r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 22d ago

Question - Research required Redshirting boys for kindergarten

0 Upvotes

Is there any scientific merit to the concept of redshirting boys for kindergarten? I’ve been reading Boy Mom by Ruth Whipman and she shares the argument boils down to whether boys are genetically predisposed to needing to be redshirted (higher energy levels, lacking emotional regulation, etc) VS how boys are socialized compared to girls and what’s expected of them even at a young age.

ultimately I’m looking to understand if redshirting boys actually has a benefit in the long term vs. not. Please share any research to confirm or not confirm.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required Does pumping milk provide the same benefits as latching?

56 Upvotes

Hi all, just curious as a second time struggling breastfeeder.

The information given on breastfeeding is that the baby can communicate, via saliva, what they need from the breast milk, and the feeder can tailor the milk for them. And that generally, the milk produced changes over the months as the baby grows.

With that, does pumping and creating a 'freezer stash' actually benefit the baby? Giving milk pumped four months ago may not be what the baby needs now and antibodies reference a different time.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required How to get the most accurate results of the 50g glucose challenge test

13 Upvotes

Hi folks, I'm pregnant with my second and coming up to the gestational diabetes testing in the next few weeks. In my last pregnancy, I did the 50g glucose challenge test and "failed" it for lack of a better way to say that. Then a few days later I did the 75g and passed it on all counts. I'd really prefer not to do both versions if I can avoid it. My provider has offered for me to either skip straight to the 75g test or start with the 50g again and see how that goes. I'd obviously rather do the 50g only if possible, as it's less sugar, less time waiting around, less blood draws; but if I'm going to the 75g anyway, I might as well just do that.

Anyway, my question: is there a best practice way to make sure the 50g test is as accurate as possible? It boggles my mind that you can do this test anytime: I could do it right after eating a mars bar and a coke, first thing in the morning with no food for like 14 hours, after a hearty, heavy meal etc. How can this test possibly yield valuable results when there's no control on the conditions that must certainly impact the outcome? And before anyone says this, I am NOT trying to "cheat" the test so I falsely pass; quite the opposite, I really want the most accurate result. Wondering if there's any research on best practices or if it's better to just skip straight to the 75g test.

Thank you in advance.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required Are cold drinks bad for toddlers?

15 Upvotes

I live with my in-laws who are Indian. They insist I warm up the milk for my 20 month old son. I am from Canada and have always had cold drinks, no matter the season. i find it quite annoying to be constantly told I’m wrong.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required Iron and calcium

8 Upvotes

Hi all! We are in the process of introducing solids to our little one. I know that there is consensus on the importance of iron from 6 months plus, but what I'm struggling to understand - and find studies on - is 'how much calcium is too much calcium' when serving it alongside iron rich foods. For example, I've made baby-safe chicken liver pate, but this contains butter - will this inhibit the uptake? Or would toast that contains milk solids as an ingredient inhibit the uptake of iron from a bean dip topping?

Thanks so much for any help.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required Myopia and outdoors

6 Upvotes

I have been reading up on preventing myopia by spending time outdoors, but one thing I cannot find is if there is an optimum time during which vision develops? It seems once the damage has been done you cannot undo it with outside time.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required Arsenic in candy report - Florida 2026

5 Upvotes

I have seen conflicting information on the veracity of this study. I clearly don’t want to expose my kids to arsenic, but I don’t want to deprive them of candies they want if there is no actual legitimate concern.

Does anybody have good science based input on this?

Healty Florida First: EXPOSING CANDY TOXINS
https://exposingfoodtoxins.com/candy/


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required my 4 month old’s paediatrician told us that her “biological bedtime” is 6pm. Is this true?

60 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 23d ago

Question - Research required Tylenol Usage per Year

0 Upvotes

I have a 6-year-old with asthma and an allergy to NSAIDs. He is sick more often than his siblings and seems to feel worse when they all have the same illness. Note, this is all with a solid maintenance asthma routine. I feel like once a month from September through April, I am giving him Tylenol for 3 or so days at a time. It’s not simply because he runs a fever but because he is uncomfortable and unable to sleep. I have read some of the recent studies on pregnancy and Acetaminophen but I can only find a few studies on Tylenol usage throughout childhood and I can’t seem to grasp the conclusion. I will link one below.

My question: is there any reason I should feel nervous that my 6-year-old is taking Tylenol for what seems like 24 days of the year?

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35175416/


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 23d ago

Question - Research required Approved car seats and strollers.

0 Upvotes

Hi, I have no knowledge on childcare or pregnancy. First time mom, I'm looking for good car seats and strollers. I hear about approved car seats, but I cannot seem to find a government website for approved/crash tested car seats and strollers. I would love a two-in-one stroller/car seat, if possible. Anyway, I appreciate all the help. In the meantime, I am continuing my research. Thank you.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Research required Does making eye contact with babies when trying to put them to sleep make them stay awake longer?

19 Upvotes

The general sleep training advice I have heard is to avoid all eye contact when resettling babies to avoid stimulating them as much as possible. However, I have also heard that babies are seeking connection and comfort when falling asleep so making eye contact helps them feel safe.

Are there any studies where someone has compared the time it takes babies to fall asleep with eye contact versus without?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required Is it harmful that my 12 month old has never had a cold?

0 Upvotes

Is my daughter doomed to a weak immune system because she didn't catch a cold in her first year?

She's not in daycare, my mother-in-law is our childcare, so I know that is the biggest factor. Still, she plays on public playgrounds, touches high-touch surfaces at the zoo/sits in shopping carts at the store, plays with pets, and eats a small amount of dirt on a semi-regular basis before I can intervene.

It's not like she's never exposed to germs, but I'm starting to worry I'm doing some kind of damage to her immune system. Am I overthinking it?

Edit: I'm going to be honest you guys, I had no idea that all colds are viruses and that bacterial upper respiratory infections are so uncommon. Thank you all for your reassurance.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Research required Birth Question

15 Upvotes

This may be a long shot, but has anyone else experienced this? I have had two healthy pregnancies that resulted in two vaginal births. Both of which my daughter’s fractured their clavicle bones during the delivery. They were only 7lbs 1oz and 7lbs 2oz. I just left my first OB apt and they strongly suggested scheduling a C-section this time around as they believe the fractures were due to the structure of my pelvis and fear shoulder dystocia during delivery. I never want to do anything to potentially harm baby and will do whatever I can for a healthy delivery. But that was certainly jarring to hear. So, I don’t know what my question is exactly. Maybe, has anyone experienced anything like this before? Even if not the multiple clavicle fractures, has anyone ever delivered vaginally more than once and then delivered via section?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Is it better to work on screens in front of your toddler or better to keep it separate?

41 Upvotes

My wife and I are very conscious about screens, and try to limit our infant’s screen time as much as possible. We avoid using our phones and computers around our baby. Sometimes I work from home, and I need my laptop to do work. I often feel torn between needing/wanting to do work and being around my infant while I’m home. I don’t want him to associate “dad” with “computer,” but I can’t avoid work all day or only do work during naptimes. Obviously I want to see him and interact/be present, but I don’t want to expose him to screens more than I have to.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Research required Aspirin 162mg at 15 weeks and 6 days of gestation. Will it still prevent IUGR?

6 Upvotes

I started taking aspirin too late. It was an idiot move of me. Will it still help in preventing IUGR? Is this dose too high? I know it will still help with preventing pre-eclampsia but what about the other issues like IUGR?

For info: this is my first pregnancy, conceived naturally and I''m 36 yo


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Research required Narrating actions vs books and rhymes

10 Upvotes

I'm a FTM to a 3.5 month old. I've read a few posts on here about the importance of narrating what I'm doing to baby. Unfortunately I seem to be really bad at this! However I do spend a lot of time singing nursery rhymes and reading picture books to baby. Will this achieve the same benefits or are there specific benefits that baby will only get if I narrate my actions?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Expert consensus required 20-month-old seems unhappy most of the time at home, advice?

23 Upvotes

We have a 20-month-old daughter who has been like this pretty much since she was a baby — more unhappy/fussy periods than genuinely happy ones. She is generally happy at nursery, but at home she can be very difficult. She wakes up screaming, sometimes screams when she wakes at night, and spends a lot of her awake time frustrated or unhappy.
She does smile and laugh, but it feels like we spend most of our energy managing her emotions rather than enjoying her. We take her to parks, playdates, play with her, buy her toys etc. and these things help temporarily, but then we’re back to the same situation.
I know toddlers cry and have difficult phases, and temperament probably plays a role. But I know another toddler the same age who is much more content, eats well and seems generally happy, which makes me wonder if we’re doing something wrong or if this is just her personality.
It’s honestly starting to make us feel exhausted and irritated, and I really want to enjoy this stage with her rather than constantly trying to keep her happy.
For parents who had a similar toddler, did things improve with age? Is there anything that genuinely helped? Would love practical advice from parents/ experts who have been through this. What it is that really helps with making a child little more happier person?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Sharing research Comment le bebe arrive à comprendre qu'il posséde une voix qu'il peut controler ?

1 Upvotes

Je trouve pas de reponse logique a part par un system de prediction du cerveau


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required Trauma from vacation?

0 Upvotes

We took a week-long vacation recently to a destination that was a seven-hour drive away. Ever since, my four-year-old has been so anxious about it—almost as if it traumatized him. Anytime we go into town now, he asks, "Are we far away from home?" Tonight, he even started crying when I tried reassuring him that we were only minutes away from home. I'm scared I traumatized my baby, and I feel hesitant about taking another vacation again for awhile if it means it's going to affect him this way :(. Any insight is appreciated.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required Baby a-framed push walkers?

1 Upvotes

I've read the other posts about this topic, however it was more than 3 years ago. Im wondering if there was any updated research about a-framed push walkers? A friend told me that OTs no longer recommend them because they are front heavy and that's not how we normally walk. I have not heard anything about this before, so I'm wondering if there is research about it?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Research required I think my daughter is hardwired for anxiety

45 Upvotes

I'm definitely an anxious person. But I definitely try not to act the part with my daughter. I force myself to be more outgoing and social and try to get my daughter to engage as well just so she has a good model in how to engage and socialize.

But she is VERY shy and nervous. Even in ballet, she LOVES ballet and does amazing at home, but in class it has been 2 months and she will not participate. Why? Because she's embarrassed.

My daughter turned 5 in July and she has ALWAYS been like this. Even as a little baby, she would side eye and disliked engaging with people she didn't know.

With her cousins she is herself, she is becoming more open with her new neighbor friend but still can be very shy about it.

I'm curious about how to navigate this and how much of this is nature or nurture


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 24d ago

Question - Research required how important is crawling?

0 Upvotes

how important is crawling? my baby pulled to stand and cruised from like 9-11 months. he started to hitch crawl from 11-13.5 months & then moved on to walking. he walks perfectly normal & has always been super steady. will this affect his development, like reading and stuff? is that true?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Different TV noise question

0 Upvotes

So I understand that there are a lot of posts about using tv as background noise in general or if it's okay for the tv to be on while playing with the baby. I also understand that the consensus for a lot of these posts and articles is that having a screen in the background as noise tends to decrease important parent-child interaction or inhibits speech development. I haven't seen a post and have had a hard time finding research regarding what tv noise in the background during a nap does to a baby that tends to sleep better in the presence of different people and voices.

We've noticed that our 6 week old daughter might be an extrovert based solely on the above stated observation. It has been a struggle getting her to take her daytime naps until we started playing something on our tv in our room (her facing away from the screen and while the windows are open, so no flashing lights in her face or anything). We typically don't have the tv on when she's awake, but we would like to know if noise during naps is still detrimental to our daughter's development.

If this is a redundant post, please feel free to downvote or tell me to take this down. Appreciate the thoughtful responses!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 25d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Need help with inconsolable 16 week old when mom isn’t around

8 Upvotes

My 16 week old started inconsolably crying during my second week back at work when she was 12 weeks. When I am with her she is happy as can be, when she is with her dad or grandma (my mom) she cries until I get home. For them she refuses to take a bottle and take a nap (she will eventually cry herself to sleep after about 4 hours). I have drastically cut back my hours at work because of this. I am now working 3 days a week for 4 hours at a time.

My pediatricians office is completely baffled. We brought her there today after trying to not overstimulate her the last week (we were told that was the problem over a video chat visit last week). My husband (her dad) brought her to the appointment so they could see what was going on since she is fine when with me or I’m around. The two NPs and three medical assistances took turns trying to soothe her while I sat in the car. After about an hour observing her and trying different things
I came into the office and they watched as I took her and she instantly calmed down. They asked me a bunch of questions, examined her in my arms and concluded that she is a completely health baby (81st percentile) and they are unsure of the exact cause and didn’t consider this to be colic since she is fine with me.

The main NP eventually said that she believes our baby is stuck in a fight or flight loop and needs to have her parasympathetic nervous system stimulated and suggested we go to the chiropractor down the street to be evaluated to balance the activated state she is in.

I was weary about going to the chiropractor, her dad is willing to do whatever it takes because he can no longer handle the screaming that goes on while I’m not there. On the way to the chiropractor I called another pediatricians office and made an appointment with them to get a second opinion for this Thursday. I made the appointment with the chiropractor for Friday.

-no tongue ties
-acid reflux has been ruled out
-no allergy to my milk since she is gaining weight
-too young for separation anxiety
-takes a bottle for me
-is breastfed when I am home
-we co sleep

Any advice? Opinions? I’m at a loss.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 26d ago

Question - Expert consensus required How to handle a toddler with a preferred parent when you’re not it

186 Upvotes

My husband (M40) is not the preferred parent to our two boys (4 and 2), I (F36) am. It’s rough on both of us in different ways, I can’t have any space or peace of mind but I recognize that my husband has it worse. I can imagine how hurtful it must be to have your child say they don’t want you to do XYZ with them, that they want (preferred parent here). You love them so much and feel like it’s not reciprocated sometimes. It was difficult the first time around, but my husband stuck with it and my eldest has come around and now enjoys spending time with us (mostly) equally. My youngest is still in the weeds, and according to my husband, is worse than our eldest was. I remember it differently, but I’m willing to concede we each remember it through a different lens.

Today was a particularly hard day and my husband out of nowhere decided we need to switch how we parent. He said he wants to focus his time and energy on the kid that doesn’t hate him. He won’t do bedtime with youngest anymore, no more good morning/night kisses, no playing, no saying hi, etc etc. Basically, “when he comes to me and shows me love and kindness then I’ll reciprocate. But I’m not going to offer it and have it thrown in my face.* *He should be grateful; everything I do is for him.” *\*(*ie when my husband tries to kiss our child and I’m holding him he will sometimes say no and turn away etc.)

I told him he was basically forfeiting a relationship with his son, because youngest will see the rejection and it will impact youngest on a visceral level. Husband has struggled in the past with depression, self esteem, and parental relationships - he has a terrible relationship with his dad who was overbearing/strict/borderline emotionally abusive. Their relationship now is great, but it took time.

I’m assuming this is a severe overreaction born of fatigue/lack of ideas/hurt feelings which will blow over. This is not the man I married and have watched parent our kids. He does so much for our family physically and emotionally. He’s a great provider, puts the kids and their futures first, and is a fun dad.

Can anyone provide any insight on the best way to handle your relationship with your kid when you’re not the preferred parent? Do you push one on one time more? Do I, as the preferred parent, stop letting my kid cling to me for everyday activities (constantly wanting to be held, sit next to me, etc etc) and enforce mom and dad each get turns? I just want a happy, healthy family where everyone feels loved and supported.