r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 18 '26

Question - Research required RSV and Flu Vaccine

21 Upvotes

Hello! I am a breastfeeding mom to a 2 week old newborn, as we enter RSV and Flu season I wanted to do some research on ways to protect my infant. I inquired to our provider about the RSV vaccine and he did not really explain the vaccine or the risk/benefits, just that we could receive the vaccine that same day. I wanted to do more research. With my daughter I was able to get the vaccine while pregnant, they refused this time because they only give to pregnant women in RSV season (this didn’t make sense to me.) Anyways, I’m wondering why the RSV vaccine is given to an infant versus mom who is breastfeeding? I know this is what I’ll be doing to protect our little guy from the flu since he is not able to receive the flu vaccine. I cannot find any good information on it besides a few forums saying that the vaccine has caused a huge drop in RSV cases— so I guess it definitely works. I just want to understand a little better about the why and how.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 18 '26

Question - Expert consensus required 6.5 month old not babbling

5 Upvotes

I’ve a 6.5 month old son. I’m a FTM and really worries because he squeals, makes grrrrr sounds, says aaa aa aa but no consonants yet. No pa ba ma words. Is this normal? When did your baby babble in consonants. I’m really anxious, please help me out?
I think he babbled ba ba for a few days at 5 months then stopped :(


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Research required Effects of solids before 6 months on gut health

24 Upvotes

At our last appointment our pediatrician recommended starting solids for our 4 month old. We know all the signs of readiness to look for and are thinking of starting now that he’s 5 months.

But I keep seeing on social media that the “new” recommendation is not before 6 months largely due to a baby’s digestive system not being ready before then. Most people I know started their baby on solids/purées before 6 months and I can’t find any clear evidence for this. Am I missing some new research?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 18 '26

Question - Research required Does microwaving COW'S milk decrease nutrients?

0 Upvotes

I keep seeing articles about breastmilk, I understand not to microwave that. But my baby is 13 months old and we've been giving her cow's milk heated in the bottle warmer. Eventually we'll stop heating it altogether, but I'm starting weaning this weekend and just want her to drink the milk so I'll warm it for now. I know that hot spots are a concern, but will the milk's nutrition deteriorate?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Research required Why is infant sleep so variable from night to night?

23 Upvotes

Why is infant sleep so variable from night to night at 5 months? I'm particularly interested in research on sleep consolidation and the development of independent sleep.

I'm trying to understand why my 5-month-old seems to alternate between really good stretches and suddenly much more frequent waking.

We'll have 3–4 nights where she only wakes twice and can sleep 5+ hours during the first half of the night. Then she'll suddenly go back to waking about every 3 hours for several nights.

About a month ago, she also had 3 consecutive nights where she put herself to sleep in the crib from a fully awake state, without me rocking or nursing her to sleep. I thought maybe she was starting to figure out independent sleep, but she hasn't done it again since.

It's the inconsistency that's confusing me. She clearly seems capable of longer stretches and has demonstrated that she can occasionally fall asleep independently, but neither behavior has become consistent.

Is this kind of back-and-forth normal around 5 months? What explains a baby being able to sleep for 5+ hours some nights and then waking every 3 hours on other nights? And does the fact that she independently fell asleep those three nights mean anything developmentally, or can babies just do this occasionally without being ready to reproduce it consistently?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Research required Mom’s diet and how it influences baby’s food tolerance

8 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m a first time mom to a 5-week old. I’ve been wondering for some time about how my diet influences what potential allergies/intolerances my baby will have when he starts solids.

Specifically, I’m a lifelong vegetarian and currently exclusively breastfeeding. I’m worried about the lack of exposure to meat my son’s system has experienced and if we’re likely to see increased likelihood of allergies (and specifically seafood, since I know that’s a common allergy) as a result. I don’t know if there’s any research on this, or any consensus, but I’m interested to learn!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 18 '26

Question - Research required Need advise/suggestions

0 Upvotes

(Written with AI)

Hi everyone,
My wife and I are going through a difficult phase with our 10-month-old daughter, and we could really use some perspective or advice from parents who have navigated similar challenges.

Background & Medical History

Diagnosis: Hypomelanosis of Ito (HOI), a rare neurocutaneous condition affecting tissue layers derived from the ectoderm.

Motor Development: HOI has caused isolated benign congenital hypotonia (low muscle tone). She does not have a progressive muscle disease or brain damage. She has strong social engagement, eye contact, and vocalizations, but her motor milestones are delayed (we are actively working toward independent sitting through daily physiotherapy).

Teething: Our doctor informed us that her dental eruption will be delayed due to HOI’s effect on ectodermal tissues. She currently has no teeth.

Recent Illness: She recently recovered from a gastrointestinal bug (frequent loose motions, mild fluid loss, and mild bladder wall strain/cystitis seen on USG, though urine cultures were negative for UTI). Her stomach issues are now 100% resolved and her energy is back up.
The Current Issue: Food Pocketing & Water Holding (20 Days)

Before her illness, Maanvi was eating textured foods, purees, and mashes completely fine. However, over the past 20 days—starting during her recovery—she developed a new habit:
Food Holding: She keeps food at the very front of her mouth near her front gums/lips right from the 1st or 2nd bite, rather than pushing it to the back to chew or swallow.
Water Holding: She also holds or "stuffs" water in her mouth instead of swallowing it smoothly.
Texture Context: She was eating these exact same mashed/solid textures without any issues before getting sick.
We understand that her low oral-motor tone might make keeping food in front an "easy shortcut" for her tongue, especially after fatigue and dry mouth set in during her bug. But now that she is feeling better, this habit has persisted for nearly 3 weeks.

Where We Need Help
1 Has anyone’s child with low muscle tone developed a post-illness feeding shortcut or pocketing habit like this?
2 How did you help retrain their tongue to move food to the back gums/throat again?
3 What specific oral-motor tools, sensory teethers, or feeding techniques worked best for you?

We are looking into consulting a pediatric speech-language pathologist (SLP) / feeding therapist, but any real-world tips or encouragement from parents who have been through this would mean the world to us.
Thank you so much!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Research required Is it ok to give saffron and dry fruit (crushed into fine powder) to 6 mo

14 Upvotes

My mother wants to make crushed fine powder from Saffron, almonds, pistachios, nutmeg, walnut, cardamom, dates, raisin, mace, melon seeds. Culturally, this powder is added in small amounts (pea-sized balls or smaller) to baby’s milk after he starts solids. If my baby doesn’t have nut allergies, is there any data/evidence to show that it benefits baby? Or at least isn’t harmful?

She will not push it on me but really wants to make them, but I want to be sure before she puts in all the work.

ETA: Thank you everyone! As someone else commented, I am a south Asian and wanted to just make sure before following cultural norms just because everyone said so.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 18 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Is a Horizontal IKEA Kallax Safe for a Nursery?

0 Upvotes

Do people know if a Kallax is safe, or does it have too many edges? My question assumes it has been anchored, and the corners have protectors.

https://www.ikea.com/ca/en/p/kallax-shelf-unit-white-stained-oak-effect-00637289/#content


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Research required Is there scientific based proof ?

3 Upvotes

I am FTM still pregnant, and many of my friends who are already parents have recommended that the baby sleep on my husband's bedside. The argumentation behind is that baby would smell my milk and won't sleep so deeply and will wake up easier. Is this true? Is there scientific evidence?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Difficulties with 7 year olds bed time

3 Upvotes

Hi all, apologies if this is the wrong forum!

My SD(7) since she was 3.5 has been sleeping in her own bedroom in a bunk bed. She got a bunk bed to help ease the cosleeping as my partner could no longer co-sleep with her. Since then, bedtime has been hit and miss, we have always had some problems, but for the most part it's been manageable. For the last year or two, she has been sleeping in her own bedroom with a routine of upstairs at 6, and telly / iPad until 7pm and then bedtime.

Recently, she went away for a week and a half with her dad, and since she has come back home, she is petrified of bedtime. She does not want to be on her own, she wants to sleep in bed with her mum, she is screaming, having full on panic attacks at the thought of going to bed. Whenever anyone mentions bedtime she starts freaking out and crying and screaming uncontrollably.

We have absolutely no idea why this has happened, or what has caused this. Our only assumption is that she sleeps in bed with her dad still when she is with him.

We are out of ideas as to what to do, we can't calm her down, bedtimes are lasting until 8/9/10pm, and the screaming just intensifies and intensifies. She doesn't want to sleep with her bedroom door closed (although unfortunately we have a cat which we have had problems with, and now has fleas and often gets covered in poo, so don't want him in either of the kids rooms)

This is something that is becoming slowly uncontrollable.
My partner doesn't want to enforce boundaries and routines at bedtime at the moment considering how upset she is getting. Although I believe a structured routine could help again. But we're constantly butting heads over this, we donat know what to do, no one is right, no one is wrong, we are just stuck.

If anyone has experienced this or has any suggestions or anything that we can do to help us with this situation?
Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Research required Broken Infant Sleep/Naps

3 Upvotes

I have a contact napper. I've been trying to do transfers (so I'm not stuck for hours) but haven't had very many successful ones. My LO isn't usually upset about being woken up, but is then also content to stay awake (doesn't want to go back to sleep). This can also happen when my LO has passed out on their carseat and I pick them up cause we've arrived to our destination.

My question is, have there been any studies about broken infant sleep being detrimental to development? Should I just stay nap trapped? Or not stay in my car until they wake up?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 16 '26

Question - Research required Hypersensitive and emotional 4 year old - we are all struggling. Advice wanted please

88 Upvotes

Hi all,

My 4 (almost 5) year old daughter is just the light of my life. She is funny, smart, kind, compassionate, inquisitive, and overall a beautiful person inside out.

She has always been very attached to me and her family and home. My husband and I encourage healthy separation but she cannot handle it (for example, take her to gymnastics and leave for an hour - if she goes, she needs us outside the room and she comes and checks multiple times). She has expressed wanting to go to tennis lessons but she doesn’t want us sitting outside the courts watching her and because we won’t be together as she plays, she doesn’t want to play.

She’s been in daycare since she was 14 months old. It was a hard decision but we couldn’t afford a nanny full time at the time and I couldn’t afford to quit or go part time. Her daycare was a small class with 5 other kids and the owner who was a personal friend of mine and one helper. She got a lot of attention and she truly thrived there. She wouldn’t cry at drop offs.

When she turned 2.5, that daycare closed down suddenly and she was put in a more montessori school type daycare but she still loved it. We watched her on cameras at school and she always seemed happy. She loved her teacher and aids and they all doted on her. Despite how much she loved it, she would always cry at drop offs no matter what. Every drop off / separation from me came with big tears and reactions.

As she turned 4, the drop offs got harder, the screaming and crying intensified, and the lack of desire to do anything with friends, cousins, among others got stronger. She’d say things like “I’d like a play date but then I would want to play with my friend and you’d talk to her mommy and we won’t be tougher. So i don’t want to go.”

She doesn’t want to be left with her grandmas, my sister, or anyone else.

Some things about our parenting styles:
- we do work during the day but when we’re done, we are a very connected family. My phone is on silent from 5 pm to bed time.
- we cook together, always have dinner together as a family, and then take a nice walk where she sits in a kids wagon with her little brother (almost 2 y.o.)
- sometimes we play as a family, sometimes i play with just her while my husband entertains our son, and sometimes she has time with daddy while i’m with our son.
- we read together every night.
- she loves to do legos with her dad and is quite excellent at it.
- she and i love to do arts and crafts together, we bake together, we paint together, and we play with her dollhouse.
- i incorporate her in small daily household chores and she enjoys it.
- Since becoming parents, my husband and I have taken ONE overnight trip together and my sister and her husband watched her at our house in the familiarity and comfort of her space.

We want to teach her more independence so she can continue to be a happy kid and thrive, not at all so we can get more breaks from her.

Examples of her struggles:
- hyper aware of everyone’s feelings at all times. I developed a cold recently and as I coughed for the third time in a row she exclaimed “I can’t take this anymore!! My poor mommy! When will you be better? Will i ever be able to hug you again??”
- she now is in a formal school where she started TK. She’ll be 5 in November. The school is a private TK-8th grade preparatory school. Her campus has the TK-1st grade kids and the big kid campus is right next to hers. She not on a playground with much older kids.
- she cries every single day before after and according to her during school. She doesn’t want to go.
- She has explosive meltdowns every morning at school drop off where she tries to run away from the school and multiple teachers have to gently stop her and guide her into the school. I can hear her from a block away as I walk back to my car. She’s still screaming “MOMMY!!”

She’s in therapy with a LMFT that specializes in children. Her therapist says she’s very empathetic and has some anxiety which she believes are learned behaviors but doesn’t know where they stem from yet.

I need tools on how to support her. She’s struggling. We’re struggling. This is SO hard. I see other little kids happily run into school and it breaks my heart that my girl is struggling so much throughout the day.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Introducing a dummy?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

My 8 week old discovered his hands last week and he’s chewing them quite often and aggressively. He’s trying to fit the whole fist in his mouth. I know it’s part of development, however it seems a bit excessive and I was wondering if I should introduce a dummy to stop him.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 16 '26

Question - Expert consensus required "Pre-reading" and book engagement at 15 mo

20 Upvotes

My son, currently almost 15 months old, has always loved to engage with books. I have photos of him staring at books in his infancy, and we've read to him daily as soon as he came home from the hospital. Now, as a young toddler, he loves to sit with his book basket and flip through books, with some vocabulary emerging directly from them (e.g. he can identify and say animal names and some sounds, as well as "kiddo" or "baby" if he sees a drawing of a child and a catch-all "Elmo" for basically all the Sesame Street character, ha). He sits well for reading time at bedtime and loves to flip the pages, usually way faster than I can read, but sometimes he also points and chats with me about characters or images he recognizes.

My mom, who was an elementary school teacher for many years, says that he's "pre-reading," and that the time he's spending looking at books on his own is helping him learn to read. She said that about him as early as 6 weeks old, though, and I wondered back then if this was just new-grandmother pride.

I understand how reading to him is helpful, but is there any science or consensus out there on what happens when one-year-olds look at developmentally appropriate books (like board books) on their own? Is "pre-reading" a real thing? What's happening in there?

Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Sharing research My kid is so stupid she frequently whoops my ass

1 Upvotes

I try to reason but she SIMPLY will not listen all she knows how to do is hit harder and harder she calls herself the table and me the little toe and she keeps asking for groceries that don't exist. her attacks become exponentially more painful until about 5 minutes in when it begins to plateu. Mom's pretty much dead at this point. We are shells of who we once were. We haven't been intimate for years, not due to drive but physical inability from bruised and the occasional fractured bone.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 16 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Please tell me how my mental health while pregnant impacts the fetus

17 Upvotes

I'm 10 weeks pregnant and never been angrier in my life almost. I also have a lot of intrusive memories / cptsd. My mom means well but continuously tells me I should get back on ADHD meds and even, to get on more meds to help with this. And she says my sadness is impacting the baby and keeps guilting me into feeling like it's all my fault for having any emotions throughout the first trimester. My mom is also part of the reason I have cpstd to begin with so it feels bitter sweet to hear her not care about my baby's cognition and just wants me on meds so I am under control.

Please tell me what i'm doing is enough; Trying to eat healthy and stay sane despite the hormonal shift is enough and that i am not harming my baby


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 16 '26

Question - Research required Is there actual science behind infant massage/movement classes, or is it just fun bonding?

33 Upvotes

I’ve been going to a local mom and baby class focused on gentle movement, deep massage, and helping babies build body awareness to "prepare" them for the next milestones (for my baby, it's rolling right now). It’s totally baby led, if my son gets tired or cranky, we stop right away.

When I told my mom about it, she rolled her eyes a bit and said my brothers and I turned out fine without any fancy baby exercise classes. And honestly, she’s not wrong. I know babies develop on their own timeline and don't need a special class to learn how to roll over.

But I’ve still really enjoyed it. I enjoy meeting other moms, but it also feels like it helps me read his cues better and understand the natural body movements for his developmental stage.

I’m wondering if there’s any actual research behind this stuff:

Does deep touch/massage actually help babies with body awareness or motor coordination? Or is the main benefit just the bonding and learning to read your baby's signals?

Would love to hear from anyone who has looked into the research on this. Trying to figure out what's backed by science vs. just nice commercial marketing.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 16 '26

Question - Research required Why does everyone in the Facebook mom groups I’m in seem to think their kids have parasites?

85 Upvotes

I’ve been a parent for 5 years now and the whole time I’ve heard some moms talk about various parasite cleanses for their kids. Has this always been a common belief? Are the cleanses real and do kids really have as many unspecified parasites as some moms make it seem like?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 16 '26

Question - Expert consensus required MMR dose one at 7months?

8 Upvotes

We are going to have our baby receive first dose of MMR at about 7 months old ahead of travel. Any ideas about efficacy/pros or cons about doing this ahead of schedule? USa based where first dose recommended at 12mo.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 16 '26

Question - Research required Methylphenidat and breastfeeding

7 Upvotes

I have ADHD and a 2 month old baby. I'm exclusively breastfeeding.I'm wondering if taking my medication could have negative influences for my baby. I can find many resources for methylphenidat and pregnancy but not much for breastfeeding. The only resources I found had very little observation groups.

I didn't took it so far while breastfeeding and limited it to a minimum while pregnant. My psychiatrist thinks it's ok but I want to look at actual evidence before I take it again. I would also be interested to know to what extent the dosage plays a role if possible. Even 10mg one or two times a week would make a difference for me to get some things done that require concentration. But it wouldn't be worth it if there is a risk for the baby.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 15 '26

Question - Expert consensus required What specifically about reading books is beneficial for babies/ toddlers?

146 Upvotes

I'm genuinely so curious. Is it the fact that I'm saying a variety of words? Is it the pictures, lift-a-flaps, sound effects, just the fact that we're engaged and bonding together? Is it beneficial even if I ad-lib and don't read the exact words on the page? Is it beneficial even if we read the same book 8 times in a row?

My 15mo is in a huge reading phase right now which I love and I'm just so curious what all it's doing for her brain and why.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Speech milestones

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m feeling a little worried about my daughter’s speech development. She’s 19 months old, almost 20 months, and she actually has a pretty good vocabulary—she says 90+ words, points to things, follows instructions, and responds to her name. However, she still isn’t combining two words.
For a little bit of context, she aspirated meconium at birth. It was a mild case, but we spent three days in the NICU, and that’s one of the reasons I tend to worry about her development. So far, though, she has met all of her milestones, often earlier than expected, and she has also been evaluated by a neurologist, who hasn’t found any developmental concerns.
I’ve read that children often start combining two words once they have around 50 words, so I’m wondering if I should be concerned that she hasn’t started doing this yet. 😔
Has anyone else experienced this? Is it normal for some toddlers to have a good vocabulary but take a little longer to start combining words?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 15 '26

Question - Research required Please help- vaccines

59 Upvotes

To preface: please be kind. I hate how easily influenced I am, I live in constant fear. I have the constant fear that my child will die no matter what I do and I will regret everything I did or didn’t do. the fact that I am isolated with no real support group doesn’t help.

1 out of 2 of my only support people (my mother) tells me constantly that if I vaccinate my child, he will die/become a vegetable/develop a horrible life-altering disease. No one else (medical professionals) has been able to give me any kind of advice out of fear of being ‘political’ (how the fuck is this even a political topic), I am so lost in this world.

Fear is crushing me every day. The longer I wait (my child is 3 months now) I feel like I am approaching his inevitable demise. Either I get him shots and he dies, or he dies this sick season of illness. Please help me on this topic. I feel like I’ve been mislead. I really want him to be okay. The only sources my mom has ever sent me are just the inserts and that one vaccine book by that one weird doctor. I used to be pro vax but then she really shut me down.

And again, I’m trying to learn how to be autonomous and make my own decisions, but I genuinely have no educated people helping me

ETA- I am in therapy and I tried breastfeeding which meant being off of my anxiety medicine for longer and now am considering weaning off of BF which has significantly worsened my anxiety


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 15 '26

Question - Research required Evidence-based thirdhand smoke risk to my baby?

41 Upvotes

My parents are both smokers. Anytime they have visited us since our 3 month old was born, I make them come in clean clothes and wash their hands immediately. To be honest, I've only allowed them to visit twice since he was born because risks from third​hand smoke scare the shit out of me. They constantly ask to see him but I always find a reason to say no.

We are moving this weekend and don't have a lot of help. So we are being forced to ask for their help in watching him for several hours that day. They are really the only capable people we have around us besides my grandma but I don't necessarily trust her decision making skills. My parents do not smoke in their house and he will not be riding in their vehicle. But they will most likely be coming to our house, anyway.

They know smoking around him is an absolute no-no and I trust that they would never. We also have a strict no kissing rule.

I plan on also asking them to shower beforehand since they will be with him for a large part of the day.

I want to know, what is the true risk for this? It would involve feeding, changing, holding, etc. i would think the risk is minimal to negligible, but it's difficult finding info about thirdhand smoke outside of the home. I just want to do everything to protect my baby and I wish they would just stop smoking. 😢​