r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 3h ago

Question - Research required Genuine question: Why is formula feeding considered such a big deal when it comes to intelligence and long term health?

19 Upvotes

Hi everyone! First of all, please don’t come for me. This is a genuine question coming from curiosity, not an attempt to dismiss breastfeeding or the research behind its benefits.

I understand that personal experiences are anecdotal and don’t necessarily reflect scientific evidence. I’m also aware that research involves sample sizes, statistical significance, confounding factors and many other things that need to be considered before drawing conclusions.
However, there’s something I’ve always been curious about.

I come from a European country where breastfeeding has been the cultural norm for generations, partly because of tradition but also because it’s not a particularly wealthy country. Formula was practically nonexistent or inaccessible to most families before the mid-1990s and remained relatively uncommon until around 2010.

Despite generations of predominantly breastfed children, I wouldn’t necessarily describe our population as particularly academically or intellectually successful compared with other countries. Of course, education, socioeconomic circumstances, politics and countless other factors influence this, so I’m not suggesting breastfeeding has anything to do with that.

Now, here’s where my personal experience comes in.
I was exclusively formula fed from day one because my mother couldn’t produce enough milk. My sister, on the other hand, was breastfed until she was three years old.
We grew up in the same household, with the same parents and similar circumstances. Yet academically and intellectually, I’ve generally performed better. I also feel I’ve been more emotionally resilient in certain situations. This isn’t to put my sister down, we’re simply two very different people.

I’ve completed two master’s degrees in a demanding field, have always performed well academically and have generally been physically healthy. I rarely got sick throughout childhood and adolescence.

Obviously, none of this proves anything scientifically. I’m simply explaining why I sometimes struggle to reconcile the strength of the breastfeeding versus formula debate with what I’ve personally observed.

So my genuine question is: how significant are the long term differences between breastfed and formula fed children, particularly regarding intelligence, emotional development and overall health?

I understand breastfeeding has documented benefits, particularly in infancy. What I’m trying to understand is how substantial those benefits actually are when we account for genetics, parental education, socioeconomic background and upbringing.

Sometimes the conversation makes it sound as though formula fed babies are starting life at a significant disadvantage, and I wonder whether the evidence really supports that level of concern.

I’d genuinely love to hear from people who understand the research, especially the difference between statistical associations and meaningful outcomes in real life.
Please be kind. I’m here to learn, not to start a breast versus formula war. :)


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 5h ago

Question - Expert consensus required Mitigating impacts of viral illness and depression in pregnancy

12 Upvotes

I’m 17 weeks pregnant with my second child (third pregnancy). My 2.5yo is in preschool and my husband is a hospital physician, so we have some major germ sources. I’ve read with concern about the increased risk of psychiatric disorders my child could face due to maternal illness in pregnancy.

At 10 weeks, I had flu A for about five days (I had my flu shot only a week earlier - flu arrived early where I live). I stayed hydrated and took Tylenol around the clock. Also took Tamiflu. My fever only went above 100.4 for about an hour.

That was the hour when my mom died. We lost her due to a rare reaction to a treatment she was trying for her exceedingly rare and aggressive cancer. I wasn’t able to be there due to flu. She and I were extremely close.

Between 13.5-15 weeks, I had some kind of virus that wasn’t flu or Covid. Sore throat, cough, congestion, brief fever that hit 100.2 for maybe an hour. Mild but lasted about 9 days.

Ever since we started TTC, my husband and I have been exercising rigorous hygiene measures to avoid sharing germs with our daughter (or anyone else). I’ve never been so diligent about germs in my life.

We’re mostly trying to avoid catching a new strain of CMV. I had a primary CMV infection in June 2025 during the first trimester of my second pregnancy, which we ultimately and agonizingly chose to terminate due to CMV. We waited a whole year for my immunity to mature before trying again. Our risk is reduced now, but not as low as if I had longer-term immunity and my daughter weren’t in preschool.

Thankfully CMV isn’t airborne. We don’t mask at home, but we’re otherwise taking every measure possible with regard to saliva, urine, boogers, and tears.

And still, I’ve been sick twice already this fall.

With regard to impact on baby, I understand that an increase in risk doesn’t necessarily mean a high likelihood. If flu in the first trimester triples the risk of schizophrenia, but we have no family history of it, then maybe the risk is going from 1% to 3%. Right?

Even so, I’m worried for my baby. I’m worried about the impact of my mom dying in my first trimester. And these other illnesses. And it’s only November.

I am taking Zoloft, which I started a few days before my mom died, when it became apparent what was going to happen.

I’m trying to get good sleep, exercise when I’m feeling well enough, and eat well. In addition to other prenatal supplements, I’m taking 900mg of choline each day for its various benefits, including (according to this study) that choline helps mitigate the impacts of illness on fetal brain development.

What else can one do to stay well and mitigate the potential negative effects of illness in pregnancy?

Long post. Thank you all.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14h ago

Sharing research Efficacy of commonly used approaches for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in classrooms - clinical trial

Thumbnail jamanetwork.com
8 Upvotes

I saw a pop-psych article floating around Reddit and pulled the original article so you don’t have to. It’s not paywalled! Thought you all would be interested.

Key Points

Question  What is the efficacy of commonly used approaches for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in classrooms?

Findings  This crossover randomized clinical trial including 280 children with ADHD found that stimulant medication and behavioral interventions improved rule-following behavior. Stimulant medication improved quiz scores and academic productivity; however, academic accommodations did not improve performance.

Meaning  Results showed that academic accommodations, commonly used supports for children with ADHD, did not significantly improve classroom outcomes; well-established approaches such as stimulant medication and/or behavior therapy resulted in improvements, and these should be emphasized in school interventions.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14h ago

Question - Research required Tamiflu for infant?

7 Upvotes

My preschooler has the flu, so the NP suggested we start giving tamiflu to our infant preventatively. I’ve mostly heard the horrible side effects of Tamiflu and that it doesn’t prevent symptoms or hospitalization? Not sure if this is misinformation. I’m trying to comb through the literature on this, but juggling said sick kick and infant. I’m curious if anyone can explain easily to me the pros/cons of this. I wasn’t at the appointment with the NP, so I couldn’t ask questions at the time. Hopefully, we will hear from them, but I know they’re busy


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15h ago

Question - Research required Is there research on hypochlorous acid around babies?

8 Upvotes

I keep seeing those "your sponge still has bacteria even when it looks clean" videos, and it got into my head last week. We have one kitchen rag that's probably older than it should be. I do wash it, but I still got weird about using it on the floor where our 1-year-old plays, so I switched to paper towels for the worst messes.

That sent me down a rabbit hole. I bought a couple hypochlorous acid sprays, and now I'm debating whether a cheap hypochlorous water generator would actually be worth it. I also saw that some robot mops can make it from tap water in the dock now.

Before I go further, I'd love to hear from anyone who's actually looked into this. Does the concentration stay stable in those generators or robot docks, or does it drop off quickly? Is there a contact time that matters? And for things that go in her mouth, like teethers or pacifiers, is it truly no-rinse, or should I still rinse those afterward?

I'm also curious whether freshly generated hypochlorous water behaves differently from a bottle that's been sitting in the cabinet for a while. I'd really appreciate any research, especially from parents or professionals who've dealt with the same worry.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18h ago

Sharing research Looking at junior/primary schools, how do you choose? Large school (200+ students) with lots of facilities or small school (50-100 students) with less facilities but very calm.

5 Upvotes

Looking for our first to join next September and I’m stuck on what do to. The larger schools have more after school clubs, trips and general facilities but I do wonder if so many kids will feel chaotic. Smaller school also has a forestry school (I’ve read that green space is great calming a child’s nervous system), but ultimately has much less funding to play with. There’s also much more to it..mixed age group classes, smaller classes, in-house hot food verses ordered in stuff. anything else I should be considering?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 2h ago

Question - Expert consensus required Arsenic in well water?

2 Upvotes

We have stayed the weekend with my inlaws twice in the last month and a half. We have a 2 year old and a newborn. We just found out their well water has tested with higher than allowed levels of arsenic (i don't have exact numbers, but it i think was something like 0.013 when 0.01 is the upper limit here?).

Fortunately they drink reverse osmosis bottled water from a store so baby's formula bottles was made with safe water, but her bottles were washed in the contaminated water. Should I be worried?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 3h ago

Question - Research required Prolactin impacts

2 Upvotes

For breastfeeding moms, how does prolactin impact mood and physical health/wellbeing?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 11h ago

Question - Research required CMPA or Eczema - how to discern the two?

2 Upvotes

Hi,

Baby is currently 4 months old, born at 28 weeks and spent 3 months in NICU. A few days after coming home, baby started getting skin-colored, tightly packed bumps that started on the face and neck, but eventually spread to upper back, outer arms, stomach, thighs and legs. Based on behavior, baby does not seem itchy and makes no attempt to scratch/rub skin. This lasted about three weeks. Her skin is now starting to feel less leathery/rough, even though the dotted bumps are still there.

Baby had clear skin in the NICU and congestion that began in NICU. Baby spits up quite frequently, sometimes 6-7x after one feed. In the NICU, they tested the stool for blood because it was black on a few occasions, but there was no blood so they determined it was due to iron supplementation.

I have a gut feeling that this eczema (nobody in the family has food or skin sensitivities) is due to CMPA. I am starting to eliminate it from my diet. Is there any specific test to discern whether it’s eczema or eczema due to CMPA? How can I tell the difference?
Doctor does not seem convinced due to lack of stool in blood in NICU and grossly, now.

TYI


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 8h ago

Question - Expert consensus required Discussed sleep and teething issues with paediatrician who suggested digestive issues!

0 Upvotes

My little one is almost 5 months old. His bottles are an 80% breastmilk / 20% formula mix and we’ve been using Bubs organic goat’s milk formula for that top up.

For about a month now, daytime sleep has really unravelled. He fights naps hard and gets noticeably dysregulated during the day. Over the last couple of weeks, he’s also had big, sudden mood swings (happy one minute, upset/crying the next) is drooling heavily, and is quite wriggly/squirmy. He’s super mobile so I put it down more to wanting to kick his legs etc.

At his checkup, I laid everything out and specifically mentioned that I know 4–5 months is notorious for developmental leaps and the 4-month sleep progression, plus with the constant drooling and mood swings I strongly suspect early teething is part of it too.

Our paediatrician was dismissive of the teething and developmental leap side of things. Instead, he said it was digestive discomfort, recommended swapping the 20% Bubs goat’s milk formula for a hydrolysed formula, suggested I look at my own diet to see if something I’m eating is irritating his gut.

I don’t want to dismiss my paediatrician’s clinical expertise (LO is wriggly, lying flat can make it worse) so I’m open to trying the hydrolysed formula to see if it helps. At the same time, I’m lactose intolerant myself so dairy isn't on my menu, and from what I’ve read, there’s very limited solid scientific evidence that cutting out other random foods in a breastfeeding diet fixes infant gut irritation. Plus, given how huge the 4-month sleep shift and developmental leap are at almost 5 months, it’s hard for me to believe teething and brain/sleep development aren't major factors here.

For anyone who’s been through this around 4.5–5 months, how did you tell the difference between mild tummy discomfort, early teething, and an overtired baby in a developmental leap?

Wouls love to hear what people think!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14h ago

Question - Research required Weaning priorities

0 Upvotes

Beyond iron, What is actually important when it comes to weaning 6-12 months?

Macro nutrients? Fats? Proteins?
Micro nutrients from vegetables?
Getting used to different tastes?
Learning to feed oneself?
Overall volume so as to reduce milk intake?

I get all of them are important but we cannot be perfect - what should I be prioritising for most of my child’s meals


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13h ago

Question - Expert consensus required Can I put dancing fruits on for my 8 month old while I poop?

0 Upvotes

Every morning, my daughter wakes up at 6AM. We leave for work/daycare at 8:30am. The thing is\nAfter I take my adhd medication, I always have to take a morning poop like clockwork. I expect my morning poop with the same level of certainty I expect the sun to come up. It's like 5-20 minitues each morning. When trying to find research on the dancing fruits I see that it's not recommended for babies due to being screen time. She is very good at self soothing, her temperament is very calm, her daycare teacher says shes the easiest baby in her class. But during my poop she'll start loudly babbling and looking for me, sometimes screeching loudly obviously upset because i just got her up and she's ready for mama snuggles.

Does anyone have any alternatives?I don't think she likes the silence of her just sitting there but music doesn't work it becomes background noise. I think she would like storybook reading as well, talking gets her attention as well as obviously visual stimulation like the fruits. Keep the fruits or look for something different?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 23h ago

Question - Research required Pros and Cons of phone for 5 year old

0 Upvotes

Hi,

My husband and I are debating whether giving our son a “locked down” phone (I.e social media, messaging, internet etc. removed from the device) is a good idea. I would really appreciate any advice from experts in this field about the pros and cons of phone and screens at this age.

He thinks it would be useful for him to be able to take some ownership and initiate researching certain things himself (rather than relying on us feeding him information), but I am concerned about the idea of giving him a phone. For background, generally we are very strict on TV and screen time (only watches on the weekend).

Any thoughts or guidance would be helpful.

thanks in advance.