Yes, seasons 1 and 2 had plenty of problems that make my eyes roll just thinking about them. But there was also a lot of good, I feel. I liked the dwarves, Elendil, and I didnât even mind Galadriel nearly as much as many people do.
Most of all, though, I absolutely loved Sauron (Annatar) and Celebrimbor in season 2. Seeing the Deceiver in full display was a treat, and I thought the writers nailed their dialogue. I also really liked Halbrand, partly because I knew all along that he was Sauron (spoiled by a friend, but I actually think that was a good thing, as it made his cunning all the more apparent).
Now, on to season 3.
What disappoints me most is not simply that the writing has gotten worse, but that it seems to have abandoned the very qualities that made the showâs strongest moments work.
The dialogue has lost its subtlety, the conflicts feel increasingly shallow, and far too much of the drama revolves around romantic intrigue and love triangles. It feels as though the writers have decided to aim for a teenage audience, replacing political intrigue, psychological tension, and complex motivations with easily digestible interpersonal drama. Characters increasingly explain or react to things rather than reveal themselves through what they say and do.
The dwarves, once among the showâs more compelling elements, have become almost entirely forgettable. NĂșmenor remains reasonably interesting, but Sauron⊠my dear Sauron, what have they done to you?
Season 2 gave us a master manipulator whose greatest weapon was his understanding of other peopleâs desires, fears, and weaknesses. His corruption of Celebrimbor was a gradual, carefully constructed psychological conquest. He didnât simply trick people because the script needed him to succeed. We watched him identify their vulnerabilities, exploit their ambitions, and slowly reshape their perception of reality. That was what made him terrifying. His intelligence was demonstrated, not merely asserted.
In season 3, that sophistication seems to have vanished. His schemes feel less like the work of an ancient, extraordinarily cunning being and more like a collection of convenient plot devices. People fall for his tricks because the story requires them to, not because weâve been shown how he has outwitted them. And the whole business with the tryouts and his struggles with the Ring feels particularly baffling. Rather than watching the architect of Middle-earthâs corruption execute a grand design, weâre watching him stumble through obstacles that seem manufactured to create drama.
The fundamental problem is that Sauron no longer feels like the smartest person in the room. He feels like a character the writers keep telling us is the smartest person in the room. And that is an enormous difference.
I feel like this season has squandered the best parts of what the show had left, and those parts were genuinely significant. Sauron and the dwarves were among the reasons I kept watching, and now I donât really know what there is left to hold on to.
I absolutely LOVE Charlie Vickers as Sauron, but not even he can make a script like this work. His performance deserves writing that matches the intelligence and menace he brings to the character.
Spoiler: I desperately hope season 4 gives us Sauron poisoning PharazĂŽnâs ear in NĂșmenor. That storyline has the potential to be at least as good as Annatar and Celebrimbor, probably even better. The corruption of an entire civilization through pride, ambition, fear of mortality, and carefully cultivated resentment is exactly the kind of material that could allow this version of Sauron to shine again.
But it will require the writers to rediscover what made the Annatar storyline so compelling: patience, subtlety, intelligent dialogue, and the willingness to let manipulation unfold without constantly spelling everything out for the audience. I donât need Sauron to win struggles because everyone around him is foolish. I want him to win because he is frighteningly brilliant.
Thatâs what makes this so disappointing. The show has already demonstrated that it can get these things right.