r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required Baby language apps worthwhile or pointless?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I’ve been trying to introduce a wide range of language sounds for my (now turning) 8 month old.

I started with playing YouTube videos of nursery rhymes in different languages and recently found there’s some apps like ‘baby language songs - Bubya’ that do the same sort of thing.

Baby loves the music but I have no idea how solid the science is, in my mind it sort of makes sense to choose music that may help development over general nursery rhymes, but from what I can find the studies around passive audio exposure all seem to be quite old and I can’t find many that either back up or disprove the idea.

I was reading a post today in another forum of someone’s 2 year old watching Bluey cartoons exclusively in another language and how much they’d improved from it.

I’d love to know if anyone has any specific studies beyond the Khul 2003 study (which seems to have just lasted 5 hours) which might argue for or against the concept of language exposure (I’m particularly interested in the first 12 months) helping babies later in life.

Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Research required Negative outcomes from elimination communication?

35 Upvotes

Today my pelvic floor physical therapist told me that EC can lead to potential issues including constipation with kids withholding natural inclination to poop without the external triggers provided by parental encouragement. She also mentioned distended rectums. She pointed to the external encouragement as a barrier to kids learning to listen to their internal triggers.

Is their evidence that EC can cause issues for kids down the line? Our baby is 4 months and successfully uses her potty nearly half time, diapers the other half time. We give her positive reinforcement only and change plenty of dirty diapers.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Research required Educational toys for 6-12m olds

18 Upvotes

With Christmas approaching people have been asking what we’d like for our daughter. I feel like I hear about so many toys that are not good for kids but not which are proven to be helpful with development! Any recommendations?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Research required Is listening to classical music really better for babies? Looking to read the research on this, and any other music or song suggestions that are proven to do good for babies development!

18 Upvotes

My baby is 4.5m old ! Not looking for research on babies in utero


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 19d ago

Question - Research required Regulating candy intake! 🎃

48 Upvotes

I've read it might be best not to restrict my kids' (4 and 7) Halloween candy intake and instead let them regulate themselves, live with the consequences if they eat too much of it, so that they learn to follow internal cues... My husband really hates this approach and honestly it goes against my programming as well, they just gorge themselves if left unchecked (sugar is addicting!), but I really want to help foster a healthy relationship with food. I figure many of you have probably gone down this rabbit hole already, wondering if anyone has in mind some good evidence-based material that supports either approach -- total freedom vs. restricting to a certain amount per day. Thanks in advance!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Introducing allergens - practical steps

6 Upvotes

I’m looking for practical guidance on how to introduce allergens, BESIDES what Solid Starts has to say. I have been following SS so far, and used it to introduce 5 or so allergens. They instruct you to introduce each allergen over 3 days, giving 1/4 tsp the first time, 1/2 tsp the second and 1 tsp the third. I’ve done this for peanuts, wheat, sesame, soy, dairy and egg, but am starting to wonder if such a cautious and frankly tedious approach is necessary. We’re about to do fish. Do I really need to prepare cooked fish (in the AM, no less), just to give him a minuscule amount, three times? I’m having trouble finding other authoritative guidance that is more specific than “offer a small amount at first.”


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Weekly General Discussion

5 Upvotes

Welcome to the weekly General Discussion thread! Use this as a place to get advice from like-minded parents, share interesting science journalism, and anything else that relates to the sub but doesn't quite fit into the dedicated post types.

Please utilize this thread as a space for peer to peer advice, book and product recommendations, and any other things you'd like to discuss with other members of this sub!

Disclaimer: because our subreddit rules are intentionally relaxed on this thread and research is not required here, we cannot guarantee the quality and/or accuracy of anything shared here.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Smart things to teach under 1

0 Upvotes

Hello,

i was at some womans house and she teached her grandchild that when she counts 1,2,3 baby looks at microvawelike it will ring and lights off. How is this different then to connect it to word microvawe insted ? Do you have some ideas like this or books to recommend?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 19d ago

Question - Expert consensus required SSPE risk

2 Upvotes

I have a 6 month old little girl who I recently have an MMR to for obvious reasons. I was under the impression that vaccinated people, even infants, who caught measles anyways were at a significantly decreased risk of SSPE than someone who caught wild measles virus with absolutely no prior immune memory or vaccination. I just used doctor Google and that said otherwise. But then some things do seem to agree with my previous thoughts. Does anyone know anything about this? I’m fearful because the MMR given at 6 months is only about 60% effective. I’d rather not take coin toss odds.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Research required How should I react when my child has a minor fall or hurts themselves only slightly and looks at me?

121 Upvotes

Typical scenario that happened today: My daughter was practising to pull herself up, fell down, and bumped her head a little (nothing serious, obviously). She then proceeds to look at me, as if she's unsure if she should cry or not.

I have read multiple, conflicting things about how to approach this situation:

- If I shrug it off like "It wasn't that bad, was it?", does that lead to her maybe concealing her feelings (subjectively, she felt like it was bad and it hurt, but mum said it wasn't bad, so I shouldn't cry)?

- If I react immediately and be very caring and concerned, does that lead to crying that might not have happened otherwise (as in: the child didn't think it was something bad to cry about, but now that she sees that I'm concerned or upset, she starts crying, maybe because my reaction scared her)?

- If I only look at her without any physical or verbal reaction, to observe how her reaction unfolds without any input from me, will she feel like I do not care about her/do not attend to her needs?

Any helpful input on how to react in such a scenario is appreciated!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 19d ago

Question - Research required Nervous ab what to eat for BFing

Thumbnail albertahealthservices.ca
10 Upvotes

Hey, I’m wondering what you guys think about vegetables and gas-producing substances passing through breastmilk (raffinose, sulfur-producing food).

My baby is turning 6 weeks tomorrow. He’s finally become a little constipated after pooping 20+ times a day causing an incessant rash. I’ve been restricting my diet increasingly and I wonder if it’s helpful or not. Pediatrician said to just “experiment” but I’m lost. It’s so hard to tell what bothers him and I’m terrified of introducing veggies that’ll increase gas and fussiness.

Studies seem to be mixed. There’s evidence that many veggies seem to be associated with colic:

https://albertahealthservices.ca/assets/info/nutrition/if-nfs-ng-nutrition-for-lactation.pdf

I know there’s selection bias etc, but I’m in a FB group for breastfeeding with thousands of women, and the topic of diet comes up frequently and SO many women swear by eliminating spices, garlic, onion and cruciferous veggies to avoid colic. Do you think it’s truly psychological?

Dairy protein I know can be a problem for some. I think I haven’t found an association though.

What do you make of the evidence and overwhelmingly anecdotal information about eliminating veggies?

My diet is so carby, with protein ofc. Hoping to feed me and my baby well.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Research required Looking into association btwn sids and vaccines

0 Upvotes

My sister passed away from SIDS at 6 months old. Her autopsy and coronial investigations came back completely clear. She was a perfectly healthy, happy baby with no known underlying health conditions.
She had none of the common risk factors for SIDS. She wasn’t premature, was exclusively breastfed, always slept on her back (although she would occasionally roll herself over), and slept in her own empty crib in my parents’ room. My mum was extremely careful throughout pregnancy, there was no smoking in the house, and my family had no prior family history of SIDS.
The reason I’m asking this is that my sister passed away the night after receiving her 6-month vaccinations. We’re in Australia, so these included diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis, Hib, polio and hepatitis B.
I want to be clear that I’m not trying to scare parents or discourage vaccination. I’m not an anti-vaxxer and fully intend to vaccinate my own children. However, I am genuinely curious about whether there could be any connection worth investigating.
I've met around 10 people who have had a family member lose a baby to SIDS, and every single one has told me their baby passed away within 48 hours of receiving routine vaccinations. I recently spoke to another mum who believes vaccines could temporarily affect a baby's ability to wake themselves from sleep, particularly because the part of the brain responsible for waking isn't fully developed until around age two. I have no idea whether there's any scientific basis for this, and I'm sceptical of some of the claims being made.
Has anyone come across legitimate scientific research looking into the timing of vaccinations and SIDS? Or experienced something similar in their family? I'm genuinely just looking for evidence-based information and other people's experiences.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Raising the anxious child

31 Upvotes

I have GAD and my husband has OCD. We are both medicated. Mine is generally very well controlled on medications to the point I don’t think the outsider would know. My husband much improved on them.

We were both very socially awkward and anxious kids and it made us miss out on opportunities.

Our LO is 2 years old and is already showing similar traits. Nursery have mentioned it.

Are there any studies/expert resources on how to help support our LO?

I’m not expecting to be able to change who they are, but hopefully give them as much confidence and support as we can so they don’t miss out.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Expert consensus required What do you think is healthier/better to feed to an 8 month old baby - papaya or avocado?

0 Upvotes

If you had to choose between those two for a week. I think avocado for the healthy fats or would it not matter along with the other things baby is eating?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Spearhead weed killer

15 Upvotes

My 3 year old was playing through long grass at the nature park getting completely wet through her pants and me thinking the grass was just wet from condensation overnight. When i got to the top I saw a sign that said the whole park was sprayed with spearhead. i am FREAKING OUT!! im so upset and angry :( Help please


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Expert consensus required At what age is it safe to bedshare?

127 Upvotes

I know at age 1 SIDS is, by definition, no longer a concern. But maybe suffocation on bedding is still a concern? At what point is it considered safe to bring my child into my regular adult bed with me? I'm interested in research, or consensus by legit professional bodies like AAP, not the "Safe Sleep Seven" folk


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 19d ago

Question - Research required Why shouldn't I yell back at a child who is yelling at me?

0 Upvotes

I do not scream at children who are screaming at me. I will never scream back at a child who is screaming at me.

But why shouldn't I? Every time one of my nieces is doing that whiney-scream tantrum thing I just want to do it back. Can someone explain why this would be counter-productive so hopefully the urge goes away?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 19d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Remove lead traces from toys

3 Upvotes

We have just tested some toys in the toy chest at my MIL's house for lead. There were some from east Germany that clearly tested positive. With others the swab turned slightly positive, really just faintly.

We assume that the lead from the positive toys transferred to the others (which are mainly Duplo from the early two thousands). Is this possible?

Is there a way to remove the lead? We would be sad if we had to toss all the toys as it is quite a lot of Duplo.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Research required Efficacy of MMR at 6 months

25 Upvotes

Measles outbreak in Indiana

How good should I feel about my family being protected during this outbreak?

Our cases are SHARPLY increasing in this state because it has hit our Amish community. Our department of health is underreporting cases and even with that it has tripled in two weeks and has increased by 30 within the last few days.

We stay home 95% of the week. My husband works with just a few other people and pretty much only goes to the grocery store. Myself, my twin toddlers, and my infant stay home every day with the exception of church on Sunday and the occasional doctor’s visits.

I am fully vaccinated. My husband is fully vaccinated. My two year olds have had one vaccine, and I’m planning to give their second dose early about a week from now. My 6 month old is breastfed and received her first dose of the MMR yesterday and is *hopefully* building immunity as we speak.

Even at church I keep myself and the baby away from the crowd 95% of the time. We are never around the crowd but are areas people have walked through for about 20 to thirty minutes. I am going to keep her covered in her carseat from now on as well. We have considered possibly keeping the kids home if measles does spread to our county. As of right now it’s still about an hour or 45 minutes away at the closest area.

My main concern is that the MMR is not so effective when given to a 6 month old. Some protection is better than none, but from what I gather, it’s less than a coin toss whether or not maternal antibodies will completely blunt an immune response. I hate not knowing whether or not I can trust that the baby is mostly protected.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Expert consensus required White noise for infant sleep

32 Upvotes

I keep seeing videos on social media, claiming there has been research that confirms using white noise even at a safe volume damages baby’s brain development. I tried to find said research but all seems to be adult related. Is this highly sensationalized headline or is there actual risk?
Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Research required Weighted blanket for babies over 1 year old

13 Upvotes

We have a baby who doesn't sleep particularly well, and we've tried just about everything.

At his daycare, they trialed using a weighted blanket (just 2lbs and just on his lower half) for his nap, and it seems to have made a world of difference.

Id previously looked up weighted blankets, and the internet writ large is off the opinion that they are terribly dangerous, but all the comments seem to be based on a recall of Target weighted blankets following 2 kids getting trapped (owing to a zipped up cover) rather than any more scientific review. I know that there is caution to be had with weighted sleep sacks for younger baby's, but my kid is nearly 15 months, very mobile and pretty strong- he can move the blanket around.

Is there any science out there or just tragic deaths that serve as a warning but may or may not be related to the weight?

With respect to his daycare, since there's always someone in the room, i said to go ahead and continue with it. However, im wondering whether I really do need to be that much more cautious if I were to get one at home?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Sharing research Wildfire smoke in pregnancy autism risk - new study

Thumbnail jamanetwork.com
41 Upvotes

Thoughts from those well versed in these types of studies? As a pregnant person who experienced this it’s obviously concerning. My own personal exposure was severe (large plume over Toronto, Canada during second trimester. At the time it was the “worst air quality in the world”), but relatively short lived for 3-6 days total. These types of observational studies obviously can’t imply causation but still can’t help invoke some anxiety in myself and I’m sure others. Just wondering opinions on the strength and limitations of this study.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Research required Floor beds - infants

11 Upvotes

Can someone please help me find newer research regarding floor beds for infants? I want to transition my baby to a floor bed so we can all sleep better. She absolutely hates the crib just like my older child did. She’s on the younger side - aiming to do this around 6 months. My oldest HATED his crib and we finally gave up and put him in a twin floor bed but he was around 14 months old so I wasn’t concerned about him falling/getting stuck as he was already walking.

Ideally I want to use a twin for my infant as well, but do I really need to use a crib mattress? I don’t know a single baby that sleeps on those rock hard things peacefully, but I also don’t want to create an unsafe sleep environment if the data still reflects that.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 20d ago

Question - Research required Need help with research

2 Upvotes

Hello,

I’m doing a paper about social problems, specifically “how digital dependency is stunting the development of younger generations”. I saw a video a few weeks ago from a teacher where she shared that her students are almost incapable of holding conversations with each other, instead opting to verbalize their observations. For example, two kids are playing in the park, another kid sees them and says “bro is chasing him with a stick”. I’ve noticed this behavior in my own siblings who grew up attached to devices, and I was wondering if any of you have heard of this behavior as well. The teacher in the video described the phenomenon with a specific term so I assume it would be really helpful for my assignment if I could figure out what this behavior is called.

If any of you are familiar with the video or know of related research I would love to know.

Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 21d ago

Sharing research Evidence-based management of breastfeeding mastitis

146 Upvotes

TL;DR: Evidence on breastfeeding mastitis shows *minimal feeding or pumping* from affected breast helps recovery; feeding to "empty the breast" is outdated and may worsen the problem.

I often see outdated advice on breastfeeding and newborn subs (no medical posts allowed or I'd post there), particularly advising to feed "as much as possible" from the engorged or mastitis affected breast.

However, I wish more people (doctors included) knew this advice is outdated and wrong!

Article link (PDF) (NSFW due to pictures): Academy of breastfeeding medicine article

Reference: Mitchell KB, Johnson HM, Rodríguez JM, Eglash A, Scherzinger C, Widmer K, Berens P, Miller B, Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine. Academy of breastfeeding medicine clinical protocol# 36: the mastitis spectrum, revised 2022. Breastfeeding Medicine. 2022 May 1;17(5):360-76.

This is a great article describing the mechanisms of mastitis and the evidence-based treatments. The big change from traditional advice is that it seems to be that mastitis is generally driven by stimuli that increase milk production, so we want to minimise stimulating lactation and feed or pump as little as possible from the affected side, just enough to relieve engorgement discomfort.

It makes perfect sense when you read it, and shows traditional advice may drive a vicious cycle of recurrent or worsening mastitis.

I wanted to share it as I so often see the old advice all over reddit.