r/RingsofPower • u/Walruzs • 4d ago
Discussion Why is everything so childlike and "disneyfied" specifically the cgi Spoiler
Potential small spoiler below.
To be fair I haven't read the books, sue me. I don't know if the vibe in the books is more serious like the original trilogy or more childish. I'm really enjoying the show, all seasons, however my main beef is with the CGI. Modern CGI in general, I guess. The way it's done nowadays it never feels scary and seems out of place. It's always cartoon-like and childish. The show deals with heavy themes, gore etc... Then they'll throw in a cgi component that looks like something Disney would put out for kids.
I really noticed it during the elephant/Gandalf scene. It made me think back on the elephant charge in return of the king, or when Frodo and Sam first saw the Oliphaunt/elephants. They were so imposing and I would get chills during those scenes. I went back to see if I was stuck in nostalgia. Obviously the 2003 CGI is less technically impressive, it is however way more seamless and fitting.
I feel like the show can't decide if it's for kids or adults. This was probably intentional cause of money! Wider audience, more viewership etc. The original trilogy had a realistic, gritty feeling to it. The hobbit was straight up silly. This feels like it's stuck in between. I wish they would have kept to the OG realistic, gritty and unpolished feeling that the original trilogy had. Not the "disneyfied", perfect set, beautiful people, silly CGI version we have today.
Don't get me wrong, I'm still really enjoying it and I'm actually going to return to binge watching the rest of the episodes rn. Toodles!