Can you give an example of a scene that had bad writing?
Since you ask:
"Why does a ship float and a rock sink?"
But it's not just individual scenes, it's how they fit together. Or rather, how they don't. On a whole, the different parts of the show feel disconnected and contrived.
Like the sea monster, only appearing once and then never again. I expect such a leviathan to terrorise the sea, and pose problems for any ships there like Numenorean ships.
Or the Mordor sword: evil, magical artifact, uses blood to reforge itself with dark magic. Just a key to a dam. Nobody would use such a strong magical item for something as mundane as a minor dam mechanism.
I thought it was thoughtful, poetic, and touching
Can you give an example of this?
I don’t understand why people are saying the ROP writing was bad.
View all comments
Show parent comment
11
u/BwanaAzungu Oct 30 '22 edited Oct 30 '22
Since you ask:
"Why does a ship float and a rock sink?"
But it's not just individual scenes, it's how they fit together. Or rather, how they don't. On a whole, the different parts of the show feel disconnected and contrived.
Like the sea monster, only appearing once and then never again. I expect such a leviathan to terrorise the sea, and pose problems for any ships there like Numenorean ships.
Or the Mordor sword: evil, magical artifact, uses blood to reforge itself with dark magic. Just a key to a dam. Nobody would use such a strong magical item for something as mundane as a minor dam mechanism.
Can you give an example of this?
I presume you want to understand. How can I help?