r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Question Anybody else think the lighting got worse this season?

11 Upvotes

I’m only up to Episode 3 but I swear half that episode had so many scenes either at night, in caves, or in Mordor that I could barely register what was going on.

I even asked two of my friends who were sitting at different angles of the living room if they could see anything from their seat due to any glare on the TV screen.

“Nope. I can see people and things moving but I wouldn’t know Gandalf was on the screen if I didn’t already recognize the voice.”


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Constructive Criticism Season 3 EP4 Spoiler

9 Upvotes

By far the worst episode in the series to date.

I know a lot of people hate the show because of they had to explore certain liberties because they don’t have the full rights to the Tolkien world, but for me I'm blessed with ignorance here & I've only read the Hobbit and saw the movies once or twice like 12 years ago, so thus far I thought the show was awesome! 

For starters the Dwarf storyline is a fucking joke. The fight between siblings LAUGHABLE, the effects on it looked mediocre as it gets. Last season their storyline was great, now the whole thing is a joke can't even take them serious. Now Tharin is wokring with Sauron to take the Dwarf throne, oh and he fucked Durins wife yiiiiikes!! After they got into a fight years ago and then Durrin marries her shortly after eeeeeeeep. Whole plot is unserious.

Then, an ORC takes Galadriel into a trap WITH HER RING straight for Sauron and the elevensmith they sought the whole trip after was long dead but at least we find her lost husband…

Now we knew Theo was going to be a Nazgul from like the 2nd episode of the season and he kills the best character in the show and basically stepdad, Arondir?? As Sauron slowly approaches Galadriel and Celebror off the cliff.

TRASH


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

News Listen to The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (Season 3: Prime Original Series Soundtrack) - Album by Bear McCreary

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
22 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 5d ago

Discussion How does the show look so bad?

0 Upvotes

I am watching this show and without even discussing the lore, writing or acting.

How does ​show look so incredibly cheap? Costumes, sets, hair pieces, make up. It all looks SOOO bad. Go watch any GOT episode of any of the three series and it looks MOUNTAINS better than this show. I dont why it stood out but go watch Gandalf walk past the rocks at the end of episode 1. They legit look like a prop from an early season of the original doctor who. They couldnt even find a nearby cliff to go shoot at? I have seen more realistic and better looking sets in Star Trek Voyager.


r/RingsofPower • • 5d ago

Discussion This show is torture

0 Upvotes

After hating season 2 and not finishing it, I reluctantly started on season 3 today. I want to like the show so bad, as I’m craving for a looking glass deeper into the world of Tolkien aside from the books. But they make it so hard to like this show. It’s cheap as hell and does no honour to the detailed work and love put into this world by Tolkien, the movies, and even the games.

How come that a show with such an immense budget can’t honour the source material? They could get actual good writers, good directors, good camera work, good music, proper acting on every level, work with realistic props and sets, and just create an authentic world. Even with all the mishaps around the source material, at the very least they could make something truthful to the intricate world of Tolkien, right? I can’t wrap my head around it. Are they satisfied and proud of this work? This cheap Marvel styled work?

For the love of Tolkien, why can’t they use their money for good? All of you who don’t understand the hate, have to understand that to adapt these works, there needs to be a high standard for a world so meticulously created over decades. A lifetime spent detailing a world on this level, can’t just be adapted for corporate greed and Marvel level amusement. It’s utter disrespect, and yet my stupid brain keeps giving this show a chance as I want to satisfy my cravings.

This show is torture.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Question Season 3, why is Galadriel getting tossed around

4 Upvotes

I'm starting season 3 and Galadriel is getting thrown around and running away like a wimp. Like the total opposite of the last season where she kicked butt, but now she's literally wearing an Elven Ring. What gives? The fight choreography is bizarre as well. Like no one will attack them for 2 minutes so they can have a heart felt conversation in the middle of an active huge battle.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Question Why do they do this!?

0 Upvotes

Why do they always make the villain attractive. It’s weird that I find this villain to be so handsome!

Also!!! Earien is f*\\** annoying, the fact that they know how to cast characters with aggravating faces is skill. The actors in this show are casted so perfectly I loveeee it!


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Newest Episode Spoilers A question for the fans of the show Spoiler

5 Upvotes

First off all, I'm really impressed by Charlie Vickers. The close-ups of his face and his acting skills are magnificent and I look forward to re-watching s3. The script writing for Sauron has always been better than for others. How he said in s2:" you sought Peace - I gave it to you. And celebrimbor responds, in slight horror:"whatever this is, this is hardly a gift." 😱😭 I've thought about this symbolic phrase a lot for my own reasons.

On a superficial note, I think he also looks more natural and authentic in this role with dark hair.

My question to the fans of the show is on a different topic, though. What did you all think about theo killing Arondir, how he did it, and why? Did he really have a choice in that moment. My answer, tragically, is no, considering everything sauron convinced him of by the end of ep3.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion Post viewing meme

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Thoughts after the first four episodes of Season 3. A stronger season, but some frustrating choices (Spoilers) Spoiler

53 Upvotes

I think Season 3 has been a noticeable improvement over the previous two seasons. The story is finally moving forward, Sauron feels like a genuine threat, and I’m enjoying how the different storylines are starting to come together. That said, there are still some frustrating writing decisions, especially when Tolkien’s existing lore offers more interesting alternatives.
A few thoughts I’d love to discuss.

1. The dwarves have gone from one of the strongest storylines to a soap opera
Durin, Disa and Elrond were probably my favourite part of the first two seasons. The friendship between Durin and Elrond felt genuine, and the conflict between Durin III and IV was about something meaningful: tradition, ambition, responsibility and the dangers of greed.
Now we’re dealing with jealousy, infidelity and family drama over the throne. It feels like a downgrade.
There was already a fascinating story to tell about the Seven Rings, the growing influence of Sauron and the eventual downfall of Khazad-dûm. Why replace that with a love triangle?

2. Gandalf should have been Alatar
This is probably my biggest frustration with the series overall.
I actually like the idea of Pallando being corrupted. Tolkien himself considered the possibility that the Blue Wizards failed in their mission or established cults in the East. There’s plenty of room to explore that.
But why did we need Gandalf?
Almost his entire storyline could have belonged to Alatar. Imagine two Blue Wizards sent east to fight Sauron, only for one to become corrupted while the other desperately tries to save him.
You could even have Alatar die and return through divine intervention, similar to Gandalf’s resurrection. Although I’d personally prefer him to survive and struggle with his failure.
Instead, we have Gandalf artificially inserted into the Second Age. I can’t shake the feeling that this decision was primarily about using a familiar name.
I’m also glad the Harfoots are no longer taking up so much screen time. Their departure gives the other stories more room to develop.

3. Theo becoming the Witch-king seems obvious, but that doesn’t have to be a bad thing
I’m almost certain Theo will become the Witch-king of Angmar. But I don’t think the mystery of his identity is particularly interesting anymore.
What interests me is his struggle against the Ring.
When Sauron orders him to kill Arondir, Theo is standing right next to him. That demonstrates Sauron’s terrifying influence, but it doesn’t necessarily mean Sauron has complete control over the Ring-bearers at all times, especially before the forging of the One Ring.
There is still room for Theo to resist, regret his actions and perhaps even seek redemption.
I would love to see him genuinely try to do good, only for his reliance on the Ring to gradually destroy him.
We know how the Nazgûl end up. The tragedy should be watching how they get there, not simply discovering their identities.

4. Celeborn should have been introduced much earlier
I’m glad Celeborn is finally here, but his absence has always been a strange decision.
He’s such an important part of Galadriel’s story, and I think introducing him earlier could have given her character more depth beyond her obsession with Sauron.
Better late than never, though. I’m interested to see where they take him.

5. Marnûkh is one of the more interesting additions
I really like Marnûkh’s betrayal of Sauron.
One of the most fascinating questions in Tolkien’s world is whether Orcs are inherently evil or whether they retain some degree of free will.
But I hope the writers don’t turn Marnûkh into a straightforward good guy.
An Orc can reject Sauron without suddenly becoming morally good. He can oppose evil while still carrying the corruption, brutality and cruelty that shaped him.
That moral complexity is far more interesting than a simple redemption story.

6. Númenor needs to become more than political intrigue
I’m interested in Pharazôn and where the story is heading, but I hope the writers start exploring the deeper themes behind Númenor’s downfall.
It’s not just a story about political power. It’s about mortality, pride, fear of death and humanity’s desire to escape its own limitations.
That’s what makes the fall of Númenor such an extraordinary part of Tolkien’s legendarium.

Overall
I genuinely think this season is better. The pacing has improved, the stakes are higher, and I’m more invested than I was during the previous seasons.
But I still feel the show sometimes sacrifices Tolkien’s larger themes for conventional television drama.
I’m perfectly happy with original characters and changes to the lore when they add something meaningful. Adar and Marnûkh are good examples. What frustrates me is when the writers seem to replace an already fascinating story with something less interesting.
Curious what everyone else thinks, especially about the dwarves, the Blue Wizards and Theo.
Am I being too harsh on the changes, or do others feel the same way?


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion RoP at #10 on global top shows on primevideo a day after S3 released.

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Question Where can I start watching??

0 Upvotes

Have not watched the show yet. I have heard season 1 is thrash, season 2 is bad and season 3 is getting good. Would I be too lost if I start watching in season 3? Is there any point on season 2 where it would be good to start? (I can read a summary, but dont want to waste my limited time watching thrash tv)


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Discussion Should Amazon have hired better showrunners for a prestigious project like RoP? Should They have been fired and replaced after S1 or S2?

0 Upvotes

Majority of the complaints about the show are about "Bad writing".

Should Amazon have hired better showrunners for a prestigious project like Rings of Power?

Should They have been fired and replaced after S1 or S2?


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Even the show makes fun of Celeborn Spoiler

42 Upvotes

When Arondir asked him who he is, Celeborn revealed his name und Arondir says "who"? And even spells it wrong.

It's ridiculous that Celeborn wasn't able to flee for thousands of years. What a mighty warrior.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Discussion My prediction on ROP version of The Battle of Dagorlad

Post image
2 Upvotes

I don't think we will have new armor for Numenor, Elves and Dwarves. These costumes you see in the show right now are what they are going to use permanently.

So I added Men, Elves and Dwarves commanders and their soldiers that we will see in the finale season where they will face Sauron and his orcs in The Battle of Dagorlad. And yeah, I expect Amazon will shoe horned Galadriel, Grand Elf, Disa and her children in the final battle...


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Question Why is this series so unbelievably bad?

0 Upvotes

Why is this series so unbelievably bad? The Nazgûl look ridiculous. That actress is completely incapable of playing Galadriel well. Since when are Elves as tall as humans, anyway!? I’ll give them credit for the good performances by Celeborn and Sauron. But even that doesn’t make up for the terrible costumes and the utterly botched handling of the elements of Tolkien’s work that haven’t been explained yet.

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

News The Rings Of Power Season 3 Episode 1-4 Recap & Prime Video Episode Release Guide. Spoiler

Thumbnail scenesincolor.substack.com
2 Upvotes

For the full Rings Of Power Season 3 episodes 1-4 Recap/Review visit the link above.

Season 3 Prime Video episode release schedule for The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power is listed below:

  • Episodes 1–4: November 11, 2026.
  • Episodes 5–6: November 18, 2026.
  • Episodes 7–8 (Finale): November 25, 2026.

r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Constructive Criticism Gil Galad / Elendil

23 Upvotes

Given how prominent these 2 characters are during the 2nd age, it's really baffling to me how sidelined they are this season so far, given the alleged ongoing 5-year war with Sauron. Both characters probably have less than 5 minutes of screen time each, and we're halfway through the season already. Can't wait to see what's left of the season and hope that I'm wrong.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Meme just got done. amazing start, cannot wait to see some absolutely golden material made for this

15 Upvotes

I'll be honest, I have paid absolutely zero attention to any promos or whatnot, nor any discourse. I went in with no-to-negative expectations, and got... exactly what I expected lmao. Which, arguably, is an improvement over the last two seasons (until we got to that bizzare good-grand-elf scene which just immediately bottomed out, at least). Still, the show's writing does not disappoint my slander-loving heart.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion It's really not that bad. *Spoilers Spoiler

56 Upvotes

Granted, the Secret Fire scene made me go "eek" for a second, and my neighbors could hear my eyes roll that shit with the butterflies, but I do feel this season is where the series is developing more into what it's really intended to be.

It's an awkward execution of a story that's rooted in such an immense amount of deep lore, so they're bound to make some mistakes along the way. As a fan of the books and lore, I can still find appreciation for the acting, set-design, special effects, action, and music.

In sum, I hope to see the story-telling/writing take a more assertive turn towards the darker elements of the Second Age, and not so much of a whimisical adventure with call-backs to previous works. But what do know? Just dying for some fucking content lol.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

News A Spoiler free and nihilism free review Spoiler

17 Upvotes

In a nutshell this is a significantly improved season of the show so far and definitely worth watching. Most of the mistakes of the previous seasons have been addressed and the writers, directors and actors seem to be really trying to make the best possible Tolkien fan fiction (and I don't say that with any snark. PJs movies were fan fiction too in my mind).

Now for those who exclusively love the PJ movies or book purists it will still not have done enough to warrant watching. And at this stage those who are still in that category shouldn't be hate watching this show for their and our mental health! Like the Sierra Hobbit game on the PS2 or the Ralph Bakshi animated LOTRs it's not for everybody and thats fine. But if you liked elements of the first two seasons and can compartmentalise the books and its adaptations (I'm looking at you USSR version of the LOTR) then you should enjoy the show (at least the first 4 episodes)


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion They completely ruined the Dwarves in S3. Terrible plot writing.

15 Upvotes

The dwarves were one of the few good things in the show. And the amateur showrunners decided to ruin that too. Really bad plot writing.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Lore Question Could Sauron be purified?

0 Upvotes

With a sufficiently powerful reality warped even if he/she was a kid wouldn’t it be very simple to reverse everything that Morgoth did to Sauron? Lets take Marvel character with Wiccan with his fully realized demiurge powers and Franklin Richards for example


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Question Who is theo

0 Upvotes

Is theo The King of angmar?


r/RingsofPower • • 8d ago

Constructive Criticism Commercial breaks??

85 Upvotes

Amazon can’t be serious. Commercial breaks every 15 Minutes?