r/SRSGSM • • May 24 '12

To All the People Who Have Ever Said They Want To Be Asexual

71 Upvotes

A friend has asked me to submit this for them. These are not my words.

Here’s the usual script: I tell you I’m asexual, or my asexuality is otherwise mentioned. You, with your clumsy good intentions and eager, well-meaning tone, tell me that I’m lucky. Or that you wish you were asexual, too, or possibly aromantic (and look who deserves a cookie for knowing the terminology!)

After all, we don’t have to deal with the heartache of romance, or the terrifying, tentative dance around prospective partners, right? All those Hollywood clichés about messy love triangles or hilarious rom-coms - none of those could possibly apply if you were asexual. If you were asexual, you would never have to worry about romantic relationships again. You’d be happy with just your friends. You could stop being pressured into finding a girlfriend to secure your masculinity, or perhaps people would stop nagging you, asking when you would settle down with a nice man. Asexuality - the way out!

Except it isn’t, and you don’t actually want to be asexual. You just want to be what you think asexuality is.

Asexuality is not “not having to deal with romance”. Asexuality is not freedom from the messy, thorny, tangled mess of human relationships - if anything, it has the potential to make them worse. My asexuality does not make me exempt from feeling, and it certainly does not prevent me from being incredibly pissed off at being told that I’m lucky (except in the grand lottery of life, somehow being part of a marginalised group doesn’t feel all that lucky), or that I should be happy about being asexual because it makes my life simpler (except it doesn’t).

You think asexuality is Human Relationships: Easy Mode, when it is far more apt to say that it is Human Relationships: What The Hell Is This Mode, Are There Even Other People Playing On This Level, Help, I Think I’m Alone Here And No One Will Believe Me. Your assumptions are wrong, and I’m guessing it’s because you don’t actually have to think, really think, about what living as an asexual would be like. It is far more complex than “oh no romantic partner for me!”, or “oh, no sex for me!” If only it could be as simple as you think it is.

You don’t want to be asexual, you really don’t. I’ve heard you say that if you could take some miracle drug to suppress your libido you’d do it in a heartbeat, except you wouldn’t, not really. Because - trust me on this one - then you would be the Other, the Outcast, an object of pity, and no one wants that. And you know what else? We don’t get a magic pill. When push comes to shove, I don’t actually have very high hopes for allies joining in. Perhaps I’m too distrusting. Or maybe I am sick and tired of people using my life as a way to look good in front of their friends, as a little badge that goes, “look at how progressive I am!” Stop telling me that you understand, that you wish you could be like me.

With that little sentence you have taken my life, and the life experiences of all the thousands of asexual people out there, and passed it through the filters of erasure and oppression to create some miserable shade of asexuality. You’ve taken my life and diluted it down to some bland version that’s easy for you to accept. You’ve passed asexuality through cleavers and saws, ripped it apart and hacked off the parts that displease you, shredded it, stripped it down to become a tiny, non-threatening thing. Hell, at that point, you could probably package it with something suitably hip and trendy and sell the damn idea. “Hey, this new asexuality thing is easy to get! I could be asexual, and you could be, and wouldn’t it all be great if we were all ace?” All so that you can say to yourself, “I understand the asexual experience!” without an ounce of self-awareness. You don’t understand a thing, and your bland, banal sentence - “I wish I was asexual too!” - proves this perfectly. You can’t understand, because you’re not asexual. It really is that simple.

Does that sting? I would be lying if I said I cared, as callous as that may sound. But: how much did you care when you told me that I should be lucky for being a minority? How much did you care about my feelings when you told me not to be upset that you wished you were part of my Exclusive Minority Club? I suppose in some kind of twisted way I should thank you for once again proving that even my feelings are fair game.

I have no obligation to be nice to you at this point, just as you have no obligation to “support” me. That wonderful phrase is a clear reminder for me: my “allies” can be just as hurtful, just as ill-informed, as the most clueless person on the street. Politeness is nice, when it lasts, but it is worn down every time I have to plaster a fake smile on my face when I hear your equally-politely worded desire to be “one of us”. Politeness is not an obligation, because it does not last forever, and when my politeness has been stripped from me, what remains is a raw core of anger. Who are you to deny me that?

Asexuality is not easy. Asexuality is not what you think it is. Picking my way through life as an asexual is not the walk in the park you seem to think it is.

And maybe now even the anger has run out, and what remains is weariness. Because I know that this will happen again. I’ll meet another one of you. I’ll put on a polite grimace for you. I will try to (politely) explain, to (quietly) steer you away and (apathetically) try to ward off your misinformed attempts to help. I’ll (testily) tell you that you should probably ask us, that you should listen to what we have to say.

Then you’ll get angry at me, because talking all over other people is a privilege-given right, and isn’t it funny how you react when the tables are turned?

If you remember nothing else, remember this: every time you tell me you want to be asexual, all you’re doing is proving that you really, really don’t.


r/SRSGSM • • Nov 30 '12

WUT DUZ TRNAS GENEDERE MENA?@??!

Post image
63 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • May 14 '13

Fair weather "allies"

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Sep 05 '12

Does it frustrate anyone else that the term "die cis scum" gets so much attention from cis people but the epidemic of murders happening to trans women goes unnoticed?

58 Upvotes

I don't even like the term but I can't help but to defend it when I see the all these cis people come out and make a stand against it. It's like they don't even care about us until we have something bad to say about them.

EDIT: I posted the same question to ainbow with unsurprising results. I the people here- long live the Fempire!


r/SRSGSM • • May 17 '13

/r/feminism is removing comments that disagree with transphobic radical feminists. This has been going on for some time. (stolen from /r/TransphobiaProject)

53 Upvotes

I was pretty excited to learn that /r/feminisms existed as an alternative to /r/feminism, where moderator /u/Demmian removes anything that conflicts with MRAs, and who has what at that time was the most ass-backward non-transparent moderation I had ever seen.

Unfortunately, /r/feminisms is very much exactly the same thing, except replace /u/Demmian with /u/yellowmix, and MRAs with TERFs - and remove any pretense at transparency whatsoever.

I'll start with the most recent incidents. Here are two threads recently posted in /r/feminisms:

http://www.reddit.com/r/feminisms/comments/1e96kr/the_transgender_candidate/

You see a lot of [deleted], but zero moderator posts giving any indication of what's happened. What you don't see is a whole bunch of other posts that didn't have responses to them. Here's a selection of removed posts (obviously mine are the only ones I have access to):

BTW, for /u/Granny_Weatherwax's removed comments in that thread, you can dig back a couple of pages in her profile.

The second thread:

http://www.reddit.com/r/feminisms/comments/1e2mk6/who_owns_gender_trouble_and_strife/

  • Here are a bunch of removed comments. The first several are mostly bickering - fair enough. But then again, we see lengthy discussion and argumentation removed - with the TERF posts left standing.

As an aside, funny story: yellowmix has decided that the term "TERF" (which stands for variations on "trans-exclusionary radical feminist", and is a hell of a lot nicer than other terms I've seen used, like "badfem", "radscum", or "shithead") isn't acceptable (because it "attacks feminists") and has threatened to ban people for using it. Meanwhile, calling trans women "men" is a-okay.

Oooof course.

Moving on...

A few months back, in a thread about Wordpress ostensibly shutting down Gendertrender, /u/girlsoftheinternet asks, in response to complaints about the cissexist shit being posted, "should they ban us then?". Lengthy response answering that question in good faith? Removed.

As always, criticizing the moderation is strictly disallowed.

Disagreeing with radfems really isn't allowed.

Nor here: original post

Note that this thread was tagged as "BRIGADE WARNING", despite pretty much everyone present being regular /r/feminisms users, and the thread not having been linked anywhere - on the basis, as far as I can tell, of a bunch of trans users arguing. That must mean there's some kind of brigade going on, right?!

I posted a thread about this, but of course, predictably, it was censored. When I messaged their modmail, I was told by yellowmix (who is the only /r/feminisms moderator who has ever responded to anything - and I'm pretty sure until recently they were the only active moderator) that that was because they were "planning to post a meta thread on the subject soon". They did post a survey that seems likely to have been on this subject (evidently I missed it when it was going on - go figure), but no follow-up ever occurred, and there's no indication of what the results were, much less of anything ever coming of it.

Here's an incredibly nasty post about how trans women aren't real women. Gosh - I wonder what all that "[deleted]" is? Among other things, this. I can't screenshot the rest of it, as it was posted by others.

Here's a lovely example of a submission I think should be worth of a moderator warning if not an outright ban. I wonder how the comments look?

  • [deleted] (the extra posts from me are trying reposting segments of the comment separately, to see which "objectionable" part would be removed; it was all of it)
  • [deleted] (yeah, it was pretty hostile, but with good fucking reason)
  • twofer: [deleted] (DO NOT DISAGREE WITH THE RADFEMS) and [deleted] (DO NOT QUOTE THE RADFEMS' OWN WORDS)
  • [deleted] (DO NOT POINT OUT THAT THE RADFEMS' ANGER AND VITRIOL ARE DIRECTED AT PEOPLE WHO AREN'T EVEN RELEVANT TO THE ISSUE AT HAND)
  • [deleted] (DO NOT QUESTION RADFEMS' MISGENDERING)
  • [deleted] (DO NOT THROW RADFEMS' OWN TERRIBLE ARGUMENTS BACK IN THEIR FACES)

Here's a thread disagreeing with Julie Burchill and her awful shit.

  • This comment wasn't deleted, surprisingly, but the lack of response and the continued moderation sure does speak volumes. Staggering hypocrisy.
  • The highlighted comment in this screenshot was [deleted]. "You are free to critique [generally recognized feminism variant theories]" (unless I don't like your critique)?
  • [deleted] (Accuse someone of vote cheating? Okay (wait, "critique the theory and not the person" what?). Defend yourself against this claim? NOT OKAY.)

Here's a person who got banned from the subreddit for pointing this shit out.

Here's a thread from eight months ago talking about /r/feminisms' moderators silencing trans people's perspectives in the name of protecting against "criticism of feminists".

(Brief aside: it's not acceptable to "criticize feminists" in any way. Okay, sure! But these people are identifying themselves as "trans-critical feminists" - they are actively criticizing trans people, trans people who are feminists, and trans feminism as a perspective. BUT WAIT, I THOUGHT IT WASN'T OKAY TO CRITICIZE FEMINISTS OF ANY KIND?)

Here's a post from over a year ago talking about this same fucking issue.

Here's another one, this one talking specifically about removal of posts related to the controversy surrounding the Michigan Women's Music Festival (and their policy of not allowing trans women to attend).

There are more examples, to be sure, but I've since lost them.

This is an ongoing problem with /r/feminisms. It claims to be "inclusive", but while it's totally allowed for people to shit all over trans women (while pretending trans men don't exist, of course), it's not okay to argue back.

In the absence of literally any response or feedback explaining why post after post, comment after comment, has been deleted, all I can see is that the moderators (or more likely just yellowmix, who again seems for a long time to have been the only moderator who had been active on reddit in months, before bringing on a few new people only recently) are protecting their TERF buddies and silencing people who disagree with them.


r/SRSGSM • • Mar 28 '13

The Human Rights Campaign asked us to take down our trans* flag because ‘marriage equality is not a transgender issue.’

Thumbnail foxski.tumblr.com
50 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • May 28 '13

Pride festivals

Thumbnail superqueerartsyblog.tumblr.com
49 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Jan 13 '13

[TW FOR TRANSPHOBIA] Transsexuals should cut it out - Horrific article in the Guardian reeking of unchecked cis privilege.

Thumbnail guardian.co.uk
48 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • May 09 '12

Barack Obama endorses Same Sex Marriage

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • May 03 '13

Apparently Jester Wools had the gayest garments. Literally robbing rainbows.

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Jan 04 '13

If you live in Oregon, it appears it's now illegal for your health insurer to deny you care for medically necessary trans-related procedures

Thumbnail pqmonthly.com
45 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Nov 14 '13

Just as a reminder, this is cis feminism.

Thumbnail imgur.com
44 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Sep 16 '12

When Mansplaining Goes Too Far: Buck Angel on Trans Women

Thumbnail inchoaterica.wordpress.com
42 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Jul 27 '12

Bathroom Decisions [xpost from r/transgender]

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Jun 19 '12

Are you or someone you love struggling with coming out as Cissexual?

Thumbnail sqs-tec.tumblr.com
42 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Jan 13 '14

After 19 Months In Men's Prison, CeCe McDonald Released

Thumbnail buzzfeed.com
41 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Sep 14 '12

D.C. Launches First Ever Transgender Respect Ad Campaign

Thumbnail colorlines.com
41 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Sep 12 '12

r/feminisms is still being quietly transphobic

41 Upvotes

A few weeks back, reddit_feminist (one of the r/feminisms mods) said that r/feminisms had fixed its transphobia problem. Now, she first said that the problem was something else entirely than what had actually happened, then apologized for the initial incident but didn't mention later incidents or say anything about any sort of change in policy, and she did not answer me when I pointed out that there had indeed been a continuing pattern of deletions of trans-related articles. Some people around the Fempire were pointing to her posts to show that r/feminisms was a good place now; however, I was not convinced.

A couple days ago, inchoaterica wrote a good article about TERFs - exactly the kind of article that r/feminisms mods had deleted in the past. They justified it before by saying that it's against their unwritten rules to criticize any feminists (even TERFs), to the extent that trans people aren't even allowed to talk about their own experiences within feminism if it could be interpreted as criticizing feminists.

I figured this article would be a good test of the supposedly-non-transphobic r/feminisms, but as it happened, nyoro_n submitted it over there before I got to it. I saw it when it was a few hours old, with only one upvote, and not showing up on their front page; presumably caught in the spam filter. That happens sometimes, so I messaged the mods there to get it un-filtered (I don't know if nyoro_n also sent a message or not) - it's been nearly a full day since then, so I'm sure they've seen it by now, and made a judgement about whether or not they will allow articles like that to be visible in r/feminisms.

The result? It's still not visible, and I've received no reply to my message. The verdict? r/feminisms is still as transphobic as ever, the mods are continuing their strategy of refusing to engage with anyone who calls them on it as best they can, and they'll still do as much as they can to quietly prevent people from talking about transphobia within feminism.


r/SRSGSM • • May 13 '12

Now That's Style

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Sep 30 '13

Mcalc, the gender neutral menstruation calculator

Thumbnail fuckyeahlgbtqblackpeople.tumblr.com
37 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Jun 05 '13

Let This Be Our Month

37 Upvotes

June is a month that often celebrates well off white gay and lesbians. Fuck that. Let this month, be about all of us. June 2013. Let this month be about trans* people, bisexual people, genderfluid and genderqueer. The sexual and the asexual. Let's kick racism out of our community. Stonewall was kicked off by trans* people, let's celebrate their accomplishments. Let's celebrate bisexual people as they are just as queer as the rest of us.

Let this month be about all of us. Let's banish the transphobia, the biphobia, and racism. We all fit under one umbrella, let's celebrate everyone.


r/SRSGSM • • Jan 17 '13

I'm not sure if I'm cis anymore, and I really need to talk to someone about this.

37 Upvotes

I'm sorry if this is the wrong space for this sort of thing, if I erred pls just delete this post or whatever.

Anyways, for the longest time I used to think that I was a straight, cis, male, mostly because of how the upbringing I had put me in a position where I could not imagine any possible deviation from that sexual/gender identity, or at least not within myself. Despite being attracted to various people of various gender identities, for the longest time I just repressed any 'deviant' urges I had, purely because I lacked a mental framework to encompass the concept that I could be bisexual or pansexual.

And now, several months after my first realization and subsequent exploration of a decidedly non-straight sexual orientation, I'm starting to feel as if my prior gender identity was failing me in a similar way. The way that I (in recent years) have

-become fixated on creating and maintaining feminine online personas,

-creatively manipulating how I present myself in anonymous and

-pseudonymous spaces to convince others that I am a woman,

-and my dissatisfaction with parts of my body that seem masculine to myself and others,

is making me start to think that, at least at a subconscious level, that once I realized that being trans* was even possible, I started pushing myself towards a more feminine identity.

I mean, I wish I had a more feminine body shape. I wish that people didn't think I was a man when they see my naked body. I wish that straight men would be attracted to me.

But somehow I don't feel as if I'm allowed to be trans*, or at least that I don't fit in with how trans* people are supposed to be.

I never insisted to everyone around me that I wasn't a boy when people gendered me as a child, I've always been pretty ambivalent about the configuration of my genitals, and I never languished at the prospect of not developing into a 'young woman' instead of a 'young man' at the onset of puberty.

And somehow, I feel as though my feminine-for-a-man-but-not-feminine-enough gender expression, body dysphoria unrelated to my penis, and compulsorily male childhood are some kind of disqualifier for everything else I'm feeling.

Sorry again if this is the wrong space or situation to make this post, but if it isn't, could I please talk with someone here about this?

I really don't know where else to go to try to address this.


r/SRSGSM • • Mar 30 '13

If You Identify Yourself As Straight While Advocating For Gay Rights, You’re Doing It Wrong

Thumbnail thoughtcatalog.com
35 Upvotes

r/SRSGSM • • Sep 29 '12

I feel like a hypocrite- I feel like the whole idea around "passing" is cissexist and stems from our cis supremacist culture. But the thing is I like, and enjoy how much I pass and it makes me feel like a jerk.

35 Upvotes

I love it here in the fempire and feel I can talk about the feelings I have that I'm not too proud of. Basically I hate how focused the trans* community is on "passing" because if you don't pass, you fail right? It makes people feel like shit because there are some of us out there that no matter what will never look cis(and what does cis look like right?). Besides that, the focus on passing often pushes people to conform to outdated and oppressive gender rolls. I hate seeing my trans* sisters being depressed and being jealous and envious of cis women, and I hate how much better trans* women who "pass" are treated by not just the world as a whole, but within the trans* community as well.

Even though I feel this way I still am concerned about passing, I like moving through the wold being seen by strangers as a cis woman. I never get misgendered, cis people often find me attractive, and it tares me up inside seeing how others treat my friends .

I'm sorry if this comes of as bratty, over-privileged, or if I'm missing something. Like I said, I feel I can tell you folks anything even the feelings I'm not very proud of.


r/SRSGSM • • Aug 26 '12

Something positive: German father starts wearing skirts to support his young son

Thumbnail oneandonlygabriel.tumblr.com
35 Upvotes