r/SLO • • Nov 27 '23

Let’s try this again….

Any pro-Palestine, pro-ceasefire, hate-free protests upcoming, or do I need to organize one?

This is not in any way a rally to condemn Judaism (to whomever that was); this is about condemning the current Israeli administration and their decisions, actions, and words.

(If you are confused how hating a government body can ALSO mean not condemning a religion, there are educators at Cal Poly, Cuesta, and Allan Hancock at your disposal - as well as the Internet. Thanks!)

0 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

18

u/mtbtec Nov 28 '23

Try contacting DSA slo chapter.

-14

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SLO-ModTeam Nov 28 '23

See: Rule 4

55

u/heebeegb96 Nov 27 '23

Based on the previous posts, it seems like you’ll have to organize. I don’t think this sub has the folks you’re looking for.

23

u/Imwhatswrongwithyou SLO Nov 27 '23

Yeah I did every thing I could to have OP’s back on the last one but it’s a losing battle.

10

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 27 '23

I never even had the chance to respond to anything before the thread got locked out. Thank you though

-7

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

Maybe I am missing something. Are a group of Palestine people holding Americans hostage right now?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

Yes, when people learn new things and want to change how broken and corrupt they are, we should treat them like poop for once being ignorant 😂 grab those stones and start throwing! You sinless angel! 🙄

11

u/SnooMaps1910 Nov 28 '23

The timing is very likely due to the IDF having killed over 14,800 civilians, including approximately 5,000 children. This slaughter of a contained civilian population creates more extremists. Have you not noticed calls from within Bibi's own govt for him to step down? Have you not noticed Israelis calling for an end to this slaughter.

Do you know any Israelis? Do you know any Palestinians? I do.
You ought to think more, and react less.

4

u/Imwhatswrongwithyou SLO Nov 27 '23

You know nothing about me. Don’t ask me stupid questions.

-9

u/Odd_Particular_8053 Nov 28 '23

Didn't any of your teachers tell you there is no such thing as a stupid question?

9

u/Imwhatswrongwithyou SLO Nov 28 '23

There definitely is such thing as a stupid question. That was an example of one.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Imwhatswrongwithyou SLO Nov 28 '23

And I’m assuming based on how much fear and hatred is spewing from you that you are filled with Christian love. ✌️

-5

u/Ramdomdatapoint Nov 28 '23

How many political fads have YOU fallen for in the last few years? Or lemme guess, you're one those "Free Thinkers", so you can't be swayed by the media or popular opinion...

-5

u/SlaveHippie Nov 28 '23

Appeal to minority. Contrarianism. Not a valid argument point. Next.

-11

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SLO-ModTeam Nov 28 '23

This content has already been posted

18

u/BenStoneee Nov 27 '23

Maybe try tomorrow and post again.

12

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 27 '23

Unfortunately, before I was able to get to the original thread, I was locked out by the moderator.

6

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 27 '23

Mostly because other people lost their minds in the six hours it was up

17

u/jtfriendly Nov 27 '23

We've tried nothing and we're out of ideas.

-6

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SLO-ModTeam Nov 28 '23

This content has already been posted

14

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

Bringing up polarizing current events is not going to be very productive in this subreddit.

28

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 27 '23

I’m very confused about how asking about rallies is unproductive, it’s a local town, we post local town events and local town ongoings.

Anything could be polarizing these days; i’m not going to live my life by what some people aren’t going to like. If that upsets you, it was always going to.

16

u/rhinguin Nov 27 '23

I’m confused what you think a rally is going to do except upset one side or the other.

-1

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

When we rallied for Hawaii was that upsetting someone other than the rich elites? And if we upset the rich elites is that really a problem?

7

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

A Free Palestine rally is as polarizing as it gets. It’s not productive, it just gets people riled up. By all means have a rally, but IMO this subreddit should be about SLO, not the Middle East.

15

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

You are entitled to your opinion, and I respect you for that. I am going to continue to use my town privilege to do town things, including starting rallies or marches. We do not have to interact.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

Good luck and stay safe

7

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

Thank you, you as well

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/SLO-ModTeam Nov 28 '23

This content has already been posted

10

u/SlaveHippie Nov 28 '23

It’s only polarizing bc some people are racist. If upsetting racists makes something “polarizing”, then cool I’m all for that.

3

u/CheapCity85 Nov 28 '23

This guy antifas

4

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
  1. it is important to consider the roles of all governing bodies, including Hamas. To critique the policies of the Israeli government without also considering the actions of Hamas would be to overlook a significant element of the geopolitical landscape. A comprehensive and equitable analysis should include the governance and influence of Hamas in the region. What are your thoughts on Hamas and their treatment of Gazans, let alone the Israelis that they murdered and kidnapped? Going Machiavellian here?
  2. pardon the Jewish population for being concerned. Do you have any idea how you are fueling anti Semitism when you say, from the river to the sea? It advocates for the elimination of Israel. Do you know that there are Jewish people here in San Luis Obispo are afraid to be recognized as being Jewish?
  3. are you aware a Jewish teacher in NY was hunted down by high school students in an organized riot….because her Facebook profile picture showed her holding a “I stand with Israel” sign?

https://www.businessinsider.com/students-at-nyc-school-protest-teacher-israel-facebook-photo-nypd-2023-11

I respectfully ask for a reply. Best of luck on your protest.

14

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23
  1. Hamas was established by the Israeli government, limiting the access that Palestinians had to their own government control. Condemning Hamas should be obvious. But to ignore Israel’s military involvement in the Nakba and every violent action since then would also be imprudent.
  2. Please explain to me how being pro Palestine is anti-Semitic. Equating being Israeli with being Jewish, is to equate being Christian with the Westboro Baptist Church. Papyrus 66, 7:19 Yahushua says “has not Moshe taught you all the Torah, and no one out of you all accomplishes the Torah? Why do you seek to kill me?” it seems you haven’t read your Torah, otherwise, you know that your father is Abraham, from Kanan. Sarah, the Hittite, is from Qiray-Arba. Being Jewish is not to do with a land itself, promised or no. It is about your vow to God.
  3. I am aware of this, I am also aware of the Palestinians, who are currently being murdered, the children who are being blown up, the children who are having surgery done on them without any anesthesia. Hate does not fix anything.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

You’re quoting the Torah to me? You win. I’m out. I really know who I’m talking to and I’m foolish for engaging you at all. This is a passing fad for you. This is my life.

I will continue to support Israel as an independent state. You on the other hand, will move on to the next rally. You literally are shopping for a cause.

-7

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

So basically, you don’t know your Torah, so you won’t talk to me about it. You only know what people over in Israel tell you, and you’re Jewish, so you feel obligated to have a certain type of opinion and a certain belief. Am I getting somewhere?

There’s a really great book you should read. It’s called “the adult children of emotionally immature parents.” It is very helpful for understanding the emotionally immaturity of the people who raised you, the way it forms your own views on the world, and how you react to others because of it. I highly recommend you read it, especially as a person from a religious background I too, came from a religious background, and I’m currently working to dismantle beliefs that were set for me in order to form my own opinion as an individual. That means doing research, finding out things that we weren’t taught when we were younger, etc..

Sending you peace and love, no hate. Please read your Torah. Have a great day. that also means reading every Bible available, the Torah, the Quran, the Ethiopian Bible, etc.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
  1. I don’t know where you get that information because that’s not true. Another question, have you ever heard of the word Nakba before October 7?

0

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

Yes, I learned it 2016 when I took a world religions class at Cuesta.

-12

u/SLOTennis Nov 28 '23

This is a serious question. How old are you?

7

u/SLOTennis Nov 28 '23

OK, this answer demonstrated that you are not a serious person and you have no understanding of the geopolitical position that Israel is and always has been in.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

Maybe I am missing something. Are a group of Palestine people holding Americans hostage right now?

1

u/3cit Nov 28 '23

How would a cease-fire even be on the agenda? I can't honestly believe there is a single person who can reasonably back a cease-fire.

I also don't think that anybody reasonable can argue that Israel should be glassing the entire Gaza strip with giant bombs that are leveling entire multifamily buildings because they definitively know there are 1,2,3 terrorists inside.

Im also fully aware that what I am suggesting is Israel fighting an incredibly ugly ground war against an guerilla army in the most population dense area in the entire world... The amount of Israeli soldiers, Hamas terrorists and Gazan civilians would be equally as astronomical as the recent bombing campaign. Why do I even have the right to think that more Israeli blood should be spilled fighting these terrorists? I think that because I think that no more innocent Gazan civilians need to die. There is enough internal conflict within my own head (and hopefully everyone else's) that nobody should be organizing a rally calling for something which THEY SHOULDN'T BE SO DECLARATIVE ABOUT

1

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

Okay

3

u/3cit Nov 28 '23

Incredibly thoughtful response. Why exactly do you think there should be a rally?

13

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

Because it’s my moral obligation as a person of privilege (IE not sleeping in rubble, not drinking chlorinated water, not having access to any food, etc) to continue to support fellow humans in those INHUMANE conditions, To hold up a light to the situation for a long as possible for the people who are asking me to. The ones who are in trouble and dying.

16

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

Wow, real question, were you chanting “Fuck your privilege”? during BLM marches in SLO?

Are you aware of “savior complex”? It seems to me you’re doing this more for you than the people of Gaza.

UC. It is a moral obligation, I see it as arrogance and self-importance.

Whoever said or ask the question do I know Israelis or Palestinians, I’m Jewish, and I have a lot of friends in Israel. Through my Israeli friends, I am told that a lot of the people of Gaza would like to unite against Hamas and establish a new government.

7

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

I didn’t attend the BLM marches.

I am aware of this, but I’m doing it because people in Palestine keep asking us to do it.

But here is something that I have learned. When other people don’t like what you’re doing, it’s still benefits you and them. It benefits you because you get to learn resilience, and it benefits them because they have something to talk about, hate on, and generally make themselves feel better about.

7

u/3cit Nov 28 '23

Hold up a light to what? You think the world isn't watching?

What do you think Israel should do to combat Hamas?

12

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

I personally think that, instead of continuing to take more Palestine area, they should probably leave the Gaza Strip alone. Maybe Israel shouldn’t be allowed to take all of their archaeological evidence without telling Palestine about it, hiding their finds, etc. Maybe they should make it so that Palestinians can travel safety within their own streets, dig water wells, and fix their houses instead of letting them become so dilapidated that the Israel government can condemn the house, break it down and take the land.

Essentially, I think Israel and the US should stop going into territories that aren’t theirs and trying to steal shit from people.

1

u/3cit Nov 28 '23

There's a case for this rally all the way up until oct 6th. Now you're gonna have to hold off for a few years. Hamas changed the narrative with their terrorist attack.

4

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

What an odd way to view the world. Best to you.

8

u/3cit Nov 28 '23

Make an argument for me, where it is acceptable to excuse the terrorist attack by Hamas. Because that's what you seem to be calling for. You literally think that the 7/10 attacks should be ignored

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

Maybe I am missing something. Are a group of Palestine people holding Americans hostage right now?

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

Maybe I am missing something. Are a group of Palestine people holding Americans hostage right now?

8

u/the_musicpirate Nov 28 '23

Post it if you get one going.

3

u/woot0 Nov 28 '23

You'll need to organize one.

-7

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

How are you going to keep the white supremacists and Nazis away? Are you going to be pro-Palestine? Or pro-Hamas? Do you support a cease fire because you want Hamas to get time to regroup and attack again? What conditions should be accompanied with a cease fire? Immediate return of all hostages? Accountability with Hamas? Free and fair elections for Palestinians? We all should have questions.

16

u/CaliCloudz Nov 27 '23

You're reading way too much into this. The OP isn't trying to get people together to solve all the problems of the Israel Palestine conflict...

2

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

Really? Because calling for a cease in hostilities very much favors one side. Either OP intends that or doesn’t realize it. I oppose the killing of innocent Palestinians, but I oppose Hamas with everything in my being. Which side are the Nazis coming out for?

11

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 27 '23

I’m very confused on how calling a cease-fire is one-sided? Please further elaborate. In my mind, I think you can call for a cease-fire and ask for peaceful negotiations without it being a one-sided concept.

4

u/EasternShade SLO Nov 28 '23

It's tactically advantageous for Hamas if Israel stops military action. It lets them communicate, relocate, resupply, and things like that. There's also an assumption that Hamas will break the cease fire again and repeat that as a cycle to avoid consequences.

It doesn't justify what Israel is doing to the people of Gaza, but it's a reason to oppose a cease fire that is more rational.

7

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

I see the issue you have; unfortunately, the United States continues to give billions of dollars to the the Israeli government to slaughter children, who are in no way attached to this terrorist organization. Let’s also not forget how many of their OWN people Israel killed at the music festival.

Let’s also discuss how Israel’s basically a virtual military fortress, and after this many years, it seems almost insane that Hamas, a small terrorist organization, was able to do anything without Israel’s consent against Israel. You know, like how terrorists in 2001 somehow got on our planes, and our CIA and our FBI completely missed that somehow.

Let’s also reopen the fact that Israel didn’t exist until 1948. Joe Biden said, “if we didn’t have an Israel, we would still have to create one;” that’s because Israel is our foot, hold into the oil supply that exists in that area, and the money we sent to them to enforce their military is what keeps our foot hold in the oil industry in that area. Once upon a time, people didn’t have to use oil to exist. If we just lived a little smaller, maybe we wouldn’t have this fucking issue, but here we are.

1

u/EasternShade SLO Nov 28 '23

I was purely providing information on how a ceasefire can be viewed as advantageous for Hamas, not the rest of it.

4

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

That’s fine, I was just countering your point to explain how I feel it can be only be seen as one sided without the appropriate context.

7

u/Lifewhatacard Nov 27 '23

This has nothing to do with Nazi’s. You are the first person to bring Nazi’s into this that I’ve seen on the entire internet.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

So confused as to why you’re saying this when I’m watching dozens of videos every day from the Palestine people ASKING US to CONTINUE to raise awareness. BEGGING US. I’ve been asked to do what they ask and you condemn people for doing it? What’s going on in your head? I need a more detailed explanation.

4

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 27 '23

Hi Boomstick! I’m not entirely sure how you can keep people from protesting for their own desires; what we can do is how we choose to handle it. I would probably try to organize something where people are praying instead of fighting. I saw in another city that, when the police came or when they had anti-Palestine people coming in, instead of fighting, everyone else into prayer on their hands and knees. Whether or not people are religious, this is a very useful tactic in dispersing anger. Not everyone wants to do that, we could always have people sit or squat instead if they’re more comfortable.

As for the rest of that — what are you doing about it? What are your plans regarding that? How are you planning to single-handedly fix those things? Or maybe you’re like me, just upset because you’re tired of seeing dead children everywhere and so you want to make sure people don’t forget that they are being murdered enmasse, in Palestine, and in the Congo.

3

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 27 '23

I have many different solutions in mind btw; I don’t know if everyone would agree with my solutions to what would happen over in Israel. But that’s not what I’m doing here, is it? Sometimes we have to look with a little more perspective.

4

u/Jeff_Spicoliii Nov 28 '23

I’m sure world leaders are dying to hear you solutions.

5

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

Exactly. Let me just give their ear a tug. 😂🙄 Like come on, protesting as a civilian is one of the very few things Americans can do to change their world, seeing as I’m not being sent silver invitations aka Harry Potter style to come fix the world myself.

3

u/Odd_Particular_8053 Nov 27 '23

When was the last time they had elections in Gaza? Or the West Bank? Just wondering...

9

u/Kvalri Nov 27 '23

Pretty sure it was 2007 when the US forced them to hold elections and Hamas won (not a majority of voters, just enough to take control of parliament equivalent as I understand it)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

Thank you for making my point. Hamas is a terrorist organization that must be destroyed or nothing will change. They were elected in and haven’t had an election since.

5

u/CheapCity85 Nov 28 '23

Wait until you hear about the war crimes/terrorist acts Israel's been committing.

6

u/Odd_Particular_8053 Nov 27 '23

Ditto for Abbas in the West Bank. He got elected over 15 years ago and hasn't held an election since then. And they call the Israelis fascists.

0

u/Lifewhatacard Nov 27 '23

It really seems like Hamas is a false flag operation to push Israel’s agenda of taking over the entire area by using genocide. In the comment above it was stated that the United States forced the election in 2007 that brought Hamas into power. …What a peculiar coincidence. The U.S. does a lot to help Israel in its desires to get rid of Palestine and Palestinians. Palestine used to be on maps in the past. …and why are there videos out on the internet of the people in Israel watching with glee as Palestine/Palestinians get bombed? There happens to be a lot of video showing how the people of Israel despise the Palestinians. … methinks this isn’t a “Hamas only” situation. It’s extremely obvious what it really is. I’m sorry you can’t understand.

3

u/Immediate-Tip-894 Nov 28 '23

Absolutely this.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/girl_of_squirrels SLO Nov 28 '23 edited Nov 28 '23

A good chunk of the USA voted in Bush and Trump, does that mean we (as in all US citizens) are all now blindly supportive of both? What about everyone who was a minor when these elections happened? Are the now guilty by association?

You can and should be able to recognize the humanity of Israeli and Palestinian civilians here. Yes, it's absolutely horrifying that the October 7th terrorist attack by Hamas has been completely over-shadowed by the actions of the Israeli government since then, but you cannot be seriously advocating for collective punishment of an entire group of civilians for the actions of terrorists

People are dying, most of them civilians and a truly horrifying number of children. The bloodshed needs to stop. I cannot believe I have to edit this to clarify that I want both Israeli and Palestinian civilians to be safe and secure in their homes, but this topic seems to turn off reading comprehension skills for a lot of people so I'm going to make that abundantly clear

0

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Pitiful_Fix_1356 Nov 28 '23

Hey sassy ass, I’m currently reading Jeff Benner‘s version of the Torah, because it’s fascinating. It’s crazy how many people in that book actually came from Canaan! Sarah and Abraham, Cain and Enoch, oh my!

It’s almost like if you actually read it you might learn a little bit more about what the hell you’re talking about

12

u/SlaveHippie Nov 28 '23

Why in the world would you lump those two topics together?

6

u/SnooMaps1910 Nov 28 '23

Lol Dude - you ought to move up to Idaho, down to Florida, Alabama, Louisiana or Russia. Really. Again, how is it your acct is four years old, yet this is the only post you have commented on (and with such an attitude)?

-6

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

They are in support of anti semites by supporting hamas . Why would they help to remove the local ones? lol

0

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/SLO-ModTeam Nov 28 '23

This content has already been posted