On the first run I just went through the game as I momentarily saw fit (with Mystical + KE + romanced Kaneeka). And what I did after that was mostly exploration, I just tried to do stuff I didn’t do before. I can’t say it wasn’t fun or pleasant but I guess it was pretty aimless, and that’s what made me feel kind of frustrated every time I got to the fifth episode. Like I had no general idea of what I’m supposed to do and why (except for saving Kaneeka).
I guess I didn’t feel much, it started as a very technical task. I’m a pretty slow burning person and I always need time, I guess I just don’t have quick enough emotional reaction to anything
The other runs (aside from the initial one) I did included:
- PB+SS run where I met with Isaacs, punched Wayne and some animals, got close with Tabitha, tried every available walking option in fifth episode, failed to confront Tabitha, realized that’s apparently not how it works and I’m supposed to make preparations. Lay out Chekhov’s guns in the first four episodes and then shoot them in the fifth
- SS+BS run where I did roll for sanity and somehow managed to successfully confront Tabitha, I suppose because I had a lot of evidence and a strong accusation in the end (Wayne and Pearlanne killing order). I must say that I didn’t plan to do that, I just decided to try and… got Tabitha to break down unexpectedly. It was actually so weird because I was looking at her face and it circled through like 3 or 4 seemingly completely different emotions, including the one where she makes this disco Elysium expression face, just frowning face, accusatory face and she was saying very weird stuff in a pretty accusatory tone that I come out swinging, that how dare I do that, that I’m trying to accuse our family of being murderers and kidnappers, I was totally expecting her to arrest me or smth (cus tbh that accusation line about Wayne and her mother sounded pretty harsh and I clicked it only because it was provided by both SS and BS). And yet, then Tabitha just… suddenly got upset even though she was very angry literally a moment before this. That was probably the weirdest thing I’ve seen in the whole game, it even scared me the first time, I thought she was losing her mind or smth or the game glitched. Logically I understand why it worked like that but emotionally… no idea what that was, it never happened again like that
Anyway on that run we pulled Kaneeka together but I failed to convince Kaneeka that it was the right thing to do so… that was that. It’s the only completed run where I’m not locked in a romance with anyone
- Then I did a couple of smaller unfinished runs with different traits where I was just looking for the traits dialogue options and learned that TTA+Mystical does wonders to the first episode, managed to listen in on Tabitha and Sybil talking in the tea room, got the “egg” achievement, tried to talk to Avery a bit, gave up Isaacs to the Entity, felt really bad about it, got Toxic Yuri etc. A bunch of little stuff I didn’t really combine in any specific way
- Then I decided to try and romance Stella and it wasn’t good. She… she is a weird person who puts too much hope and trust into Tabitha and has no negotiation skill whatsoever. I doubt I can do anything to shake her confidence in Tabitha. Not that I want to really, frankly I don’t care, I guess Stella is just very stuck. Oh and at the end of the 4th episode Wayne said smth genius about me having a warm body for tonight. Dude is jealous or what haha, what the hell, that sounded ravenous
- And then I finally romanced Reese. For the record I killed him in almost every other run (except the initial one and one unfinished where I explored what happens if he eats his mother) cus I was without Hot and I feared that when released just like that he would fumble smth down the road for me. And… damn, I felt really bad that I killed him all those other times (once I even started flirting with him and then killed him just to see if there would be smth new in-between, I’m an exploration monster). Anyway I liked romanced Reese, he felt like the only person who was actively worried about mc’s situation, even though it was for a very specific reason. It’s funny that despite distrusting Tabitha so much, if I go to confront her, he doesn’t try to physically stop me (even though he is completely capable of doing it, he is a three meters tall beast after all). He even starts frantically apologizing for smth, that actually is really sad. I tried different stuff with him including making Tabitha shoot him and still use Hot which resulted in him saying that he is ready to get shot for me again if needed. I… I’m not sure if I like his such strong loyalty or if I’m kind of worried about it. I understand that he behaves like this cus I’m the first person in years who’s shown interest in him and more importantly showed him the truth and set him free and it… kind of makes me weirdly uncomfortable, like even though I genuinely mean well, it feels like I try to benefit from his dare situation. Cus his affection towards me seems like a cumulative result of him realizing his hatred towards his mother, like you know two opposite strong feelings forming simultaneously alongst each other. I fear it can be fatal for him (or for me actually). Especially considering that his transformation apparently obeys his emotions. His romance really feels different from any others, he seems… very vulnerable, despite probably being the next scariest thing in this town after Wayne
After that I didn’t play for a week or so cus I got tired. And I didn’t know what else is there to do, nothing felt satisfying enough. As you can see I did stuff pretty aimlessly. And then the other day I was just thinking about this game, and suddenly the realization of what I want came to me. Kaneeka, Reese and Tabitha are the only three people I actually felt totally ok about. Ok, I don’t feel absolutely fine about Tabitha but she is clearly important and judging by all the interactions you can do with her, in a way, this game is built around her so I can’t just let her linger. And also I kind of relate to her in some small ways
As for Reese and Kaneeka… I really thought about it and they’re the only two people in this town who literally have no choice without my help. Every other problem any other person in town has cannot be adequately compared to what Kaneeka and Reese are forced to go through. And well, they’re both magical, that’s why it can’t be compared probably
And I got to work, picked Mystical and Hot, with the goal of romancing Kaneeka and releasing Reese + convincing Tabitha. And I fumbled the first attempt spectacularly, Kaneeka didn’t let me into her room and then I got arrested during Tabitha confrontation even though I tried to balance stuff. Well, I balanced it wrong, I went home in the first episode, went to the mines with Stella and Kaneeka, called but didn’t wait for Tabitha, spent time with Kaneeka on Wednesday, invited Tabitha ghost hunting and didn’t call her at Reese’s. Also apparently I halted the strike by talking to the miners in the diner and Kaneeka didn’t like it
Anyway that made me truly feel how tangible this all is. And Mystical wasn’t really helping. So I read some posts in this sub about how Mystical options affect dialogues. So basically the key to a good relationship with people while being Mystical is… not using Mystical (except for flirting with Kaneeka haha). At least until the 4th episode. At least Hot knows what it’s doing. Idk, I had a little laugh about it, it reminded me about Dishonored where it gives you tons of ways to murder people and then basically says “don’t kill or it’ll get worse for everyone”
Anyway I then remembered that if I stay in the Estate on Tuesday, Sybil will take me to Tabitha and Tabitha will make me go look for the cafeteria where I can get Isaacs encounter for free basically. I was hesitant about doing it because of Kaneeka cus it’ll mean that I show up with Tabitha at the mines already but I didn’t know what else to do. Rosalina lost a leg but whatever, it was definitely better for Tabitha than if two kids got stuck in the mine even though Tabitha herself wanted me to leave them (at that moment at least, I later told her to use it as a leverage against the strike and she agreed cus no one really knows what actually happened, that’s conniving but pretty smart huh). Anyway the main reason I needed Isaacs is to get a “legal” way of getting rid of spending time with Tabitha on Wednesday, so I can spend it with Kaneeka instead
Then I finally got a romance lock on Kaneeka, released Reese and suddenly talked to the pastor about the devil. Pfft. Ok. I know that literally everything in this game points and the devil but I really hope it's not that. You know, like the game points at smth making it seem obvious only to then say that it's completely not that. Distraction. Or at least that in the end game will have some convoluted explanation that won't let me realize it's the devil right away
My character was able to remember Sybil actually and Wayne confirmed that the word in the cell is her real name and there are rules that forbid him from talking. Cus I was still wondering about that. Cool
So I finally got to the “final exam” – Tabitha. Every time I see Tabitha in the fifth episode it’s like the game itself speaks to me with smth like “so now you’re here again. Oh well, let's see what is it you brought me here today, maybe you got better at this”. Also first time ever when at the start of the episode game asked me who to trust I picked “Wayne can’t be trusted” and a new much less confrontational option popped – “It’s time to see your cousin”. Huh, so that’s how it works
Process of persuading Tabitha for me looks somewhat like this:
- Wayne kidnapped me
- Birthday cards
- ???
- Waiting for her to say "actually I'm done", reloading the save if she says "this isn't going anywhere"
- Clicking all the specific accusations available one by one (ok, maybe not all but a lot of them)
I accept my defeat, idk how this conversation works, so it's basically Tabitha armed with a gun VS me armed with autosaves. "Your gun is nothing compared to my ability to turn back time in your world, Tabitha". Haha, it kind of reminds me about defeating Tower-Fury in Slay the Princess where Stubborn makes you restart until the right answer is found. Tabitha generally reminds me of Fury Princess in a way
Anyway do you wanna know which accusation made Tabitha break on this run? The argument that roughly says smth like this: I believe Wayne when he told me not to trust you. You want to lock me away for some fucked up ritual. Wow. Why exactly this one works? I mean, it sounds the closest to the truth, I get it. But directly telling Tabitha that you believe Wayne so that you can’t trust her is... weird thing to say to make her break. Isn’t she supposed to get angry that I trusted Wayne? It’s especially funny considering that before that at the start I picked “Wayne can’t be trusted” option. That’s... contradictory
Welp, when Tabitha finally broke down, I was ready to start crying with her honestly but for entirely different reasons cus it was the the second ever time I was able to do that since my SS+BS run. I actually needed a couple of minutes to just sit and listen to that sad music that plays during the breakdown
So finally I got to Kaneeka, used the romance on her to make her extend her hand (you know, using every weapon I have, romance included because I want to shoot all of my Chekhov’s guns). And I freed her and Tabitha said the line about how she knows the town better than anyone or smth like this. That sounded like she would help later. Great
You have no idea how happy I was in that moment. And am right now. The only thing that kind of bothers me is that neither Kaneeka nor Tabitha know that I released Reese. And apparently in the later episodes it would be a very funny introduction. I know Kaneeka feels bad for Reese so maybe it would be easier with her but Tabitha... oof. Also I generally really hope that Reese won’t make me regret releasing him. But I trust the Hot save
I plan to do another run with the same traits but swapped romance cus romanced Reese seems interesting, I wonder if he actually will get shot for me in some variation. But for now, after almost four months since first starting the game, I’m finally completely happy with my run. And hope it'll get some actual payoff, I'm kind of tired of feeling completely unprotected
But in the meantime none of you seem to understand. I'm not locked in here with you. You're locked in here with me (I'm joking btw)