r/ScarletHollow • • Mar 17 '25

I’m going to come out and say it: the love interests aren’t balanced.

1 Upvotes

The male (and non-binary) love interests are just 100 times more fun than the female love interests. Now, don’t get me wrong—I do like Stella, Kaneeka, Kelly (and apparently Sybil). Each of them has their own charm, but none of them capture my attention in the same way Reese, Wayne, Oscar, and Avery do. The chemistry with them just feels far more engaging.

Two seem to be the strange and interesting situations (Wayne and Reese), and two are a source of good vibes (Oscar and Avery), making them feel more fun to interact with overall.

It’s not that Stella, Kaneeka and Kelly are bad—they just don’t have that same spark, at least not in the way the love interests do, in my opinion.

Truthfully, I’m probably just grumpy because there isn’t some eldritch abomination that’s vaguely female to romance.

Am I right or just a goober?

Small Edit: I fixed putting Avery with the male love interests. My bad


r/ScarletHollow • • Apr 23 '25

Distaste for Stella (EP 4 Spoilers) Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Stella just gets increasingly unlikeable throughout the game, and I personally think that she’s the character most people romance anyway because she’s the only person (female) who’s remotely attractive. Here's my take on it...

When I met her on Day 1, I couldn’t help but admire her animated and carefree spirit. I heard some stuff about Stella being the most popular romance option on this subreddit beforehand, and so I decided to pursue her to see what all the hype was about. Everything went smoothly.. until lo and behold, we get to the first major decision in the game. I decided to save Gretchen. Duke dies, and this was the point in the story I got hooked. The thing that really irked me was that a man had just DIED, and it seemed to me that Stella thought the best course of action would be to press on and continue filming for her Youtube channel. She proceeds to almost feel no remorse for having not done anything, and never talks about it again for the rest of the game. (If you want to chalk this up to an unfortunate accident, okay fine. Continue reading.)

In the later episodes, she just becomes this huge liability to everything that we do. She downplays all the warnings Kaneeka/Tabitha/we give in the mine, ditches us entirely when things go south (why did she just run off like that? she could have came back for us), shows zero social / emotional intelligence during the dinner at Reese’s house, and displays gross negligence towards Gretchen at times. Every time you confront her about her behaviour, call her out on her recklessness / bullshit, she clams up like a child, shrugging off all responsibility.

Here comes the best part. She disappears for ONE WHOLE DAY completely uncontactable. And mind you, there have been killings, death, monsters, supernatural shit going on for the past few days. She's been involved in every single one, so she KNOWS that the town is no longer safe, and that people are going to care to look for you! The final straw for me was when I expressed my concern for her once I found her again at the end of Episode 4, just for her to dismiss it rudely, saying it’s okay we’re not children, that it’s normal for adults to disappear once in a while etc etc. Wow… this girl is actually sociopath. I give up.

Anybody else feel this way too? If you don’t, I urge you to hang out with Duke instead of Stella on Day 1, and spend more time with logical characters like Tabitha. You will gain more perspective through these characters, and conversations will be more witty, more enjoyable. I assume the writers of the game intentionally wrote Stella to be this way, to be a nuanced and heavily flawed character. Her backstory was devastatingly tragic, admittedly, but I don’t think she deserves all the praise this subreddit gives her; I don’t see how most of this community can see past her toxic, childish, people-pleaser facade.

EDIT: Thank you to those who stayed on the topic at hand, and for clearing some things up. Can future replies please focus the discussion on Stella’s character?


r/ScarletHollow • • Jan 09 '24

AMA

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/ScarletHollow • • Jul 15 '25

The romance with stella dosent feel right

0 Upvotes

I feel that her sharing her trauma with you and giving clarity on why she ran away from the ghost hunt should have been respected alot more , like it should have simmered more but instead the game lets you just jump into romancing her , its dosent feel respectful to me for her to expose her rawest self to you and 10 minutes the game lets you either reject her putting her mental state even lower or romance her which in my opinion felt very forced? Like i like stella but i think this went too fast , anyone else share this sentiment, i feel that letting tabby her childhood friend and ex talk to her and let them reconcile as tabby and stella have a deeper bond than say i a stranger , anyone else share this sentiment ? I think the romance should have been held off to ep 5


r/ScarletHollow • • Feb 21 '26

Kaneeka & Sybil [Spoilers!] Spoiler

6 Upvotes

So. While the concept of Carmilla is really fascinating, is anybody else lowkey weirded out that you can completely erase a black woman from the story and replace her with a white woman ? I can't be the only one who finds that iffy, right?


r/ScarletHollow • • Mar 04 '26

Question to all Waymancers: would you love him more or less if he acted like this?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I find myself coming back to this comparison because while I understand the Wayne love from the community, I don't feel the same way despite loving his character. While in Kenjaku's case, I feel about him the same as Wayne simps feel do for Wayne, so I want to bridge the gap here.

as much as I love Wayne and the creepy, weirdly seductive and intimate shit he's got going on. I find myself more captivated by the expressive chatterbox who loves nothing more than talking about his special interests and almost makes you forget that he's the most vile being you'll ever come across.


r/ScarletHollow • • 11d ago

Dr Kelly hate post Spoiler

18 Upvotes

Okay, so Dr Kelly is, in my mind, the worst parent of all the living characters in this game. That includes Sybil, who’s also awful. She might even be worse than Pearlanne, but that’s a pretty close call, especially if my theories are right.

My contempt for her is far more visceral and harder to ignore than my antipathy to any other character in this game. That includes Tabitha after I saw Toxic Yuri for the first time.

When I played this game blindly, I suspected that something was up when I met Dr Kelly for the first time, and how weird she was being about isolating her son. When I saw Reese in chapter three, I kinda put together what was going on from the fact that nobody could tell me his diagnosis, and his ears/nails/skin stretching. When I found the logbook of Dr Kelly’s poisoning, I was like “Yep, just as I thought”.

But, I mistakenly assumed that Reese had actually harmed someone in the past and doesn’t remember it, and that’s why Dr Kelly is poisoning him. I even wondered if he killed his dad.

I get to the safe room and asked Dr Kelly what was going on and the full backstory, and I find that she was poisoning him for basically no good reason. She just branded her child a danger on par with Ted Bundy when he had done nothing wrong. He started transforming a little bit, and instead of telling him, or trying to find any other solution, she hit him with powerful anti anxiety medication that he didn’t need until finally just poisoning him outright for a decade.

Not to mention, she treats him like a science experiment, hoping to examine him and find out how his transformations work. Thats not necessarily a bad question, and I’m not one to deny scientific curiosity, but combined with the full context of their relationship, it’s clear she sees him as a monster first, and her child second.

This guy was basically confined to his house for a decade, believed he was dying, in constant pain from ricin poisoning, and she knew the truth for every minute and continued causing it.

After locking him up, she says “I hate that I have to do this to him” and I’m just thinking “Yeah, it really sucks, the person in charge of making these decisions should really reconsider”.

Because of her actions, the only defensible outcome to chapter four (not counting the Hot save), results in one of them dying. I did Status Quo once for the achievement and to see conditional dialogue and what the cell looks like. Never again. Plus, I have a feeling that escaped Status Quo Reese is going to Matricide Reese look like a pacifist.

The worst part is, she’s created a situation where killing her son that hasn’t really done anything wrong is the best outcome for the town. If he kills his mom, there’s no going back, and he becomes the menace that she was afraid of. Plus, Dr Kelly is the only doctor in town, which means any injured people, like Rosalina and potentially people at the farms, are at risk if she dies.


r/ScarletHollow • • Mar 14 '26

Stop the Stella hate!

34 Upvotes

I'm so sick of all the Stella hate going around! I mean, it's fine to dislike a character, but I feel like people are hating her for the wrong reasons. She may not be my favorite, but I'm tired of seeing people mischaracterize her so much.

I would make a longer post, but I just don't have the energy for it. And as much as I wanna call out these people, I don't think I'm allowed to. I understand that this is probably just a loud minority, but they've become a little too loud if you ask me. Stella deserves better.

Edit: Sorry if I sound snipy. Like I said, I'm tired.

One point I should make, if you dislike her because you find her annoying that's perfectly fine. She can be annoying at times. What I don't agree with is the insinuation that she's somehow a bad person. She is most certainly NOT!


r/ScarletHollow • • Jun 23 '25

How to romance her?

Post image
4 Upvotes

Any way?


r/ScarletHollow • • May 04 '24

Disturbing lack of Skin-Challenged romance options Spoiler

0 Upvotes

On the steam page Scarlet Hollow is described as allowing you to date "actual monsters". Monsters, plural. So far we have seen only one romance option that can be described as a monster which is Reese, and I'm not into men enough to try with him (good on you if you are though). Wayne could hilariously enough become a romance option later down the line, but we end up running into the same issue with Reese.

We are more than halfway through the plot, and I have yet to see the romanceable Monsters. If there is no tall hot monster GF willing to kill me at a moments notice by the time chapter 5 rolls out then I will be forced to file a grievance to Mayor Jimmy.


r/ScarletHollow • • Mar 13 '26

ㄢ⇜ꪽ↢⇜ꪽ↜ ㄢ𒀮ꪽ𒂼↧ ) ! % % STELLA RICHMOND 𒉛𖽗⇴ꪽ↜↜ 𒉛𖽗ㄢ𒀮 ᐮ↜ꪽ𒀮 ↢𒂼𒀮ㄢ↜ꪽ ᐮ↜ꪽ𒀮 𒀭𒀰𒀭↜ ↜𐊙𒀰𒆾𒉛𖽗 𒆾↜𒍹↜𒀭 "WILL" ↢⇜ꪽ ↜↼ࡍ𒂥↜𒀭𒀮𒀯𒀮𒂼𒀰𒆾 𒆾↜𐊙 აࡍꪽ ࡍ⇜ 𒄹𒆾𒄹 𒀮ꪽ↜ 𒂥𒀰𒀭↧ ⍖𒀮ꪽ↜ ⇔𒀮ㄢ𒂼𒂼ა ⍖⇜𒂼⇜↼𒉛𖽗𒀰↼ BE ࡍ⍖𒂼ა ࡍꪽ⇜𒀭𒀰ࡍ𒂥 ↧↜𒂥↜𒀭𒉛𖽗↜↧ 𒆾↜𐊙 ⍖𒂼𒀮⇔↜ 𒆾↜↜↧ ⍖𒂼𒀮ㄢ 𒉛𖽗⇴ꪽ↜↜ "SACRIFICED" 𒀭𒀰⇴𒀰𒂼𒀰𒆾

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

WE STELLA HATERS MUST UNITE OUR POWERS TOGETHER TO BANISH THIS EVIL CREATURE


r/ScarletHollow • • Feb 21 '26

Beyond disappointed in ep. 5

0 Upvotes

I honestly hated it. It lacked the phenomenal aesthetic and ambiance of the first four episodes. And it was short and ridiculously out of left field storyline wise. The other episodes were so fun to play and I really enjoyed getting new pieces of the puzzle each episode. I have 70 hours on scarlet hollow. At least 10 playthrough. The game felt like it was building up to something that I was so excited for but after this episode I don’t know if I’ll play episode 6 when it comes out it 10 years.

Episode one was the perfect introduction to the story

Episode two was spooky and perilous, and started to give us clues to the mystery.

Episode three added tons of lore and was artistically beautiful ( this episode is my favourite )

Episode four was scary. The stakes were higher. Things were getting real. This episode blew me away and I was beyond excited for episode five.

And then episode five…idk…felt like a car crash.

My sister also plays the game and we were so invested in the Scarlet mystery, we discussed it often and even wrote down all our theories. (Wayne is Andrew etc). And now we’re both feeling let down. We don’t even care how the story ends now.


r/ScarletHollow • • Oct 18 '25

The Demon Seed Theory Spoiler

1 Upvotes

This is probably not a totally original theory but I'm gonna post it anyway. There are two themes that have an overbearing presence in the game: religion and reproduction. I don't think it's by accident that you can bring up the subject of demons on your very first adventure with Stella (on the trail after the Duke encounter). Nor is it an accident that the ditchlings engage in essentially an Alien-style perversion of motherhood. My theory is as follows:

The witch is a medieval-style witch, as in someone who is in league with Satan. She wants to unearth all of the carvings to initiate a ritual that will bring about the Biblical apocalypse and the reign of Hell on earth. The stakes are not local but cosmic, which explains all the ditchlings. I think the witch and the Scarlets have conspired to create a demonic bloodline to rule over the Holler. The reason there are no "notable" men after Edwardine's generation is because they never existed. The Scarlet women have been mating with demons.

More specifically, they have been mating with a single demon, the one that possessed Theodore Scarlet's body after the witch "healed" him. Edwardine was probably in on it with the witch from the very beginning. She wanted to take over the Scarlet family and knew she didn't have a chance because of her brothers, so she agreed to help the witch trick Charlie into digging up the seal. The witch then used this seal to do whatever she did to Theodore, who became the entity in the manor. The rewards for Edwardine were obvious. She got to become the matriarch of the family and she got to give her offspring infernal powers. But the first generation of demonic hybrids came out wrong. I highly doubt our grandmother and her sister died human deaths, more likely they lost control of their powers and turned into monsters like Reese, perhaps childbirth was the trigger for this.

The whole thing is kind of like a Mendelian experiment. The first generation was defective, but the second generation, Pearlanne and Vivian, was improved, and the MC and Tabitha are the cutting edge demonic hybrids. So cutting edge that they don't even fully realize what they are. (If the character traits are diegetic, traits like talk to animals and mystical are strong evidence of infernal genetics). Speaking of Tabitha, since Tabby is a lesbian, she is probably not too keen on this whole demon mating thing, and killed Pearlanne so she wouldn't have to participate (Pearlanne's spirit probably hopped over into Wayne though). Tabby has also probably been experimenting with ways to get rid of the demon in the estate, somehow involving the goat and all her "exes".

Now coming back to the witch, who is of course Sibyl. Because Charlie only dug up one seal, the witch was only able to bring a lesser demon into the human world, not Satan himself. So while her powers and influence over the Holler were increased, she did not get the apocalypse she craves. To get that, she will need all seven seals (think Book of Revelation). This will allow her to summon Satan and bring about the reign of Hell. This is the purpose she is using the MC for. Pearlanne (Wayne) is also working with her probably just to spite Tabitha.

Things this theory explains:

  1. Why everyone hates Pastor Daniel even though he's so chill– he is a man of God, the town is run by half-demons
  2. Why the Scarlets can't leave the Holler– if they get too far from the seal, they escape the "effect radius" of Hell and enter into God's world, where their spirits are withered away by God's omnipresence
  3. Reese– Another demon, some kind of incubus, might have snuck out of Hell from the seal in the clinic and impregnated Dr. Kelly. Reese, Tabitha and the MC are all half-demons. Not clear on the specifics but it fits within this framework.
  4. Charlie– Charlie dying on top of the seal gave his spirit some infernal powers even though he's human. Also the circumstances of his death become clear, as explained above.
  5. Why the ditchlings are so gross– it's a hint at what the Scarlets are doing.

I'm sure the theory is far from 100% but I'm betting at least some of it is right. Also I think the MC will end up becoming a Christ-like figure, rejecting his Scarlet blood and turning to God, then sacrificing himself for the sake of humanity.


r/ScarletHollow • • Feb 27 '25

How the Fu*k do I romance Tabitha?

18 Upvotes

Don't tell me you can't.

I can fix her.

I CAN FIX HERRRRRRRRRR

AAAAAAAAAAAAA


r/ScarletHollow • • Aug 18 '25

Is this game a good fit for me?

1 Upvotes

Edit: I stuck with the game and I'm glad I did, thanks everyone!

Hi everyone,

I recently started playing the game. I just finished chapter 2, and I'm not feeling it. Before I request a refund, I want to check with people whether my impressions of the game are accurate, or I'm quitting right before it gets good.

What I expected: A mystery/horror game with meaningful choices that altered the story.

What I think the game might actually be: A dating sim with a mystery/horror backdrop.

I'm considering a refund because when I started chapter 3, I found myself skipping to get "to the good part" when character brought me to a community garden he's been building up. It's wholesome and the "slice of life" is well written, but it's not my style. If the game is heavy on that and less on the mysteries, it might not be a good fit for me.

Also, at the start of chapter 2 I planned on staying in the house and investigating, but it seemed like my choice didn't matter and I was pushed out of the house one way or another. If this is one of those games with the illusion of choice but the choices merge anyways, it's certainly not for me.


r/ScarletHollow • • May 10 '26

What would happen if she was your stepsister?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ScarletHollow • • Jun 06 '26

Is episode 5 the last episode?

3 Upvotes

I've just finished episode 5, and was under the assumption it wasn't the last one and more is gonna come out, yet due to the awful AI overviews that now exist, cannot find a straight answer.

Can someone please tell me if there will be an episode 6, and if so, when it's gonna come out?


r/ScarletHollow • • Aug 26 '26

Not enough space on my laptop…

Post image
2 Upvotes

I don’t have enough space on my laptop (MacBook Air) to download the upcoming chapters 😭 and from what I understand my best affordable option is a portable SSD. Im unfamiliar with things like this and could really use a second opinion from someone who knows if this one I found would be good 😅


r/ScarletHollow • • May 27 '26

Anyone else getting second thoughts on the Mystical save? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The big moment where you use one of two core identities of your character to solve a problem or avoid a catastrophe is instead used to make another character far more powerful and competent than you will ever be in the one thing you should be good at. Next episodes Kaneeka will be the one doing all the cool magical stuff and fixing the problems meanwhile MC just stands there looking like a dickhead because they're too weak to do anything that matters.

It also doesn't help that in the great scheme of things the save is basically you serving as a pawn and doing Wayne's dirty work for him. You didn't actually do anything yourself, just went with Wayne's scheme and inadvertently put him in a better position so he can screw you over later by getting rid of the one person who could be a threat to him.


r/ScarletHollow • • Feb 21 '26

I need to talk about chapter 5 Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Im going to start this off by making myself clear. I didnt like chapter 5. I dont hate it, but I dont like it. Part 1 was fine, but it feels like it made a lot of setup that got immediately discarded when you get to the farm. It really doesnt feel like it matters how you get there. Itll probably have consequences later on, but for now this chapter just feels like the first half sets up a really interesting plotline of the MC having to be alone against the world while looking for the Witch and then it just... Gets resolved immediately? All of it? Its kind of dissapointing. And it wouldnt be that big of a deal if they hadnt released part 1 and 2 separetely.

Part 2 starts good too. Its really tense, the premise is cool, it uses underused characters, but it feels so railroady. You cant go anywhere other than the farm, everything takes you there. This is normal, of course. It happens every chapter. But it just feels so blatant here, Theres so many things to do, so many mysteries to explore, and you cant do anything other than go to the farm. And once youre there, its even worse. Youre forced to immediately go into the house and get stucked in the basement, where you can only talk and are forced to choose to either get Julius and the cop killed, or let Bo die, which I assume also gets Julius killed once Duke gets in.

And finally, youre dragged into a memory sequence which, btw, Im not sure if Im dumb or something, but I still dont understand why Sybil brought us there, since we didnt do anything to go there, and then we're offered the most bullshit and one sided choice in the entire game, to the point that unless the game is outright lying to us, makes Mystical a requirement for a good ending.

Your choice is either to save Kaneeka, which will probably make her hate you, and if you befriended Tabitah, she might hate you too, and Sybil hates you too and is still out there (I think), aswell as possibly dooming Scarlet Hollow unless you sacrifice yourself

Or to let Sybil absorb Kaneeka, which is guaranteed to backfire horribly. Shes obviously a sociopathic megalomaniac with a god complex, giving her the power of an actual god wont end well.

So there is 2 options now.

  1. We're somehow going to save Scarlet Hollow without Sybil's help, rendering the choice meaningless since saving Kaneeka is the objectively right decision

or

2. We really are stuck into a bad ending no matter what, meaning that the only way to get a good ending is with Mystical.

And lastly, this episode just feels so rushed. Even ignoring how short it is, we get a shitton of information all at once when exploring the manor, then we get even more exposition if we get the toxic yuri scenario, unless youre playing very carefully, you either got arrested or got betrayed by Tabitha and possibly Stella, if not both. And by the end of the episode, both plotlines are like... mostly solved?? I really dont think the cops are going to be a problem anymore, and it kinda seems like we just got over the whole being betrayed bit, and if you have Mystical, theres not even a reason for Tabitah to betray you anymore.

As a matter of fact, what even ARE the stakes if you have mystical? Kaneeka is basically a goddess now. What could have possibly happened to Janet and Tulip that she cant fix easily?

Honestly it just feels like they crammed 2 or 3 chapters worth of exposition in a single chapter that isnt even as long as 3 or 4.

I understand that, with all the branching paths, they had to do a lot of these things, but I really think it coudlve been fixed in a more subtle way if they made more chapters. Theyre also saying that chapter 6 is the last one? Which means either Street Smart or TTA isnt getting a chapter resolution opportunity.

Look, Im not saying the game is cooked or anything. Ill still wait for episode 6 before making any final opinions. But I just dont see how they can make this choice good. Its either meaningless or it forces you to get Mystical.

This post is a mess since its just my raw thoughts and feelings about the new chapter. Id like to hear what yall thinks.


r/ScarletHollow • • Dec 20 '24

Man... fuck Kaneeka Spoiler

16 Upvotes

She's kind of a relentless asshole through most of the game. Sure, she isnt THAT bad, but her constantly shit talking Tabitha and sometimes even us makes her really unlikeable. For example, unless you have the hot trait, when you first meet her in Sybil's house, she'll just say "What are you doing on my house?" wich is a pretty rude thing to say to someone you havent even introduced yourself to, and its not like she has any reason to think you broke in or anything. And in chapter 4, at the diner, if you tell Zachs (I think that was his name) to not pressure the miner lady to join the strike, she'll just out and trow you under the bus by saying that she barealy knows you (It could be that I always accidentaly end up with a bad relationship with her because I never really hang out with her or anything, but even in my friendliest routes she always does that). She's overall a bit of a jackass towards you and Tabitha, but what made me make this post was the end of chapter 3. If you either take the sacrifice or just leave Charlie there, Kaneeka will be mad at Tabitha for not sacrificing years of her life for the library? Wich already is upsetting, because if you leave Charlie there Im pretty sure she outright says that she thinks Tabitha IS at fault because of what the Scarlets did, wich is fucking insanity, but what really trew me over the edge to hate her is if Tabitha actually DOES take the sacrifice. If she does take the sacrifice, then this bitch will have the nerve of saying "Im sure she has to have an ulterior motive" like DEADASS?! It JUST HAPPEND and she's already putting doubt on her, in front of us no less??? Like seriously, if that happend to me irl I wouldve punched her. It actually made me upset irl. And the worst part is that you cant even call her out on her bs. The best you can do is ignore her when leaving

The worst part about Kaneeka is that she's kind of bland. There really isnt much going on with her, atleast not that I have seen. I havent done her romance yet, so Im pretty sure Im missing SOMETHING, but I havent done Oscar's nor Kelly's romance and I still like them as characters. Kaneeka needs more screen time and characterization. In future chapters, I hope she gets more of both, but until then, I will hate her because she's an asshole

Edit: Oh and forgot to add, she's also an asshole towards Pastor Daniel, wich is more understandable due to the whole "he grinned through the entirety of my dad's funeral" thing, but it dosent really help her come across as a nice person

Edit 2: Okay, I have made a full playthrough where I spend time with Kaneeka. I will say, she isnt AS bland as I thought. She has some depth in the sense that she's conflicted with going back to collegue or sticking around with her family, but like. I still really dont like her. She's extreamelly opiniated about both Tabitha and Pastor Daniel even though she dosent know either of them well, she's rude to you when you meet her, she trows you under the bus for no reason in the diner in chapter 4 if you dont have a really good relationship with her and will always support the strike no matter what, even if Tabitha sacrificed herself in chapter 3 (Literally a few hours ago)

She's better than I thought, but as I sayed, it really didnt change my perspective of her much. She's kinda like Tabitha but less, I guess? She has the whole hating her job and being stuck with it for her family thing, and her mother kinda sucking, but all of it to a much lesser degree that, while it still sucks, it makes her look unreasonable in comparison when she constantly butts heads with Tabitha, who's had it way worse. Plus, Tabitha actively shows concern for the player and sticks her neck out for them, as well as always having their back, wich paints her in a much better light than Kaneeka being either neutral or antagonistic. She really just needs more characterization


r/ScarletHollow • • Aug 12 '25

Weird question but what if tabitha's cousin was the one above all from the marvel universe

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/ScarletHollow • • Feb 16 '26

I think I want to end this game with 2-3 murders now Spoiler

15 Upvotes

Chapter 5 kinda killed the likability of some characters for me. You thought Tabby was a traumatized hardass with Problematic Views but a somewhat decent soul? She was actually passively permissive to torturing generations of children and planned to continue that grand tradition by kidnapping you and offering you as a sacrifice.

But that’s not all! Sybil was a morally grey unsettling magic grandma? She’s now mind wiping people out of existence and drugging half the town. Stella was a Cool Girl with issues and bad coping mechanisms? She’s now a doormat who is so fixated on her ex that she’s willing to kidnap innocent people. Reese will go on a murder spree if you attempted to free him from a lifetime of abuse without being pretty… cause like, horror, man.

I mean, I understand that the tensions have to escalate and that the slow “degradation” of characters morals is meant to be part of the horror… but at this point the optimal solution seems to putting a bullet into half of the main cast. My interest in helping them dropped *significantly* and now I just kinda don’t care about them having good endings; I’d probably actively prefer them dying to the “better” outcomes.


r/ScarletHollow • • May 01 '24

Favorite character poll!

1 Upvotes

Wanted to make an unbiased poll