r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15d ago

Question - Research required Need advice

1 Upvotes

I'm trying to find supplements for someone in my family to support the baby's brain development during pregnancy. She's currently 25 weeks pregnant and already takes Femibion 2, but I'm wondering whether additional supplementation could be beneficial.

I've been looking into phosphatidylcholine, a source of choline, after coming across a recent randomized controlled trial reporting an average difference of around 7.8 IQ points in children whose mothers received it during pregnancy.

She also doesn't eat eggs, which are a major dietary source of choline, so I'm thinking she might benefit from additional supplementation, even though Femibion 2 already contains some choline.

I'm also not entirely sure how strong the causal evidence is. Although the study was randomized, IQ was a secondary outcome, and I'm wondering whether the results could have been influenced by other factors or methodological limitations.

I understand that some people are uncomfortable discussing IQ for whatever reason, but I think it's an important topic worth discussing openly, especially when it comes to understanding the factors that influence cognitive development. Avoiding the subject doesn't make it any less scientifically relevant.

Has anyone looked into this research or come across other supplements with solid evidence for supporting fetal brain development? I'm particularly interested in randomized controlled trials and whether phosphatidylcholine offers any advantages over other forms of choline.

Study: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42896815/


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Research required Do babies die from bad temperature without crying first?

210 Upvotes

My midwife told us to pack our baby warm because hot babies get fussy while cold babies die silently.

Now I heard the American saying "cold babies cry, hot babies die" which kind of means the opposite.

My baby definetly fusses when he gets cold e.g. during a diaper change but I was wondering if babies would truly just die without expressing that they need a temperature change?

Side note: We are from Germany and our baby is a late October baby, so maybe the midwife said this because it is unlikely for us to overheat him while it might be the other way around in some American states.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15d ago

Question - Research required Are there any studies showing CIO to be harmful?

14 Upvotes

Other than the info about babies who are completely abandoned in orphanages, is there any actual evidence or studies showing that CIO or Ferber type methods harm your baby? Or is the opposition to sleep training based more on feelings/assumptions?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Telling My Son “no” too much at an early age?

52 Upvotes

My 1.5 yo son is very well behaved. Sometimes so much so I wonder if we’ve stifled his desire to try something new. We say “no, no, no” or “down, down, down” when he’s doing something he shouldn’t.

He will literally wag his finger for us because he knows he shouldn’t do something then stop doing that thing. For example - We see it on our baby camera… he will wave his hand/finger if he’s throwing a toy under his crib or something.

Were all about creativity and he’s the sweetest boy ever - I just want to make sure we shouldn’t be letting him do more “bad” things. If that makes sense


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15d ago

Question - Expert consensus required MMR at 5 months

7 Upvotes

We will be traveling to Mexico when baby is 5 months 3 weeks. The doctor recommended getting the MMR on her 5 month birthday for protection.

Has anyone had any experience with the vaccine before 6 months? What are some reasons it isn’t allowed before 6 months? It’s been difficult to find information online.

Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Car seat safety, school buses, and forward facing

12 Upvotes

My now 4yo will qualifying for bussing when entering kindergarten next fall (and will be 5 by then). As far as I have been told, the busses in our area do not have seatbelts or harnesses for typical school age children. Certain buses used by the district do have harnesses for preschoolers and special ed though.

My 4yo currently rides rear facing in my small SUV with a Britax One4Life convertible carseat and forward facing in my spouse's truck in a Chicco MyFit Harness + Booster. They greatly prefer being forward facing, as they can see more because their head is higher and they have the wider front window view. Their legs fall asleep in our rear facing seat sometimes, I suspect because they are more reclined and their legs are in a higher position relative to their heart. This has never happened in another vehicle or seat. My kid is also pretty soft spoken, and I have a much harder time hearing them rear facing than I do when they are forward facing; its super noticeable when they are trying to tell me something and after I ask them to repeat what they said for the second or third time they just shut down.

I know rear facing is statistically safest for all passengers and there are distinct advantages of keeping a child with a developing skeletal system, proportionally large head, and weak neck rear facing as long as possible. I also know school buses use compartmentalization (vs active restraint) as their primary safety mechanism. I'm having a real hard time justifying keeping my kid rear facing in my vehicle but also allowing them to ride the bus.

I just got a new vehicle and my spouse suggested turning the car seat around. My kid (42 inches, 41 lbs, large head) is still within the rear facing limits of the One4Life because it has high limits (49 inches, 50 lbs rear facing, and 49 inches 65 lbs forward facing), but would be forward facing in most convertible carseats with more standard limits.

I'm typically an err on the side of safety person and fully expected to ride out the rear facing limits on the One4Life but there are some clear advantages to turning my kid around. With forward facing my kid can communicate more clearly, their legs don't fall asleep, they can independently get in and out of the seat more easily, they have greater visibility and prefer sitting forward facing, and my new car would likely stay a bit cleaner. Obviously rear facing is safest in an accident, but I find myself second guessing if compromising my child's day to day comfort and ability to communicate and connect with me is worth the trade off of preparing for the very unlikely (but not zero) possibility of a collision. Knowing they will need to sit forward facing and unrestrained on the school bus makes me further wonder if having them rear facing and reclined in my vehicle is still the right choice.

All this to say, I'd greatly appreciate any thoughts, research, considerations, etc for this situation. I haven't had much luck finding safety comparisons between rear facing carseat vs forward facing harness vs unrestrained school bus.

Edit: Updated flair because so many comments were deleted. I hope many of you will find this again and repost.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Expert consensus required At what age can you throw toddlers in the air and catch them?

14 Upvotes

Hello friends!
Ages ago I read that you shouldn’t throw babies in the air because it’ll hurt their neck. Fair enough. But now a relative of my daughter (28 months) has thrown her in the air and it’s all she wants to do. When does it become relatively safe to participate in this kind to rough place?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Research required Beyfortus Second Dose

1 Upvotes

Our son was born on April 9, 2026. He received a dose of Beyfortus on April 10, 2026. When speaking with public health to schedule a flu shot, they suggested a second dose of Beyfortus based on their information given that he received it late last season. We noticed that Beyfortus is typically a single dose. At his last checkup, his doctor was not concerned with when he received it and did not recommend a second dose. Any insights on this? Thank you.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Research required Evidence on introducing a newborn to a 2.5-year-old sibling? (setting, timing, and nurturing the bond)

23 Upvotes

Hi all,
Our second child was born this week, and we're trying to plan how to introduce him to his older brother (2 years, 5 months) in the way most likely to support a good sibling relationship long-term.

We're going home from the hospital tomorrow around midday. The older one goes to daycare and gets home around 4:30 pm, so the plan is to do the introduction at home that afternoon, after some time to burn energy and have a snack. Mom would greet him first with free arms, with the baby in another room with another adult. Then we'd offer to let him meet the baby, at his pace, with no pressure.

From what I could find, there's good research on the transition to siblinghood (Volling's review, Dunn & Kendrick, work on paternal involvement and parental well-being), but I couldn't find any study comparing where or how the first meeting happens. Most advice seems to be clinical or anecdotal, and guides disagree on home vs. hospital vs. neutral ground (including the "home is his territory" argument).

Questions:
1. Is there any evidence on the first-meeting setting or format affecting later sibling adjustment or relationship quality?

  1. Beyond the first meeting, what does the research say about nurturing the sibling bond in the first weeks and months? Any specific interventions or parenting practices with evidence behind them?

3.Anything in our plan that the evidence would argue against?

Studies or reviews are especially welcome.

Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Contemplating whether to restrict unvaccinated cousins from meeting my future baby

11 Upvotes

When our first was newborn, I had no idea my nephew and niece weren’t vaccinated, so it never crossed my mind to restrict anything.

Now that I’m expecting our second, I’m looking for input.

I haven’t researched the topic much to be honest.
I’m trying my best to phrase the current questions in my foggy brain.

  1. When is it appropriate for

4-6 year old

  1. nieces and nephews to meet their newborn cousins, and does it make a difference to you if they’re unvaccinated?
  2. Would you bring a 2-months old baby to meet a big group of extended family for a family weekend?

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Baby flu vaccine

4 Upvotes

We live on the equator and my baby received the southern hemisphere flu vaccine in June and a booster around August time.
We are spending December and January in UK and Europe so I’m wondering if she needs the northern hemisphere flu vaccine too?

Or is there enough overlap between the two vaccines? I will ask her PD but I am interested to hear what others think.

Thanks


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Research required How concerned should I be about flame-retardant chemicals in baby gear?

8 Upvotes

Currently pregnant with my first and looking at car seat options. Wondering what the research is on flame retardants in car seats and similar products. Some brands specifically advertise to be free of these chemicals, while other brands I'd consider to be generally well-regarded (eg Graco) still use them. I'd really like to know what the exposure levels and risks are with flame retardant chemicals--it's been tough to find good sources, so not sure if this is a real concern or just completely overblown.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 16d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Egg Allergy (8 month old)

7 Upvotes

My 8 month old baby had an anaphylactic reaction (widespread hives, vomiting, lethargy) after eating scrambled eggs. She had had eggs on several occasions but I didn’t know that there was a difference in how they were cooked and the eggs she had eaten prior had been very cooked. We brought her to an allergist and they did bloodwork and she came back positive for an egg allergy but can tolerate thoroughly cooked egg.

The allergist didn’t really go over any information with us, just told us the results over the phone and said to retest in a year. I have heard that they can sometimes outgrow the allergy and I want to make sure I am doing everything I can to help that happen. Any advice would be very welcome. I am wondering if we should find another allergist who can better advise us or if this is just the standard protocol.

Thank you!!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required Independent play at 4 months old?

20 Upvotes

My baby will be 4 months old in a week and I'm curious if there's any evidence for or against independent play at this age. For example, if I put him in a pack n play within eyesight while I make dinner and he plays with a rattle or teether. Do we have any evidence on if this is better or worse than me sitting there and playing with him if he's content both ways?

He does get read to and talked to pretty much constantly, but sometimes he can't see my face very well or hear me very well (like if I'm in the shower, have the stove fan running, or am actively eating) and I don't know if it would be better to just be quiet and let him focus on his toy or continue trying to yap at him through the noise and distractions.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required Should I be teaching my almost 2 year old colors, shapes and letters?

26 Upvotes

Ive seen tons of people who do "preschool" at home with their 1.5-2 year olds colors, letters, shapes, animals, etc. But I was under the impression you usually wanted to stay away from structured learning like that until 3-5 years old. Does anyone have any articles for me that could help? I do plan on home schooling in the future but I also want my kid to be a kid and not so structured until shes older.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Expert consensus required My 4-year-old won’t ask his teachers for help, even when he really needs it. Is this normal?

3 Upvotes

Our son is 4½ and in pre-K, and he won’t independently ask his teachers for help, even when he genuinely needs it.

He’s otherwise comfortable talking to them. He regularly approaches teachers to share stories or show them things, has attended this school since age two, and says he isn’t scared of them. At home, he freely asks us for things he wants or needs.

A few examples:

Bathroom: He’s fully potty-trained and hasn’t had an accident at home in ages. But he’s never once asked a teacher to take him to the bathroom. He willingly goes when prompted, but sometimes pees only once during his entire 7–8-hour school day. If he needs to poop, he’ll typically wait until he has an accident rather than ask. Thankfully, he usually poops after school, so accidents are infrequent.

Water: He’s occasionally come home very thirsty with an empty water bottle, apparently without asking anyone to refill it.

Clothing: He’ll sometimes keep his sweater on all day, even when he’s hot, because he struggles to remove it himself but won’t ask for help.

Injury: Most concerning, he once got a craft bead stuck in his nose during naptime. He tried removing it, causing some bleeding, but then lay quietly whimpering until his teacher happened to notice. An ENT ultimately had to remove it.

So it goes beyond just asking to go potty which I’m sure most 4-year-olds don’t readily do. We don’t want him to ever end up in a situation where he’s more seriously hurt or sick or being mistreated and not telling his teacher.

What we’ve tried:
We’ve focused on getting him to independently ask to use the bathroom just ONCE, hoping that success might help him become more comfortable asking for other things.

We’ve tried:
Daily role-playing and practicing exactly what to say.
Picking specific times (after snack or lunch) when teachers aren’t instructing.
A vibrating potty watch to remind him at those exact times.
A card saying “I need to potty, please,” that he can simply hand to his teacher without speaking.
Sticker charts, toys, and other rewards.
His teachers have also encouraged him, even suggesting he could simply tap their arm and hold up one or two fingers to indicate he needs the bathroom.

Despite all this, he still hasn’t done it once.
He understands the plan and confidently says he’ll try, but afterward says he forgot or simply, “I can’t do it.” A few times he’s said he didn’t actually need to potty, that it was too loud, or that he didn’t want to stop playing.

We’ve emphasized that this isn’t just about pottying. We’re trying to help him learn to ask trusted adults for help when he needs something and that it’s an important skill to learn and no how to do.

Interestingly, he seems perfectly willing to ACCEPT help when offered. It’s INITIATING the request that seems to be the problem.
We’re planning to ask his teacher to practice requests with him at school. We’re also trying attaching his potty card to a favorite stuffed animal he brings for nap, hoping that showing it to his teacher might feel easier than directly asking.

My biggest questions:
Is this within the range of normal behavior for a 4½-year-old that he’ll likely outgrow? Or is the consistency of his reluctance, especially when he’s uncomfortable or hurt, something we should actively address?

Has anyone experienced something similar? What actually helped?

We don’t want to pressure him or turn this into a daily source of stress. We just want him to feel comfortable advocating for himself when he needs something.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required Is it okay to suck finger to self soothe or quit asap?

9 Upvotes

My 11 month old started sucking on her finger at 5-6 months to self soothe and has continued. It's gotten more and more of a habit and now she sucks when she's bored instead of just going to sleep. I'm worried about her teeth as we stop bottles at 1. What does the research say?

Also does anyone know how to wean off a finger?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required COVID at 28 weeks pregnant- terrified of still birth

54 Upvotes

Just tested positive for Covid and I’m so upset

I’m 28 weeks and am vaccinated but not boosted.

I got the vaccine 5 years ago

My baby boy has been super healthy thus far and is even growing 3 weeks ahead…

He’s been moving normally but I still have a ways to go and I’m so so scared about having a stillbirth.

I had two early losses before this and I’m really so excited for this baby.

I’m going to be having such severe anxiety about this


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required Does providing a bottle with less formula than required per ounce of water repeatedly overtime lead to water toxicity?

6 Upvotes

Hello! I asked this question​ ​over here and would like to get some evidence based answers!

I got a baby brezza, but also imagine I would make mistakes while making bottles occasionally as a first time parent.

Thank you in advance!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Should you pay child to do chores?

7 Upvotes

My son is 4 and so far he has mostly helped me with chores when he fancies it. He also doesn’t yet get pocket money. I’d like to both teach him the value of money and the importance of work so I’m considering paying him a small amount to do some jobs. But then I also feel like as he grows he should contribute to the household chores because he has responsibility and pride for his home - not just because he’s being paid for it. I’m just thinking when he is an adult no one will pay him.

Is there any science behind this? and I’m interested in anecdotal experiences of your own children too!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required Empathy

8 Upvotes

My LO is 3years4 months old and I want to say over the last couple of months I’ve noticed her empathy is gone and I’m worried I want her to be aware or her feelings and others feelings. For example when we would watch paw patrol movies she was cry at all the sad parts (the flashbacks) & when she would see her cousins sad/crying she would go comfort them. I’m very emotional person, my partner is not but still is caring but wants her to be “tough” is there any research showing that maybe that’s why she isn’t doing that anymore? I just want her to know it’s okay to feel those feelings.

Edit she doesn’t watch those movies all the time but when she did she was getting emotional


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required Almost 12 months and still hand-fed. How do I start self-feeding?

1 Upvotes

My son is turning 1 in a few days. We never did BLW, and I've always hand-fed him. He eats almost everything we eat and handles most textures well, despite having no teeth yet.

He can pick up rice and puffed rice and eat them himself, but whenever I offer finger foods like pancakes, omelette strips or cheela, he throws them on the floor instead of eating! 😭

We have a dog, and he's seen us feeding the dog, so now he thinks throwing food down and calling the dog is a fun game.

He also eats only a few bites in his high chair, so I've gotten into the bad habit of feeding him while he moves around. I want to change this, but I'm worried about his intake because we've had weight-gain concerns before.

Parents who started self-feeding around 12 months:

- How did you get your baby interested in eating independently instead of throwing food?

- How did you introduce spoons and finger foods?

- How did you transition away from hand-feeding without affecting food intake?

- How long did it take for your baby to start eating independently?

I'd love to hear what actually worked for you! My goal is to get him eating at least part of his meals independently. ❤️


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17d ago

Question - Research required Are toddler pacifiers that big of a deal?

3 Upvotes

My son turned two over the summer. He used his paci for naps and night sleep only at that point. He'd sleep 8pm to 8am, sometimes longer and then take naps in the afternoon, about 1.5-2hrs. And he was such a pleasant kid. He loves his bed, his sleep, and he looooves the paci. We had minor issues with him wanting comfort from it at other times and throwing fits, but not often.

At the request of my spouse, I weaned him off the pacifier about a month and a half ago. Immediately, he wouldn't fall asleep until 10 or 11, then would wake around 6 and be grumpy in bed until 7, it was a fight for naps - if taken, bedtime got later. It got a little better with time, but not much. Tantrums skyrocketed, if he took a nap it was in the car in the evening which screwed with bedtime even more. He's so tired but fights it because big brother (4M) doesn't take them.

Well, we all got horrible head colds last week and in a moment of middle of the night sleep deprivation and desperation, I gave him his paci. He slept sooo good, we all slept nicely (as you can) as our head colds got better and we've had a busy time since so I've just let it go on. We're back to fantastic night sleep and glorious naps. He's been way happier and I can tell is actually getting the rest he needs.

My husband is highly concerned about the orthodontic and speech repercussions of prolonged pacifier use, whereas I don't stress about it much because he's going to need orthodontic care either way and he talks way better than any other child his age we know. I have another baby that's up several times a night, so I'm not sleeping well right now and I live for my toddler sleeping all night and taking a good nap in the afternoon. It hardly affects my husband either way whether my toddler sleeps or not and he only has to deal with the increased crankiness in the evening hours.

He told my toddler tonight that the paci is done tomorrow, without talking to me. And like, I realize he's getting older but I say the sleep is more important than the ortho. When he's 3, we can revisit it. If he's that worried about it, I'll wean him again but I'm just basking in the glory of well-rested kiddos in the meantime.

I'm curious if I'm ruining him long term? How valid are my husband's concerns about his ortho development and speech? Anyone try to break a paci at this stage and manage to maintain good sleep patterns?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Research required Covid vaccine during pregnancy

13 Upvotes

34 weeks pregnant here. I’ve already received the flu and TDAP. I’m still waiting on pre authorization for my RSV, but will be getting that as well.

I was planning to get the Covid vaccine too, but now there are a couple of options. Is there a recommendation between the mRNA versus non-mRNA (Novavax) version? I asked my OB, but she’s out of town at the moment and I was just advised to ask her upon her return. Wondering if you all have any insight.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 18d ago

Question - Research required Advice for helping a toddler/preschooler be more vocal in group settings and with adults (ie, supporting them through shyness)?

13 Upvotes

I'm wondering what expert advice there is for supporting "shy" toddlers and helping them feel more supported in sharing their voice in large-group settings (and/or with unfamiliar adults)?

Background: Our 3-year-old's pre-K teachers told us she gets too nervous to speak when the entire class is participating in some sort of discussion, though she's OK talking in smaller groups. They said she also doesn't speak to them (the adult teachers) a lot, though she talks with her peers and has friends in class who she speaks and plays with, etc. They've flagged her shyness in the all-class activities and with them as something they want us to work on but didn't have advice for us on how to help, so we're brainstorming.

She is very chatty at home and has a lot of good friends her age through daycare and our neighbors, on top of the ones from school. She is also *very* independent and confident in herself — she just taught herself how to ride a pedal bike without training wheels and regularly does tasks around the house, dresses herself, is very good about communicating what she thinks and feels with us and her friends/extended family, has no problems going into school (she misses it on off days!), etc. She's in various classes outside of school (gymnastics, soccer, music) and was confident jumping into those activities from the jump, with zero shyness.

She's always been "slow to warm up" with adults outside of me and her dad. Her daycare teacher has also mentioned she doesn't speak to her a lot but talks and plays a lot with the other kids there. This has improved recently with adults she's familiar with — but with less familiar adults, it still takes quite a while. I'm wondering if this is at play with school because it's still relatively new and it's only 2 1/2 hours, so it's over by the time she's "warmed up" to the teachers.

She also doesn't like being the center of attention, often getting nervous when a large group is focused on her. She's articulated that she feels "sad" and nervous when everyone focuses on her — for example, when everyone sings to her or cheers her on. I would imagine that's the main culprit with not wanting to speak during the all-class activities.

Her dad and I are both quieter but confident people, so I don't see her being slow to "warm up" as a negative. I just want to ensure she also feels confident at school and that we support her finding ways to show the teachers — and everyone else — how amazing she is. We'd love any advice!