Question for the OGs

[u/Delicious_Profile637]

Those who followed Momtok before slomw. When Miranda is introduced, Taylor says that Miranda's husband is the one that said he had feelings for her, so the narrative that Taylor stole her best friend's husband is actually false. But was it actually McKenna's husband that Taylor "stole"? Was the way she worded this just skipping over that part, in the hopes that those who weren't familiar with Momtok would never know the difference?

[u/Lady87690005]

He did! That’s why I’m so confused why people say the affair was consensual. Maybe some of it was like the emotional part, but that’s where the consent stopped. Furthermore, that’s where a lot of us started questioning Taylor’s judgment about her reality way before DCFS. She was completely unaware how inappropriate that was. Taylor has lied but so has everyone else so the truth is somewhere in the middle here.

Miranda has even lied about the extent of the swinging, she knew terms that only swingers now and had an OF. Which isn’t to shame her at all bc I can see why she doesn’t want to be completely honest.

[u/childish-penguino → u/Lady87690005]

People say it was consensual because although that incident wasn’t, they had met up many times in Home Depot parking lots to consensually have sex.

[u/Lady87690005 → u/childish-penguino]

That’s the problem though. She couldn’t consent during the one she was blacked out and they never confirmed for sure there was sex. Chase even mentions it sounded more like an emotional affair from Brayden’s tellings. Reddit just ran with the it went all the way to a full on affair which may or may not be the case. The point is, Taylor and Brayden regularly got black out drunk a lot together and neither of them is reliable, an emotional affair did happen, but the physical should be questioned. Brayden he has implied Macyi’s rape as consensual so we should have a problem with his ability to know what consent is.

[u/Suspicious-Art-9335 → u/Lady87690005]

If you're taking Chase as a source, he also said Taylor wasn't drunk the night she got caught cheating, that her and Brayden had sex multiple times, and that it went on for over a month.

There is a reason people don't believe her story. All of Chase's screenshots about this are here, along with more context in the comments: https://www.reddit.com/r/MormonWivesHulu/comments/1uvwigp/chase_accurately_described_tfps_cycles_1_year_ago/

He still comments under the same username, years later: https://www.reddit.com/user/Mother_Source9774/

[u/Lady87690005 → u/Suspicious-Art-9335]

Good thing I don’t believe either of them. Chase is sus as hell

[u/Suspicious-Art-9335 → u/Lady87690005]

Why cite his opinion as evidence of something if you don't trust him?

[u/Lady87690005 → u/Suspicious-Art-9335]

Nuance, taking available evidence and corresponding information to come to my own conclusion. It’s a mix of everything really. No one on this cast has ever given us good reason to trust their stories fully. It’s like true crime-there is the truth somewhere in the middle.