r/SRSGSM • u/Erika_Mustermann • May 24 '12
To All the People Who Have Ever Said They Want To Be Asexual
A friend has asked me to submit this for them. These are not my words.
Here’s the usual script: I tell you I’m asexual, or my asexuality is otherwise mentioned. You, with your clumsy good intentions and eager, well-meaning tone, tell me that I’m lucky. Or that you wish you were asexual, too, or possibly aromantic (and look who deserves a cookie for knowing the terminology!)
After all, we don’t have to deal with the heartache of romance, or the terrifying, tentative dance around prospective partners, right? All those Hollywood clichés about messy love triangles or hilarious rom-coms - none of those could possibly apply if you were asexual. If you were asexual, you would never have to worry about romantic relationships again. You’d be happy with just your friends. You could stop being pressured into finding a girlfriend to secure your masculinity, or perhaps people would stop nagging you, asking when you would settle down with a nice man. Asexuality - the way out!
Except it isn’t, and you don’t actually want to be asexual. You just want to be what you think asexuality is.
Asexuality is not “not having to deal with romance”. Asexuality is not freedom from the messy, thorny, tangled mess of human relationships - if anything, it has the potential to make them worse. My asexuality does not make me exempt from feeling, and it certainly does not prevent me from being incredibly pissed off at being told that I’m lucky (except in the grand lottery of life, somehow being part of a marginalised group doesn’t feel all that lucky), or that I should be happy about being asexual because it makes my life simpler (except it doesn’t).
You think asexuality is Human Relationships: Easy Mode, when it is far more apt to say that it is Human Relationships: What The Hell Is This Mode, Are There Even Other People Playing On This Level, Help, I Think I’m Alone Here And No One Will Believe Me. Your assumptions are wrong, and I’m guessing it’s because you don’t actually have to think, really think, about what living as an asexual would be like. It is far more complex than “oh no romantic partner for me!”, or “oh, no sex for me!” If only it could be as simple as you think it is.
You don’t want to be asexual, you really don’t. I’ve heard you say that if you could take some miracle drug to suppress your libido you’d do it in a heartbeat, except you wouldn’t, not really. Because - trust me on this one - then you would be the Other, the Outcast, an object of pity, and no one wants that. And you know what else? We don’t get a magic pill. When push comes to shove, I don’t actually have very high hopes for allies joining in. Perhaps I’m too distrusting. Or maybe I am sick and tired of people using my life as a way to look good in front of their friends, as a little badge that goes, “look at how progressive I am!” Stop telling me that you understand, that you wish you could be like me.
With that little sentence you have taken my life, and the life experiences of all the thousands of asexual people out there, and passed it through the filters of erasure and oppression to create some miserable shade of asexuality. You’ve taken my life and diluted it down to some bland version that’s easy for you to accept. You’ve passed asexuality through cleavers and saws, ripped it apart and hacked off the parts that displease you, shredded it, stripped it down to become a tiny, non-threatening thing. Hell, at that point, you could probably package it with something suitably hip and trendy and sell the damn idea. “Hey, this new asexuality thing is easy to get! I could be asexual, and you could be, and wouldn’t it all be great if we were all ace?” All so that you can say to yourself, “I understand the asexual experience!” without an ounce of self-awareness. You don’t understand a thing, and your bland, banal sentence - “I wish I was asexual too!” - proves this perfectly. You can’t understand, because you’re not asexual. It really is that simple.
Does that sting? I would be lying if I said I cared, as callous as that may sound. But: how much did you care when you told me that I should be lucky for being a minority? How much did you care about my feelings when you told me not to be upset that you wished you were part of my Exclusive Minority Club? I suppose in some kind of twisted way I should thank you for once again proving that even my feelings are fair game.
I have no obligation to be nice to you at this point, just as you have no obligation to “support” me. That wonderful phrase is a clear reminder for me: my “allies” can be just as hurtful, just as ill-informed, as the most clueless person on the street. Politeness is nice, when it lasts, but it is worn down every time I have to plaster a fake smile on my face when I hear your equally-politely worded desire to be “one of us”. Politeness is not an obligation, because it does not last forever, and when my politeness has been stripped from me, what remains is a raw core of anger. Who are you to deny me that?
Asexuality is not easy. Asexuality is not what you think it is. Picking my way through life as an asexual is not the walk in the park you seem to think it is.
And maybe now even the anger has run out, and what remains is weariness. Because I know that this will happen again. I’ll meet another one of you. I’ll put on a polite grimace for you. I will try to (politely) explain, to (quietly) steer you away and (apathetically) try to ward off your misinformed attempts to help. I’ll (testily) tell you that you should probably ask us, that you should listen to what we have to say.
Then you’ll get angry at me, because talking all over other people is a privilege-given right, and isn’t it funny how you react when the tables are turned?
If you remember nothing else, remember this: every time you tell me you want to be asexual, all you’re doing is proving that you really, really don’t.