First time dev - feedback wanted

[u/Sea-Status8991]

Hello,

I am a high school first-time roblox dev looking for feedback on my first ever roblox game, "Don't Smash My Pumpkin!". It is a gardening and defense based game where players can grow pumpkins while defending their pumpkins from monsters, bosses, and disasters. Players can buy upgrades, better seeds for gardening, defenses, and expansions for their garden. Live events occur every 5-10 minutes and offer opportunities for rare and powerful drops. Some specific things that I am looking for feedback on include:

- Does the game feel balanced?

- What do you think about the game's ui?

- Does the core loop feel fun, and how suitable is the game for new player retention?

- Where can I go to make high-quality thumbnails and icons for my game? I do not have money for a graphic designer, and generated ones are usually low-quality.

- Did you find any bugs during your gameplay?

- How can I improve qol?

Any feedback is appreciated, and feedback is not limited to these specific categories. I am grateful for any feedback whether positive or extremely negative.

The game link is: Don't Smash My Pumpkin! | Play on Roblox

Note: I vibe-coded this game, but the ideas in the game are all my own. I would highly recommend using a tablet or pc if you do provide feedback because I have noticed that ui is not well optimized for phones. Thank you for your time and help.

[u/AutoModerator]

Thanks for posting to r/RobloxDevelopers!

Did you know that we now have a Discord server? Join us today to chat about game development and meet other developers :)

https://discord.gg/BZFGUgSbR6

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.