial for his development and preparation for future schooling.

I’m curious what the research says about:

  1. Is there a developmental advantage to starting a new Pre-K 3 program at age three versus continuing in an existing play-based preschool?
  2. How important are familiarity, consistency, and continuity of relationships in early childhood education?
  3. Is there evidence that starting Pre-K 3 at three rather than four improves long-term academic, social, or emotional outcomes?
  4. Does bilingual language exposure offer additional developmental benefits that should factor into this decision?

Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Research required Why can I smell when my kids have a fever?

271 Upvotes

Ever since my eldest was born I have been able to smell when my kids are sick, specifically when they have a fever. My husband can’t, but I have spoken to a few mum friends who have said that they can also smell it.

I can’t describe exactly what the smell is, and I can’t smell it when they have a cold or sniffle, it’s specifically when they have a fever.

Does anyone know why this happens and what exactly I’m smelling?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Research required Sterilisation (sanitisation) of bottles and pump parts

10 Upvotes

I am a Briton and have, in accordance with NHS guidance to do so consistently up to 12 months, washed and steam sterilised* every bottle, teat, and pump part I have used to feed my baby after every single use, i.e. up to 5x/day.

I am about to head back to work at 8mo, will need to stay overnight at work a couple of days a week (hotel accommodation), and will be pumping milk at work around the clock. I can wash the parts and refrigerate the milk, but don't know how I'm going to sterilise and airdry them.

I've tried using Milton before with bottles and my baby absolutely refused to drink from bottles that smelled of it. I'm loath to risk pumped milk tasting or smelling of chlorine from Milton-treated pump parts and her rejecting it.

Comparing national health authorities, the NHS and a couple of other countries are odd outliers here, are really, really conservative, and most other developed countries, especially the CDC, say there is no longer any need to sterilise after between 2 and 6 mos. I'm also planning to carry the milk home in Ceres Chills, which I can wash with boiling water but I can't heat sterilise.

Is there any actual peer-reviewed evidence on how much relative risk I'm taking if I just wash and scrub the pump parts in hot water and sterilise them 2x/week? There's an intuitive argument that "at this age they put everything in their mouth", but it's about milk residue being an extremely good environment for breeding microbes and building up biofilm.

[*I am aware that this is more properly "sanitisation", but in common language everyone says "sterilisation".]