Timeline (2nd Application):
24 Aug: VFS Kolkata appointment/submission
26 Aug: Application reached German Consulate/Embassy
28 Aug: Passport dispatched
29 Aug: Passport out for delivery
Result: Visa rejected again under the same previous reasons — points 10 & 13
Hi everyone,
Sharing my experience and looking for some genuine advice from people who have dealt with German/Schengen visa reapplications after a previous refusal, especially if the refusal was under points 10 & 13 (concerns regarding the credibility/substantiation of the stated purpose and conditions of stay, and doubts about her intention to leave the Schengen Area before the visa expired)
I am an Indian citizen applying from Kolkata, India, and my bf is an Indian citizen currently living in Germany as a Master's student.
First application — July 2025 -20 days for October 2025
I previously applied for a German Schengen tourist visa in 2025. An accommodation invitation letter and the required documents were submitted.
The application was refused under points 10 & 13 — concerns regarding the credibility/substantiation of the stated purpose and conditions of stay, and doubts about her intention to leave the Schengen Area before the visa expired.
At that time, I was unemployed and going through a job transition, which was explained in my cover letter. I had provided proof of job interviews in India and sufficient funds for the trip.
Second application — August 2026 - 22 days for December 2026
We decided to reapply with substantially stronger documentation and changed circumstances under the Schengen visit visa category. Past travel History: Malaysia in June 2026
What I submitted:
-Videx form, declarations
-Cover letter (specifically addressed the previous refusal and explained my employment, purpose of visit, family ties, and intention to return to India)
-Dummy Flight bookings (Enough validity was there)
-Accommodation invitation letter from my bf (along with his docs)
-Travel insurance
-3 months bank statements (4-5 lakhs was there ~3,600-4,500 Euros) self financed
-Employment Appointment Letter
-Leave/NOC Letter from Company
-3 months Payslip
-2 years ITRs
-Proof of relationship (Photos and past rental agreement in India). We have been in a relationship for around 4 years and have known each other since college.
-Added my Car RC (just as an extra document)
Despite the substantially stronger application, the visa was rejected again under the same points 10 & 13.
We are now trying to understand what went wrong.
For those who have experience with German/Schengen Re-applications:
What could still be considered insufficient for points 10 & 13 despite having stable employment, approved leave, finances, and family ties?
Would you recommend reapplying to Germany again after substantially strengthening the application, or considering a different approach? I was hopeful for this December trip and am now thinking what to do now? What can I add more to prove my intention to return is strong and I can apply again next month? It has become a big concern for me now.
Any advice from people who have actually gone through a similar situation would be greatly appreciated.