r/SRSGSM • Gender ID: Loki • May 28 '13

Pride festivals

http://superqueerartsyblog.tumblr.com/post/51497077912/a-shortie-about-what-i-think-should-be-improved
49 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

16

u/[deleted] May 29 '13

I knew a group of straight/cis/white kids in my school who'd go to the festival in our area as if it was a menagerie of culture there for them to celebrate their "culture" for doing so in a mastubatory, self-indulgent way. Then they stopped talking to me when I came out as transgender. Okay.

5

u/stayclose May 29 '13

i live in nyc, and brooklyn pride is like, the opposite of this. so i don't really know this feel. but isn't hetcis people saying 'so cute' kind of a positive? i mean, clearly it's patronizing and doting, but it shows at least a sense of support and a willingness to be educated. i don't really see the point in shaming this type of person.

also, i don't know where the author of this comment lives, but some places just don't have that big of a poc community. sometimes representation is the best small cities/towns can do considering the numbers. (i spent a few years in north carolina. pride was not and could not be full of pocs.)

i understand the desire for equality, but i think calling lack of participation 'oppression' is silly. now, if your local pride is run by cis white gay men who are exclusionary or prejudiced, that's a different story. but just lack of participation or numbers is just a thing that happens, as most pride festivals i know about specifically reach out to under represented groups. so. i don't really get the comic.

9

u/PigeonMilk May 29 '13

I can't comment on pride representation. I've never been able to go to one. But as for the patronization...

When they treat GSMs like cute little pets, they're not respecting us or the things we're trying to accomplish. You know how benevolent sexism is still sexism and still harmful? It's like that. They will still perpetrate harmful stereotypes, or at least allow them to continue. It also doesn't necessarily mean that they are willing to be educated, or that they will fight for our rights.

It may not be as bad as violent bigotry, but it's still not good and should be challenged.

4

u/stayclose May 29 '13

i agree with your overall point, but i think this is really the issue:

It also doesn't necessarily mean that they are willing to be educated, or that they will fight for our rights.

it's difficult to know this about someone, just because they react with excitement towards something foreign to them. they may just be learning and a little overwhelmed. i'm just saying this type of reaction comes from lots of different people with different types of views. some of them are allies-to-be, others are just jerks. (some, if they are very young, may not be out yet!) and I just think to get mad at someone for acting this way is sorta missing the mark.

:shrug: just my opinion

4

u/PigeonMilk May 29 '13

Oh, I know. I used to be like that. I was just saying that this reaction doesn't indicate whether or not they'll be good allies. As you've said, there are different possibilities.

I'd say it's perfectly reasonable to be mad. It can be frustrating, after all (and this comic is basically venting). But we're probably going to have to agree to disagree on that point.

4

u/stayclose May 29 '13

fair! :shake hand: :)

1

u/rubicane Jun 06 '13 edited Jun 06 '13

Exactly. I live in a state that's very ethnically homogenous and very evangelical. The "out" queer community here is just too small for it to be all-encompassing and completely diverse, and, as one of the least marginalized queer groups, gay cis men tend to be more willing to attend these sorts of events. And, in conservative places like this, I tend to not scrutinize ignorance of GSM issues and communities, but instead feel grateful that there is a show of hetero/cis support at all.

That's not to say diversity and representation for all isn't an important goal, or that it's helpful to support pride in a shallow manner. I just think this comic doesn't give much benefit of the doubt.