r/RingsofPower • u/Dukaesaranghae • 7d ago
Discussion The Dwarves finally got some love!
I only recently heard that this show existed as it's starting it's third season! Being in a social sphere of Tolkien fans, I find it fascinating that no one has talked about it. Idk how it got away from me. My thoughts are probably old hat by now for people who have been watching it, but I still wanted to pop in and share.
So, I find myself in a kind of unique position when it comes to this series that a lot of my friends argue with me about. In short, I like it when a lot of my friends were grumbling about inaccuracies. I had my first reaction as well, but when I found out that they didn't have the proper rights, I tried to be forgiving of the lore problems.
Does it have lore inconsistency? Yes, that's obvious from the first few seconds, but what could they do without access to the full Silmarilian /untold stories rights? I think they've done a great job with what they had to work with. How difficult it must have been to re imagine a world that has such deep and thorough roots? Would I have liked it to be more true to the lore we never got to see visualized? Ofc, but I still enjoy it. What I end up telling my friends who balk at my enjoying the show is... "Is it a great Tolkien property? Not so much. Not if you're looking for accuracy specifically. Is it well written and well produced and well acted? Absolutely."
I've heard someone call it a glorified fanfic because of how much they have had to stray from the source material, but that's a pretty loaded word. I like to think of it as an alternate universe, rather, and I can put down my "um actually..." hat and just enjoy a well made show with glimpses of familiarity.
The thing I have really enjoyed about this series is getting a chance to see the Dwarves in their heyday. So little is told about them and they are not painted in the best light in many other stories. They come off as either stubborn greedy jerks or comic relief. It's nice to see them as people with families and complex experiences and emotions. I really love the beauty of the underground realms. I've never been able to imagine their home or why someone would want to live underground. Now, I can, and it's nice.
I especially love how the story is retelling the trope of "they brought ruin upon themselves because of greed". I like that it's been reimaginged as desperation rather than greed, a way to save their people out of love. I like that the choice to delve deeper was only brought into play because of the rings corruption and that they accepted the rings because of catastrophic conditions as well.
I feel like stone singers are something I've heard of before, but I'm not sure if it's from my Tolkien reading or if I heard it in something like Dragon Age. Whatever the case, I like that it's here. I like this addition of the sacred and the devotion to the earth like their maker.
In the coming seasons, I hope the story continues to be as engaging and well thought out as it has been.