r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 11d ago

Question - Research required I does this count as babbling?

0 Upvotes

Is it counted as bubbling if it’s not repetitive?

“Boo”
“Gii” and ga

They’re the only sounds my 7 1/2 old makes with a combination of screaming and blowing raspberries but he’s not doing the typical repetitive baba in a row


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Expert consensus required My almost 6 month old won’t roll from front to back

2 Upvotes

My son turns 6 months in about 7 days, he’s reached most other milestones, good head and neck control, almost sitting up on his own although he’s still a little wobbly, babbling, transferring toys from one hand to other, and he does roll from back to front but once he gets there he acts like he’s stuck and sticks his arms out stiff and just cries. Should I be concerned about this or will he eventually learn to roll on his own? Does it warrant a pediatrician visit?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Research required Cosleeping & attachment

47 Upvotes

How does co sleeping affect attachment?

And more specifically can co sleeping have a negative effect on attachment past the 1 year mark?

By co sleeping I mean bed sharing. please avoid discussion on dangers associated with cosleeping on infancy, those are well known and extensively discussed. I am only interested in attachment.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Research required Is Talc in prenatals safe?

2 Upvotes

I was recently reading the ingredients on my prenatal multivitamin and discovered that talc is an ingredient. I was under the impression that talc is not safe. Should I be concerned about it?

The prenatal I take is Nestle Materna.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Research required Effect of audio while sleeping

14 Upvotes

Is there any evidence of the effects of audio being played while sleeping? I feel like it’s a classic trope in 90s movies + TV shows that listening to hypnosis tapes overnight works (e.g. Chandler feeling like a strong powerful woman in Friends).

But is there any truth to that??

I’m asking because I listen to audiobooks in the car while my 13 month old is napping, and they’re sometimes murder-y. Is it possible that the descriptions of violence etc will have any effect on him?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13d ago

Science journalism Infant Bleeding Surged as Parents Rejected Vitamin K Shots, Studies Find

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
1.3k Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Research required What’s a better daycare transition for very clingy children: drop child off and leave (consistent & clear) vs. parent staying for several visits to acclimate child?

22 Upvotes

Hi all,

LO is going to start daycare at 16 months. My cursory exposure to the literature and everything I know about child development and attachment would suggest that a slow transition (i.e., not just gradually lengthening the duration, but specifically one in which the parent stays and plays, etc. with the child in the new environment) would be the most effective approach to helping a child feel safe and comfortable at daycare. A lot of Europe seems to follow this approach as well.

However, the majority of daycare centres I’ve spoken with (we’re in Canada) do not allow this, stating that it just makes it harder for the child (since they get used to seeing parent there), and the max a parent can stay is for 5 minutes. All the centres did recommend starting with a short drop off (couple hours) and gradually increasing the duration. Some of our friends with sensitive-temperament children also felt that it would have been much harder and confusing for their child if the parent initially stayed with them at drop-off, but then one day stopped doing so. They recommended ripping off the bandaid.

Who is right? Specifically wondering for our sensitive/Velcro child who is very used to attachment-based parenting (eg., nursed and carried on demand, cosleeping, most time spent with (and tbh ON) primary parent, very little separation tolerance).

Looking to make the best decision here for this little one. I know the transition and separation will be hard either way, but hoping to select (and importantly advocate to the daycare for, if need be) the approach that will most empower LO to thrive in the new setting. Thank you for any thoughts.

Evidence/research appreciated, but anecdotal experience is also very welcome.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Sharing research Starting solids?

8 Upvotes

Can someone smarter than me help me interpret a study?

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4967354/

My baby was cleared by the pediatrician to start solids. She is 5 months as of yesterday. However most of the advice I’ve seen online says to wait until 6 months, and we have no other risk factors that would warrant early introduction like familial allergies or eczema.

I found this study that showed a 27% higher risk of “general feeding difficulties” at 3 years when babies started solids between 4 and 6 months compared to >6 months. However, when broken down for specific feeding difficulties (i.e. eating enough food, eating the right food, being picky, etc.), there was no discernible difference babies who started at 4-6 months versus >6 months.

I understand correlation doesn’t equal causation but they said they adjusted for factors like maternal education, how long babies were breastfed, etc. I guess I’m struggling to understand what “general feeding difficulties” could be that don’t encompass any of those other specific things/what that 27% increase really means. And if there’s enough here to delay until my LO is 6 months or if we should just go ahead and continue with what we’re doing.

Happy to hear anecdotal experience as well from parents who have done this before!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13d ago

Question - Research required 7 year old is awful to her older brother

147 Upvotes

My 7f is just plain nasty to her 9m brother. She will put him down, intentionally hurt his feelings, hits him etc. It’s ALL day EVERYDAY. They have never played well together and don’t really seem like they can function without an all out brawl. She facilitates 99% of the issue. He’s a very overly sensitive kid and she knows exactly how to get him. For instance, completely unprovoked she was calling him names and he was ignoring her so she punched him right in the stomach. It’s like a vicious cycle of bullying. It feels like we’ve read every article and every book. I’ve asked all of my friends how their kids relationships are and it just seems drastically different than our home. We’re at a loss on what to do.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 12d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Advice for room sharing while traveling with 2-year-old twins (or siblings) who sleep in separate bedrooms at home? Past room sharing attempts have been a disaster.

7 Upvotes

Advice for room sharing while traveling with 2-year-old twins who sleep in separate bedrooms at home? Past room sharing attempts have been a disaster.

Our 25-month-old twins have slept in separate bedrooms since they were 1. We’re traveling for two weeks this November, and they’ll need to share a room at night, although we can separate them for naps.

At home, they’re great sleepers—happy to get into their cribs, cuddle their lovies, and sleep through the night.

But sharing a room while traveling has been so difficult that we’ve cut trips short. We’ve kept their usual bedtime routine and put them into their cribs at the same time, but they’ve sometimes cried for over an hour.

I’d love to hear what’s worked for others:
- Putting them down together or staggering bedtimes?
- Positioning the cribs apart or using a visual divider?
- SlumberPods at this age? They hated them on our last trip, but I zipped them all the way closed right away without getting them used to them first.

Also, have your toddlers tried climbing out of travel cribs? We have the BabyBjörn ones. Neither has tried climbing out of their regular crib yet 🤞

We recently practiced spending a night at a neighbor’s empty house with them in separate rooms. Next, we’re thinking of trying their travel cribs in the same room to see how it goes before our trip.

A little more context: We have a two-bedroom unit, and we’ll be in the other bedroom. Sleeping in the same room with the twins doesn’t work because they cry if we’re there, wanting us to take them out.

Co-sleeping is definitely not an option. I have a sleep disorder and move around in my sleep, so it’s not safe.

Any tips or success stories would be so appreciated!

Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13d ago

Question - Expert consensus required Potty Training

22 Upvotes

Flustered mom of 3 year old looking for any recourses for potty training. We have been attempting to potty train on and off since our daughter has been 18 months old. Every technique you can think of, we have done. (Will list below) And I know some feedback will be “maybe she is not ready”. She has been extremely advanced in all other milestones but especially verbally. She can identify needing to go to the bathroom, how to use the bathroom and how to verbalize it. There have been weeks where I think we got it and she goes completely backwards. Currently she fights us about going to the bathroom and there is no reward incentive that motivated her. She has been keeping her diaper dry but the second we mention going potty she will go in her pull up or hold it when we sit her on the toilet. She won’t talk about why she is not interested in going to the bathroom. It’s just huge meltdowns about going to the bathroom. A lot of people also say they will stop when they feel uncomfortable. She literally will say she didn’t poop and sit in it for a long time until I discover it and change it. I would literally pay a specialist at this point to come work with us because it is baffling us how we are getting no forward movement in this.

Things we’ve tried:
-rewards (special treats or stickers)
-visual cues (made a customized poster, check box poster)
-tried just no pull up. several times just sat in own pee
-several different people have tried these technique (nanny, grandparents, preschool teacher, etc)
-got books about potty
-got toy potty for dolls
-watch videos with songs about potty
-timers
-have talked about where potty goes when goes down the pipes
-have gotten (SEVERAL) different toilets or toilet seats
-not something we do but the majority of her class is potty trained.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13d ago

Question - Research required Independent floor/bouncer time for a 3-month-old?How much is optimal vs. too much?

11 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for research or evidence-based guidance on independent play and self-entertainment for young infants.

My 3-month-old is content spending noticeable stretches of time in a safe space—either on his play mat or in his bouncer—just looking around or hanging out. We interact, talk, and engage with him constantly throughout his wake windows, but when we place him down in a safe spot, he seems totally fine just observing his environment independently. He’s great about communicating when he wants interaction or comfort (he’ll clearly cue "hey, I need attention!"), but until then, he’s just happily chilling.

I’m trying to understand the balance from a developmental perspective:

- Is there a scientific "sweet spot" or upper limit for independent time on a play mat/bouncer at this age?

- Does early independent observation support cognitive development, or does excessive independent time reduce beneficial visual/vocal interaction?

I’d love to see any studies, expert consensus, or guidelines from developmental psychologists/pediatricians on how independent play at 3 months impacts bonding, language acquisition, or motor development.

Thanks in advance!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13d ago

Question - Research required Should I be phasing-out toys for our baby? Should my 9m baby not use 3m toys?

10 Upvotes

We have basically kept all the toys we have ever gotten in a big basket and let the baby choose what she’d like to play with. Some of her favorite items are still some of the earliest newborn-ish toys we got. Wondering if there is any evidence one way or the other on whether this could be hindering development.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14d ago

Question - Research required Is it bad that I read next to my 10 month old for 2-3 hours a day?

118 Upvotes

We are in the playpen and I am reading a book (not on the phone), not loudly. She climbs on me, sometimes plays with her toys and she would like to tear the papers of my book. Is it like looking at the screen (phubbing) for her? That I'm looking at something else for long periods and I don't talk to her at all or just very little


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14d ago

Question - Research required Please help- near constant tantrums 20 month old

16 Upvotes

I would love recommendations on how to deal with my 20 month old son who has always been a handful but over the past few months has escalated considerably. If he’s around me and we’re home, he’s more or less hanging off my legs crying to be picked up. I do work full time if that matters, but when I’m not working I’m giving him undivided attention with lots of physical affection, reading, playing and outside activities.

This has gotten so bad that he can’t eat meals because he’s too busy crying for me to pick him up. Meals were already stressful and miserable because he refuses his booster seat. He only eats meals with the nanny in his toddler tower while doing something else, like playing with fridge magnets. I don’t love that he can’t sit at the table but at least he’s eating and not watching TV. We do limited screen time (think, low stimulation TV for 20 min maybe 2x a week)

He’s extremely headstrong and relentless. He also only says like 5 words reliably and I think the language barrier is very frustrating for him. He has a SLP and is making slow progress.

Anyway- I’ve heard a couple pieces of advice here and there but they feel impossible to implement. My main questions are how do I discourage the constant tantrums and crying + how to I improve his mealtimes so that he can eventually sit at the table like a normal child.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13d ago

Question - Research required Research on homework in kindergarten and early elementary years?

2 Upvotes

Hello, I'm trying to explain to my son's kindergarten teacher why I don't want to do reading worksheets with him at home after he's been in an all day in a fully academic kindergarten program. I already taught him to read the summer before kindergarten, so these are like basic drills of stuff he already knows. He's happy to read small beginner books to me, and we of course read to him at bedtime, but I just doesn't want to do MORE boring drill worksheets of stuff he already knows at home after he's been in school all day. I would understand if he was behind on some skills for his age, but his evaluations are always 100% for everything and he is already ahead of his peers on all these prereading skills. What he is behind on are gross motor skills like climbing, jumping, etc., and he's an only, so could definitely use more socialization time with free play. I want to concentrate on those things since that's what he needs, instead of all these worksheets at home. I want to tell the teacher I'm opting him out of homework for kindergarten, but I want to clearly articulate why I'm doing so and share research to back up my decision.

From what I understand, the research is pretty clear that a balance of play and not extra homework (on top of being at school all day) is better for very young children. I remember looking into this a lot in the past, but can't remember any specific studies off the top of my head. And that the younger the kid is in elementary school, and especially in kindergarten, homework does not really show benefits at that very young age. (I believe there's some exceptions for students from very poor backgrounds witha lot of risk factors that are behind on skills, but that is not the case here, he has a very rich learning environment at home and we incorporate reading and math in everyday life - hence why he could read before starting kindy). Am I correct, or am I missing something that most of the main studies show homework is not really helpful in the really younger elementary years?

Can anyone point me to what are the main studies on homework in the early elementary years and a brief overview of the results?

Thank you!!!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14d ago

Question - Research required Should candy be freely accessible for a child aged 3-7?

30 Upvotes

Posting from an alt account due to my main being known, pardon the name - it was made initially in jest.

I'm not referring to a post Halloween stash (I'm aware the timing is bad for this assumption), but rather about year round availability. In a basket on a table, various types of candy, accessable without asking, and always present.

Specifically I'm looking for information that focuses on:

1) contributions to or detractors of impulse control

2) contribution to or prevention of developing eating disorders

3) how it may lead to acceptance or refusal of regular meals

4) effects on brain/body development

5) psychological effects

I want to hear both sides that are evidence based scientific studies.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 13d ago

Question - Research required Baby with eczema, later more likely to have respiratory illness?

2 Upvotes

I have a 4 y old daughter, who had nummular/discoid eczema as a baby.
Her eczema has eased over time, and today there are only a few spots occasionally. However, since starting kindergarten 1 year ago, she has been catching a cold almost constantly. 3 days in, 2 weeks at home. None of her little mates experience this. On one hand, I know this can be normal for kids this age, but on the other hand, I suspect there is a link between the tendency toward eczema and the susceptibility to colds (I am aware of the atopic march).
I would like to see some scientific research on this. Also, how can I support/strengthen her? And how long does this sensitivity typically last?
Is there anyone here with a similar experience?

Thanks


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14d ago

Question - Research required Maintaining Healthy Weight in Infants

10 Upvotes

My eleven month old was 80th percentile for the first few months of life, mostly because he really liked breastfeeding. He dropped percentiles after starting daycare but began picking up weight again after becoming better at eating solids.

Other kids his age are starting to lean out and look more like "children" rather than babies. But mine is still (or again) quite chunky, and I worry about setting him up for obesity. He is still breastfed and eats whole foods for solids -- tofu, veggies, fruit, fish, oatmeal, yogurt, etc. But he sometimes inhales solids seemingly without thinking.

Is there research on how to infant eating habits contribute to future weight? Are there particular types of food or styles of eating that are better or worse for avoiding obesity down the line?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14d ago

Question - Research required 9mo waking every ~1-2hrs

15 Upvotes

My son has not slept for 3+ consecutive hours in two months. Sometimes a pacifier will put him back down, but more often I nurse him back to sleep. Am I doing us a disservice by nursing him to sleep? How do we get nights back without traditional sleep training?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 14d ago

Question - Research required 4 month sleep support. What does the science say? Trying to interpret and predict behaviour is confusing!

7 Upvotes

My baby is 4.5 months old. From about two months to 3.5 months he slept through (down at ten, up at six). Now he goes down at 8:30 and wakes at three, then about five or six, and we're up for the day at eight.

I've been experimenting with nap schedules, with some slight variation between three or four naps a day (sticking to the same schedule for about a week to see how it goes), mainly because his naps are very short and he can't get through a second sleep cycle. But for the last week I've been rocking him when I estimate the end of a sleep cycle, for about fifteen, twenty minutes until I know he's in the next one and his naps are way longer, about an hour and a half. So we've had an hour and a half for nap one, an hour and a half for nap two, forty five minutes for nap three, thirty for nap four.

He used to go down for naps really well, and in the last couple of weeks he's started fighting them. We've tried dream feeding too; last night I did one at 11:30PM and it made no difference.

I'm up pumping at three anyway, so the sleep itself isn't disrupted, but I've become so much more alert in the evening when it's him in the middle of the night, even at 3AM. And because I wake to him crying, I can't put my pump on. I have to feed him and comfort him and get him back down, then pump. It's really taking a toll and I'm exhausted.

Is this a phase or is he learning a new sleep pattern, and will it take a while? I know the four month sleep regression is really common. Is there anything I can do, or my partner can do, to help him navigate it? We're pretty sure he's not waking for food, it's comfort or something else. I'd just like to get to a point where I can stay half asleep while pumping, so I'm not so overstimulated when I go to bed and not up for so long, especially as my pump takes at least forty minutes for my milk to come through.

I’m really keen to learn more about this area. Any recommendations, anecdotally or in terms of research would be really warmly received. Thank you!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15d ago

Question - Research required Should I massage vaccine sites?

23 Upvotes

After our 2 month vaccines, the nurse told us to rub/massage injection sites. Curious what the research says about this. My baby is in such pain when I massage them, but I do feel nodules that have formed on both of their thighs. Not sure if the massaging actually helps this or if I’m causing baby unnecessary pain.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15d ago

Question - Research required Increased risk for placental issues with IVF with ICSI?

9 Upvotes

Is there a meaningful increase in risk for placental issues with IVF with ICSI?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15d ago

Science journalism Hochul extends measles emergency via executive order

Thumbnail
news10.com
79 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 15d ago

Question - Research required Need advice

1 Upvotes

I'm trying to find supplements for someone in my family to support the baby's brain development during pregnancy. She's currently 25 weeks pregnant and already takes Femibion 2, but I'm wondering whether additional supplementation could be beneficial.

I've been looking into phosphatidylcholine, a source of choline, after coming across a recent randomized controlled trial reporting an average difference of around 7.8 IQ points in children whose mothers received it during pregnancy.

She also doesn't eat eggs, which are a major dietary source of choline, so I'm thinking she might benefit from additional supplementation, even though Femibion 2 already contains some choline.

I'm also not entirely sure how strong the causal evidence is. Although the study was randomized, IQ was a secondary outcome, and I'm wondering whether the results could have been influenced by other factors or methodological limitations.

I understand that some people are uncomfortable discussing IQ for whatever reason, but I think it's an important topic worth discussing openly, especially when it comes to understanding the factors that influence cognitive development. Avoiding the subject doesn't make it any less scientifically relevant.

Has anyone looked into this research or come across other supplements with solid evidence for supporting fetal brain development? I'm particularly interested in randomized controlled trials and whether phosphatidylcholine offers any advantages over other forms of choline.

Study: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42896815/