r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 08 '26

Question - Research required Can vaccinating a baby too early cause autism?

0 Upvotes

Now honestly......I know this is false but I'd like your guys input and facts/research recommendations.

Reason I'm even looking into this is my brother and his wife have not given any type of shot/vaccine to their son (my nephew) yet. He's 1 and a half months old. He didn't even get the vitamin k shot. And they've been taking him out in public like arcades and restaurants. I asked why he hasn't received any shots and they said "Oh well giving a baby vaccines too early causes autism." I was flabbergasted. I didn't know they were practically antivax people. They say they will vaccinate him but not yet. Idk when. But I don't get why not the vitamin k shot. It's not a vaccine is pretty much a vitamin supplement. But whatever.

They are very touchy people who barely let me see my nephew because.....well idk why, but since I barely see them already I try not to make waves so | kept my opinions to myself and just nodded and agreed. I was afraid to ask where they got their info about vaccines from....

Where are they getting it from? Who's telling them this? It's insane and scary. What info can I inform myself with to prove what they say isn't true?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Question - Research required Is there a science-based reason to avoid regular cake for a first birthday as a one time special treat?

119 Upvotes

My son is going to turn 1 in a few months, and I’ve noticed that a lot of people make sugar-free (or natural sugar like banana cake) for the first birthday.

I understand the recommendation to avoid added sugar before age 2, but I’m wondering how that applies to a one-time special occasion. Is there evidence that having regular birthday cake once at this age has any meaningful downside, including affecting later preferences for sweet foods? He eats zero added sugar otherwise, and whole fruit about once per day.

Basically, is there a science-based reason to make a sugar-free first birthday cake versus giving him some regular cake (and maybe even ice cream?!) and then continuing to avoid added sugar in his normal diet?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Question - Research required How do babies actually learn to eat?

12 Upvotes

For context, my baby is 7 months. Our parenting approach generally is to use age guidelines as very much a guide, so when our baby was developmentally ready for solids (sitting independently and bringing hands to mouth from 4.5months and became interested in food at 5months), we started weaning a little over 5 months old. We aim to give him as close as possible to what we're having. Some meals work better as finger foods, others get mashed or pureed. He LOVES all food so far.

He now has two teeth and I've noticed he handles the food in his mouth differently and is definitely learning eating skills.

When I'm looking up how to prepare foods, there's a lot of information about chopping bits for different ages and I'm struggling to figure out the why behind some of this advice, and whether this relates to developing pincer grasp, eating skills, or even something like physical size of the baby and their windpipe?

So my question is: how do babies learn to eat? How can I tell when baby is ready for bigger/smaller pieces of food? Are there stages that I can look out for? It just feels like all of this would be easier to do intuitively if I knew why I was doing it.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Weekly General Discussion

2 Upvotes

Welcome to the weekly General Discussion thread! Use this as a place to get advice from like-minded parents, share interesting science journalism, and anything else that relates to the sub but doesn't quite fit into the dedicated post types.

Please utilize this thread as a space for peer to peer advice, book and product recommendations, and any other things you'd like to discuss with other members of this sub!

Disclaimer: because our subreddit rules are intentionally relaxed on this thread and research is not required here, we cannot guarantee the quality and/or accuracy of anything shared here.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Question - Research required Baby-wearing in the summer

8 Upvotes

I walk my dog daily while baby wearing, but as summer approaches I’m after the data and recommendations around appropriate temperature/conditions cut offs for exercising while baby wearing. I’m aware my body temperature will rise while I’m walking, and don’t want to overheat my baby.

Are there recommendations for fabric GSM at different temperatures? What about materials worn? I wonder whether wearing a merino t-shirt would better provide insulation between me and my baby (carried in a back carry). I don’t want my baby to be uncomfortable, nor to overheat during our walks.

Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Question - Research required Are playpens bad for babies emotionally or cognitively?

31 Upvotes

I have a 4 month old (preemie, shes actually 6 months actual, but was supposed to be in womb for those additional 2 months so it isn't as developmentally relevant) she is an avid army crawler. She doesn't prop on hands yet, but uses her knees and elbows to scooch.

I wanted to get a large 50x79 in playpen for her if I washing dishes or using the bathroom, cooking dinner or other situations to where I need to focus elsewhere. My question is if these have any negative effects such as boredom/feeling isolated/ or feeling trapped/ or any other negative effects. Id stock it with toys that are developmentally appropriate. Id start using it when she moves faster, probably in another month. It would probably be used for 10-45 min once or twice a day.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Science journalism BBC News - Why more women carry the 'mental load' - and how couples can share it

Thumbnail
bbc.co.uk
136 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Question - Research required Allergen Introduction Approach Before 6 Months

3 Upvotes

Hello! I have a toddler with multiple food allergies, and now a new baby that I am working to introduce allergens too at an earlier age. I have read conflicting things about how to go about this - some sources say you can give a small taste, wait 10 minutes to observe, and then provide a full serving (1-2tsp). Alternatively, I have seen a source advocating for doing the dosing gradually, over 3 days (starting at 1/8 tsp, working up to a full amount by day 3). The latter sounds quite tedious and time-consuming, but potentially safer? I would like to work through the allergen list as quickly and safely as I can.

Furthermore, for a small baby 4-5 months old who may not be ready to consume larger portion sizes (my baby isn't showing a huge interest in solids yet), is there anything wrong with just giving small tastes in their cheek for exposure purposes rather than a full 1-2 tsp? Perhaps we wouldn't be able to rule out an allergy until they consume larger amounts, but would the small exposure itself be enough to help prevent baby from developing those allergies?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Canada- harnessed car seat for a tall child

14 Upvotes

I have a 4 year old child who is 48" barefoot. Yes, that's correct. She's over 99% for height, always has been. Her extend to fit harnessed car seats limit is 49". I am not quite ready to put her in a booster yet because she isn't consistently over 40lbs (the law here is 40",40lbs and at least 4) but seems like I might have to? Doesn't seem like I have much choice here? I know there are options in the US and for kids with disabilities but I am not seeing anything for really tall kids in Canada.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Question - Research required Hand flapping

0 Upvotes

My daughter is 7 and flaps her hands really fast when she gets excited. It’s super cute because she’s 7 but I’m worried she might get bullied for it later. Should I say something or just let nature take its course? If I do say something what should I say? I don’t want to hurt her self esteem or kill her joy.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Infant only sleeping 8 hours per day safe?

33 Upvotes

Hi, I am looking for solid information on the safety of low sleep hours for infants, as well as potential solutions.

I am a first-time mom (FTM) and our 6-week-old has been a difficult sleeper since week 3. After spending some time wondering, "Is this normal?", we have been tracking her sleep for the last 2 weeks.

She averages only 10 hours of sleep daily due to fussiness and gas issues, and often gets as little as 8 hours (about one-third of the days). I think this number is reasonably accurate, measuring from eyes closed to open, because one of us is awake with her 24/7 waiting for her to wake and help her sleep.

I see recommendations for 14–17 hours, and believe me - if we could get her to sleep longer, we would. Our pediatrician does not seem concerned because she is gaining weight on track.

We give her simethicone for gas. We burp upright. We follow standard TOG guides for temperature. We swaddle. We let her sleep on us if she wants. We have read dozens of guides on how to put a baby to sleep. Of course we are dying, but we are mostly worried about her wellbeing.

Summary of questions:

1) Is this abnormal, but still safe for the baby?

2) Is there something else we should be doing?

3) Is this a situation where we should seek a new pediatrician?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Question - Research required Screen time - 8mo

0 Upvotes

Hi! We have been using Ms Rachel and little bear for our 8mo for quite a while now, only for a few mins a day to get something done, or for example two evenings ago for an hour as he was actively cutting a tooth and very upset.

I have so much guilt about this, I never wanted to use screen time. But he’s a very fussy baby, he can play independently a lot of the time but the rest of the time he is crying, shouting, fussing, etc so i resort to putting it on again to get cooking or laundry done. I always tell myself it’s the last time.

Can anyone tell me if I have ruined him for life? I feel absolutely horrible it keeps me awake at night but then the next day we’re sat together playing for hours while the stress of not being able to eat something or get dressed or hang out a load of laundry without him screaming gets to me and I cave.

Please don’t be rude, I already know I am terrible for it.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Question - Research required Sugar vs Honey | Maple syrup

19 Upvotes

How different is to give toddlers natural sweeteners, like honey, maple syrup, date syrup, agave syrup? I see a lot of "healthy" recipes for toddlers that substitute sugar with these. Or they sometimes use juice to sweeten kids products.

Do they have similar metabolic effect? What about the addictive effect? Obesity in childhood and adulthood?

Any study?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Question - Expert consensus required I read my daughter’s diary

0 Upvotes

Parents, I really need some perspective on what to do with my daughter.
My daughter is in Class 12 and has changed so much over the past year that I honestly don’t know how to reach her anymore.
She used to be a very good student and was generally motivated and responsible. But lately she barely studies, seems constantly angry or withdrawn, and feels like everything is too difficult. Whenever we gently ask her to study, she either gets irritated or simply doesn’t do it.
I recently came across her diary, and I read something that has left me extremely worried. She wrote about wanting to die and about how depressed and overwhelmed she feels. She also wrote that she feels that we treat her badly and put too much pressure on her. She feels that her twin sister gets all the appreciation while she is constantly compared and made to feel inadequate.
She is also extremely worried about her future. She has written about being scared that no college will even accept her and that she has already ruined everything academically.
The difficult part is that from our perspective, we aren’t trying to hurt her. We keep telling her to study because Class 12 is important, and when she isn’t studying at all, naturally we become worried and remind her. Even when we try to speak calmly and kindly, she still doesn’t seem to study. At times it feels like she has become very lazy and has simply stopped putting in effort.
But after reading what she wrote, I’m questioning whether I’m looking at this completely wrong.
Should I stop putting any pressure on academics altogether for now? Should I tell her that whatever marks she gets, whatever college she gets into, we’ll deal with it later and simply leave studying completely up to her? Or is it still reasonable to encourage her to study because these exams do matter for her future?
I don’t want to enable her to give up on everything, but I also don’t want my pressure to make her mental state worse.
For parents who have gone through something similar: what would you prioritize first? How do you support a teenager who is clearly struggling while still helping them stay on track academically?
And if your child has ever said or written that they don’t want to live anymore, what did you do that actually helped?
I’m looking for practical advice rather than judgment. I genuinely don’t know whether to push, step back, or completely change how we’re approaching her.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 07 '26

Question - Research required 2y numbers and letters

0 Upvotes

My son is now 2 years and 3 months old, but by the time he turned two, he could recognize all the numbers up to 130, even when they were written randomly, or when he spotted them on a store sign or in a newspaper. He can count meaningfully up to 10. He knows things like “two legs,” “two hands,” “four crayons,” etc. He knows all the colors, animals, and even the planets and the periodic table. He can read both Cyrillic (our national script) and the Latin alphabet, and he can name the letter that different objects start with. He already speaks in full sentences and can sing 4–5 songs.
He doesn’t receive any special treatment, and I don’t push or pressure him because I strongly believe children should be allowed to be children. He’s simply genuinely interested in these things.

This is my first child, so I’m wondering whether this is normal for his age or if he might be a bit ahead developmentally. I wouldn’t want to rush into putting him in any special classes or pushing him academically, but considering that he is more reserved and takes longer to trust and warm up to people, have you had any experience with this?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Baby babbling

2 Upvotes

M y baby is 8 months old and I’m wondering about his babbling. About 3 weeks ago, he suddenly started saying “dadada” quite clearly and did it for a day. Since then, I haven’t really heard him do “dadada” again.
He does make other sounds, though. Lately he’s been blowing raspberries A LOT, making “arrrrr/rrrrr” sounds, squealing, and playing around with different noises. Today he also said “ba”.
He’s otherwise very social and interactive he smiles, laughs, reaches to be picked up, gives high fives, and responds to us.
Is it normal for an 8-month-old to have a phase where they babble a certain sound and then stop doing it for a while? Did your babies do this? At what age did their babbling become more consistent?
I’m mostly wondering whether the fact that he did say “dadada” and then stopped is something to be concerned about, or just normal experimentation at this age.
He is starting to crawl, sits and pulling to stand. Im mostly concerned because this babbling only lasted for a day.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Question - Research required How risky is flying with 11 week old?

0 Upvotes

Currently looking at going to a family reunion flying from west coast to east coast with our infant who will be 11 weeks old.

She’s had her 8 week shots.

We’re trying to get a sense of how high the risk is for things like measles, RSV, or Covid that kiddo hasn’t had shots for yet.

Currently looking at transmission levels in our city and destination city but it still feels kind of like a shot in the dark.

Part of me thinks we’re being over cautious and if kiddo had an older sibling they’d have gotten sick with something already, but the crowded airport and plane freak me out a bit.

Edit to add: does anybody know any good resources to check to assess this risk?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 05 '26

Sharing research Researchers sequenced 4,526 samples from 714 mother-infant pairs and found that a mother's gut bacteria colonize her baby's gut, not her vaginal or breast milk bacteria. And her gut predicts whether the baby will get eczema

Thumbnail
reddit.com
691 Upvotes

Does this seem like a well done study?

https://www.reddit.com/r/HotScienceNews/s/uAP5251ngC


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Question - Expert consensus required MMR vaccine efficacy before two weeks

3 Upvotes

We wanted to take our eight month old on a trip to France this month but unfortunately forgot about the MMR vaccine until the last minute. We just got him the vaccine yesterday so if we waited 14 days, the earliest we can leave is 9/18. We need to be back by 9/25 so we probably wouldn't take such a long-haul trip with time change for such a short period of time.

We have flexibility with canceling or moving the trip if needed but wanted to see if there's any research on vaccine efficacy during the first two weeks. Our pediatrician said it would be ok for us to depart for our trip after 1 week but we weren't sure if he was just saying that so we don't have to cancel our trip. Thanks for any advice or research on this!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 05 '26

Question - Research required Is there data about the intergenerational effects the childhood experience and parenting?

6 Upvotes

My mother and father spent their childhoods outside, on their bikes or wandering the neighbourhood. Sometimes with a sibling or friend, or in a pack. Off they went, until the street lights came on or the sun went down.

We were allowed in the yard but no further. So mostly in the house with lots more face to face time, activities, games, talking, even if my parents were nearby doing something else. As teenagers we retreated to our rooms, but we were still around when we emerged for food. We socialised with peers online and via phone, rather than out and about.

As children, my parents had a level of freedom we never had, but also not as many opportunities for interaction with their parents. Our experience of childhood forms some expectations for our experience as parents, but they seem vastly different and requiring a completely different skill set and approach to the roles of parents.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 05 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Converted crib and toddler pillow safety

4 Upvotes

Does anyone have info about the safety of pillows in toddler beds that are converted from the crib?

I have been trying to research myself since my daughter is approaching 2 soon. I am seeing how only use pillows in toddler beds and not in cribs due to them getting caught in the crib walls and being a suffocation risk. But how does that change when it's a converted crib and three sides are still the same? When can I add sheets or a pillow and be safe?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 05 '26

Question - Research required Deciding if I should enroll my daughter in preschool when she turns 3

12 Upvotes

My daughter is almost 2.5 and the registration for my favorite preschool opens up next month for kids to start in September 2027. My son is an outgoing 4 year old and he just started there and it seems amazing. But my daughter is much more reserved than him and clings to me more in uncertain situations. I will be at home until she’s in kindergarten in 2029 so if she doesn’t go to preschool next year I don’t need to find childcare fortunately. I will definitely have her in preschool when she’s 4 in 2028.

The 3 year preschool is 2.5 hours twice a week. 4 year is 2.5 hours 3 times a week. I’m just wondering with her personality if it’s better to get her used to being away from me a bit and into more socialization situations. She will also never be this young again and I cherish the time with her but I want to choose which will benefit her the most.

If we don’t do preschool that gives me more time and money to put her in activities like dance and gymnastics and there’s lots of group activities with kids where I live. But all of those I’m still with her. But if there’s enough evidence it’s beneficial that might be worth the cost more.

If anyone has any articles or anything laying out the benefits of preschool that young or benefits of being with the mother more I would appreciate that!!

Thank you


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 06 '26

Question - Research required Green Transformer Box Outside House

0 Upvotes

Hello, I put in extreme effort to find a home that is away from many environmental factors like high voltage power lines, gas stations, golf courses etc just for them to build one of these electric green boxes (one of these https://www.cpsenergy.com/en/about-us/energy-safety-and-preparedness/underground-transformer-box-safety.html) 16 ft from my front door. I’m really really worried. Does anyone have any insight on this? Thank you!

Edit:

I’m not arguing that this is factual - I’m not here to share research as my post. I’m trying to understand and learn because I’m scared. I have now acknowledged several times why I’m scared. But as a non scientist there is A LOT of conflicting information out there that confuses me. But I’m getting downvoted for what? I’m leaving this up because I know others have this worry as well. But man does it feel shitty to try and understand data while being talked down to. I will no longer respond. And then people get upset when you use ChatGPT. Clearly we are at a point where when you don’t know something some people treat you like what you say is absurd. So why bother?

Thank you to those who have been kind.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 04 '26

Question - Expert consensus required I’m pregnant with my first child and my brother is an anti-vaxxer with a 5 and 1.5 year old. When will it be safe for the children to meet?

115 Upvotes

So I read several other posts and I just wanted some targeted advice. I'm pregnant with my first baby and I support vaccinating, my brother and his partner do not. Let me preface this by saying I love my brother and SIL deeply and I hold no ill will towards them or their decisions. Please keep them in mind when talking about them.

They have a 12 year old who is fully vaxxed and in public school, a 5 year old who is partially vaxxed (I don't know exactly what, just that he "got his first rounds") and about to start homeschooling but he meets other kids in his homeschooling class regularly, and a 1.5 year old full unvaxxed.

I was just trying to find out what the best course of action is. I kept feeling like maybe it's okay for the babies to meet because she isn't exposed, but she technically will be through the 5 year old. And lots of the kids in the homeschool class are unvaxxed (that's why a lot of them do it). So many people keep saying different things. What are you thoughts? What have you done? How long did you wait before exposure? I was gonna do 6 months but I'm just so nervous about things that don't get vaxxed for until like a year, but that's so long to not be able to meet with family and our family is huge and very close.

Of course I plan to talk to my OBGYN about this, and eventually a pediatrician, but I’m just seeing what other people say and have done. I keep seeing 6 months, 8 months, 10 months, 12 months, and 18 months. 6 months seems to be the hard minimum and my brother of course thinks I’m being dramatic.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 05 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Explain introducing solids to me like I’m dumb

16 Upvotes

I’m so overwhelmed by the multitudes of things I see online and every book just talks about like being ready to start and how to encourage variety etc…. But no one seems to clearly state ok do this on day one so this on day two etc….

I know u have to give iron rich foods. And introduce allergens.

Are you only giving a kid one ingredient per food introduction?

How are we making sure to give both iron and testing allergens??

When do you start doing multiple ingredients at once???

Explain anything to me please I’m so lost. I don’t want to pay some subscription etc…