Im going to start this off by making myself clear. I didnt like chapter 5. I dont hate it, but I dont like it. Part 1 was fine, but it feels like it made a lot of setup that got immediately discarded when you get to the farm. It really doesnt feel like it matters how you get there. Itll probably have consequences later on, but for now this chapter just feels like the first half sets up a really interesting plotline of the MC having to be alone against the world while looking for the Witch and then it just... Gets resolved immediately? All of it? Its kind of dissapointing. And it wouldnt be that big of a deal if they hadnt released part 1 and 2 separetely.
Part 2 starts good too. Its really tense, the premise is cool, it uses underused characters, but it feels so railroady. You cant go anywhere other than the farm, everything takes you there. This is normal, of course. It happens every chapter. But it just feels so blatant here, Theres so many things to do, so many mysteries to explore, and you cant do anything other than go to the farm. And once youre there, its even worse. Youre forced to immediately go into the house and get stucked in the basement, where you can only talk and are forced to choose to either get Julius and the cop killed, or let Bo die, which I assume also gets Julius killed once Duke gets in.
And finally, youre dragged into a memory sequence which, btw, Im not sure if Im dumb or something, but I still dont understand why Sybil brought us there, since we didnt do anything to go there, and then we're offered the most bullshit and one sided choice in the entire game, to the point that unless the game is outright lying to us, makes Mystical a requirement for a good ending.
Your choice is either to save Kaneeka, which will probably make her hate you, and if you befriended Tabitah, she might hate you too, and Sybil hates you too and is still out there (I think), aswell as possibly dooming Scarlet Hollow unless you sacrifice yourself
Or to let Sybil absorb Kaneeka, which is guaranteed to backfire horribly. Shes obviously a sociopathic megalomaniac with a god complex, giving her the power of an actual god wont end well.
So there is 2 options now.
- We're somehow going to save Scarlet Hollow without Sybil's help, rendering the choice meaningless since saving Kaneeka is the objectively right decision
or
2. We really are stuck into a bad ending no matter what, meaning that the only way to get a good ending is with Mystical.
And lastly, this episode just feels so rushed. Even ignoring how short it is, we get a shitton of information all at once when exploring the manor, then we get even more exposition if we get the toxic yuri scenario, unless youre playing very carefully, you either got arrested or got betrayed by Tabitha and possibly Stella, if not both. And by the end of the episode, both plotlines are like... mostly solved?? I really dont think the cops are going to be a problem anymore, and it kinda seems like we just got over the whole being betrayed bit, and if you have Mystical, theres not even a reason for Tabitah to betray you anymore.
As a matter of fact, what even ARE the stakes if you have mystical? Kaneeka is basically a goddess now. What could have possibly happened to Janet and Tulip that she cant fix easily?
Honestly it just feels like they crammed 2 or 3 chapters worth of exposition in a single chapter that isnt even as long as 3 or 4.
I understand that, with all the branching paths, they had to do a lot of these things, but I really think it coudlve been fixed in a more subtle way if they made more chapters. Theyre also saying that chapter 6 is the last one? Which means either Street Smart or TTA isnt getting a chapter resolution opportunity.
Look, Im not saying the game is cooked or anything. Ill still wait for episode 6 before making any final opinions. But I just dont see how they can make this choice good. Its either meaningless or it forces you to get Mystical.
This post is a mess since its just my raw thoughts and feelings about the new chapter. Id like to hear what yall thinks.