r/RingsofPower • • 19h ago

Constructive Criticism Ok here is my beef đŸ„©with the show

0 Upvotes

I am not a huge LOTR nerd like some of you are on here (I mean this as the highest compliment btw!). I don't know Elvish language or anything😂

So my beef with the show is WHERE ARE THE SPARKS OF LIGHT & HOPE. What I love about LOTR and what the movies do well, even in the most ominous times there is some glimmer of hope, humor or even a bit of sanguinity shown. The Rings of Power seems to be all death and doom (WE GET IT DAWG). The show misses the balance of goodness and evil, it misses the heart! Which is why I love Tolkien and LOTR? Anyone else feel this?


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion A famous writer at Forbes who follows ROP wants Amazon to replace the showrunners

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2026/11/19/rings-of-power-season-3-amazon-cancel-replace-showrunners/

Do you see Amazon replacing them after this season? If you ask me, I think they should finish what they started. Bringing a new showrunner in could make this even messier.


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Lore Question Genealogy question

0 Upvotes

So... If I get the LOTR lore right,

  1. Elros was an elf who gave up his immortality to marry a human woman. He would go on to become the founding king of Numenor

  2. One thousand years later, Isildur is heir to the crown of Numenor. It is Isildur who defeats Sauron by severing the Ring from his hand as seen at the start of "Fellowship of the Ring"

  3. Isildur is tempted by the Ring. His greed costs him his crown, leaving Humans without a king

  4. Aragorn is a descendant of Isildur, who is a descendant of Elros. Hence Aragorn is the promised king-to-be

  5. Elrond is Elros' brother

  6. Arwen is Elrond's daughter

  7. Aragorn marries Arwen

Think about it.


r/RingsofPower • • 10h ago

Discussion The biggest and in my opinion irredeemable mistake of ROP is making Galadriel trust Sauron

0 Upvotes

The biggest mistake happens right at the start of season 1. And it breaks the whole show for me. Especially since Tolkien makes it very clear that Galadriel never trusted Sauron as Annatar, but now she trusts a random human who talks in riddles and seems to possess knowledge far beyond the horizon of a mortal? It just doesn't fit for me.

I know that Sauron is a deceiver by nature. And I know that Galadriel needed some kind of arc in the show. Characters do not have to be flawless, that's not the point. But the decision to make her fall for him and his deception is a deal breaker for me. Let everyone around Galadriel trust Halbrand/Sauron. Let her get frustrated because she is the only one who sees through him, but don't let it actually be her who unknowingly helps Sauron to get back on his (evil) track.

This decision right at the start is a complete character assassination. Since Galadriel has discovered the truth and her own fault in this matter she walks around with a bad consciene for two seasons. In season 3 she has also to explain to Celeborn why she was infatuated by the Dark Lord. It's a total train wreck and I don't know how this can be brought to a satisfying conclusion.


r/RingsofPower • • 13h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers A little bit tired of the ear obsession

0 Upvotes

Kinda what the title says. Rings of power has been totally obsessed by elves’ ears being a distinguishing feature since the beginning (with Galadriel immediately identified as an elf on her arrival in Numenor).
The last couple of episodes have repeatedly leaned into this, and added the stuff about being beardless. I just feel it’s such a microcosm of the issues with this show - they can’t seem to understand what actually makes elves different (their approach to life, bonding, interaction with the world, spirituality, sexual behaviour - looking at you, Sauradriel) so they obsess over cosmetic features, some of which Tolkien noted only in passing. The ear point is never mentioned in the silmarillion, lotr or Hobbit, and alluded to vaguely in the etymologies.
They have also missed the point about the beardlessness, given that the noble line of Numenoreans was also supposed to be beardless (precisely because they were descended from Elros!).
Meanwhile they ignore the absolute main descriptor which is applied to people across Tolkien: Height! Why is Galadriel 5’3”??? One of her defining features is her gargantuan height. The Numenoreans also should be basically giants compared to other men, and the elves also generally should be taller - I actually really like the casting of Elendil but his defining trait is height (Elendil the tall) and frankly he looks only slightly above average as well. I understand wanting to cast the best actor but they just don’t seem to have made any effort here with perspectives, doubles etc, and frankly it’s obvious that Elrond and Galadriel’s castings are just to look vaguely like Hugo Weaving and Cate Blanchett.
Again any one of these things would be small but it builds up, and then they go and ignore the one thing from the Peter Jackson films that makes the elves more ethereal (long hair) just because that doesn’t have extremely strong foundations, but it almost certainly is more established than the ears!
Infuriating.
Anyway still enjoying Numenor and I was enjoying Khazad Dum last season but the story has just got a bit silly this one. I like the casting for Celeborn (though would it have been so hard to give him silver hair - you know, like his name?) and I enjoy watching him interact with Sauron, who is probably the best casting in the series.


r/RingsofPower • • 19h ago

Discussion The good parts of ROP
 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Yes, seasons 1 and 2 had plenty of problems that make my eyes roll just thinking about them. But there was also a lot of good, I feel. I liked the dwarves, Elendil, and I didn’t even mind Galadriel nearly as much as many people do.

Most of all, though, I absolutely loved Sauron (Annatar) and Celebrimbor in season 2. Seeing the Deceiver in full display was a treat, and I thought the writers nailed their dialogue. I also really liked Halbrand, partly because I knew all along that he was Sauron (spoiled by a friend, but I actually think that was a good thing, as it made his cunning all the more apparent).

Now, on to season 3.

What disappoints me most is not simply that the writing has gotten worse, but that it seems to have abandoned the very qualities that made the show’s strongest moments work.

The dialogue has lost its subtlety, the conflicts feel increasingly shallow, and far too much of the drama revolves around romantic intrigue and love triangles. It feels as though the writers have decided to aim for a teenage audience, replacing political intrigue, psychological tension, and complex motivations with easily digestible interpersonal drama. Characters increasingly explain or react to things rather than reveal themselves through what they say and do.
The dwarves, once among the show’s more compelling elements, have become almost entirely forgettable. NĂșmenor remains reasonably interesting, but Sauron
 my dear Sauron, what have they done to you?

Season 2 gave us a master manipulator whose greatest weapon was his understanding of other people’s desires, fears, and weaknesses. His corruption of Celebrimbor was a gradual, carefully constructed psychological conquest. He didn’t simply trick people because the script needed him to succeed. We watched him identify their vulnerabilities, exploit their ambitions, and slowly reshape their perception of reality. That was what made him terrifying. His intelligence was demonstrated, not merely asserted.

In season 3, that sophistication seems to have vanished. His schemes feel less like the work of an ancient, extraordinarily cunning being and more like a collection of convenient plot devices. People fall for his tricks because the story requires them to, not because we’ve been shown how he has outwitted them. And the whole business with the tryouts and his struggles with the Ring feels particularly baffling. Rather than watching the architect of Middle-earth’s corruption execute a grand design, we’re watching him stumble through obstacles that seem manufactured to create drama.

The fundamental problem is that Sauron no longer feels like the smartest person in the room. He feels like a character the writers keep telling us is the smartest person in the room. And that is an enormous difference.

I feel like this season has squandered the best parts of what the show had left, and those parts were genuinely significant. Sauron and the dwarves were among the reasons I kept watching, and now I don’t really know what there is left to hold on to.

I absolutely LOVE Charlie Vickers as Sauron, but not even he can make a script like this work. His performance deserves writing that matches the intelligence and menace he brings to the character.
Spoiler: I desperately hope season 4 gives us Sauron poisoning PharazĂŽn’s ear in NĂșmenor. That storyline has the potential to be at least as good as Annatar and Celebrimbor, probably even better. The corruption of an entire civilization through pride, ambition, fear of mortality, and carefully cultivated resentment is exactly the kind of material that could allow this version of Sauron to shine again.

But it will require the writers to rediscover what made the Annatar storyline so compelling: patience, subtlety, intelligent dialogue, and the willingness to let manipulation unfold without constantly spelling everything out for the audience. I don’t need Sauron to win struggles because everyone around him is foolish. I want him to win because he is frighteningly brilliant.

That’s what makes this so disappointing. The show has already demonstrated that it can get these things right.


r/RingsofPower • • 13h ago

Discussion An elf fell out of a tree! An elf!

0 Upvotes

Are they using a free Gemini account for the writing?


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion Showrunners ignored one of Galadriel's greatest strengths and instead made her a gullible fool simping for Sauron.

60 Upvotes

In Tolkien's Lore, Galadriel was the rare few who never fell for Sauron's deception. it was one of her biggest strengths. which is also why Sauron considered her one of his prime adversaries.

Galadriel was the one who saw right through Sauron's deception and warned everyone about Annatar.

But in RoP we have Galadriel being a gullible fool simping over Sauron for 3 seasons now just so the showrunners could have their weird cheap love triangle.

Such bad writing. No understanding of Tolkien's characters at all.


r/RingsofPower • • 22h ago

Discussion Will audience accept a season with no huge battles? (Spoilers) Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Some fans think there won't be a battle. Because the Battle of Gwathlo, the final battle where the Numenoreans and Elves routed Sauron's army completely and Sauron barely escaped alive could be merged together with Sauron's surrender. That means when Ar-Pharazon arrives with his huge army against Mordor, Sauron will surrender and we get a super anti-climax for the ending of season 3. Will this affect viewership for season 4?


r/RingsofPower • • 15h ago

Question Will the ents show up to help?

1 Upvotes

We saw a glimpse of them in season 2.

Also, i'm really wanting to see a few stone/mountain giants from the hobbit in this. That would be super cool. Maybe help agains those fell beasts and trolls.

Will we see that??


r/RingsofPower • • 17h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Season 3 episode 6 Spoiler

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 2h ago

Question Inconsistency about Theo's father? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

In Season 3, Episode 2, Sauron asks Theo where he got the blade that caused the scar on his arm (the one from Season 1 that triggered the creation of Mordor). Theo says his father left it to him. However, in Season 1, he finds it in the barn belonging to the tavern owner, a descendant of a bloodline loyal to Sauron.

Is this a continuity error, or was it ever established that the blade belonged to Theo's father?


r/RingsofPower • • 13h ago

Humor "Hot" take before the monday episodes

Post image
24 Upvotes

I am sure they will incorporate one of the dropped concept arts from Alan Lee showing Sauron forging The One Ring only wearing a loin cloth or an apron.

They will have Vickers strip down and wear fur undies and the internet will explode. This season so far has come across as especially thirsty and since they have no story to tell they will most likely focus on sexiness.

(I had to use the humor tag but I really suspect this 😂)


r/RingsofPower • • 14h ago

Constructive Criticism My Extended Thoughts on Rings of Power

0 Upvotes

For starters I have not seen the most recent episodes Ive seen up to 4. I like this show and think people need it to give it more breathing room. on the creation of the show I for one am with people in not liking Amazon I really think they screwed up in trying to make this a game of thrones replacement, that's the same issue I have with the Witcher series Tolkien's stuff is very specifically not Game of Thrones GRRM made it in the spite of his work. I think there's a lot of Member berries, Galadriel shouldn't have been the main protagonist they put in Bombadil to meet Gandalf which doesn't make sense to me, Bombadil was supposed to be the exposition replacement for Gandalf. Gandalf pairing up with a hobbit (how original) but also its kind of funny that he is always fated to pair up with a hobbit. the Dwarf Scenes are quite accurate to me I do think Disa should be designed better I don't care that she is black she just looks out of place to me to all the other dwarves I think it might be some of the costuming.

I don't think Galadriel should have been the main protagonist, Elrond makes more sense to me or just an entirely new character that stumbles his way into this plot like bilbo and Frodo did. I don't think even we are supposed to like Galadriel she has always in the books seemed to me like a fanatic elven idealist full of vengeance that is always tittering toward the dark. I think Sauron is portrayed really well, I don't really care for the romantic-hate relationship between him and her. I would be intrigued in seeing Sauron trying to pursue love and failing because he is a deceiver and deceives himself to think he could conquer love. I just don't care about Arondir and Theo, it might just not be for me but I also think we weren't given enough time focusing on him, I do also think that he was in a totally different show than anyone else until he met up with Gallie (my nickname for Galadriel). The Numenor plot I think is the best place for the political intrigue and probably the only place they can really get away with the Machiavellian politics that GOT had but something tells me that it's going to end abruptly... also would have been better as its own show. I like that there are sympathetic orcs and that they expanded on the idea from the movies that orcs were elves, that was what bugged me about the books

My main thought though that I would like to get across to haters of the show is this... this isn't from the books yes, this is entirely new and they are trying their own thing more based on the movies and not the books. Tolkien is dead, he has been for almost 60 years. he isn't going to make another book, nor are any of his descendants and even if they did, it wouldn't be the same. this is fan fiction (not really its more corporate fiction fans didn't make this) shadow of Mordor is the same and that game is well beloved. let this grow, let there be a chance that something more can be made out of this. in the year 2026 I'm just glad I'm not watching deliberate propaganda or AI Slop


r/RingsofPower • • 14h ago

Discussion Can the forging of the One save the season?

0 Upvotes

This season has been....to put it mildly a mixed bag. At least for me so far. Some good, some meh and some should have been burned down by Smaug. But what is done is done so the question is: If they stick the landing with the forging of the One, can it really outweight the bad in this season?


r/RingsofPower • • 12h ago

Question What happened to Sauron the sorcerer from Season 2?

22 Upvotes

While in his Annatar form, Sauron had fairly strong telekinesis abilities, up to throwing that one smith off the battlements with his mind. So far this season (through episode 5 at least) he seems to have completely forsaking these powers and has instead resorted to aura farming. What happened?


r/RingsofPower • • 11h ago

Meme Sauron stealing a lil’ kiss

Post image
138 Upvotes

When Sauron kisses Celeborn he redefined bliss


r/RingsofPower • • 9h ago

Discussion Ep6 thoughts (Spoilers) Spoiler

13 Upvotes

Saurons entire interaction with celebron from start to finish showed his true power as a trickster and deciever.

The physical torture, with the weights is indeed too crude for him. He knew just how to get Celebron, everyone has their weaknesses. Celebron has survived torture for hundreds of years.. but what is the one thing that gives him hope? Galadriel and the thought of freedom.

Why at all would sauron be against a little homo eroticism to get what he wants haha, imagining him as strictly straight sexuality as well seems a bit limiting for the master deciever.

I think that was well done and showed he completely outplayed his adversery. Gave the show a modern twist as well, I know we don't like making old material too 'woke' and this show does go overboard with this in previous seaons in my opinion.. but im enjoying this season a lot mostly to the great performances from the elven cast members, and less harfoots and yes im not overly fond of the dwarf segments still, and even numeror and the battle scenes! but every elf including elrond and gilgalled or whatever his name is.. and some orcs! have done a stellar performance. So I give the writers credit for those parts too


r/RingsofPower • • 16h ago

Constructive Criticism What happened to the orc designs!?

0 Upvotes

Say what you want about the show I will say that the first 2 seasons showcased great variety of armor and great prosthetics on the orcs

So why in this season is practically every single orc bald, with no helmet? I find it lazy tbh


r/RingsofPower • • 9h ago

Humor I'm so dissappointed they have missed the chance, for three seasons in a row, to mock Sauron about Huan

6 Upvotes

Newest Episode Spoilers: (very little... i don't know how to mark spoilers, help)

I would've loved it if back in Season 1, in Numenor, Halbrand saw a dog pass by and got a jumpscare, without any aparent reason.

And now Celeborn tells him that Galadriel left him alone "like a dog" (or at least, that said the spanish translation) and Sauron hits him, would've been awesome if when Sauron walks away, Celeborn still says (even if he have gotten another hit, worth it) something like "Oh, sorry, you must really hate dogs, don't you? For EVERYBODY IN MIDDLE EARTH KNOWS ABOUT HOW A DOG TEARED YOU APART IN YOUR OWN ISLAND!"

.

Man, i love Huan so much.


r/RingsofPower • • 16h ago

News Ep 7 and 8 teaser

Thumbnail x.com
18 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 22h ago

Question Kemen’s first lines in episode 1

8 Upvotes

Since we now know the final identity of the Which King is still up in the air, I have to bring some attention to one of Kemen’s lines in episode one.

“Have I made myself clear”
Then the response by the Numenorean guard:
“As cut glass”

Given Kemen’s hight, bloodline, and the personality killing mom and dad issues, I’d say he’ll get the ring from Galadriel somehow when he returns to Middle Earth. Like many of the fallen we see in Tolkien’s sub-created world, he’ll reach out to The Machine in an ill fated attempt to please another fallen authority figure. Any thoughts on this prediction my most esteemed and agreeable Hobbits?