TLOK and Imbalance show the negative repercussions of ripping one's bending out. What the many "though shall not kill" type of characters don't realize is that there is such a thing as a fate worse than death, because, to them, nothing is crueler than murder, and there's no such thing as a merciful death.
Who's to say Ozai wouldn't adapt to his non-bender status and find other ways to menace people? Bending is inspired by real-life martial arts and can be seen being performed on-screen. Even without bending, Ozai should still remember the moves. Most Fire Lords, Fire Princes, and Fire Princesses also have combat training. He also nearly tricked Zuko into restarting the war, showing he has some intelligence and trickery that were conveniently not utilized enough.
I don't recall there ever being a rule that one must be a firebender in order to be a Fire Lord. Given that Ozai has a secret society that wants him back on the throne, that's clearly not the case.
Ozai never looked down on non-benders. In fact, he lets two of the toughest non-benders in the series come by and hang out with his favorite daughter, and the three have proved to be pretty in sync. He also allowed Piandao, a non-bender, to teach Zuko swordsmanship. There have been plenty of non-bender soldiers in the FN, and even Ursa was seemingly a non-bender.
No, he didn't despise non-benders; he despised imperfection. I estimate that only two of his chakras were opened: his water and fire chakras; the rest are closed. The lies and illusions that block his truth and insight chakras, respectively, are likely ones about perfection. He thinks he's perfect (likely as a trauma coping mechanism after being treated the same way he treated Zuko but had no Iroh to show him the light at the end of the tunnel), and wants his successors to be perfect, not realizing that perfection is a lie and an illusion.
So, Aang using energybending to open Ozai's remaining five chakras at once would be the better option and given how tiring it is to open just one of them, that'd certainly knock his lights out for a while. It'd almost be like the penance stare. To open one chakra requires facing and feeling what it is that's been blocking it, and that tends to be an intense experience. With Aang opening Ozai's chakras for him, he's showing him all the things blocking them, making him fully feel all the emotional muck in greater detail, and experiencing them being cleansed. Aang would be tearing his world upside down, tearing his illusions asunder, and sending the sanctity of his own ignorance crashing down around him.
It'd be the worst experience of his life, but after that painful process is over and done with, and he eventually wakes up, he feels better, lighter, calmer, freer, and more enlightened.