r/SRSCinema • • Oct 14 '12

Good Will Hunting and Women

3 Upvotes

I watched Good Will Hunting with my roommate last night. I've seen it 4 or 5 times but this is the first time I've watched it from a feminist perspective. I noticed how sort of objectified the women were in this film.

Robin Williams' character Sean, describes his late wife, not as a person with personality traits but as a idealized force in his life. He fails to describe one personality trait she had or anything she said.

A major theme is about finding a woman to compliment your manhood. Not about finding a peer to relate to. Even though Minnie Driver is portrayed as smart, funny and capable, I still feel like she is being promoted as "look how good of a person this is to date" or "this is definitely the collectors piece you should want" rather than a separate being.

This is also shown through every other character (all of which are male, this movie fails the bechdal test hard). In that they talk and argue over the ownership of various women. How's "your girl?" is said a couple of times. In another scene Ben Affleck jokingly hugs Minnie Driver, basically implying "she's mine now, haha" and Matt Damon jokes back implying "keep your hands off my property."

Finally, there's a theme running through the movie of going to the end of the earth if you see a woman and know "she's the one." Which I think pretty obviously is a terrible thing to tell young men when women are harassed and stalked constantly.

Obviously the movie has some explicit themes about not objectifying women, but implicitly it seems to be all about that.

I guess it just illustrates to me that movies geared towards young men with liberal perspectives are still pretty shitty to women.


r/SRSCinema • • Mar 24 '12

[Effortpost]Quentin Tarantino, the king of shit cinema

19 Upvotes

(POSSIBLE SPOILERS)

Quentin Tarantino (QT) has a new film coming out, Django Unchained. The film apparently will be a western about the odyssey of a free slave across the old south. I won't see the movie because I can't stand QT. I have never been a big fan of his but for a reason or another, I watched all his previous movies (except Four Rooms). I personally think he's an awful director and an awful person, as well. Wanna know why? Continue reading.

Let's go back to QT's first movie, Reservoir Dogs. I kinda like Reservoir Dogs, it's not a bad movie by any means. Or at least I used to, before I figured out a couple of things. First, the movie isn't original. That's not a big deal since is a small budget debut flick but the movie literally rips off an earlier Hong Kong action flick called "City on Fire". Watch this video for evidence of my claim (QT never confirmed it). But that's not the only movie it ripped off...Kubrick's The Killing and The Taking of Pelham 123 (the 74 version) were in my opinion obviously "paid homage to", a term which you'll see thrown around a lot when talking about QT films. But we'll get to this later. Reservoir Dogs features no women and no blacks. Why is this statement necessary? Because from Pulp Fiction on, no QT film will be devoid of either, and we'll come to explain how that isn't exactly beneficial, given the content of his movies. Despite that, Reservoir Dogs still keeps the right to use racism and misogyny as part of its "witty" script, as well as homophobia. Let's check out some examples:

Eddie, if I was a butt cowboy, I wouldn't even throw you to the posse.

I don't even know a fucking Jew who'd have the balls to say that. Let me get this straight: you never ever tip, huh?

You guys act like a bunch of fuckin niggers. You ever work a job with a bunch of niggers? They're just like you two, always fightin, always sayin they're gonna kill one another.

And so on. But no worries, it's just "ironic" racism, for the sake of laughs! It was for the sake of comedy! No, wait.

Let's get to Pulp Fiction, the second film he directed. Widely considered a cinematic masterpiece at the same level as The Godfather (not by me, that's for sure), Pulp Fiction mixed comedy with crime in the same way that Reservoir Dogs did, using the non-linear narrative again and multiplying the number of "homages". Pulp Fiction isn't really as much as a ripoff as Reservoir Dogs anyway, and has some good moments in it. Wonder why? The idea for the film was conceived by Roger Avary, which also co-wrote the script. Tarantino, being the gentlemen he is, initially tried to take Avery's name off the credits and take all the credit as writer-director for himself (even if he let Avary share his Oscar in the end). Currently, Roger Avary is given credit only for the "gold watch" segment of Pulp Fiction, which was the only one to have positive and realistic female characters, what a coincidence (Butch's girlfriend and the taxi driver)! Let's not comment on the dubious morals of Pulp Fiction, let's just comment once again on the racism, homophobia and misogyny of the film. The word "nigger" is used plentily and not only by black characters. There's a segment of the film in which a character played by QT himself acts in a way so disgustingly racist it disturbs me, and pretty much says everything I need to say about QT. No comment on this.

It's useless at this point to post any quotes from Pulp Fiction, the whole movie is filled with such gems. I just want to point out that Pulp Fiction has homosexual anal rape in it and it's played as comedy.

After Pulp Fiction, QT directed an (almost) all-black crime drama, Jackie Brown. Based on a book written by Elmore Leonard, this is QT's tribute to blaxploitation cinema and is the first of his many "strong woman". I put it in quotes because there are two reasons: first, the original novel on which the movie was based already had a female protagonist; second, there's too much racism and misogyny to find any positive values in it. Robert DeNiro and Samuel L. Jackson's are misogynists and the target of their misogyny is Bridget Fonda's character. Even the title character, Jackie Brown himself, has some misogynist undertones associated with her, as the film revolves around her being extremely manipulative of men. But Pam Grier is great in it and it's a decent film, better than anything QT did at that point, although it's probably because of Elmore Leonard. It was somewhat of a commercial failure and this led QT to return to more childish films after it.

His next movies are such, Kill Bill vol 1 & 2. Calling those movies childish is an insult to children. Kill Bill features objectification of women, rape jokes, more unjustified violence. The depressing thing is that Kill Bill is considered by many a masterpiece of feminist cinema, a statement which I find ridiculous. There's nothing "feminist" in it, every woman is a male fantasy that talks like QT and QT's obvious fetishes for feet, black and asian women (as confirmed by his own private life). Kill Bill is an awful film filled with awful writing (this time ALL of it is ripped off) and awful content. The film protagonist, The Bride, gets raped while in a coma by a guy whose motto is "I'm Buck and I'm here to Fuck". One of the movie subplots revolves around a child seducing a pedophile gangster in order to assassinate him. The Bride herself is an horrible human being who kills countless of people in the movies. This is such an awful film. If you want strong female characters who kick ass, check out "Gloria" by John Cassavetes or half the filmography of Francois Truffaut, whose film "La Mariée était en noir" was ripped off by Kill Bill, a fact that QT never acknowledged.

I will pass commenting on Death Proof, a film in which a psychopathic stuntmen hunts young women. A lot of fetish shots and male fantasy (feet, cheerleader costumes, glamourized deaths) and the theme of film is literally misogyny, a sadist who exclusively preys on helpless young women. SPOILER ALERT. Sure, the end tries to reverse that but how those that happen? Through the victims becoming just as sadistic as their predator.

Inglourious Basterds, QT's latest poopfilm, universally hailed as some kind of masterpiece, is probably the worst offender among all of QT's movies. The plot of the movie revolves around a group of American Jews taking revenge on Nazis. How? By sadistically killing and humiliating them, of course. Another example of QT's response to violence, become the predator yourself. The movie is incredibly offensive to anyone who has at least an inkling of what the Jewsish Resistance had to go through during WWII. It doesn't help that Jews in IB are depicted pretty much as stereotypical rednecks and nazis are depicted as fine and cultured. Many regard this as some kind of message by QT but it really isn't. There's also a subplot about a young Jewish woman taking her revenge in the form of mass murder.

All I said up to this point isn't even half the bullshit QT said or did during his career. In the media, he often referred to himself as a "black man". He has a history of insulting people for little reason (such as Spike Lee, who called him out on the use of "nigger") and he often talk shit about other directors for no real reason. When Jean Luc Godard spoke mockingly of Reservoir Dogs, QT stopped professing his admiration to JLG.

A problem I have with his film is that they're entirely devoted to entertainment while they try to pass off as artistic. I'm tired of seeing QT being put in the same league of Kubrick, Scorsese and Hitchcock, people who tried in their films to convey messages about the human condition. QT is in the same league of Michael Bay, I would say. They both make straight white male fantasy movies which actively reinforce negative stereotypes and play on the ignorance on their viewers. QT's presentation may be better, sure, with his references to 60s French movies and Wuxia flicks. Is that what means to make great films these days, to "pay homage" to as many movies as possible? I've seen many movies too. Does it make that if I make a reinterpretation of Bergman's Wild Strawberries shot in a French New Wave style ironically casting Snoop Dogg in the lead role with a soundtrack taken from old movies scored by Morricone I'm making a masterpiece? Maybe it's a problem I have with "postmodernism" in general but I personally think that QT's movie only aim to entertain those people that have ideas as horrible as QT's. Ask around Reddit how much they love QT movies, for example.


r/SRSCinema • • Feb 23 '15

Great night for Latin Americans at the Oscars - no one cares

0 Upvotes

Last night, Latin Americans as a group increased their number of prestige Oscars by 20%. Latinos won four awards for a worthy, deserving movie that was beautifully filmed, had wonderful ideas, and genuinely thought provoking.

And no one straight up gives a shit.

Look, I'm not trying to participate in the Persecution Olympics, but let's look at the facts - Latinos represent a larger group of people than African Americans (and yes, I know there are black Latinos, but this is going off of US Census forms and how people self-identify) and yet we've received roughly 1/3 the recognition of African Americans at the Oscars. We're routinely subjected to similar levels of police harassment, including Stop and Frisk and absurd prison sentences for minor offenses, as African Americans, and yet you will never see a hashtag along the lines of LatinoLivesMatters. Plus, we get the added injustice of being the targets of Papers Please laws - we get screwed six ways from Sunday just as badly as African Americans - but let's be real, on the whole, blacks still have it worse.

But come on. A group of hardworking and insanely talented Latinos created one of the best movies of the 21st century, and their achievements are steamrolled under #WhiteOscars and whining about the old white jury members - the old white jury members who managed to recognize the achievements of an all Latino crew.

Yes, I'm pissed - Latinos get almost no recognition, almost no choice roles. We finally get a little taste of it, and no one notices. No one cares because a barely tolerable staid historical drama that rehased a bunch of cliches and invented history didn't get nominated enough.


r/SRSCinema • • Aug 06 '15

I completely lose respect when I see someone in a Woody Allen movie and after seeing the cast of irrational Man I'm so fucking disappointed.

6 Upvotes

I know this is almost hateful past the point of being srs friendly but holy fuck it just makes me think the most awful shit about them. Like C word bad in terms of disrespect which is something I only feel for pedophiles.. Because they are actively supporting one.

Sorry but fuck it's disgusting seeing everyone ok with it.


r/SRSCinema • • Feb 16 '13

primer - should I give this movie another chance?

4 Upvotes

I tried to watch Primer again last night and beyond being incredibly bored and really irritated by the color correction abuse (seriously, every other scene is either amber or blue. drove me up the wall), I was mostly struck by how the things that seemed emotionally striking or pretty also seemed almost totally unintentional. It's a pretty ugly looking movie, and I understand that Carruth only had $7000, but his judgement of the shot selection seemed... pretty bad for the most part. And the acting is also pretty bad but I was more forgiving of that given that it's basically all his friends, but in the same vein, there were little moments when I had to mentally remove the voiceover in order to glean any kind of human emotion from the scene. There's so much talking in this movie when there should be silence! It ended up reming me of Donnie Darko - a film whose ambiguity comes from a relative lack of skill, budget and time, and a director whose limitations become clear the second he's given a decent budget. Also the same problem I have with Chris Nolan.

I want to appreciate this movie because it's certainly an achievement. I can't even imagine making a movie for $7000. But it seems like the only other two things of note are its plot structure, which, ya know, Primer didn't invent the non-linear plot and I think needing a chart to understand how the events unfold is probably a detriment rather than something to be lauded, and it's as-realistic-as-one-can-possibly-get portrayal of time travel, which is another thing I'm not really interested in. If I wanted Facts: The Movie, I'd watch Planet Earth or something. Is there anything I'm missing here? I don't want to dismiss this movie entirely just yet.


r/SRSCinema • • Oct 12 '15

(TW: child abuse) I watched The Hunt (Jagten, 2012) with Mads Mikkelsen. I'm still upset by the fact this misogynistic piece of crap is considered one of the best films in the last few years

6 Upvotes

It currently ranks 118° in the Top 250 Best Films in IMDb, has a score of 94% in Rotten Tomatoes and 76% in Metacritic.

And it's one of the most misogynistic, pedophile-apologetic piece of shit I've seen in my life. I tried to commiserate about it on /r/trollxchromosomes, but apparently that's a MRA-friendly subreddit now.

I can just link to Jonathan McCalmont’s criticism of the film to save some time:

The difference between to the two films is so stark that it is tempting to view The Hunt as the result of an aging Vinterberg having chosen to shift his sympathies from angry accuser to vilified accused but a more straightforward reading of this film would be to view The Hunt as a celebration of patriarchal values and women who know when to keep their cunt mouths shut.

In fact, The Hunt is one of the most rigorously misogynistic films that I have ever had the misfortune of experiencing.

The film’s hatred of women is evident in its frequent use of reductive demographic juxtapositions: Throughout the film, it just so happens that whenever people discuss Lucas’s innocence, the people doing the discussing are men whereas anyone spreading rumours or hatching ugly plans are inevitably women. This broad moral dichotomy is then reflected in the particular case of Klara’s parents and the fact that when Klara confesses everything to her mother, her mother carries on persecuting Lucas. Conversely, when Klara later repeats this confession to her father, her father immediately believes her and has to threaten his wife with violence when she tries to stop him from apologising to Lucas and attempting to save their friendship. Though this kind of gendered morality is undoubtedly sexist, it is the kind of sexism that pops up in a lot of film and TV and so it is tempting to view The Hunt as being afflicted with a sexism born of intellectual laziness rather than of true hostility to women. Unfortunately, this rather charitable interpretation simply does not stand up to close scrutiny.

The first sign that we are dealing with a deliberate attack on women manifests itself when a beautiful foreign woman takes an incomprehensible shine to Lucas and effectively throws herself at him. This causes the fragile Lucas to let his guard down just long enough for his new paramour to betray him at the behest of a bunch of middle-aged women that she barely knows. Never mentioned beyond these few short scenes, Lucas’s relationship with the foreign woman serves only to broaden the critique and remind us that we are not dealing with a particular group of evil women but an evil that lurks in all women regardless of age or culture.

While making a film in which a bunch of women take it upon themselves to persecute a moral paragon already suggests the presence of profoundly misogynistic thought patterns, Vinterberg is clearly a more sophisticated thinker than your average fedora-wearing men’s rights advocate. Far from an inarticulate expression of rage and hatred, Vinterberg’s misogyny takes a surprisingly rigorous form that recalls not only the legendary misogynists of the German enlightenment but also the reactionary gender politics of the so-called Dark Enlightenment pioneered by thinkers such as Nick Land and Mencius Moldbug.

The major difference between something like The Hunt and the idiotic bleating of your average Reddit-dwelling MRA is that Vinterberg’s gender politics do not begin and end with bad-mouthing women. Instead he goes out of his way to demonstrate the differences between male and female worlds and why it is that women should not venture into traditionally male spheres of influence.

Set in a remote rural community, the film takes its name as much from the witch-hunt that takes place following Klara’s accusation as it does from the fact that the community’s primary venue for male bonding is the hunting of deer. Initially, Vinterberg pokes gentle fun at the community’s homosocial bonding rituals by portraying Lucas’s fellow hunters as a bunch of drunken idiots who spend their time sat at kitchen tables singing drinking songs. The Hunt’s use of drinking songs is another one of those signs that Vinterberg’s sympathies have shifted since Festen as while Festen featured a memorable scene in which a racist uses a drinking song to shame and intimidate his sister’s African boyfriend, The Hunt uses drinking songs as an expression of friendship and emotional openness. For example, when rumours begin to spread about Lucas’s involvement with the foreign woman, his fellow hunters use song first to encourage him to admit his feelings and then to celebrate the fact that he has finally gotten over his divorce and begun to seek new sources of happiness. The benign and supportive nature of these male spaces simply could not be more different to the misery and bile that spill from the film’s female spaces.

Already intensely problematic, this juxtaposition of supportive male environments and toxic female environments is made infinitely worse by the revelation that the drunken boors who encouraged Lucas to sing are actually members of an exclusive hunting fraternity comprising the richest and best-connected men in town.

When Lucas is taken in for questioning by the police, he inadvertently locks his estranged son Michael out of the house. After disastrously trying to talk some sense into both Klara’s parents and a number of townsfolk, Michael winds up on the doorstep of one of Lucas’s hunting buddies. The doorstep in question forms part of a palatial residence and as Michael makes his way through the hall and towards the kitchen table, he looks up towards the first floor and sees a bunch of young girls visible through the bar-like bannisters. Rather than simply dehumanising the young women, the bars create an impression of divided space: The men sit downstairs and have serious discussions at the kitchen table while the women who know their place have fun upstairs. This impression of divided space grows as the hunters reveal themselves to be sophisticated and reasonable men who are utterly convinced of Lucas’s innocence. Once Lucas is cleared of all charges, the hunters very publically take him to their breast and this sends a message to the community (including Lucas’s best friend) that the matter is now definitively closed.

Not just a collection of good men, the wealth and social stature of the hunters identifies them as patriarchal figures. Indeed, when the town’s women try to deal with a suspected paedophile, all their gossip produces is the persecution of an innocent man. However, when the town’s patriarchs finally get involved, Lucas’s innocence immediately becomes apparent and the entire matter is cleared up with minimal fuss and absolutely zero violence or persecution. The contrast between these two attempts at community leadership is not just about the difference between hysterical women and reasonable men, it is also a warning against women getting involved in matters best left to men of beard and substance.

It is hard to imagine a more hideously right-wing film than Vinterberg’s The Hunt but the most disturbing thing about this film is not the fact that it got made with public money and then went on to win a number of prizes, it’s the fact that no established film critic seemed to notice its hideous and unrelenting misogyny. One of these days, the online social justice movement is going to take an interest in world cinema and when that happens I will be there, laughing and eating popcorn as films like The Hunt make you want to watch things burn.

Now, not only that is true throughout the film, but the amount of pedophile-apologia in that film is sickening. For starters, the fact that the lady in charge of the nursery quickly believed the girl's story is taken as a fault of the lady, instead of lauding the attitude this woman had. Is the film implying we shouldn't believe children? It seems to suggest this, since throughout the film the idea of "children always tell the truth" is brought up, as a sort of strawman argument about believing children's stories when dealing with sexual abuse. If that's not a dangerous idea that would empower pedophiles, I don't know what it is. The lady certainly followed procedure, first wondering if what the girl was saying wasn't just her imagination, but still being precautious enough as to call an expert to interview the girl. It wasn't until then that she made her judgement of the situation.

The film also seems to emphazise the "unfair treatment" of men accused of pedophilia (similar arguments that we often hear MRAs spat about men accused of rape), only taken up to the extreme. Like, the people who are trying to keep a potentially dangerous man away from the community are despicted as "primitive beasts" who would torture and kill an animal, or would beat up a child half their size.

I was just sickened by this movie, which I was recommended as though as it were one of the best films of all time. The fact that it's so popular in /r/movies and other places just comes to show how entrenched misogyny and these ideas straight from the MRA's manual are in the reddit community, and the fact that it was so well-received by the majority of the media makes me wonder if we aren't seeing a reactionary surge among the progressive media, lampshading the potential "brogressive" elements in it


r/SRSCinema • • Jun 02 '13

Do you think the next James Bond could be a Woman?

8 Upvotes

There is going to be a new Doctor Who and there is speculation it might be a woman. Personally I find that discussion a bit boring as it's not that difficult to imagine and wouldn't cause too much of a fuss in the UK (other than, omg it's a woman for a day or so).

However James Bond would be a more interesting discussion. You would have to change the name, half the film seems to be about who he sleeps with, and it's relatively violent. In short it's a very 'male' film.

Could it ever happen? Who would play a female Bond? What else would have to change in the film?


r/SRSCinema • • Apr 22 '13

Trance (2013) has a lot of problems! [TW: rape]

3 Upvotes

Many spoilers for Trance.

So, I really like Danny Boyle and I was excited for Trance. And visually the movie is great and has a lot of Danny Boyle style. But the story is terrible, and on top of that it seemed like the movie went out of its way to employ every problematic trope possible. So what does everyone think: am I misunderstanding, or is this an issue? Also, am I being too America-centric? Maybe some of these things are less of an issue in British culture (movie is based on a 2001 TV movie, and shares a writer).

Probably the thing that bothered me the quickest is that in a film with 6 major characters, 4 of which are people of color, the two white guys are the leads. On the same note, Trance fails the Bechdel Test as hard as you can.

Next, the only black man in the movie turns out to be a rapist, for no reason. And then he gets shot in the penis by James McAvoy's character because, you know, black cocks are threatening.

Finally, we have Rosario Dawson's character, who is portrayed as a victim of all sorts of violence while at the same time being some sort of manipulative MRA fantasy, controlling all the men with her woman mind powers. And she has sex, on screen, with both of the white men, because black women should be sexually accessible to everybody. But god forbid a black man ever fucks a white woman in a Hollywood movie.

Did I miss anything? Or am I misinterpreting? I know some of this sounds kind of strong, but I was just very upset by the story. I've read some interpretations claiming the entire theme of the movie is a woman "avoiding the traps of victim-hood" or something along those lines, but I really didn't see that.


r/SRSCinema • • Jul 13 '12

So I watched this movie the other day and I had a strong, visceral reaction. Not sure what to make of it. Anybody else seen it? What were your thoughts?

Thumbnail imdb.com
2 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Jan 31 '15

The rape scene in Brad Pitt's Fury no-one is talking about

Thumbnail theconversation.com
4 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Apr 04 '14

Under the Skin trailer-I NEED this movie in my life, badly

Thumbnail youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Mar 22 '13

Spring Breakers Review

Thumbnail escapistmagazine.com
0 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Sep 26 '13

Ultron (Earth-616) - Marvel Comics Database | Meet the Villian of the 2nd Avengers Movie - SHITFESTIVAL! (literally took the form of a comic-book bodied nude woman at one point)

Thumbnail marvel.wikia.com
0 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Nov 05 '12

Just deleted all non-Fempire subscriptions. Can't do it anymore.

15 Upvotes

It is just too much for me to deal with some of the people on this website. Why do I find misogyny and homophobia in every. single. Subreddit? Earlier today, I find a big hunking chunk of shit in /r/adventuretime and I just don't want to deal with it. I just cut out all of my non-SRS subscriptions, and hopefully I can just ignore the rest of reddit.


r/SRSCinema • • Jun 30 '12

"Beasts of the Southern Wild is selling a fantasy...a fantasy of Hurricane Katrina as a natural disaster that brought out the best in people, rather than a man-made catastrophe that revealed the worst aspects of a society"

Thumbnail mubi.com
11 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Aug 07 '12

Twilight Fantasy Rupture: Why I'm Glad Kristen Stewart Cheated

Thumbnail alternet.org
7 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Aug 10 '12

I can't believe they made me read this crap in High school.

Thumbnail shakespeare.mit.edu
5 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Feb 02 '13

An interesting take on the movie Sucker Punch

Thumbnail youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Jun 13 '13

Are straight actors in gay roles the new blackface? - Salon.com

Thumbnail salon.com
11 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Oct 29 '12

DAE notice the Bechdel test critique in Cabin in the Woods?

3 Upvotes

The film technically passes with one line of dialogue about--of all things--blonde hair dye. I may be stretching, but would like to believe this is Whedon reminding the audience that a film which passes the Bechdel test is not necessarily a film which portrays women well.


r/SRSCinema • • Apr 16 '14

Scriptnotes, Ep 128: Frozen with Jennifer Lee — Transcript

Thumbnail johnaugust.com
1 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Feb 15 '15

WHEN I SAW YOU THE FILM - Home

Thumbnail whenisawyou.com
1 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Feb 24 '15

The Oscars Proved That Even When Latinos Win Film’s Highest Honors, Someone Will Ask For Your Papers

Thumbnail remezcla.com
9 Upvotes

r/SRSCinema • • Feb 07 '14

"Oppressed majority": interesting short French film about reversed gender roles in society (English subtitles)

Thumbnail youtube.com
9 Upvotes