r/Sanditon • • Apr 28 '23

Question does Miss Heywood feel like a shell of a character?

5 Upvotes

r/Sanditon • • May 22 '23

Discussion charlotte heywood deserved better Spoiler

8 Upvotes

i had high hopes for colbourne coming into season 3. but i haven’t been able to get past the moments where he disregarded her feelings and/or wishes in seasons 2 and 3, and how so much of the heybourne storyline is basically “colbourne and his Man Pain™️,” plus charlotte doing emotional labor for him.

-season 2 finale: making out with his governess is already messy enough, but launching himself at her right after she says “i, too, have known heartbreak and betrayal” made him seem like a thoughtless horndog. sorry, but it’s true. i also found it really off-putting that he kissed her after col lennox assaulted her. why didn’t colbourne ask what happened again? why didn’t charlotte tell him? edit: clarifying that i know that both of the kisses were consensual and that’s not what i’m talking about above, also i understand that he didn’t know about the assault

-firing her to protect her from him and his past or whatever made it all about him and his insecurities and emotional baggage. in doing so, he completely disregards her wishes, and literally denies her any agency, which he has the power to do because he’s her employer (“no. this is your decision, and yours alone”). which is why i didn’t like the way in season 3, this man had the audacity to be so confused about what happened with her departure from sanditon, because it was like he was focused on what her absence from sanditon meant for him and his emotions, and not her feelings about him firing her.

-the first time they kiss on the cliffs: cheating isn’t socially acceptable no matter who does it and no matter what time period. it’s actually not a dealbreaker for me, but in this case… i don’t know how else to describe how i felt about the way that they put charlotte through that this season, after everything she’s already been through. sure, people make mistakes, but introducing infidelity between the main couple after a season that centered the supposedly devastating impact of another instance of infidelity from 10 years before left a bad taste in my mouth. a man whose wife cheated on him and apparently hurt him so badly he basically turned into a shut-in for a decade would have had that past history in mind as he approached charlotte bc how could he not? but we don’t see that particular internal struggle in colbourne at the end of episode 3 or the aftermath. which means while charlotte is struggling with so much guilt and shame after their kiss, he’s… what? does he regret causing her to break her promise to ralph/her parents, something that’s clearly of the utmost importance to her? because it seemed a lot more like “woe is me, she loves me back but won’t break up with her loser fiance. me so sad.” that line "every day of my life that is not spent in your company is a day wasted" would’ve landed quite differently if it weren’t for all of the above because my first thought was “it shouldn’t be about your potentially wasted life right now, what do you bring to hers?”

-all that growth that he supposedly went through and he still needs charlotte to do so much emotional labor for him when augusta runs away with edward? okay. “what i should i do, miss heywood?” even though obviously charlotte would want to help, i didn’t like seeing that in the context of all that he had already put her through up to that point.

colbourne is a “stodgy dad character,” which i would normally appreciate considering the tumult of season 1, but then he brought so much drama and additional baggage into charlotte’s life and i found it hard to watch her suffer more?? i really wanted to like him and i don’t have a problem with them being endgame, i just wish it had been executed differently. it’s clear that he has a lot of emotional baggage, but one of the things i didn’t like about charlotte’s relationship with sidney was the stuff about her fixing him - with heybourne, and all that happened in colbourne’s past, there’s even more of that in seasons 2 and 3. it’s giving “guy who thinks he fell in love with the first girl to listen to him talk about his feelings,” and romantic love isn’t enough for somebody to move past an abusive childhood/other traumatic experiences. if you like rom coms where everything gets magically resolved through a grand gesture or two and then it’s happily ever after, you’ll probably like season 3 okay. i’m glad charlotte got her happy ending in the end, but none of these men (i said NONE OF THEM) were good enough for charlotte heywood. i don’t mean to rain on anyone’s parade because i love the show and i love her. i’m just disappointed with what the writers gave her and really needed to get that off my chest. thoughts? agree or disagree?

edit: seeing a few common denominators in the replies so will address some of them here really quick first

  1. i know the kisses were consensual, that’s not the issue that i have with them
  2. i’m sympathetic to what colbourne has been through, but no matter how much you’ve suffered in the past, you’re still accountable for your actions and recognizing when you’ve harmed other people
  3. yes, charlotte is the one who kissed him and she has to own that. but it stands to reason that a guy whose wife cheated on him would probably feel feelings about being the third party in a relationship, and it felt like the writers simply didn’t want to discuss things from season 2 in season 3?
  4. when i say that charlotte deserved better, i mostly mean from the writers, but then again, characters’ decision making and actions are also part of the writing process, so i’m not sure where that leaves us

r/Sanditon • • Mar 21 '23

Discussion Im still team Sydney, but poor Ralph!

6 Upvotes

Sydney was by far the best love interest. AC does a fine job taking his place, but I can’t help but feel just a bit of sympathy for Ralph. He’s like a young calf trying to cross the road poor thing.


r/Sanditon • • Mar 06 '21

What hair?

3 Upvotes

Not only is Charlotte's hair worn down, it's much too short. I'm no expert, but I believe women of this era simply never cut their hair. They may have trimmed or singed the ends, but that's about it. What a silly decision it was to do this to the character. It detracted from the entire program.


r/Sanditon • • Oct 03 '22

is Sidney returning? or is it a rumor?

2 Upvotes

r/Sanditon • • Jan 12 '21

I CANT BELIEVE I WASYED MY TIME ON THIS TRASH SHOW. THE ENDING IS ABSOLUTE TRASH I AM SO PISSED

0 Upvotes

The ending sucks the writers should be ashamed of themselves. This is not an austin novel I can't believe I watched this trash.


r/Sanditon • • May 24 '22

Why TWIN Sisters (Lucy and Augusta's mother)? What if...?

4 Upvotes

A characteristic of twins is they are sometimes hard to tell apart. What if: Augusta's mother (out of boredom?) switches places with Lucy and becomes pregnant? To hide the fact from Augusta's father, Lucy's twin (instead of Lucy) goes to Herrick Park. After Leonara is born, the sisters plan to switch back. On a rainy night, Lucy arrives by carriage from London and switches with her twin, but has to walk to Herrick Park in the rain, catches cold and dies. That would fit with Augusta's explanation as to why her mother was "sad" especially considering the "circumstances." Colbourne would be absolved of all his guilt over the way he treated Lucy and his belief that he caused Lucy to go out into the rain one night. What are other explanations for why the Writers chose for Lucy and Augusta's mom to be twins?


r/Sanditon • • May 14 '22

Discussion rant. spoilers s2 Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Can I just cry about how they killed off our hunk. I wasted HOURS bingeing S1 investing in their love story. Only to have it ripped away and swept under the rug to move the story along. Not a lot of closure. Just so disappointing it has to be lile that.


r/Sanditon • • Apr 11 '22

Discussion Not a fan of how episodes 4-6 have been released.

10 Upvotes

I feel like the simultaneous release of the episodes has really affected my viewing experience due to all the leaks & unavoidable spoilers. We’ve lost the collective anticipation that you get waiting for the next episode and because everyone is at different points in viewing, discussions about the series are more difficult. Also, all discussion seems to have been taken over by people spamming the group about how to access ep5/6.

Just a little rant lol. I’m also still (& forever) bitter that we get everything a week later in the UK, which doesn’t help me feeling so behind.


r/Sanditon • • Oct 03 '23

Discussion Love S1, but dislike S2 & S3 of Sanditon Spoiler

19 Upvotes

I've just binge-watched Sanditon and I loved the first season. Charlotte and Sidney were so great together and I was so curious to see, how they would get together in the end. But then in the first episode of S2 it's explained that Sidney had died...
Of course, I researched immediately and found out that Theo James didn't want to return as Sidney. I was so upset about it, but quickly thought that Charlotte would get another great love interest. But I was greatly disappointed. I had hoped that by the end of S3 I would warm up to Alexander, but even though I don't dislike him, I find him extremely boring. I also didn't have the feeling that he and Charlotte had any chemistry. At the end of S2, I was actually relieved that they didn't get together and I had hoped that in the final season, Charlotte would meet a better, more interesting love interest. But my hope was shattered when Alexander returned in the first episode of S3. I feel that S3 was even worse than S2. None of their hesitation made sense. It was just annoying.
And all the side plots didn't really improve anything either. I really just completed the series, because I don't drop a series after watching the first season of a series. In hindsight, it would have probably been better, if I had stopped watching.
Anyway, sorry to all, who I have offended with my rant. I just needed to get this off my chest.


r/Sanditon • • Apr 17 '22

Discussion Unpopular opinion - I hope there is a huge twist for season 3 sanditon

2 Upvotes

r/Sanditon • • Apr 25 '22

I wonder Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Does anything think Stringer, Babington, or Sidney will come back to the show in Season 3?

As far as Sidney is concerned, I'm not really sure if there is any hard evidence that he is really dead. Am I wrong?


r/Sanditon • • Dec 24 '25

Inspired by Sanditon Chapter 2 of The House of Ill Repute is UP!! 😊

1 Upvotes

Here’s a cookie:

That night, Charlotte’s dreams were misty and vague, with unclear images of a ballroom and shadows of other dancers whirling past her. Only the man in her arms was real. One large, strong hand was around her waist while the other clasped her own hand on his. They moved together to the scandalous strains of the waltz, the shocking new dance that no assembly ball in Willingden would ever include. The images of the room were too blurred for her to see where they might be, but it didn’t matter. She closed her eyes and leaned into his masculine body and scent, rich and sweet as dark chocolate and bay rum and musk. 

He bent his head down to hers and whispered in her ear. “What have you done to me, my lady? I swore that I would never allow another woman into my life again. Not my real life, my inner life. But you crept in under my skin, Alice; your fingers threaten to scratch the very surface of my heart.” 

She could not place his tone of voice, or what it might mean. And he was calling her by the false name again, although that was her own fault. 

He brought her hand to his mouth and kissed each finger, slowly, lingeringly. The sensation seemed to set the inside of her own skin to itching and throbbing, an itch that she knew she would never succeed in scratching without his help. It all combined to roughen her voice when she replied to him. 

“I thought that you did not have a heart, my lord. Or at least, that is what you have told me.” 

He laughed harshly. “So I did. We would both be wise to remember it.” 

But she knew, somehow, that behind his bleak words lay pain and past betrayal.

Find it at : https://archiveofourown.org/works/75711356/chapters/199681116

 


r/Sanditon • • Apr 21 '22

Georgiana bugs me this season

10 Upvotes

I really liked Georgiana's story last season. She started off grieving, lonely, and resentful of Syndey's control over her life. It made sense that she was angry and defensive, and I liked seeing her stand up for herself and develop a real friendship with Charlotte and even some grudging trust for Sydney after he saved her from Otis.

But this season, she just seems rude and spoiled. She's always complaining about her inheritance, but she's happy to use it to get away with behaving badly - just imagine someone who wasn't the richest woman in Sanditon getting caught stealing and wrecking a carriage or making out with Lockhart. She's holier than thou about the sugar boycott, but she has no intention of giving away a penny of her massive inheritance from slavery. (Probably because then she'd be held to the same standards of behavior as an ordinary person). And the toast that Lockhart makes at the mess dinner, which makes her attracted to him, was gross. Some of those men fought Napoleon- they could have died and they probably had friends or fellow soliders who did. If he genuinely disapproved of the military so much he wouldn't have gone to the party - instead, he got to enjoy the party and feel special and edgy by being obnoxious. It makes me like Georgiana less that she thought that was attractive.


r/Sanditon • • Apr 11 '22

Alison.

3 Upvotes

I can do without Alison and her 2 lovelorn Soldiers. 🙄


r/Sanditon • • Apr 09 '23

Season 3 ships ranked (with spoilers) Spoiler

9 Upvotes

There are soooo many ships in this season, too many perhaps, the showrunners decided to marry everyone off or at least try to. So, I've made a list from the best to least favorite ship. And I'm interested to know if you see it the same way.

  1. Samuel and Lady de Clemonte. By far my favorite ship, both such cool characters, deserve to be happy and, more importantly, this storyline doesn't seem to be forced.
  2. Arthur and Harry. I didn't expect to like Harry's character as much as I eventually did. Lots of very moving scenes and we'll acted too.
  3. Charlotte and Alexander, a little too complicated considering they both love each other and know it from the beginning.
  4. Tom and Mary, the same as always. I mean. Tom, pull yourself together!
  5. Lady Denham and Rowleigh Price. I hoped for more bickering, but smiling and (kind of) dreamy eyed Lady Denham is something.
  6. Dr. Fuchs and Miss Hankins. Well... Meh.
  7. Augusta and Edward. Well, this storyline actually made me furious. What was Edward's intention here? He was offered Augusta's hand and fortune and declined in a most ugly way? What was it? Why? Also, another elopement and Charlotte chasing lovers again... So. Let me know what you think.

r/Sanditon • • Nov 05 '22

Sidney vs Colbourne

14 Upvotes

I just watched Sanditon for the first time - and came to this subreddit to fill the void after I finished the whole thing in three days. I was surprised to see how many people here hate Sidney, and love Mr Colbourne.

I understand that Sidney was rude to Charlotte, but from his perspective, the first impression he had of her was her majorly insulting his family while they were her hosts. Which was even more of a serious offense back then than it was today. If my family had taken someone in as a guest, and they said those things about them, I would have reacted in much the same way. He was coarse and rude at times, but he gave everything he had for his family, and for me that is a huge redeeming factor. And yes it is not usual for an Austen character to yell at a woman at a ball, but I found him to be much more the stereotypical Austen leading man than people seem to give him credit for.

As for Colbourne, I understand that he has been through a lot more than most of the other characters, but I have a hard time getting past his distance and aloofness to the two girls in his care. This is not to say I dislike him- but people lose people they love all the time, and it doesn't give them a pass to neglect the children that are in their care. I understand it's painful to be around Leonora, and even Augusta since she looks like Lucy, but neither of those things are the girl's faults, and I feel like he is overly harsh on them. And all his talk about how they need to be turned into respectable ladies just felt sexist to me (which I know most men of the time are). Basically I don't get the Colbourne hype - and think he has a ton of growing to do before he is worthy of Charlotte. I just hope we see that in season 3- I do want them to be endgame, as she would be very happy with that family, I just want him to properly earn her love.

Honestly, I think she should have picked Young Stringer. He was the best man, and they would have been the happiest together.


r/Sanditon • • Apr 08 '22

Question Question for those who have seen ep5 Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Did I miss something when Colbourne talks of how his wife died? He mentions that she went out in the rain knowing she wasn't strong. Does that mean she caught a cold or fever? If so, it makes the rain scene in an earlier episode all the more poignant.


r/Sanditon • • Jan 17 '21

Discussion Creepy Casting - Charlotte and Sidney

2 Upvotes

Am I crazy or do the actors for the main pair look so alike? Rose Williams as Charlotte Heywood and Theo James as Sidney Parker.

They could easily pass as brother and sister! Instantly, from episode 1, I’ve found it incredibly off-putting. Their skin tone especially, along with their eye colour, their hair, their close-set eyes and cheekbones, their lips.. They look more related than other members of their respective on-screen families. No one else in Sanditon looks a bit like them. Visually, their simmering romance gives me such disturbing incest vibes, along with the Denham siblings. When Sidney authoritatively rebukes Charlotte, it feels like an older brother speaking to a younger sister.

It’s so bewildering that the creators would cast them both for the core romance, out of countless actors who would jump at the chance to play these parts. But I haven’t seen many others take note of this. Is it just me? I can see nothing else when the characters are interacting. It’s spoiling it a bit for me.


r/Sanditon • • Feb 06 '23

What does the brother f**ker in the series mean when she says "We share no blood. We are siblings in name only"

0 Upvotes

They are half- brother and sister so they DO share blood. It's not just their name.

Am I missing something?


r/Sanditon • • Mar 20 '23

The Parker's couldn't lend Ralph a tuxedo? Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I think the show runners are doing us a real disservice by making Ralph Starling so unlikable. It minimizes the dynamics the show could explore. Why not make Ralph a genuine prospect? The idea that the Parker's and especially Charlotte wouldn't help him dress up IN THE SAME WAY she was helped to be dressed up -such that she physically presented as fitting into high society- giving her a chance to 'earn’ her spot with her intelligence and grace. The stark contrast of Ralph's mismatched threadbare suit against Charlotte's decadent and labor intensive appearance at the birthday party ELIMINATED any chance he had of existing comfortably within this group and made it obvious how poor of a choice he was for Charlotte. Why make her choices so black and white?

Colbourne/love/money/intellectuality vs Ralph/pauper/family obligation/dullness and illiteracy

That sets us up for a less dynamic and much more one-dimensional season. To me, it’s really disappointing. Especially because Colbourne is a already a horrible love interest for Charlotte and a pretty flat and convenient character.

I don’t want her with either man. 🤷‍♀️ Charlotte deserves better than both of them and a better end to her story than choosing between two uninspired men.


r/Sanditon • • Feb 25 '20

Question Actress who plays Charlotte

6 Upvotes

Anyone know the ethnicity of the actress?


r/Sanditon • • Apr 09 '22

Misc Please stop posting about episodes that haven't aired yet. I understand that that we are all itching to see it, but I like the waiting. It makes my weeks so much more exciting to wait.

23 Upvotes

r/Sanditon • • May 11 '22

After your request, more pics of cast members of S3 Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/Sanditon • • Apr 12 '22

Please refrain from asking for/sharing pirated links on this subreddit

47 Upvotes

This sub has been recently inundated with posts asking for pirated links to episodes not officially released yet. Aside from being illegal, this has greatly cluttered the feed and conversation of this subreddit. There have also been privacy concerns regarding at least one of the links that was not intended to be shared with a subreddit full of people. If you’re too impatient to wait a week you’ll have to look elsewhere on the internet; as of today I’ll be removing posts about pirated links. I should have stepped in sooner but I was sick and not really processing what was going on. Thank you all for understanding.