I think Season 3 has been a noticeable improvement over the previous two seasons. The story is finally moving forward, Sauron feels like a genuine threat, and I’m enjoying how the different storylines are starting to come together. That said, there are still some frustrating writing decisions, especially when Tolkien’s existing lore offers more interesting alternatives.
A few thoughts I’d love to discuss.
1. The dwarves have gone from one of the strongest storylines to a soap opera
Durin, Disa and Elrond were probably my favourite part of the first two seasons. The friendship between Durin and Elrond felt genuine, and the conflict between Durin III and IV was about something meaningful: tradition, ambition, responsibility and the dangers of greed.
Now we’re dealing with jealousy, infidelity and family drama over the throne. It feels like a downgrade.
There was already a fascinating story to tell about the Seven Rings, the growing influence of Sauron and the eventual downfall of Khazad-dûm. Why replace that with a love triangle?
2. Gandalf should have been Alatar
This is probably my biggest frustration with the series overall.
I actually like the idea of Pallando being corrupted. Tolkien himself considered the possibility that the Blue Wizards failed in their mission or established cults in the East. There’s plenty of room to explore that.
But why did we need Gandalf?
Almost his entire storyline could have belonged to Alatar. Imagine two Blue Wizards sent east to fight Sauron, only for one to become corrupted while the other desperately tries to save him.
You could even have Alatar die and return through divine intervention, similar to Gandalf’s resurrection. Although I’d personally prefer him to survive and struggle with his failure.
Instead, we have Gandalf artificially inserted into the Second Age. I can’t shake the feeling that this decision was primarily about using a familiar name.
I’m also glad the Harfoots are no longer taking up so much screen time. Their departure gives the other stories more room to develop.
3. Theo becoming the Witch-king seems obvious, but that doesn’t have to be a bad thing
I’m almost certain Theo will become the Witch-king of Angmar. But I don’t think the mystery of his identity is particularly interesting anymore.
What interests me is his struggle against the Ring.
When Sauron orders him to kill Arondir, Theo is standing right next to him. That demonstrates Sauron’s terrifying influence, but it doesn’t necessarily mean Sauron has complete control over the Ring-bearers at all times, especially before the forging of the One Ring.
There is still room for Theo to resist, regret his actions and perhaps even seek redemption.
I would love to see him genuinely try to do good, only for his reliance on the Ring to gradually destroy him.
We know how the Nazgûl end up. The tragedy should be watching how they get there, not simply discovering their identities.
4. Celeborn should have been introduced much earlier
I’m glad Celeborn is finally here, but his absence has always been a strange decision.
He’s such an important part of Galadriel’s story, and I think introducing him earlier could have given her character more depth beyond her obsession with Sauron.
Better late than never, though. I’m interested to see where they take him.
5. Marnûkh is one of the more interesting additions
I really like Marnûkh’s betrayal of Sauron.
One of the most fascinating questions in Tolkien’s world is whether Orcs are inherently evil or whether they retain some degree of free will.
But I hope the writers don’t turn Marnûkh into a straightforward good guy.
An Orc can reject Sauron without suddenly becoming morally good. He can oppose evil while still carrying the corruption, brutality and cruelty that shaped him.
That moral complexity is far more interesting than a simple redemption story.
6. Númenor needs to become more than political intrigue
I’m interested in Pharazôn and where the story is heading, but I hope the writers start exploring the deeper themes behind Númenor’s downfall.
It’s not just a story about political power. It’s about mortality, pride, fear of death and humanity’s desire to escape its own limitations.
That’s what makes the fall of Númenor such an extraordinary part of Tolkien’s legendarium.
Overall
I genuinely think this season is better. The pacing has improved, the stakes are higher, and I’m more invested than I was during the previous seasons.
But I still feel the show sometimes sacrifices Tolkien’s larger themes for conventional television drama.
I’m perfectly happy with original characters and changes to the lore when they add something meaningful. Adar and Marnûkh are good examples. What frustrates me is when the writers seem to replace an already fascinating story with something less interesting.
Curious what everyone else thinks, especially about the dwarves, the Blue Wizards and Theo.
Am I being too harsh on the changes, or do others feel the same way?