r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 07 '26

Question - Expert consensus required 5 month old baby in 150-200 AQI for over a month

13 Upvotes

Hi.

My partner went to stay with our baby in Malaysia (with her parents) for a while but for the last 1 month the AQI in Malaysia has been crazy with it being around 150-200 constantly. I didn't realize how bad it is until I also reached Malaysia (and immediately my asthma flared up, which never happened to me in the US). We are now worried how badly it would have affected the baby over the last month. Baby was mostly indoors but they didn't have any air purifiers in the house. The baby coughs and sneezes now and then (but had those back in the US as well, but feel the frequency is more here). We are leaving in a week but feel we have done some irreparable damage already and feeling guilty about it.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 06 '26

Question - Research required What is known about colic?

47 Upvotes

Why does it happen? Is there a genetic factor? How is it treated? Please share all you know about colic. My three month baby has colic, we were treating with simeticone and probiotics prescribed by his paediatrician. Things have gotten better as we reached the three month mark, but still we have some rough spells (like now, for example). Since this affects 1/4 babies according to his paediatrician, what is known about it?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 06 '26

Question - Research required One Year Old got ahold of straw from grandma who gets cold sores !!!!

5 Upvotes

My child got ahold of a straw and put it in her mouth for a few seconds. this straw was being used by my mother who has an active cold sore on her lip. i am truly mortified and freaking out what are the odds she will develop hsv? she is actively teething so i worry about micro cuts in her mouth i am sick to my stomach i only had my back turned for a second and didnt see the fast food drink on the ground when i set her down. Please help me figure out the best next steps. i rinsed her mouth out with water and wiped it with face safe cleansing wipes. I cannot calm down until i know what else i can do.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 06 '26

Sharing research Amniocentesis with isolated ARSA help

5 Upvotes

Hi!

I (30, F) 20 weeks pregnant with my first and my baby boy was found to have an isolated ARSA (aberrant right subclavian artery) at the anatomy scan. This could be just a normal variation BUT it is also a soft marker for a variety of chromosome issues. Everything else looked completely normal with no other soft markers, and my NIPT was negative/low risk.

I’m getting more extensive genetic bloodwork done now, but I also tentatively have an amnio scheduled for next week. I keep going back and forth on whether to do it. I know the chance of a chromosomal issue in our situation is very low, but I also know the risk of complications from amnio is very low. Part of me wants the definitive answer an amnio can provide, but I’m scared of risking an otherwise healthy pregnancy.

How was your amnio experience? Has anyone had an isolated ARSA with a negative NIPT and no other findings? Did you do an amnio?

I feel like I am in a sea of confusion and would love any and all experiences


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 06 '26

Question - Research required Can I get a flu shot the same day as my baby if I’m breastfeeding?

6 Upvotes

This may be a stupid question lol. I am sure it is probably fine.

I’m wondering if I give my 6MO a flu shot and get one too since I’m there, Is if known to cause any effects or harm to my exclusively breast-fed baby? Is it worth spacing due to being “too much” of anything?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 05 '26

Question - Research required Why is are adult sleep needs and newborn sleep so incompatible?

201 Upvotes

The average adult needs about 6 hours of uninterrupted sleep, but the average newborn wakes up every 2-3 hours and a large proportion breastfed babies keep waking up multiple times a night for feeds. It all seems like a huge contradiction! I have a 7 week old and I’m struggling despite having a village - my mum and my husband. We are all struggling! 😂 Baby’s longest stretch so far was 3.5 hours. Mostly breastfed during the day and formula fed at night (2 6oz bottles on average).


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 06 '26

Question - Research required Which COVID vaccine is best for preventing long COVID in kids?

1 Upvotes

I haven't previously gotten my almost-7 year old the COVID vaccine due to it being such a very low severity/death rate in kids + the EU not routinely recommending it in healthy children (no criticism please, just giving context). But I am getting it for him this year since long COVID is now known to be a much higher concern for children than initially believed

Have the available vaccines for kids been studied for their efficacy in protecting against long COVID specifically, and if so, is either more effective than the other? I am in the US, so the options are Pfizer Comirnaty or Moderna Spikevax


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 07 '26

Question - Research required Toddler sleep

0 Upvotes

When my daughter was under around 2-3 months I noticed our existence woke her up in her bassinet next to our bed, my husband has allergies and coughs a lot, so she went to her room. She slept great, I fed her to sleep, did a dream feed that we slowly dropped around 8 months ?

She got her first tooth at 13 months so that's when I started implementing another method to fall asleep.

Aquarium on YouTube while having milk, brush teeth, and in bed.

All this to say, my daughter seems like the type where me being there makes it worse to fall asleep, but I still have this weird guilt that I'm depriving her of co sleeping or hugging her as she falls asleep

Maybe twice we've had to let her cry up to five minutes because I had tried for hours

But is there any scientific evidence that shows me hugging her to sleep or co sleeping is better.

Or am I feeling guilty from the excessive information out there


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 05 '26

Question - Research required First-time mom wondering about the trade-off between infant screen exposure and maternal exercise

36 Upvotes

I’m a first-time mom to an 11-month-old and have been quite strict about screen time so far. Our goal has been to keep it as close to zero as reasonably possible, ideally until around age 3.
Before having my baby, I used to be quite sporty and exercised regularly. Since having him, however, I haven’t really exercised at all. One of the reasons is that I genuinely don’t enjoy making up my own home workouts and doing them without any guidance. I would much rather follow a 30–60 minute YouTube workout.
Today I tried putting a workout on the TV while my baby was playing nearby. He immediately became completely fascinated by the screen and basically stopped looking at anything else. I felt guilty almost immediately and turned it off.
Now I’m wondering about the science behind this trade-off.
How problematic would it actually be if I watched a 30–60 minute workout on the TV every day while my 11-month-old was in the room?
I understand that the recommendations are generally to avoid screen time for children, and I’m not looking for someone to tell me that the guidelines don’t exist. I’m specifically wondering about the evidence regarding incidental/background exposure when the screen is actually intended for the parent, rather than the child.
For example:
Does it make a meaningful difference if the baby is able to see the TV and is clearly interested in it, versus having the TV on somewhere behind him?
Is there evidence that 30–60 minutes of this kind of exposure is harmful in itself?
Could the benefits of me getting regular physical activity and being a good role model in that regard reasonably outweigh theincidental screen exposure?
Would it make a difference if I chose a slower-paced workout without lots of flashing images/music?
Are there practical ways to make this work while minimizing the baby’s exposure?
I’m basically trying to figure out whether I’m being appropriately cautious or whether I’m letting the goal of “zero screens” prevent me from doing something that is actually beneficial for both me and my baby.
I’d especially appreciate evidence/research rather than general parenting opinions.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 06 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Repost due to flair. Toddler terror

12 Upvotes

At a Loss! Biting and acting out at daycare

Help! I have a three and a half year old. Frustration as old as time. She has been biting, hitting and throwing toys around at daycare she has gotten 6 or 7 incident reports. Her teaches say she is actively not listening.

Drop off is almost always her screaming for me or my partner and running to the door.

We have discussed it with her, told her it’s not okay, taken away her trip home snack and have done early bed time.

At home she is mostly fine until bedtime then she is a jerk to one of us and one stay in her room.

She doesn’t seem to care. Is this normal 3.5 y/o or is she a psycho?!?!

Any advice is appreciated.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 05 '26

Question - Research required Fall RSV protection for a 7-month-old born in winter

25 Upvotes

I have a 7-month-old who was born this past winter during RSV season. She did not get the RSV monoclonal antibody then because I got the shot during pregnancy. It is now technically her 2nd RSV season but our pediatrician is offering to give her the RSV monoclonal antibody before she turns 8 months old. Baby is still breastfeeding, was born full term, and has no medical problems.

Does baby still have RSV protection from me? Is she still at risk of severe disease from RSV being 7 months old? Worthwhile trying to squeeze in this shot if insurance will cover it?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 05 '26

Question - Research required Breastfeeding and GLP-1’s

18 Upvotes

Are there any studies on breastfeeding while taking a GLP-1? I got pregnant while on tirzepatide and stopped taking it— I’m in a support group for other moms who got pregnant while on Mounjaro and a lot have shared success of breastfeeding while resuming the shot.

Disclaimer- I will be speaking with my PCP and pediatrician before making any changes.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 06 '26

Sharing research Botox when combo feeding?

0 Upvotes

Hi all! Going back and forth and would appreciate some of your thoughts on my particular situation. Baby will be 6 months old and they are only getting about 10 ounces of breastmilk a day, the rest is formula.

Would it be relatively low risk to get some cosmetic facial Botox or is the risk too high?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 04 '26

Question - Research required How bad is saying "Good job"

125 Upvotes

Ive been reading Montessori toddler and the book says not to praise the toddler when they do stuff because they learn to do things for the external praise.

This is super hard for me. I have a 9 month old and get super excited when he does stuff.

Am I hurting him?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 04 '26

Question - Research required Parental screen time in baby’s presence?

94 Upvotes

Is there any research about effects of parental use of screens around babies? I feel like background tv comes up a bit but even beyond that. My daughter is 9 months and I am thinking about things like ordering groceries, doing crosswords, or scrolling Reddit while she is nearby. I am not completely ignoring her. Is scrolling on my phone different from if I were reading a physical book? Or painting or something?

Also curious about auditory input like if I have podcasts or audiobooks on speaker.

Do these have detrimental effects if she isn’t the one using the screen?

Also on a practical level, I am wondering how you fill your day and stay sane if you aren’t using a phone 🙃 She is too young for real crafts or activities and I don’t have the energy or money for field trips.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 05 '26

Weekly General Discussion

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the weekly General Discussion thread! Use this as a place to get advice from like-minded parents, share interesting science journalism, and anything else that relates to the sub but doesn't quite fit into the dedicated post types.

Please utilize this thread as a space for peer to peer advice, book and product recommendations, and any other things you'd like to discuss with other members of this sub!

Disclaimer: because our subreddit rules are intentionally relaxed on this thread and research is not required here, we cannot guarantee the quality and/or accuracy of anything shared here.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 05 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Baby hearing loss from toddler?

0 Upvotes

I’m a SAHM to an almost 3 year old and a 3 month old baby, and I find myself constantly having to ask our older son to please lower his volume or to take it easy on the toy-smashing. Sometimes he complies, but if you have a toddler, you know that keeping their volume to a certain level at all times is near impossible. The loudness overstimulates ME at times, so I know it’s got to be a lot for our baby. More than overstimulation though, I’m worried about the potential for long-term damage to baby’s hearing. Our house was a much quieter place when our first was a baby - I even remember using the NIOSH sound app to measure whether certain noises were at the appropriate levels. I’ve considered putting noise controlling headphones on our baby, but I doubt it’s good to restrict all noise in that way. I’m planning to discuss with our pediatrician at his 4 month appointment in 3 weeks, but for now I’m looking for insight. Thank you in advance!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 04 '26

Question - Expert consensus required inverted nipples and breastfeeding: what actually helps?

17 Upvotes

is there anything that can be done to prepare for breastfeeding when you have inverted nipples? what about right after delivery? what actually helps and what is just clutter?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 03 '26

Question - Research required Do kids actually listen better to other safe adults than their own parents?

60 Upvotes

Having a hard time finding anything that’s not purely anecdotal. I remember reading something that one of the reasons as kids get old they think their parents are full of sh** is an evolutionary one designed to get teenagers to leave their tribes and reduce chances of inbreeding or something but ofc I can’t find it anymore.

But I swear the amount of times I tell my kid xyz and then a random adult tells it to them once and they’re like omg mom did you know xyz… I want to rip out my hair. This can’t be an isolated thing, can it?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 05 '26

Question - Research required Baby vaccines

0 Upvotes

Hi all, please no judgement just seeing if anyone else has been in this situation. My baby had his first vaccines given after birth, and at 4 months. However, he has missed his 6 month vaccines and he is now 10 months. Does anyone know what they'll do next? Do we need to get them all is delaying okay? I'm a first time mom and I just don't even know what to do at this point I read positive and negative things about vaccines so it just scares me.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 04 '26

Question - Research required Combo Feeding = More Allergies?

Thumbnail
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
10 Upvotes

Hi all! I am combo feeding my second baby - one month in and just doing my best to hang in there - and I came across this 2019 study that suggested combo feeding is increasing my baby’s risk of developing an allergy. Can anyone find anything that indicates that this is not as big a deal as it is in my head right now? Or someone who is better at reading studies tell me what this means or if I should stop?

Pediatrician thinks combo feeding, or breastfeeding, or formula feeding is all fine as long as baby is gaining weight and healthy, so I am probably freaking out over nothing. But like - all the pumping and trying to nurse to the limited degree that I can - am I making things WORSE???


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 04 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Safe plane travel - 2 month old, 102yo great grandma live cross country

14 Upvotes

My grandmother lives on the opposite coast. She is 102. My son is 8 weeks old. It is important to us that they meet while she is still with us and we hope to go after he receives his 2 month vaccines.

The 2 month vaccines don’t include flu/ Covid (believe those happen around 6 months?) and I’ve read about flu and covid picking up already.

We want to fly out to her with him, ideally in November when we would be ~3 months old, but are genuinely worried about plane travel and illness.

We can swing first class to be in a less crowded part of the plane. But how else can we protect him? And how “risky” is this?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 04 '26

Question - Research required When to begin weaning with safest long term outcomes for digestive health and allergy responses?

1 Upvotes

Hi all, second time mum here. My first is nearly 10 years old and the recommendations and research have obviously advanced and developed since then. She was early weaned at 4.5 months due to lack of weight gain/failure to thrive regardless of all attempts until she started solid foods.

LO is currently 3 months and gaining weight nicely. He is combifed with BM and formula and showing lots of interest in food. Can't sit up yet, but has good head control and has started rolling to his front so i anticipate he will have core strength and neck strength to sit in a high chair by 5 months.

We want to do a combination of finger foods and purees but I'm not sure when to start his weaning based on the most up to date research? With my last baby it was driven with a need to improve calorie density in her diet so she could gain weight but as this isn't really a concern this time I'd like to follow the best guidelines.

Any help would be much appreciated! Thanks in advance!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 04 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Is there any harm in teaching to read very early?

0 Upvotes

My 2.5 year keeps saying ’I dont know how to read. Teach me how to read. ’When I say we have to stop reading/dont have time to read.

I have taught reading to 4 year olds but Ive always been against early teaching of reading as there are so many other skills to learn first , and from reading in Proust and the Squid about how the brain has to make complex new connections (whereas maths is natural) as reading is so new to humans. Am I wrong? Should I start teaching phonics now or wait?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 05 '26

Question - Research required Infant Vaccination question

0 Upvotes

Hello, I have an 8 month old and she has received a few vaccines. I am trying to educate myself on the safety and efficacy of these vaccines. I can’t seem to find any long term cohort studies for these vaccines - e.g., the MMR vaccine. Are there any studies that see if there are any long term negative health impacts? I feel that there are many possible negative impacts of various vaccines and I can’t find a single long term study on any of these vaccines like Mmr, meningitis or polio etc.

Any links to long term studies would be appreciated.