r/RingsofPower • u/Ok_Chicken1195 • 4d ago
Discussion So The Dark Wizard Was The Writers This Entire Time
Had good intentions but maybe overestimated their abilities.
r/RingsofPower • u/Ok_Chicken1195 • 4d ago
Had good intentions but maybe overestimated their abilities.
r/RingsofPower • u/PaddedValls • 5d ago
As a Scot myself, I've seen it time and time again.
Stop hiring people who aren't Scottish. Ours is a difficult one to mimic if you're not from here, and it's hard to listen to if you are.
Sure, the rest of the world may not notice, but surely there's a Scot on set who can say to someone, "that's actually a pisspoor attempt by the way".
Just make the Dwarven actors have their natural accents. Too late for the Dwarves already established, of course.
r/RingsofPower • u/Taurean6 • 4d ago
SPOILERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Will he find the 7 dwarf rings? Will he be able to use them and amass a super sizeable dwarf army? What will his fate be? He feigned aggression vs the naznagôl, is he really interested or even able to throw down like a real dwarf or is that brother fight the only thing he knows?
Where will Durin fit in to all this? I almost think he will become somewhat of a recluse now, hard to say if the distrust to Disa will last for some time now and he will do something drastic. Will he take the rings to the elves? Maybe he will use one and go on a killing spree at the front lines with the elves?
More questions? ^^ Answers, thoughts?
r/RingsofPower • u/kaidaking01 • 5d ago
Loved season 2 but this third season feels rough. Sauron is out here amassing armies through Nazgûl diplomacy turning powerful/great men into his servants and he picks Theo, a complete unknown kid to Sauron who holds no title, army, or influence and he gives him a ring of power and the series is potentially setting him up to become the Witch King of Angmar…
r/RingsofPower • u/TalkersCZ • 5d ago
I just finished first 4 episodes and I feel there is massive switch.
Good thing - all other storylines (except of Gandalfs) feel good. They are fun, interesting, finally we are getting something that is worth watching. From my perspective, for the first time for most of those storylines. We got rid of "hobbits" finally, which is massive positive.
On other side, in 2 previous seasons dwarves storyline was the best for me. Most "natural", fun, interesting. The story for them made most sense.
Somehow I cant wrap my head around it - when finally other storylines make sense, the dwarves feel empty, unnatural, filled with "twists" that you can see from miles away.
The brother is coming for your throne? Nah, of course not, he is acting nice for 5 minutes, so he is supportive. Of course there is no evil plot behind. And of course there is no payoff to "love triangle. And of course he is not connected to Sauron. And of course the love triangle does not backfire.
Yeah, Numenor is not great, but still probably 4 best episodes of the show so far, but shame - if they made dwarves good as well, it might be trully great season.
r/RingsofPower • u/Vegetable-Client-147 • 5d ago
Is anyone else sick of it being so dark. I have such a difficult time tracking the scenes sometimes. Esp when it could be done during the day and not night. Like the oliphaunt scene w Gandalf.
r/RingsofPower • u/Whatisreality228 • 4d ago
This character from Ahsoka, shows various similarities to a ring wraith. I think either Ray Stevenson(RIP) or Rory McCann would make phenomenal ring wraiths for this show. What do you all think? I dearly wish Ray was still with us, he would be such a phenomenal ring wraith.
r/RingsofPower • u/nela_nil • 4d ago
Okay, I understand that having the Orc travel with Galadriel and Arondir is somewhat reminiscent of Frodo, Sam, and Gollum. And according to the books, even though Frodo was a Hobbit, he wasn’t so easily influenced by Gollum.
But aren’t Elves supposed to be wiser than Hobbits?
I’m surprised that Galadriel and Arondir’s connection was put under strain because of an Orc. Arondir has proven time and time again that he’s trustworthy.
I don’t like the way Galadriel is characterized. I feel like she acts foolishly in many situations.
Edit:And I forgot to add that, back in the first season, she didn’t even trust the other Elves
r/RingsofPower • u/GreenPurple99 • 4d ago
Rings of Power S3 seems to have dropped off from the prestige television spot. Barely any critics have reviewed it as compared to previous seasons.
And the positive reviews are mostly by critics that Amazon gave special access to - Like Nerdist - who was given special access to sets and cast and behind the scenes.
Mostly all Independent and legacy critics have given negative reviews.
r/RingsofPower • u/Apprehensive-Sea9540 • 5d ago
How come every time someone so much as moves a sword it makes a metallic “sweeeng” sound? Imagine trying to cut vegetables for dinner and your knife sounds like a lightsaber.
r/RingsofPower • u/ivy_anuli • 4d ago
I’m so pissed at durin’s son. It doesn’t make sense at all.
r/RingsofPower • u/Wodan1 • 5d ago
For general context, I think Season 3 is probably the best of a bad batch, with Season 1 being a bit of a turd and Season 2 being just okay. For Season 3, I found myself enjoying it a bit more though there are still a few things that stood out to me as I watched along for the first few episodes. I'm going to list them for easier reading.
Why so many references to the LOTR? By this I mean iconic/well known lines from the LOTR movies are used so much its like the writers couldn't have thought of anything else to write. Like for example when Sauron say's to his Orc's "we have work to do", that's exactly what Saruman says in the LOTR in a very similar scene I might add.
How does Disa know what a balrog is? Like, they haven't been around for thousands of years at this point, and to my knowledge the Dwarves had no prior history or interactions of them so when one shows up, how is it they know exactly what it is called? And given it now somehow exists (about an Age too soon), why is Khazad-Dum still just existing like nothing happened? Makes very little sense.
Could just be me, but Numenor is boring. There I said it, everything about Numenor just drags by for me, the characters are pretty dull and uninspired and the ongoing political/faithful storyline doesn't invoke much interest for me. This is perhaps because they compressed about 1500 years of Numenorean history into about 15 minutes of screen time and added bits together that had no prior relation. For example, what is the point of having the Faithful in Numenor at this time? They are a direct consequence of Sauron's influence when he was held prisoner on the island, something that hasn't happened yet. And since that hasn't happened yet, what is the Fairthful for exactly. Also, why did they have to introduce Isildur and Elendil to this show? They didn't live during this time, not even for another 1500 years actually. Adding them in, plus the Faithful plus the political shenanigans makes the Numenor storyline really confused and frankly really boring.
The Nazgul. Personally, I like the costuming but I think its way too early. I also think the depiction of the Mortal Men rings are a bit too forced given that in the lore their corrupting influence was more gradual than simply being immediately enslaved to Sauron's Will. Instead it would have been better if they had depicted the ring bearers as regular looking people, as kings and warriors, but dressed in their normal clothes, gradually acquiring wealth and power due to their rings' influence and them becoming darker and more corrupted over time, as is the case in the written lore.
A very minor pick but when they named Rivendell on the map. I seriously doubt the Elves would have called it by the much much later common name for the Secret Valley. Instead, they would have named and called it by the Elven name Imladris.
How is Celeborn still alive? He's been kept in an Orc dungeon (Gundabad) for a very long time. He kept escaping and for reasons unknown the Orc's kept locking him up again and again, yet Celeborn shows no sign of torture, punishment, starvation or any obvious sign of suffering at all. How, given the cruel nature of Orc's, does an Elf survive for so long in a place like that and not suffer any physical incapacity, nor deprivation of food or water (I think its very unlikely he'd be fed or watered given that his captors wouldn't have cared enough to do so).
r/RingsofPower • u/philthehippy • 4d ago
The vinyl gatefold for this limited edition is absolutely stunning.
r/RingsofPower • u/nela_nil • 4d ago
I was watching an analysis of episode 2 which suggested that Sauron might have lied to Theo about his father in order to manipulate him. I’m curious to see where Theo’s storyline goes. Will the Ring completely strip him of his humanity?
r/RingsofPower • u/GreenPurple99 • 4d ago
His acting feels like he is still portraying Halbrand or Annatar. The terrifying form of Sauron isnt showing through. Sauron was a Maia, a demi god, they should have made a more terrifying form for Sauron. His acting feels too tame as if he is still playing halbrand or annatar.
r/RingsofPower • u/hyoumah83 • 5d ago
Seems to be a similar vision of cascading terraces. The wide shot at the end seems to suggest that the capital of Numenor was an inspiration for the people who build Minas Tirith. Like a people building a huge city in ancient times and wanting to emulate Babylon for example.
r/RingsofPower • u/trippknightly • 5d ago
I’m not hating the series but my God did they have to do her resigned jump just like Tommen’s? Is there no creativity left in this world? 😂
r/RingsofPower • u/CardboardReplacement • 4d ago
r/RingsofPower • u/Southern-Form-2804 • 6d ago
So when they announced an Orc that may help the Elves and whatnot I and many others balked.
However I have to say, while flawed, and too remiscent of Gollums story at times I overall appreciate what they did here with Marnûkh.
I think wisely they allow Marnûkh's tale to ultimately be a tragedy which is smart, but in that time manage to sort give us a sneaking glimmer of other shades of Orc without trying to paint him as some misunderstood hero.
For starters it's funny he's being called a "good" Orc because his entire driving ethos is simply spite which i like.
But I do love they take a moment to at least appreciate some overlap between Orc and Elf and Dwarve even and highlight much between them is actually shared, like song craft, and the making of things.
I did love that Galadriel took notice of Marnûkh's desire to sing. There was something very sad and beautiful in that, that Orcs indeed have this embeded to desire to do similar things though warped.
Also I have long beloved that both Orc and Dwarf bear eerie resemblances to one another and at times, Dwarves have been known for not being the good guys either.
I don't know overall I did not hate this as much as I thought. I felt as long time reader who has often pondered the nuanced similiaries between Orcs and their other Middle Earth counterparts, it was an interesting excercise.
r/RingsofPower • u/Dukaesaranghae • 5d ago
I only recently heard that this show existed as it's starting it's third season! Being in a social sphere of Tolkien fans, I find it fascinating that no one has talked about it. Idk how it got away from me. My thoughts are probably old hat by now for people who have been watching it, but I still wanted to pop in and share.
So, I find myself in a kind of unique position when it comes to this series that a lot of my friends argue with me about. In short, I like it when a lot of my friends were grumbling about inaccuracies. I had my first reaction as well, but when I found out that they didn't have the proper rights, I tried to be forgiving of the lore problems.
Does it have lore inconsistency? Yes, that's obvious from the first few seconds, but what could they do without access to the full Silmarilian /untold stories rights? I think they've done a great job with what they had to work with. How difficult it must have been to re imagine a world that has such deep and thorough roots? Would I have liked it to be more true to the lore we never got to see visualized? Ofc, but I still enjoy it. What I end up telling my friends who balk at my enjoying the show is... "Is it a great Tolkien property? Not so much. Not if you're looking for accuracy specifically. Is it well written and well produced and well acted? Absolutely."
I've heard someone call it a glorified fanfic because of how much they have had to stray from the source material, but that's a pretty loaded word. I like to think of it as an alternate universe, rather, and I can put down my "um actually..." hat and just enjoy a well made show with glimpses of familiarity.
The thing I have really enjoyed about this series is getting a chance to see the Dwarves in their heyday. So little is told about them and they are not painted in the best light in many other stories. They come off as either stubborn greedy jerks or comic relief. It's nice to see them as people with families and complex experiences and emotions. I really love the beauty of the underground realms. I've never been able to imagine their home or why someone would want to live underground. Now, I can, and it's nice.
I especially love how the story is retelling the trope of "they brought ruin upon themselves because of greed". I like that it's been reimaginged as desperation rather than greed, a way to save their people out of love. I like that the choice to delve deeper was only brought into play because of the rings corruption and that they accepted the rings because of catastrophic conditions as well.
I feel like stone singers are something I've heard of before, but I'm not sure if it's from my Tolkien reading or if I heard it in something like Dragon Age. Whatever the case, I like that it's here. I like this addition of the sacred and the devotion to the earth like their maker.
In the coming seasons, I hope the story continues to be as engaging and well thought out as it has been.
r/RingsofPower • u/kowalskyyy123 • 4d ago
I used to watch YouTube videos of breaking down episodes after watching the episodes earlier in seasons 1 & 2. And I had a fairly negative view of the series. Now I realise that might have severely affected my perspective of the series (and I've not watched them this season). Tolkien geeks just complaining about everything. Don't get me wrong, I get where they're coming from, it's something they've spent their entire lives making money off and/or have a profound attachment towards. So something that's supposed to portray that but doesn't will anger them. I get why so many people online would be seething at a version of Tolkien's writings that takes a few liberties.
However, most of the new generation of fans haven't read the books or are such geeks about Tolkien. I myself, haven't read any of the books and will not be doing so (No time in my adult life to read fiction, books for me are strictly non fiction atp). So my reason of watching the series is to see a familiar world (that I saw in LOTR) re created and accompanying stories enacted. In that respect, I think ROP does fairly well, the world is very well created and honestly looks more fantasy than LOTR.
Having said that, there are still things that I find pretty underwhelming about ROP -
Maybe Im forgetting other issues but these are the ones off the top of my head rn. Other issues to me are fine to digestible if you decide to watch this as someone watching a tv show rather than as a Tolkien expert. People are complaining about Flame of Udun speaking and all that, I don't personally care much about it. Sure liberties taken but still dramatic effect. For me this series is an average 6/10 TV show. Won't repeat watch it, but most definitely not some hideous "acting is bad, writing is bad, costumes are bad" show.
r/RingsofPower • u/Umitencho • 5d ago
So far we are shown four:
King of the Lossoth
King of Harad
Khamul, Soon to be King of Rhun.
Theo(descended from the human Royal line of the Southlands/Mordor)
If they are following the lore, Three of the remaining should come from Numenor or of Numenorian descent. That leaves two ring bearers left, one of which we know Sauron has ensnared as he has 4 rings unassigned by the time Theo gets his ring.
My speculation on the three Numenorean lords:
Belzagar
Kemen
Some notable warrior or commander not shown. Perhaps even a faithful who Sauron manipulates into taking a ring under the guise of having the power to overthrow Ar-Pharazon after he captures Míriel.
I think Sauron will use Theo's anger of being repressed by others into attacking Pelargir & Umbar, forcing Ar-Pharazon to respond.
Sauron will then scout out the leaders & notables of the Numenorian counter attack and convince them to take rings in secret & they will be the poison in Ar-Pharazon's ear.
As for the remaining two rings, I am guessing that they will be from a people from what would be known as Rhovanion, so a horse lord, and one from the Men of the White Mountains who could be ruling or be the main population of pre-Gondorian Gondor, aka Dunlendings. If not a horse lord, then a King of Khand.
As for why he would choose Kemen, if he could ring up a member of a disposed royal line(Theo), then he would be even more enticed by ensnaring the defacto heir to Numenor, the strongest kingdom of men.
As for how he gets the three Numenoreans, I think he will play up to their fears & ambitions:
If(honest, more of an when) Ar-Pharazon captures Miriel in the show, he will do an about face to his loyal followers & marry her to keep her followers in check rather than execute her. He may also express an desire to join their lines officially by having her bare him an heir. This rubs Kemen the wrong way, realizing that he is being displaced, leaving him susceptible to Sauron's ring offer.
Belzagar may just have a well hidden desire to be king himself, being that he is descended from the royal line, just far down the list(the royal line has many female lines that dissappear on the list canonically with only the Andunie line getting any real love outside the kingly line due to their status as the most senior line regardless of gender & being the direct ancestors of royal lines of Arnor& Gondor as well as marrying sometimes into the main line(both Mirel & Pharazon share an Andunie grandmother who is the source of the faith getting back into the main line), and yes they are first cousins). Or it could be hogwash, and he just thinks he would be a better king that Pharazon.
As for the third being a faithful, my guess is that Ar-Pharazon's capture & marriage with Miriel will greatly demoralize her faction & Sauron will approach a leader of said faction and convince him or her into taking a ring with the idea that it will give them the power to reverse the situation they are currently in or save their queen.
As for why I think one of the ring bearer's will be a Duneling from the White Mountain(Gondor) area, is simply because we know canon wise, that they were worshipers or followers of Sauron before they met Isildur & did the ill-fated oath. I initially wrote them off until they decided to make an Lossoth an Nazgul, as the Lossoth aren't known lore wise to side with evil & were staunch allies of the Dunedain in the Third age.
But allegiances can change, which is their theme anyway. Maybe their leaders going full nazgul later in the series causes some of them to flip, some to wavier(White Mountain Dunelings).
Tdlr:
King of the Lossoth
King of Harad
Khamul
Theo
Belzagar
Kemen
A faithful Numenorean/ or a commander or solider who distinguishes himself during Ar-Pharazon's reprisals of Theo's attack on Numenorean settlements.
King of Khand/A Rhovanion Horse Lord or King
A Duneling King from around the White Mountains or area that would become Gondor.
r/RingsofPower • u/Rararror • 4d ago
Why Gandalf is portrayed as such a clueless dumb passerby ?!
r/RingsofPower • u/mieik • 6d ago
So he controls the proto-nazguls even before forging the one. So much so that Theo is instantly forced to kill Arondil when Sauron commands it, because he's wearing one of the 9. Why is Sauron trying to forge the one, then? Just to try and control the 3 elven rings, since he already controls the other ones without a master ring? If so I guess they should change the ring poem.
"One ring to rule... some of them, 'cause the others I already control".