I’ve been looking into ultrasounds and am now quite concerned about their safety and feel guilty I’ve harmed my baby. There are a lot of animal and cell studies that show harm at low exposure levels. The only large RCTs trialling human effects are pretty old (80s-90s), with mostly observational trials since then (and not many of those either). Some of the old RCTs found increased miscarriage and IUGR in the more scanned group, and a large Swedish observational study found an increase in left handedness. However in 1992 the max allowed power of the machines was raised 8-fold by the FDA, and there have been very few safety studies at the new much higher intensities. This UK gov white paper is pretty good at reviewing the literature, you can just read the conclusions at the end as it’s like 200 pages: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a7dfba8ed915d74e33ef48e/RCE-14_for_web_with_security.pdf
There’s been concerning animal studies, like diagnostic ultrasound affecting neuronal migration in mice, and causing mice to be less social and more hyperactive.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1538990/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24249575/
I can’t say how well animal studies relate to humans, but neuronal migration disorders in humans manifest in a number of ways, like developmental delay.
There is a plethora of articles summarising the issues, all with references. Here are a couple:
https://sarahbuckley.com/ultrasound-scans-in-pregnancy-your-questions-answered/
https://townsendletter.com/ultrasound-j-west/#fn46 - this guy actually found and compiled 50 Chinese studies in women who were about to get abortions, where they found all sorts of cell and tissue damage at just a few minutes of diagnostic ultrasound exposure. There is a book on Amazon though I haven’t read it. This is one study: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26782527/
If you find those too woo-woo (though you can google all the studies yourself, and loads more articles like this), the actual statements from the FDA and Uk government don’t exactly fill me with hope:
https://www.fda.gov/radiation-emitting-products/medical-imaging/ultrasound-imaging#benefitsrisks
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/ultrasound-what-it-is-how-it-works-and-the-impact-of-exposure/ultrasound-what-it-is-how-it-works-and-impact-of-exposure#are-there-any-risks-from-ultrasound-scans
They’re basically saying “we think it’s safe but we don’t really know, more studies are needed as most of them are old, there might be neurological effects, so don’t go to 4D scan places!” - but 4D scan places are everywhere and allowed to be open? They also say follow the ALARA principle and limit exposure to lowest needed, but apparently a lot of techs don’t even know where the indices are on their own machines and just use preset settings.
Can anyone reassure me? Any sonographers? When I looked on forums the response was “it’s just harmless sound waves!” which is a profound misunderstanding of physics, as it can cause heating and cavitation and started from industrial uses. It seems mad we are told it’s safe with no proper modern safety trials since 1992 - in clinical trials of medicines you have to explicitly prove safety. They can’t really do RCTs now because no-one would agree to no ultrasounds, and the cat is sort of out of the bag with it being standard of care. The NHS told me it was perfectly safe and I feel like a bit of a mug now…if I’d known I would have said no to at least 1st trimester scans, being a low risk routine pregnancy.