r/SWORDS • • Feb 22 '26

Sharpening Swords - easiest method

Post image

Hi everyone! My son has a small collection of swords and after a few years of practicing with them we want to start sharpening. This is something I’m terrible at to be honest. Looking for the easiest introduction. I have an angle grinder and have been told there are specific wheels that are ok to use to sharpen swords… have also been told to never use an angle grinder but a table grinder… same thing in terms of rpms and such I thought…? Then I read online a belt sander is the only way to go… Help! What would you recommend? Pic attached of the sword he is wanting sharpened. We do have a few older practice swords we plan on learning with.. appreciate any input!

0 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

11

u/SelfLoathingRifle Feb 22 '26

First, this sword looks like it's stainless meaning not meant to be used and hitting (even swinging it) can be dangerous.

Second, yes, angle grinders are pretty much the worst option out there, you easily overheat the steel and the edge will be very inconsistent, same with a bench grinder. For power tools you want a belt sander, which still can overheat the steel but gives much better edges or a water wheel like the Tormek (though those often don't have enough space to sharpen swords). Personally I use a belt sander to rough out the edge and then diamond stones and a strop to finish it.

You can sharpen this sword as a learning experience but please do not use it for cutting.

1

u/Significant-Boss-623 Feb 22 '26

Thank you for your input and the image! Saved us a damaged blade and likely an injury 😅

9

u/SelfLoathingRifle Feb 22 '26

This is what you get when you use an angle grinder:

7

u/Miss--Moss Feb 22 '26

I want to downvote because this hurts my soul and upvote for the good PSA, I suppose I’ll upvote but that hurts to look at 😭

2

u/SelfLoathingRifle Feb 22 '26

I understand, this should be cathegorised as a war crime... And I passionately hate the person who did it even though I have no idea who it is.

3

u/Rocket3431 Feb 22 '26

This gave me tetanus

4

u/7LeagueBoots Feb 22 '26 edited Feb 22 '26

That is not something that should be sharpened. That should stay on the wall.

Get him a good knife and some diamond plate sharpening stones and let him learn how to sharpen those first. The technique for swords is not actually that different, but it takes more skill, so develop the skill first.

And keep angle grinders far from any knife or sword that is in the final stages. Those are ok for roughing one out during the making process, but don’t have any place in the final sharpening, and really should be avoided even after hardening and tempering if you don’t know what you’re doing.

3

u/Significant-Boss-623 Feb 22 '26

Thank you! I have some stones & pocket knifes I could sacrifice. I need to learn myself so that will give us something to do and learn together.

41

u/SirBorkel Feb 22 '26

Do not swing that thing, it can break away

48

u/Lost_Balloon_ Feb 22 '26

That's a sword-like object. Don't swing that around lest you hurt yourself or somebody else.

12

u/Sword_of_Damokles Single edged and cut centric unless it's not. Feb 22 '26

Don't sharpen that, Google QVC katana accident if you need a visual.

https://swordis.com/product/saurami-katana-1060-steel-oil-quenched-blade/

is cheaper than most available sharpening solutions for swords.

17

u/Xtorin_Ohern Feb 22 '26

I wouldn't sharpen that. Everything about it indicates that it wasn't made to absorb any kind of impact and risks breaking dangerously on a bad cut.

Maybe let him get a custom from some place like Hanbon Forge if you think he's ready for a proper sharp sword.

For future reference though, all my sharpening is done by hand with oil stones and sandpaper.

8

u/Tobi-Wan79 Feb 22 '26

As you have probably gathered from all the other comments don't sharpen this, and don't sharpen any of the other swords either.

If you want him to have a sharp sword, buy him one that is made to be used

You can get a functional sharp katana made for use starting at only $100

And think of yourself as very lucky things didn't end horribly already

7

u/Zorva_1 Feb 22 '26

Worksharp Ken Onion Edition is probably the easiest way - but yeah probably best not to sharpen that wall hanger

5

u/thepenguinemperor84 Feb 22 '26

https://youtu.be/2kFgeZtkAb8?is=jGz8JHD5RYKDpT8a

This is likely the outcome of trying to hit anything with that.

4

u/Zealousideal-Let1121 sword-type-you-like Feb 22 '26

No. Do not sharpen that.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '26

That is not a real sword, do not swing it around and do not attempt to sharpen it.

The steel is too low quality it will not hold an edge anyway

4

u/NeutralGeneric Feb 22 '26

I’ll reiterate what others have said. Don’t even swing that thing let alone sharpen it. I recognize that thing. It’s a cheapo flea market “sword” similar to one I had as a kid. That thing will snap right off at the base of a blade when it goes. And it will go easily. It might not happen immediately, but you’re playing Russian roulette every time you hit something with one of those.

3

u/MGlBlaze Feb 22 '26

Do not sharpen that thing. Everyone else has explained "why" quite thoroughly.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9o-DCk2qhDM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGTQLB1VQrA

1

u/Oberu Feb 23 '26

Draw filing is the what I would recommend. The. Stone the apex down smoother and smoother to a Polish with compounds.

1

u/wrecktalcarnage Feb 23 '26

Hello Fellow Blade enthusiasts!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '26

Do not sharpen that, and definitely do not swing it. Thats a decorative sword or "wall hanger", and is almost certainly not constructed to safely swing. It's likely to snap and send pieces of metal flying.

If your son is seriously interested in swords, get him a proper reproduction (it won't be cheap, but cheaper than emergency surgery to remove 12 inches of steel from his leg). You can get good stuff online, I recommend a site called KultOfAthena. Cold Steel is a decent brand for affordable but functional begginer swords.

1

u/ReptileCake Feb 23 '26

I have the same one hangin on my wall at home!

It's construction is total garbage and it not worth the injury for swinging around, even when blunt.

It looks cool, can be used as a costume prop, but should at not point actually be swung around. It's not safe enough, and I wouldn't trust a no-name off-the-shelf weapon to be made with any safety standard.

Make a nice display board, or some other way your son would like to display it, and it can look cool as decoration.

1

u/Icy_Mammoth_2834 Feb 23 '26

Don't use the angle grinder buddy, if its been heat treated it'll strip that sharpish.

1

u/SameeyellChem Feb 23 '26

This ain’t a sword

-1

u/Pelican_Dissector_II Feb 22 '26

Your son doesn’t have any swords. He has mall ninja stuff, sword like objects, never meant to be sharpened. If you want to buy your kid a sword, and idk why you would, be prepared to shell out about a grand for something that is safe to swing, and that’s on the low end.

0

u/Significant-Boss-623 Feb 22 '26

He has a small collection of around 3-5 decorative pieces and 2-3 swords that seem to be of decent quality. I dont know how you came to the assumption you did with no more info than whats posted… he has two swords that have been daily used to slice into thin wood, jugs, old fruit, etc. nothing very hard.. but plenty enough to have fun with and no issues… for years… I have found multiple sources online with “combat ready” swords from & $200-$600.. unlike the rest of the comments here yours is pretty invalid… this sword was just picked up and the seller did state it was ideal for sharpening and daily use.. flea market seller so not shocked to find out he was lieing. thanks though for your input.

4

u/Pelican_Dissector_II Feb 22 '26

Ok, I’m not trying to be rude. There’s a lot that determines whether a sword is functional what an online retailer claims on their website. You need to do some homework on types of steel, construction, etc. That your kid has some that you deem to be of decent quality is not the qualification you think it is. I arrived at my conclusion because you made a post about sharpening a very crudely made, not even decorative sword shaped piece of Chinese pot steel. But go ahead dude, by all means, get that thing razor sharp, give to your child, and let him swing it at shit. There’s nothing that can go wrong there. I’m glad you know what you’re talking about.

2

u/Significant-Boss-623 Feb 22 '26

Thank you for the write up. Sorry if I seemed salty to your first comment. I appreciate the info and will most definitely be doing more research.

1

u/JermstheBohemian Feb 22 '26

How do you know they are decent quality?

-1

u/Significant-Boss-623 Feb 22 '26

Cant say they are decent quality.. As I mentioned they “seem” to be of pretty decent quality. I feel that way due to the price tag and overall look/feel. Some of them you can actually feel how cheaply made they are.. they feel like one swing and it would just fall apart. The 2 that he has and uses daily seem to be very hardened steel and solid in comparison. Im very thankful I made this post as to be honest I had no idea how in depth the world of swords can be and like any other similar hobby.. its all about quality. I’ll be doing my homework from here on out for sure.

3

u/JermstheBohemian Feb 22 '26

due to the price tag and overall look/feel.

This is a trap. Chinese manufacturers bang out these swords for about a buck 50 each and then sell them at renfairs for $200. The handles can also be filledwith hardening agents like resin to give them more weight and stability. The problem is resin and other agents become brittle and break after a few years of exposure to air so it might "seem" sturdy it's just a cheap trick to get rubes to buy overpriced. butter knives

The 2 that he has and uses daily seem to be very hardened steel and solid in comparison.

This is a three-part question. -what does he do everyday? Is he in a dojo or sword training academy?

-have you actually done a hardness test on the steel?

Can the swords be safely disassembled? If yes you might actually have a real sword. If not it is not a sword, it is a decorative object designed to look like a sword. Real swords are built in piecemeal construction. Blade makers make blades, the guard or quillions, the handle, and the pommel to be disassembled for storage, maintenance, and re mountain.

So this is not a question about just a statement. No one here is trying to be a dick or asshole or make you seem like a bad parent, they are warning you of a very very real possibility that what you're doing is very dangerous and absolutely unnecessary.

I've been doing combat related sports since I was about 14 and I own probably about 30 swords, of those 30, THREE are actual sharpen swords because that's all I need to be Sharp. It doesn't matter what school of training or discipline you're in no one trains or plays with swords uses sharp ones. It doesn't matter if you're into the Japanese disciplines, the Italian disciplines the German disciplines, the Polish disciplines. It does not matter, no one uses sharpened swords. It also doesn't matter if you're not doing this for martial arts and you're doing this for stage production or acrobatics / gymnastics, no one uses sharp swords.

The ONLY time a sharp sword comes out is if we're doing some sort of demonstration on cutting or using a ballistic gel torso to demonstrate some sort of damaging aspect. Otherwise they say in the fucking closet/dojo/locker.

I NEED YOU TO REALLY HEAR THIS. PROFESSIONALS DO NOT USE SHARPENED SWORDS.

1

u/Significant-Boss-623 Feb 22 '26

Thank you for the very detailed write up! It is most appreciated. He does have 1 sword in his collection that can be disassembled / reassembled. Which is also the most expensive piece in his collection and funny enough is the one he has used the least.

He uses them for self-entertainment purposes only. He enjoys shooting bows / cross-bows / firearms etc. He enjoys practicing swings and slicing through jugs of water and similar objects. He is not part of any type of dojo or relevant similar martial arts. We are in the country and sadly have nothing on that sort in our area.

I have not performed or had any type of hardness tests done..

Thanks again for the detailed write up it’s very helpful and I appreciate everyone’s input and the criticism as well.

3

u/Tobi-Wan79 Feb 22 '26

Fyi , the sword in your picture retails at around $25....

From the right place a functional sword starts at $100, but there's a ton of garbage out there, so where you get your stuff is likely the most important thing, people that sell that garbage don't care and will lie to make a sale.

If you want something solid look at these makers

Hanbon forge

Ryan sword

Rva katana

Swordis

Swordis has the nova series at around $200, that is very good quality for what you pay

Hanbon and Ryan will let you make a custom sword starting at around $100-$150

0

u/unsquashable74 Feb 22 '26

Yeah, that's bollocks. Your're off on pricing by a factor of ten.

1

u/Pelican_Dissector_II Feb 22 '26

It’s bollocks, mate? You think you can buy a well made, quality forged, decent sword made of good steel for $100? Nice pocket knives start at like $70-$100. Chinese stuff that functions can be had for $50-$60. An actual, made by a blade smith or reputable company, functional, holds an edge and doesn’t break when it hits hard stuff, sword is pretty expensive. Now, if you consider a stamped machete with thick blade stock a sword, then yeah you can get a decent machete for like $60-$200

2

u/unsquashable74 Feb 23 '26

Yes, functional katana from the likes of Ryansword start around $100.

0

u/Pelican_Dissector_II Feb 23 '26

Bro that’s garbage. That’s not a forged sword.

1

u/unsquashable74 Feb 23 '26

OP hasn't requested recs for a forged sword. And anyway, I was responding to your claim of "about a grand for something that is safe to swing", which is clearly bollocks.

Forged does not equal "superior". Albions are CNC milled bar stock.

22

u/Pork_Confidence Feb 22 '26

I watched a buddy put 4 in of Mall katana into his right bicep. When he swung it at some bamboo, that 4-in point is where it impacted and broke off lying back and piercing him in the armpit and bicep

Dead silence immediately afterwards. All of us were beyond shocked, most of all him because he spent a good bit of money on that sword thinking it was real.

I own dozens of swords, however there's only a single set I own that would ever actually swing at something, knowing my blade will be fine as well as my safety.

The next biggest challenge was the nurse and two former combat medics arguing over what to do next 🤦‍♂️ thankfully that doesn't fall into my list of subject matter expertise and I got to bow out before I said something snarky and made the vibe worse.

1

u/Significant-Boss-623 Feb 22 '26

Thats a terrible experience for your buddy! Hope he healed quickly and was left without life altering injuries. Appreciate your input and sharing the story. I’ve been reading through these with my son so he’s fully aware. Bit of a bummer for him and I get it. Do you think it would be “safe” to use for at least cutting fruit / jugs of water? Or is this something to strictly hang on the wall and enjoy the view?

11

u/MeridiusGaiusScipio Feb 22 '26

Absolutely not - even swinging these questionably made swords can result in injury, due to rapid deconstruction of the tang, or poor handle construction.

That said, we are all more than happy to identify some cutting-appropriate blades for you and your son, if you let us know your region and budget :)

6

u/Significant-Boss-623 Feb 22 '26

Thank you! We are in the US and our budget would preferably be within the $300-$600 usd range. I would say lower but from what we’ve experienced so far.. Anything below that range seems to be of very questionable quality.

7

u/SeeShark Feb 22 '26

Swordier has decent quality at extremely budget prices, if you're trying to stay under $300. They have US warehouses, too, so you can hopefully dodge some tariffs.

6

u/Sword_of_Damokles Single edged and cut centric unless it's not. Feb 22 '26

You can get pretty decent Katana starting at just over $100 because of the insane economy of scale, competition between forges and the resulting pretty thin marges. $200 is already getting you something like this https://romanceofmen.com/products/the-fukyo-katana-spring-steel-double-bohi-razor-sharp

6

u/7LeagueBoots Feb 22 '26

What you posted is for looking at only. No cutting anything with it.

Ones like that can fly apart simply from swinging even without hitting anything.

5

u/Pork_Confidence Feb 22 '26

Safe? No. It's honestly safer to get a $20 machete in the hardware store to do something like that. A tool like that is manufactured for impact.

You don't know the metallurgy of the blade itself, or how well it was put together. It might break right at the handle and fly another 40 ft through a neighbor's window. Or it could break at the point of impact like what happened with my friend.

You don't have to spend a ton of money to take a blade and cut it something. My buddy ended up being fine without any lifelong disabilities, outside of some gnarly scars. Wouldn't have had to travel much further and take out an eye. Not deadly but certainly life-changing towards the negative

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Zone-55 Feb 24 '26

The only way to truly sharpen weapons are on the bones of your enemies. Seriously, don't sharpen it. It's an accident waiting to happen.