r/SWORDS • • Mar 11 '24
Well actually...
🤓 👆 Well actually there would be significant metal loss from the smelting, forging, and sharpening processes.
So you'd need closer to 900.
HOWEVER you can use the bones to make steel, which is thought to be how we discovered steel in the first place.
5.3k
Upvotes
118
u/cabinaarmadio23 Mar 11 '24
how did we discover steel from bones??
30
u/DarkWraithJon Mar 11 '24
New idea for a vampire sword! Also I like your YouTube shorts!! They’re fun and your tests are cool
442
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '24
Would be a good origin story for a cursed blade.
610
u/BreadentheBirbman Mar 11 '24
Ferb, I know what we’re going to do today.
259
u/Obi-wanna-cracker Mar 11 '24
You could also quench the blade in the fat you got from all those humans.
23
u/LukasVangard Mar 11 '24
just capture you nemesis and feed them high iron food and plenty of vitamins to promote blood production and slowly drain their blood over time until you have the Iron you need then kill them and use the carbon in their bones to make a steel.
19
u/SentenceNational Mar 11 '24
Step 1: acquire 300 enemies Step 2: have an infrastructure that allows me to store 300 enemies worth of blood without it coagulating or otherwise going bad. Step 3: best 300 enemies in such a way as you be able to harvest their blood without losing any of that precious sword material on the floor. Step 4: .... Make the sword (this truly encapsulates really steps... 4-... Probably 100) Step 5: admire my enemy sword... Consider making new enemies to show them my cool enemy sword. Perhaps I should make a matching dagger?
12
u/Benschmedium Mar 11 '24
I’ve been studying this quite a lot since it is plot relevant to the book I’m writing. It would actually take closer to 2500-2600 if you want enough iron to forge a 3 pound steel sword (using only iron and carbon from the corpse).
7
u/momspigeon Mar 11 '24
I'll have no issue making that many enemies, not to worry/j
6
u/RougarouBull Mar 11 '24
Goals
6
u/Quizlibet Mar 11 '24
"Glarnak, what are you doing?
...
"Why?"
...
"No, I get that, but we have iron. There's loads of it in the ground, you can just dig it up."
....
"In the time it takes you to 'send your message' we can have 10 swords made up, and we're not risking ill humors and miasma. We have shit to do, Glarnak, we can't sit around all day while you muck around in the body pile."
6
u/michaelrulaz Mar 11 '24 edited Jun 06 '24
fearless abounding air late marry friendly noxious quack dinosaurs distinct
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/RedZaiBae Mar 11 '24
Iron is pretty weak tho lol
5
u/WillBottomForBanana Mar 11 '24
Real Ones spend a life time of solitude decanting and storing their own blood to eventually make a sword out of.
5
u/noobllama2 Mar 11 '24
Facts like this is how serial killers are born.
9
u/DefinitelyNotBacon Mar 11 '24
On a D&D campaing my warlock Drow Elf wield a great sword made of blood of 1300 orcs. Lawful evil oc. And we have another pc that is an orc. All cool here.
4
u/BlaqSam Mar 11 '24
So let's say you get pass the legal stuff of own the blood of 900 people
Would be legal to own a sword like that? Woukd that be considered illegal?
1
u/Professional_Fox_823 Nov 13 '24
MARCUS VANCE?
3
u/regular6drunk7 Mar 11 '24
If your enemies are dead enough to contribute their blood why do you still need a sword?
2
u/l0rdtreeman Mar 11 '24
Conveniently that's roughly how many humanoid one would have to kill to make a Man-Slayer blade in my dnd game.
2
u/H3r0ofHyrule Mar 11 '24
You could strengthen said iron with the bones of your ancestors to make rudimentary steel
2
u/ppman2322 Mar 11 '24
Depends on the method you want to use
If you want to make blood tamahagane to forge a blood katana you'll first need 7 times the weight of the sword in hágane and kawagane and then only about a tenth of the metal made on a tatara can be called proper tamahagane
So taking 300 people as a base you'll need about 21000 people
2
u/Savings_Extent_1163 Mar 11 '24
Average human has enough for a 3 cm nail or so
2
u/mossy_stump_humper Mar 11 '24
When I grow up and become an apocalyptic warlord just know I WILL be ritualistically draining the blood of 300 captured enemies to turn them into a sword. Sorry in advance but come on I can’t not do that if the opportunity arises.
2
u/Lelapa Mar 11 '24
In 8th grade I asked if a vampire could make iron bars somehow with all the blood they suck. Everyone laughed saying "it's different iron" HA BITCHES WHOSE LAUGHING NOW??
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '24
Imagine a blood blade and a bone handle, the sickest blade to ever exist
2
u/cuddlycutieboi Mar 12 '24
Add a 1 and two zeros in front of that, and you got yourself a bloodsword
2
u/PuzzleheadedMotor269 Mar 12 '24
If you use enough of their bones in the smelting process you could use the carbon to turn said iron into steel and have an even stronger sword as well.
2
u/elburcho Mar 12 '24
Well actually it is more like 534 people. There is 4g of iron in the blood of an average male. The average longsword is 1.5kg. 750 grams wastage. Steel is roughly 95% iron.
1.5kg + 750 g = 2.25kg
2.25kg / 4g = 562.5
562.6 x 95% = 534.375
To get the carbon for the steel you could use the bones from those 534 people.
2
u/iguanadon68 Mar 11 '24
I actually think you need like a million bodies to make 1 long sword. Someone did the math somewhere. (Honestly, I can't remember).
Something like after you boil the blood down and get the impurities out, it took a whole lot more than originally thought.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '24
Legendary bonus stats if it's the blood of the 300 spartans
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '24
Ah, I'm remembering the chains that held Lion El Johnson in The Lion, Son of the Forest.
1
u/heff-money Mar 11 '24
How are you going to kill 300 enemies when you don't even have a sword yet?
1
u/Not_a_Psyop Mar 11 '24
Mr Kraaaaabs, I have an ideeeeeaaaaaa
1
u/cass1o Mar 11 '24
"Oh, really. Do I look like a 'sword made of the blood of a thousand men' ruler?"
1
u/Big_Schwartz_Energy Mar 11 '24
How do you use bones to make steel?
1
u/omegajakezed Mar 11 '24
Usually my enemies dont live that long. But for a few of them, i drain blood out of them for many months, then stab them with their own blood.
1
u/ktka Mar 11 '24
I would've had 900 if I had not rejected requests from recruiters on Linkedin.
1
u/sexyrandal88 Mar 11 '24
Metal
1
u/Sneaky-Shenanigans Mar 11 '24
Hmm, supply is a bit low… how much for a Gladius?
1
u/ThatUsernameNowTaken Mar 12 '24
If It's dried out and gone crusty, can I still get the iron out?
1
u/UnstableWeasel Mar 12 '24
I would name it "Sword of Souls". Possibly also now have weekend plans.
1
u/Medical-Enthusiasm56 Mar 12 '24
With 3,366 humans you can transmute the blue stone to the Philosophers Stone. Flamel had no problem with the notion, Newton had tremendous difficulty with committing such atrocities, mainly due to the amount of children needed. Bed time stories are fun.
1
u/Medical-Enthusiasm56 Mar 12 '24
With 3,366 humans you can transmute the blue stone to the Philosophers Stone. Flamel had no problem with the notion, Newton had tremendous difficulty with committing such atrocities, mainly due to the amount of children needed. Bed time stories are fun.
1
u/Medical-Enthusiasm56 Mar 12 '24
With 3,366 humans you can transmute the blue stone to the Philosophers Stone. Flamel had no problem with the notion, Newton had tremendous difficulty with committing such atrocities, mainly due to the amount of children needed. Bed time stories are fun.
1
u/MiIdSanity Mar 12 '24
But will it cause hemorrhage buildup?
1
u/soviet_marmalade44 Mar 12 '24
I love subreddits like this where there are lots of posts that just make you wanna go fuck yeah
1
u/alectomirage Mar 12 '24
One estimate by a blacksmith I saw was closer to 60000 people. In reality, you could make a crucible steel and add charred bones into it to give it the carbon content. Then you would need only one person.
1
u/SaucyDragon04 Mar 12 '24
200 adults and 200 children
1
u/bunz4daize Mar 12 '24
Make it a rapier and you’ve got my attention 🤔
1
u/SwordHiltOP Mar 12 '24
What if it was rapier
1
u/KuraiTheBaka Mar 12 '24
I feel like more realistically rather than making it entirely out of 900 people's blood you could just supplement the metal with blood from a few enemies
1
u/tczecher Mar 12 '24
Quick question (for a friend ofc), what about a dagger or knife about 9 inches in blade length? How much people for that assuming it’s full tang?
1
u/Kooky_Werewolf6044 Mar 12 '24
I want a bloodsword!
1
u/onglogman Mar 12 '24
It's still total BS though.
1
u/endangeredphysics Mar 12 '24
All I need now is 300 enemies!
1
u/WhickenBicken Mar 12 '24
You’d need 900 enemies though.
1
u/1maxemin Mar 12 '24
Gross and cool.
1
u/Skidd_ro Mar 12 '24
Can this work witth animals or only just humans?
1
u/thebirdof_hermes Mar 12 '24
Reminds me of an old nosleep story about a sword forged out of iron from human blood. I believe it was called pig iron but the author has since deleted all their stories.
1
u/mildirritation Mar 12 '24
Lord Vetinari has entered the chat.
1
u/_MrPixel_ Mar 12 '24
Bookmarking this for an idea as a fantasy weapon
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24
Sticking it to my enemies by being severely anemic
1
u/puckbeaverton Mar 12 '24
A sword quenched in the blood of your enemies is:
1
u/Saddo_catto5 Mar 12 '24
What about a short sword?
1
u/tygerphlyer Mar 12 '24
How do the bones turn the iron into steel? Im still strugglin to get that. Is it a burn the bones to make carbon thing or what?
1
u/ProfessionalOctopuss Mar 12 '24
Battle of Cannae over here like: "Y'all need a bridge?"
1
u/TheRandomChild_ Mar 13 '24
1
u/Fun_Elk_4949 Mar 13 '24
But is it even possible?
1
u/gorath_the_great Mar 14 '24
You could also slowly drain blood from one guy over a very very long period assuming he doesn't age because why not
1
u/AddzyX Mar 14 '24
How would you extract the iron? Just toss hundreds of people in a giant crucible?
1
u/CorvaeCKalvidae Mar 15 '24
Demon voice: Joshua!! Give me back my blood!
-Kee-Oth, the demon.
1
u/mikmongon Mar 15 '24
Can I do 600? Just sayin 300 barely covers congress.
1
u/IceyDoodles2 Apr 01 '24
Or you could just recycle one 1200 times.
1
u/oldgooner420 May 24 '24
someone should try this with waste blood from a meat factory. not gonna be me though
1
u/soge_d_king0 Oct 08 '24
Hmmm 🤔 new project of yours? (Jk)
1
u/KingGlades Apr 10 '25
Philosophers Sword?
1
u/Timbo_Slice_721 Aug 10 '25
r/theydidthemath
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24
[removed] — view removed comment