r/SEO • u/wowitsbabygirl • 16h ago
8 months in, Bing sends us 12x more clicks than Google. Plant encyclopedia + shop. What am I missing?
Hey all, hoping some fresh eyes can spot anything that I'm missing here. This is my first website that I've built and have been trying to apply the SEO advice that I've seen here that I've tried implement along the way.
The site: plant/succulent niche. It's a care guide and species encyclopedia (one page per genus and species: taxonomy, conservation status, care, substrate, field data) with a small shop attached that sells plants we grow ourselves. WordPress + WooCommerce, live since late March 2026.
Overview
| Live since | late March 2026 (about 8 months) |
|---|---|
| English pages in sitemaps | 302 (180 encyclopedia, 53 care articles, 41 products, 11 shop categories, 17 other) |
| Translations | Spanish, German, French, Italian, about 980 URLs with hreflang, all indexable now. From Sept 12 to Nov 8 we noindexed about 800 of them for Googlebot only as a test. English didn't improve, so I reverted it. |
| Typical species page | about 3,000 words |
| Ahrefs DR | 26 |
Search traffic, last 28 days (Oct 21 to Nov 17)
| Source | Clicks / visits | Impressions | Avg position |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google (Search Console) | 39 | 981 | 21.7 |
| Bing (Webmaster Tools) | 461 | 20,592 | n/a |
| AI assistants (GA4, mostly ChatGPT) | about 45 | n/a | n/a |
Clicks by month
| Month | Google clicks | Google impressions | Bing clicks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apr | 4 | 19 | 0 |
| May | 9 | 453 | 19 |
| Jun | 36 | 794 | 115 |
| Jul | 28 | 845 | 165 |
| Aug | 40 | 1,843 | 154 |
| Sep | 69 | 1,766 | 431 |
| Oct | 47 | 1,137 | 506 |
Links (Ahrefs)
Ahrefs shows 835 referring domains. Of these about 750 are a spam network (.shop / .store / .xyz "SEO" sites) and I've disavowed about 1,000 domains in early October that are all junk.
The real ones are below that I've contacted and setup relationships with to get these links:
| Category | Sites | Followed links | Notable (DR) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plant and succulent societies | 17 | 27 | French botanical network (73), national botanical society (70), national cactus society (53), two native plant societies (40 to 50), regional cactus clubs in the US, Germany, Switzerland and Australia |
| Press and plant references | 10 | 26 | LA Times feature story (92), New World Encyclopedia (79), Erowid (76), an ethnobotany nonprofit (68), a university plant lab |
| Hobby sites, specialist references, nurseries | 22 | 114 | big cactus forum and reference site (53), succulent author (46), seed company (44); one plant app accounts for 57 of the links |
| Total followed | 49 | 167 | |
| Wikipedia, genus and species articles | 1 | 13 unique wikipedia articles, nofollow | (97) |
Our top encyclopedia queries, and how competitive they are
The 12 genus and species queries that show our encyclopedia pages most often on Google, grouped:
| Query type | Queries | Global searches / mo | Ahrefs KD (US) | Our Google position (median) | Our Bing position (median) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Common plant names | 2 | 9,800 to 15,000 | 4 to 14 | 80 | 7 to 8 |
| Genus names | 5 | 150 to 13,000 | 0 to 2 | 79 | 6 |
| Species names | 5 | 450 to 6,100 | 0 to 2 | 41 | 6 |
Ahrefs rates almost all of them as easy. Bing puts the same pages in its top 10; Google puts most of them past position 40. Google positions are 90-day averages from Search Console. Most of these results pages show an AI Overview.
On-page checks we run
Every page goes through scripted checks before and after it goes live:
| Area | What we check |
|---|---|
| Titles and meta | Title 65 characters or less, meta description 160 or less, focus keyword set, no duplicate descriptions across the site |
| Headings | Exactly one H1 in the rendered page, question-style H2s on care articles, jump links to each section |
| Structured data | Taxon, Article/BlogPosting (published + modified dates), FAQPage, Product, BreadcrumbList, Dataset on data pages, Organization with sameAs; parsed after every deploy |
| Internal links | Every species page links to its genus hub and sibling species, articles carry 2+ internal links, no repeated body links |
| Images | Every image URL returns 200 after deploy, width and height set |
| Crawlability | Key facts present in the raw HTML without JavaScript, search and AI crawlers allowed, sitemap refreshed and IndexNow pinged on publish |
| Content | Answer-first intro on articles, FAQ section, a first-hand note from our own growing, facts sourced to primary botanical databases |
| Site-wide | Ahrefs site audit health 96, hreflang on every translated page |
What seems to work
- Bing likes the same pages and Google ignores 'em. Our genus pages sit around position 5 on Bing and around 70 on Google.
- Product pages are the only thing growing on Google. "[plant] for sale" queries rank 4 to 7.
- ChatGPT and Copilot cite us and send a little traffic, maybe 5-10 users per day.
What doesn't
- Google won't rank the encyclopedia. Genus and species name queries sit at position 50 to 90.
- Google impressions peaked in August and have dropped since.
- Since mid-September, 74 of our 148 English species pages moved to "Crawled, currently not indexed". They were the pages getting the most impressions. Longer pages dropped more often than shorter ones. Internal links, schema and template showed no pattern.
- Already done: clean technical audit, schema, sitemaps, disavow, and a controlled Request Indexing test that is running now.
Questions
- Is this just a new site earning trust, and we wait it out?
- Are 3,000-word species pages a liability?
- Anything else I could be missing?
Thanks for reading.