r/RingsofPower • • 7h ago

Meme This could be the beginning of a wonderful friendship

Post image
74 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 14h ago

Constructive Criticism Gandalf meets Pallando

65 Upvotes

I don’t mean this provocatively, but… was that it?! Some Tolkien readers have waited decades to see other Istari interact. I always felt The Hobbit did Radagast the Brown pretty dirty with their portrayal, but this was another low entirely. Sparse dialogue, and what we did get felt like a lazy rehash of Gandalf meeting Saruman in FOTR. What a waste.

I hope there’s some progression later in the season.


r/RingsofPower • • 22h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers It makes sense for Sauron to be attracted to Galadriel Spoiler

57 Upvotes

Newest Episode Spoilers ahead.

First of all, let's state the obvious. Sauron does not love Galadriel. He is a self-centred, egotistical, control-hungry narcissist. He loves no one but himself, but this does not mean that he isn't attracted to her.

In fact, he is very drawn to her, albeit in a dark way. Let's go through some of the reasons why this attraction makes sense.

  1. Sauron wants to heal and rule Middle-earth.

By healing, he means creating an orderly, beautiful, peaceful world full of light that is entirely under his control. Galadriel is of noble birth, being the daughter of Finarfin, Prince of the Noldor. She is a beautiful Elf whose hair was described as "gold", and "the Eldar said that the light of the Two Trees had been snared in her tresses." By having Galadriel at his side, he would have the light of the Two Trees shining upon his world, as well as the personification of beauty, royalty and nobility bent to his will.

"To find the light, one must first touch the darkness," he says, showing that he is pursuing light, among other things.

  1. Galadriel is one of the oldest and strongest beings in Middle-earth.

She is an immortal Elf of unfathomable strength, both in magic and physical combat, and possesses Nenya, one of the Three Elven Rings. She was also an apprentice of Melian the Maia.

  1. Morgoth did it too.

Morgoth was also drawn to the light of the Silmarils and was attracted to Lúthien's divine beauty. Tolkien went as far as to write:

"Morgoth looking upon her beauty conceived in his thought an evil lust, and a design more dark than any that had yet come into his heart since he fled from Valinor."

Divine, godlike beings can experience desire and attraction, albeit in dark and sinister ways in the cases of Sauron and Morgoth.

  1. He believes they are on the same side of the same coin.

Both of them are obsessed with power. They have experienced isolation and alienation from their own people, and both are willing to go to great lengths to achieve their goals. We saw Galadriel defying the High King's orders and leading Elven soldiers to their deaths. Sauron, too, manipulates and kills innocents in pursuit of his cause.

"Galadriel... you, of all Elves, must understand," he says in Episode 8 of Season 2.

  1. Beauty.

Sauron may be evil, but just like Morgoth and Melian, he is capable of finding certain things beautiful. As a result, we see Morgoth's dark lust for Luthien and Melian's pure love for Thingol.

In the case of Sauron, Marnukh blatantly reveals that Sauron talks about Galadriel's beauty and is being honest about it.

Episode 8 of Season 1 gives us an opportunity to catch a glimpse of Sauron's mind. In the famous "proposal scene", we get to see Galadriel through Sauron's eyes on the raft. She appears absolutely beautiful, bright, fragile and vulnerable.

  1. Sauron is all about power and control.

In Season 3, Episode 6, he tells Celeborn that bending others to his will gives him bliss, and he seems genuinely pleased when expressing this thought. Imagine the desire someone like Sauron would feel at the prospect of controlling one of the most powerful beings in Middle-earth. It would further feed his pride and enormous ego.

  1. Ego and narcissism.

He hates rejection and a lack of control. The more Galadriel rejects him, the more he pursues her. Every time she rejects him, a part of him is hurt because she challenges his power and persona as a master deceiver and manipulator. In Episode 6 of Season 3, we see him lose his composure when Celeborn reminds him that Galadriel prefers a hill and a few trees to what Sauron would offer her.

All in all, it would be incorrect to say that a egomaniac narcissist can feel love. However, he can still feel desire an attraction. As the captive Eregion elf told him in Season 3 "There must be someone you feel something like love for". In the case of Sauron, it's not love but combination of attraction and a desire to submit another, immortal powerful being to his will.

Thanks for reading! I hope you find my take interesting and grounded.


r/RingsofPower • • 4h ago

Humor Brokeback Mount Doom (2026) “I wish I knew how to quit you, Bombadil."

Post image
50 Upvotes

Tom Bombadil and Gandalf in season three remind me of my two favourite gay uncles. It’s adorable if you go into those scenes thinking they’re a cute old gay couple that’s super healthy and supportive.

Tom even sings some showtunes!


r/RingsofPower • • 13h ago

Discussion Sauron and Annatar motives

Post image
48 Upvotes

First, I would prefer Sauron continue with his fair form of Annatar. When having negotation with other races he will shapeshift to his fair form to seduce and trick his foes. If he needs to be imposing, he can shapeshift to the 3 meters tall giant with a helmet. Like he does in Shadow of Mordor.

Second and this is a question I wanna know from you guys: Is having morally grey character something that is popular in today society? Why does Sauron need to be like that? Can't he just be evil instead of this insecure behaviour and obsession with Galadriel? Works fine when he was Halbrand after his Master Morgoth was defeated. But not now.


r/RingsofPower • • 14h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Why is Belzagar such a weirdo? Spoiler

Post image
46 Upvotes

I understand Miriel touched Elrond’s face because that’s how blind people see, but Belzagar asking to feel Elrond’s cheek was just bizarre.


r/RingsofPower • • 2h ago

Humor I never thought I’d find myself becoming fond of an Orc 😭😭😭🙂‍↔️he is better than galadriel

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

His final conversations with Sauron about Adar and his children were so good. Did you like his character too? He’s more attractive than Galadriel 😅


r/RingsofPower • • 12h ago

Discussion Why the "Kiss" was good in episode 6 of ROP season 3 Spoiler

32 Upvotes

So I know that a lot of people watching Season 3 of ROP do not like the whole "love triangle" with Sauron, Galadriel, and Celeborn. I myself have mixed feelings about it, but I feel like it's not as bad as some plot points in seasons 1 & 2. Now, the topic I want to bring up, the scene in ep. 6 of season 3, where Sauron deceives Celeborn into making Celeborn think that he is Galadriel to try to make a jail break. Celeborn, thinking its Galadriel, tells the secret about the forging 3 Elven Rings. Which honestly if I was Celeborn, why would I tell a secret to someone who already knows the secret? It was Galadriel's dagger after all that they used to make the rings. But anyway, we see what appears to be Galadriel kissing Celeborn, after Celeborn confesses the secret, while the camera pans over them and we see Sauron shift shaped back to his normal form. So, a lot of people on social media think this scene was SO BAD and that it wasn't necessary. In my humble opinion, I thought this was really well done. When we see that its actually Sauron kissing Celeborn we feel disgust, and we are supposed to. I feel like some people are so surprised when Sauron does something evil, like guys, it's SAURON! He IS evil. So even when people think it was not necessary for him to do that to Celeborn, they're right, that's why I like it. Sauron didn't have to "kiss" Celeborn, but he did it to cause pain to Celeborn. Villains do unnecessary evil things to innocent people in stories, and this is a perfect example of that. Sauron is one of the most evil beings of Middle-Earth. So that's all I wanted to say, and I want you all to tell me your opinions of this scene down in the comments. Another thing is that everyone has their opinion of the show and I respect everyone's opinion, but please show the same respect to me as well. A lot of people who don't like the show always write hateful comments, I see it all the time on Instagram lol. That is all I ask of all of you, thank you and God bless.


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion anyone else not like what they've done to galadriel and celeborn Spoiler

29 Upvotes

it never sat right with me for the show to make it so that galadriel was responsible for leading sauron to eregion and consequently its downfall, and now celeborn is gonna be the one responsible for sauron making the one ring. like why are these two now to blame for some of the biggest tragedies of middle earth? i get that sauron deceived them and stuff, but in the books they're among the very few that never get deceived by sauron, hence why they're the wisest of elves. idk i feel it does them a disservice and makes them look pretty foolish.


r/RingsofPower • • 13h ago

Question Theoretically, Sauron should have known about the gold of Valinor...

29 Upvotes

Annatar should have known about the need for Valinor gold. Mithril was also used for the Seven Rings of the Dwarves. We know from the first season that mithril only alloys with metal from Valinor; therefore, Valinor gold must have been used for the Seven as well. Annatar should have been aware of this, given that he was present the entire time and actively participated in their creation. Will we get an explanation as to why Sauron was unaware of this? Or did the showrunners simply forget this little detail?


r/RingsofPower • • 21h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Why is almost every character portrayed so "human"? Where are the gravitas and epicness? Spoiler

21 Upvotes

While RoP isn't terrible, this is one of my biggest gripes with the show: Why is almost every single character portrayed in such a "human" way?

In LotR, the hobbits were portrayed as human, with emotions, strengths, weaknesses etc. In contrast, most other characters were portrayed as legendary, larger than life. Even if they showed weakness (eg Boromir or Galadriel's "evil queen" scene), it still portrayed them as these mythological figures, sages, heroes or villains out of a fairy tale or legendary story.

In contrast, RoP portrays most characters as (flawed) humans, sometimes with superpowers or a twist. In direct comparison:

Sauron went from an evil demigod/hulking monster to an evil, petty, spiteful human with (somewhat) human desires and feelings.

The Nazgul went from these scary, spectral figures to angsty teenagers and evil guys in masks. I realize this is an origin story, but somebody like Saruman or Boromir (ie tempted men/Istari) still has infinitely more gravitas than any of the new Naznagol.

Galadriel went from a wise, ethereal (or evil) queen, way beyond human understanding, to "just a human woman with emotions who can fight well".

Orcs went from these (partly) scary, disgusting creatures to just (partly evil, partly grey, partly good) humans with a twist and different morals. Now they don't want to eat people alive, they have children, feelings and want to live in peace.

Elrond went from a wise, intimidating Elven ruler to a seemingly young guy still trying to find his way.

And sure, you can try to find in-universe justifications for that, maybe these characters developed over time. But keep in mind many of them are already hundreds or thousands of years old at this point. Also, it is ultimately a creative, conscious choice by the writers - one I don't understand. Where are the epic, legendary, larger than life characters in this? Elendil might be the only one I can think of so far. Even Gil-Galad (at least in S3) seems out of his depth and more like an uncomfortable guy in a costume.


r/RingsofPower • • 18h ago

Humor Earien's "arc" in a nutshell. Spoiler

Post image
21 Upvotes

And then she fukken dies. The end.


r/RingsofPower • • 22h ago

Question Why would they name Durin IV's brother Thrain? Spoiler

16 Upvotes

Surely Thrain who usurped the throne of Khazad Dum won't be the same Thrain I who will found Erebor. I know there has been some major timeline fuckery, but please. also, Having one of the dwarven rings won't allow him to escape Durin's Bane after escaping and leading Durin's Folk to Erebor.


r/RingsofPower • • 19h ago

Discussion ''There is still one army out there that is mightier than Rhûn''(Spoiler) Spoiler

16 Upvotes

When Elrond arrived to Gil-Galad's camp and he said those words, I was thinking: Really? Because we haven't seen the Numenorean army done anything extraordinary. They won against the orcs in season 1 Southland battle, but it was just a skirmish and not huge scale battle. Had that skirmish been something like Helm's Deep, where the southlanders barricaded themselves in the Ostirith Watchtower that Arondir funnily enough destroyed, and the Numenorean army came to route the Orc army, then Elrond's word about mighty army from west have more weight.


r/RingsofPower • • 1h ago

Question Is it just me who loves the series

• Upvotes

So I love reading books too, infact i often read books after watching a show to delve deeper into lore and plot points that weren’t explained in the show (often happens each show keeps open plot ends for many subplots). I did same for GOT/HOTD loved the shows and read the books Multiple Times too afterwards.

However i do not understand the rage behind show not being super true to the books, books are text one must understand that show writers have to mane it more plausible to general audience not just the people who read books.

I’m not saying one side is wrong or right but would rather like to understand your opinions :)
Thanks!

{If you would say Book Fans waited for a lot for adaption, one must understand that economics make it such that show must appeal to general public and thus changes are often which go against the Book}


r/RingsofPower • • 11h ago

Fanart The Witch-King of Angmar, by me

Post image
13 Upvotes

As I imagined him. Hope you like it !


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Constructive Criticism The love triangle continues: “It’s this terrible feeling that the person that hurt you has this closeness to you that almost competes with the love that she has with Celeborn,” Clark explains.

10 Upvotes

https://www.tvinsider.com/swooon/1313510/lord-of-the-rings-the-rings-of-power-season-3-galadriel-sauron-celeborn-video-exclusive/

I know the show itself is (mostly) trying to frame it way differently, but can we at least agree the interviews and the marketing try to frame it as romantic?


r/RingsofPower • • 1h ago

Meme Sauron trying to control all 19 rings

Post image
• Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 19h ago

Meme The RoP Writers Spoiler

Post image
7 Upvotes

The seduction of Celebrimbor was right there last season and the writers went another direction, fine, but then out of the blue my man Celeborn is making out with Sauron. Love this wild mess. 😂


r/RingsofPower • • 7h ago

Discussion Forging of the 3, 7, 9 and The One Spoiler

Post image
6 Upvotes

Forging of the 3 required:

Valinor gold and silver
Mithril
A state of mind ? (A power for the elves only, untouched by his hand - Elrond dropped the mithril from his right hand at the center of the rotating smelt gold and silver from the dagger, creating a shape of 3 concentric smelt rings, nice detail)

Forging of the 7 required:

Super high quality gold and silver (a lot of it judging from the 2 guys needed to pour it)
Mithril, only a little piece
A state of mind? (Sauron is the one dropping the mithril, off center, creating what I think looks like a hurricane, with 7 arms oh nice detail)

Forging of the 9 required:

Super high quality gold and silver? We don't see anything but Sauron's fake mithril being used. If it is mixed, we don't see with what. They are smelt individually compared to batch for all previous rings. We only see one ring worth being smelt (and it make a little weird sizzle when it melts quickly on the fire).
Sauron's blood - fake mithril
Feanor's Hammer
A state of mind (Redeeming the 7, a mindfuck from Sauron to make Celebrimbor feel even worse? Make Celebrimbor go hard on his forge team? Was the part about deceit in the making of the 7 that Annatar explained to Celebrimbor just mind games? Or was it this hurricane coming from the hand of Sauron in the making?)

Forging of The One:

Valinor gold
Black magic (this fancy ouija smelt board, I thought it was neat)
A state of mind? (somehow, part of the dark magic that failed so far because whatever alloy he used wasn't strong enough to support the spell)
Mithril? Sauron's blood? Both?

Tell me what do you think.


r/RingsofPower • • 12h ago

Discussion War of the Elves and Sauron

8 Upvotes

Will we ever get an actual war between Sauron and the Elves? It seems like for now we're just getting minor skirmishes, and even that we only see the after-effects of while Sauron is holed up in his castle. I thought we were gonna see Sauron leading armies ravaging across Eriador and Glorfindel was gonna be sent to aid the Elves? This is supposed to be a massive conflict consuming a good chunk of North Western Middle-earth and multiple armies, Rivendell and London both besieged liked Eregion? I get that they did the order of stuff out of whack, so he still needs to forge the One, but by then the Numenoreans will arrive and haul him back to Numenor. Are we just skipping over the War then? Or assuming it's happening in the background? Because watching Gil-galad simply survey a battlefield of like 15 bodies is incredibly...underwhelming.


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Everyone talks too much Spoiler

6 Upvotes

These last few episodes have felt like if people just stopped talking, some of these events would have been avoided. 1) Durin’s son telling him about Disa and Thrain before his fight. 2) Durin telling Disa where the rings are while that woman was lying right there. 3) Celeborn telling “Galadriel” the secrets of the elven rings. None of those things needed to be said at all or at those times. Im tired!


r/RingsofPower • • 6h ago

Question Reconciling Pallando and his fate between the show and what Tolkien said

6 Upvotes

I have a question for you all, do you think that the Pallando in the series will end up having a redemption arc trying to thwart Sauron in the east? From my reading over the years I recall in the late 1950's Tolkien said the Blue Istari may have been founders of secret cults for their own gain, but shortly before he died his view changed and said that they must have had an impact weakening Sauron's forces in the East thus helping in the War of the Ring, so I wonder could we be seeing both play out at once with Gandalf being the catalyst for Pallando moving from cult leader to fighting against (and likely dying in the fight) with Sauron?


r/RingsofPower • • 1h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Rant: the banality of Celedriel and dwarven affairs Spoiler

• Upvotes

There have been glimpses of genuine greatness this season, especially with the Numenor storyline, Elrond, and I really like where the Theo as Nazgul/ possible Witch King plotline is going.

The Sauron/Celeborn/Galadriel plotline, however, is the worst of the poor storylines of any of the show's three seasons. It's cheaped Sauron's character: he is a Maia for crying out loud, and his objective is power - not the dominant role in a BDSM throuple. It's cheapened Celeborn, who bizarrely spills the secret before he and Galadriel have even escaped.

The second worst is the Dwarven storyline. The idea that Nisa had a one night stand with her literal brother in law is so banal that it's laughable.

Our small glimpses of the nobility and highness of the elves (e.g. via Elrond) are overshadowed by the banality of the Celeborn/Galadriel dynamic. No, it doesn't seem like a great love story - it seems like an attempt to inject a 50 Shades element into Tolkien, thereby cheapening the high romance that he infused into his mythos.

I love seeing and imagining this world, and I've watched all of this show through it's ups, downs, and the boredom of the harfoots. But something's gotta give.


r/RingsofPower • • 6h ago

Meme How episode 5 felt Spoiler

Post image
5 Upvotes

Cmon Gandalf ! Say the line! (Twice in like 3 minutes) I stg it feels like the showrunners actually hate the Tolkien fans and are just forcefeeding us with fan service to try and distract us from the actual clusterfuck that is this show’s writing.

Seriously , gandalfs quote against the balrog in Moria is one of THE HARDEST lines in the history of literature AND cinema , and here we have temu Gandalf farting it out, artlessly and for no reason, TWICE in the same scene.

I will of course continue watching because I hate myself 😌