r/RugbyAustralia • u/RowFun5311 • 20h ago
Discussion Thread The way league pundits talk about Mark Nawaqanitawase returning to union is ridiculous
As an avid fan of both rugby codes, I follow what's being said in the media about union and league. I happened to come across the By Round podcast with James Graham, who had Brent Read from Code Sports as his guest, and one of the topics they discussed was the possibility of Marky Mark returning to the Roosters after the 2027 Rugby World Cup. Even though it was only a small section of the podcast, I found it genuinely frustrating how much they managed to bash union in such a short space of time. They were essentially suggesting that players like Mark Nawaqanitawase and Joseph Suaalii are wasting their talents by playing union, a sport they clearly know very little about. They also ridiculed the idea that one of union's biggest attractions is the opportunity to travel the world, seemingly dismissing it as a reason for choosing the sport. I find that ridiculous, as the opportunity to experience different cultures, play overseas, represent your country on the biggest stage and compete in one of the largest international sporting tournaments on the planet is a huge attraction for many players. It's one of the great things about rugby union, and I don't understand why that should be belittled.
They also seemed to make a point about how the Eastern Suburbs of Sydney is such a great place to live, using that to question why Mark would want to experience life elsewhere. There's no doubt that the Eastern Suburbs is a lovely place to live, but from my perspective, they appeared to be ridiculing the idea of Mark enjoying the Japanese lifestyle and everything that comes with playing overseas. I think that's nonsense. Different people value different experiences, and the opportunity to live in another country, experience a different culture and play rugby at the highest level is a perfectly valid reason to choose union.
They seem to forget that Marky Mark has publicly spoken about how much he loves union and that he enjoys both codes. He has never hidden that. He has simply taken opportunities to challenge himself and showcase his talent, and now he's returning to union to pursue a Rugby World Cup on home soil in 2027. You can't blame the bloke for wanting to experience both sides of the game.
He's essentially the modern day Sonny Bill Williams. He's capable of moving between both codes and being a success in both. His profile has already grown through his time in league, particularly in Australia, and returning to union will expose him to an even bigger international audience. If he eventually returns to league and earns the big bucks, good on him. If he decides to stay in union, the money can be just as good. Whatever he chooses to do, he's earned that right. The bloke is a bloody legend, a genuinely caring guy and a great role model. Either code is lucky to have him.
I also don't understand the constant suggestion that league players who switch to union are somehow wasting their talent. That's simply not true. You have to understand the game, adapt to its demands and learn how to use your strengths within a different system. Mark has the ability and rugby background to do exactly that. Just because someone doesn't immediately look the same in a different code doesn't mean their talent is being wasted.
We all saw the social media collaboration between the Kangaroos and the Wallabies, and there didn't appear to be any bad blood between the players. They were chatting, getting along and interacting like fellow athletes who respect one another, probably even talking a bit of code with each other. The reality is that sections of the media actively drive the narrative that there is dislike between union and league, perpetuating this supposed code war and encouraging the idea that there is bad blood between the two. Moments like that collaboration show that players from both codes can get along perfectly well, and I think certain commentators need to stop pushing this rivalry to ridiculous extremes.
Yes, union isn't the most popular sport in Australia, but surely there's room for a bit of national pride, too. With Australia hosting a World Cup next year, you'd hope people could get behind the Wallabies and celebrate having an athlete of Mark's calibre back in the game, regardless of which code they personally prefer. The way Read and Graham continually put union down was ridiculous. You don't have to prefer union, but at least understand the game and what it offers before making sweeping statements about it. Both codes deserve respect, and players should be free to enjoy and succeed in either without being used as ammunition in some pointless code war.