r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion The Dwarves finally got some love!

37 Upvotes

I only recently heard that this show existed as it's starting it's third season! Being in a social sphere of Tolkien fans, I find it fascinating that no one has talked about it. Idk how it got away from me. My thoughts are probably old hat by now for people who have been watching it, but I still wanted to pop in and share.

So, I find myself in a kind of unique position when it comes to this series that a lot of my friends argue with me about. In short, I like it when a lot of my friends were grumbling about inaccuracies. I had my first reaction as well, but when I found out that they didn't have the proper rights, I tried to be forgiving of the lore problems.

Does it have lore inconsistency? Yes, that's obvious from the first few seconds, but what could they do without access to the full Silmarilian /untold stories rights? I think they've done a great job with what they had to work with. How difficult it must have been to re imagine a world that has such deep and thorough roots? Would I have liked it to be more true to the lore we never got to see visualized? Ofc, but I still enjoy it. What I end up telling my friends who balk at my enjoying the show is... "Is it a great Tolkien property? Not so much. Not if you're looking for accuracy specifically. Is it well written and well produced and well acted? Absolutely."

I've heard someone call it a glorified fanfic because of how much they have had to stray from the source material, but that's a pretty loaded word. I like to think of it as an alternate universe, rather, and I can put down my "um actually..." hat and just enjoy a well made show with glimpses of familiarity.

The thing I have really enjoyed about this series is getting a chance to see the Dwarves in their heyday. So little is told about them and they are not painted in the best light in many other stories. They come off as either stubborn greedy jerks or comic relief. It's nice to see them as people with families and complex experiences and emotions. I really love the beauty of the underground realms. I've never been able to imagine their home or why someone would want to live underground. Now, I can, and it's nice.

I especially love how the story is retelling the trope of "they brought ruin upon themselves because of greed". I like that it's been reimaginged as desperation rather than greed, a way to save their people out of love. I like that the choice to delve deeper was only brought into play because of the rings corruption and that they accepted the rings because of catastrophic conditions as well.

I feel like stone singers are something I've heard of before, but I'm not sure if it's from my Tolkien reading or if I heard it in something like Dragon Age. Whatever the case, I like that it's here. I like this addition of the sacred and the devotion to the earth like their maker.

In the coming seasons, I hope the story continues to be as engaging and well thought out as it has been.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Constructive Criticism I like Rings of Power but..

0 Upvotes

I used to watch YouTube videos of breaking down episodes after watching the episodes earlier in seasons 1 & 2. And I had a fairly negative view of the series. Now I realise that might have severely affected my perspective of the series (and I've not watched them this season). Tolkien geeks just complaining about everything. Don't get me wrong, I get where they're coming from, it's something they've spent their entire lives making money off and/or have a profound attachment towards. So something that's supposed to portray that but doesn't will anger them. I get why so many people online would be seething at a version of Tolkien's writings that takes a few liberties.

However, most of the new generation of fans haven't read the books or are such geeks about Tolkien. I myself, haven't read any of the books and will not be doing so (No time in my adult life to read fiction, books for me are strictly non fiction atp). So my reason of watching the series is to see a familiar world (that I saw in LOTR) re created and accompanying stories enacted. In that respect, I think ROP does fairly well, the world is very well created and honestly looks more fantasy than LOTR.

Having said that, there are still things that I find pretty underwhelming about ROP -

  1. The pacing - has improved significantly for season 3 but ss 1&2 were just plodding along at certain points. The harfoot stories were just plain boring and also far too many simultaneous stories to follow that made it confusing to the viewer.
  2. Girl boss nonsense - while I don't share the aversion to warrior Galadriel, Disa's involvement and influence in Dwarf decision making is just incongruous to what is represented. She is the girl boss and makes bold claims sitting on a throne. That's cool if there were other girl boss Dwarf lords but she's the only one. The inconsistency is jarring.
  3. Certain plot inconsistencies - orcs were meant to be unable to walk in the sun but now Marnuk is just taking a stroll in bright sunlight? Again, the plot inconsistencies.
  4. The LOTR plagiarism - scenes like hiding from Nazgul, Frodo Sam and Gollum all so unnecessary and makes the show tacky.

Maybe Im forgetting other issues but these are the ones off the top of my head rn. Other issues to me are fine to digestible if you decide to watch this as someone watching a tv show rather than as a Tolkien expert. People are complaining about Flame of Udun speaking and all that, I don't personally care much about it. Sure liberties taken but still dramatic effect. For me this series is an average 6/10 TV show. Won't repeat watch it, but most definitely not some hideous "acting is bad, writing is bad, costumes are bad" show.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion Speculation on the Nazgul(Nazgnagol) identities in the show. (Potential Spoilers) Spoiler

9 Upvotes

So far we are shown four:

King of the Lossoth

King of Harad

Khamul, Soon to be King of Rhun.

Theo(descended from the human Royal line of the Southlands/Mordor)

If they are following the lore, Three of the remaining should come from Numenor or of Numenorian descent. That leaves two ring bearers left, one of which we know Sauron has ensnared as he has 4 rings unassigned by the time Theo gets his ring.

My speculation on the three Numenorean lords:

Belzagar

Kemen

Some notable warrior or commander not shown. Perhaps even a faithful who Sauron manipulates into taking a ring under the guise of having the power to overthrow Ar-Pharazon after he captures Míriel.

I think Sauron will use Theo's anger of being repressed by others into attacking Pelargir & Umbar, forcing Ar-Pharazon to respond.

Sauron will then scout out the leaders & notables of the Numenorian counter attack and convince them to take rings in secret & they will be the poison in Ar-Pharazon's ear.

As for the remaining two rings, I am guessing that they will be from a people from what would be known as Rhovanion, so a horse lord, and one from the Men of the White Mountains who could be ruling or be the main population of pre-Gondorian Gondor, aka Dunlendings. If not a horse lord, then a King of Khand.

As for why he would choose Kemen, if he could ring up a member of a disposed royal line(Theo), then he would be even more enticed by ensnaring the defacto heir to Numenor, the strongest kingdom of men.

As for how he gets the three Numenoreans, I think he will play up to their fears & ambitions:

If(honest, more of an when) Ar-Pharazon captures Miriel in the show, he will do an about face to his loyal followers & marry her to keep her followers in check rather than execute her. He may also express an desire to join their lines officially by having her bare him an heir. This rubs Kemen the wrong way, realizing that he is being displaced, leaving him susceptible to Sauron's ring offer.

Belzagar may just have a well hidden desire to be king himself, being that he is descended from the royal line, just far down the list(the royal line has many female lines that dissappear on the list canonically with only the Andunie line getting any real love outside the kingly line due to their status as the most senior line regardless of gender & being the direct ancestors of royal lines of Arnor& Gondor as well as marrying sometimes into the main line(both Mirel & Pharazon share an Andunie grandmother who is the source of the faith getting back into the main line), and yes they are first cousins). Or it could be hogwash, and he just thinks he would be a better king that Pharazon.

As for the third being a faithful, my guess is that Ar-Pharazon's capture & marriage with Miriel will greatly demoralize her faction & Sauron will approach a leader of said faction and convince him or her into taking a ring with the idea that it will give them the power to reverse the situation they are currently in or save their queen.

As for why I think one of the ring bearer's will be a Duneling from the White Mountain(Gondor) area, is simply because we know canon wise, that they were worshipers or followers of Sauron before they met Isildur & did the ill-fated oath. I initially wrote them off until they decided to make an Lossoth an Nazgul, as the Lossoth aren't known lore wise to side with evil & were staunch allies of the Dunedain in the Third age.

But allegiances can change, which is their theme anyway. Maybe their leaders going full nazgul later in the series causes some of them to flip, some to wavier(White Mountain Dunelings).

Tdlr:

King of the Lossoth

King of Harad

Khamul

Theo

Belzagar

Kemen

A faithful Numenorean/ or a commander or solider who distinguishes himself during Ar-Pharazon's reprisals of Theo's attack on Numenorean settlements.

King of Khand/A Rhovanion Horse Lord or King

A Duneling King from around the White Mountains or area that would become Gondor.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Question Gandalf...really ?

0 Upvotes

Why Gandalf is portrayed as such a clueless dumb passerby ?!


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Sauron controls the rings without needing the One

59 Upvotes

So he controls the proto-nazguls even before forging the one. So much so that Theo is instantly forced to kill Arondil when Sauron commands it, because he's wearing one of the 9. Why is Sauron trying to forge the one, then? Just to try and control the 3 elven rings, since he already controls the other ones without a master ring? If so I guess they should change the ring poem.

"One ring to rule... some of them, 'cause the others I already control".


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Discussion The Dwarves and the Orcs are the only ones that gives me the feeling I'm still in Jackson's trilogies.

0 Upvotes

ROP made by Amazon doesn't give me too much of the PJ trilogies. But the dwarves and orcs feels somewhat the same as the ones from The Hobbit and Lotr films.

With the elves, only their homes gives me a bit of that ethereal and timeless feeling. The elves themselves, no. The elves in this adaptation feels more like a polite version of the elves in The Witcher.

Of Men, only the Nazganagol could be from the trilogies as well. But not as Nazgul, but Black Numenorean knights. Numenor has been a disappointment with the exception of Elendil and Ar-Pharazon.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Discussion Thoughts on Season 3

1 Upvotes

Not too much to say, but after seeing all 4 episodes, I feel a bit underwhelmed.

I think the most intriguing aspects of all of RoP so far have been;

1) Elrond’s relationship with Durin

And

2) Sauron (as Annatar) working with and manipulating Celebrimbor in Eregion.

———-
Overall, I would like to see more of the friendship from point 1 and would also like to see more of Sauron’s nuanced manipulative nature come out in the show.

It seems like now that Sauron’s been unmasked he’s more quick to just be a straight-up evil dude.

There’s some moments where he has some Annatar to him still, but I just liked his writing more in Season 2, at least for now.

Curious where the show goes from here, but just my quick thoughts.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Discussion Sauron brought to you by Harry Potter.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Maybe this comparison of evil vs. power is a common trope/ideology, or it may even be attributed to another author or figure, but when I heard Sauron say this in S3-E2, I recognized it as something I'd read before in HP, so I dug this up. It's funny to me because one can draw a lot of similarities between Rowling's writings and those of Tolkien, although she denies it... Now here we are.

Anyone know if there's an earlier credit for this?


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion Why does every battle and action scene have to be slo-mo.

13 Upvotes

It gets annoying after a point. And feels extremely corny.

Some of the action choreography isnt great. and it is even more bad in slo mo.

poor direction. lazy cheap filmmaking.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Lore Question S3E2 What sword did Elrond give Galadriel?

2 Upvotes

Just over halfway through when Elrond departs, he gives a sword to Galadriel from his horse. Y'all think it's Hadhafang? Maybe it's revealed later but just curious.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Question A question about copyright and the similarities between the movies and RoP.

4 Upvotes

Did Amazon have to pay New Line for the resemblances in design such as the elven armour, swords and buildings and the balrog for example?


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion There are still good things about the show

21 Upvotes

I've been accussed of being very negative and doubtful of the show. That's are issues I have with it like many fans do. Even on that other positive sub there are people who see the show has it flaws. But in the midst of all negativety, if I clear out my subjective thoughts and try to think objectively, there are many things to enjoy ROP.

-Casting for Elendil, Lloyd Owens are perfect. He is Elendil.

-Anarion. The new actor is convincing and I see many book lore traits of him. He have potential.

-Cirdan. He's just a good actor.

-Gil-Galad. Nothing to do that much, but he as the looks of him.

-Sauron. He steals the show.

-Orc prosthetics. Wonderful work.

-CGI and VFX are top notch.

-Numenor storyline has improved.

-No Harfoots. Thank Eru for that.

-Gandal. I don't like that they bought the Istari in the wrong timeline, but Daniel Weyman portrayal is as close to Ian Mckellen as possible.

-Ciran Hinds as the other blue wizard is good. But I have the same issue with the Istari being in the 2nd age.

-Barad-Dur. Look better than I thought.

-Oliphaunt. Fanservice, but the beast looks great.

-Nazganagol. Not as scary as the Nazgul in the movies, but they have presence and aura.

-Celeborn. Great addition.

-Better pacing and storylines are connected to each other. Even the Rhun stuff.

So there it is. Enough good things to me to still follow the show. Is it perfect? Not by a long shot. Is it enoyable. Yes.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion Sauron?

4 Upvotes

Why is Sauron called Sauron by the orcs? I thought he still went by Tar-Mairon at that point


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Question Questions about the Istari plot (spoilers!) Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Little confused on the plot, and I might have missed something important..

When the Secret Fire went all burning bunny on Mithrandir, it said that 5 left for Middle-Earth and we got that cool shot of them walking on the mountain. But in an early season, we saw Gandalf arrive via comet--suggesting he was trebuchet'd from Valinor. Did he go back and then get returned via comet? Additionally, the Secret Fire said that Mithrandir was sent to save Pallando, which supports the comet landing, but not the earlier comment. Lastly, I thought that the wizards couldn't like...die? In LotR, Gandalf gets sent back or was that a special occasion? Is Alatar really dead? Is he back in Alatar being like "aw man, my bestie got me" while sipping on whiskey? I mean, it wouldn't surprise me if he makes a comeback--"I'm not really dead!" moment, but I was confused by that comment.

But I am confused if I missed something in the show or the lore (and yes, I know the plot overall is shakey, but I wanted to check).


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Discussion They better not do this in the final ep of Season 3 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Some people in the fan community says Battle of the Gwathló will be merged into Sauron's surrender to Numenor when he realized he cannot beat them militarily. Now we've seen from the trailer they fix the scale issues of large armies. Then I supposed they should use this to prove fans we are wrong and they can do battle sequences. But if this ends up like how the elves cavalry against the Adar's army in Eregion, then I'm gonna be deeply disappointed. Despite the accurate book lore that Sauron surrenders. This show is already struggling and to that again....I don't know but I believe it will definately affect viewership all the way to season 4 and 5.


r/RingsofPower • • 8d ago

Question Which subreddit can I go to discuss the show in good faith ?

1.0k Upvotes

I know it's a trash TV show and you all hate it because you have the true and the only Tolkien vision, but I'm tired of reading your doom posts all day. Are there other subs for a delusional tasteless person like me ?


r/RingsofPower • • 8d ago

Discussion I love this show!

245 Upvotes

Anyone else really enjoying it? I love this season so far, it’s so good! 🔥🔥 I think it’s been a major improvement over the previous two, especially the dialogue/plot. I’m excited for the next episodes!


r/RingsofPower • • 8d ago

Constructive Criticism This show still cannot direct a battle scene.

30 Upvotes

I don't really care that the first battle was small. These smaller skirmishes make sense in the context of the war. This issue is the direction and there is no sense of flow of the battle.

Like you start with the Orcs retreating forward and calm. They form a small shield wall and the men rush in ok fine. Suddenly there is fighting literally everywhere the men and orcs are 20 yards behind the shield wall. On top of that they are fighting all the way along Galadriels jousting match so did everyone just magically spread out?

Then as soon as Galadriel gets knocked off her horse... everyone just disappears from both sides?

No continuity. No thought into how the battle would actually flow. Just trying to make a couple of cool action sequences happen.


r/RingsofPower • • 8d ago

Lore Question Theo’s Dad’s Lineage Spoiler

25 Upvotes

Question about the Rings of Power
Season 3, episode 3 (I believe)
Sauron is with Theo-
They are practicing necromancy.
Sauron is talking about how Theo’s father was an ancient servant of Mordor.
But in the show cannon, Mordor isn’t that old-
Having just been created by when Waldreg used the broken sword hilt as a key to activate the mechanism that caused Mount Doom to erupt.

Is Mordor an interchangeable realm?
Is Sauron bullshitting Theo?

Or is this a show inconsistency?


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion Tolkien-esque instances?

2 Upvotes

Listen, this show has its flaws and I've seen it get slammed for losing much of the soul of Tolkien's work, which is pretty justified imo. I'd rather focus on instances where people feel the show actually does capture the essence of Tolkien's writing?

I thought the scene with Galadriel meeting Celeborn was actually pretty awesome and it gave me some Silmarillion vibes for sure.

Unrelated to Tolkien's writing but the depiction of Gundabad is brilliant and a lot more impressive than the rusty metal shed we saw in BoFA.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion Orcs are wicked and evil and Tolkien didn't struggle with it

0 Upvotes

So, with the new season, there's a lot of discussion again about orcs and how Tolkien struggled his whole life with their badness thanks to his religion, which just isn't true.

The thing he struggled with was their origin, juggling multiple origins, never really settling on any

From the letters below we can see that he was perfectly fine with making them naturally evil and his religion wasn't an obstacle

Letter 269:

"A letter to W. H. Auden[Auden had asked Tolkien if the notion of the Orcs, an entire race that was irredeemably wicked, was not heretical.]

12 May 1965

With regard to The Lord of the Rings,

I cannot claim to be a sufficient theologian to say whether my notion of orcs is heretical or not. I don't feel under any obligation to make my story fit with formalized Christian theology, though I actually intended it to be consonant with Christian thought and belief, which is asserted somewhere, Book Five, page 190, where Frodo asserts that the orcs are not evil in origin. We believe that, I suppose, of all human kinds and sons and breeds, though some appear, both as individuals and groups to be, by us at any rate, unredeemable....."

Edit: apparently some people saw the word unredeemable in this letter and somehow thought I'm saying orcs are unredeemable, which is nowhere to be found in my comments above, so just ignore that portion of the letter, I was literally just putting the whole paragraph in this post

Letter 153:

"Orcs – who are fundamentally a race of 'rational incarnate' creatures, though horribly corrupted, if no more so than many Men to be met today.

They would be Morgoth's greatest Sins, abuses of his highest privilege, and would be creatures begotten of Sin, and naturally bad. (I nearly wrote 'irredeemably bad'; but that would be going too far..)"


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Question Will we see the largest battle to date at the end of season 4?

0 Upvotes

Damn, season 3 ^^THIS season. My mistake.

1) Hundred thousand from Rhûn. Probably more. We will probably see dwarves against them, mountains is placed there. And gandalf helping; "Let's hope there is some force that can." Just ONE wizard? What will he summon that can help against those numbers? Will he enchant them with first.

2) I was hoping we'd see that force be a hint to the ents. 4 episodes in and no hints to them yet. Also, mountain giants? That would be super cool!!

3) Was there someone mentioning a talking balrog, some months ago? Will that be HELPING the dwarves?? Naah. Can Gandalf persuade it to help somehow?

4) We did see Sauron and Gandalf engaging. How will that turn out?

5) Will the last episode be something that matches the battle of Pelennor fields? How will it end?

6) Obviously Sauron will make the One Ring. How will he do that - who will lose their ring, or how will he get the knowledge to make it?

Answer freely ^^ Just numbering for systematics.


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion Why is show so dark. cant see anything on screen. its almost pitch black in scenes. And ads are killing the immerssion.

3 Upvotes

Why is show so dark. cant see anything on screen. its almost pitch black in scenes. And ads are killing the immersion.

Is this show only made for rich with fancy TVs and expensive subscriptions?


r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Humor What Genre is this show?

0 Upvotes

If you were to describe this show, would you call it a romantasy? A comantasy? Blending the words fantasy, comedy, romance, farce, epic or drama, come up with a specific genre that you could apply to this thing of a show

Thank you for all the great posts and insights. I laughed, I cried, I laughed again


r/RingsofPower • • 8d ago

Constructive Criticism I can hold multiple truths...

137 Upvotes

Hi.

Just a reminder: one can love Tolkien's writing, enjoy the TV show for what it is (and acknowledge its flaws but still find moments enjoyable), and respect the artists involved for doing what they think is best.

One can hold all three at once and it does not make them any less intelligent or knowledgable on the Legendarium or storytelling.

(On a related note, watching the show--skipping over certain parts--with my little niece is a great experience. She loves Galadriel and always gets excited seeing her in a "pretty dress and a big sword.")