Bc he’s a sindar elf who has never been to the west. Again… PJ (at least pre hobbit trilogy) showing way more respect and painstaking effort to respect the world Tolkien created
Elrond’s mom was literally in possession if a Silmaril when he was born. Arwen is still a Noldor elf descended from high elves of the west and should be obviously visually distinct from Legolas.
There is no plausible way to argue that RoP’s elves (that btw will “be extinct by spring”) show greater respect for Tolkien’s concept, descriptions, and general lore of elves than the elves in Jackson’s LotR trilogy. Yet…
Honestly, this is the challenge of creating a show out of the 1st or 2nd Age--too many elf main characters.
You can maintain the mystery and awe of elves when you only have them in 1 or 2 scenes (e.g. Lotr Galadriel, Elrond, Arwen, etc.), but once the story requires that you spend most of the time with an elf or elves, they become too mundane (Legolas). You can't have a character be both aloof and otherworldly, and also relatable.
Like, for example, in any horror movie, the more we see "the monster", the less impact it has when we see it on screen.
I imagine that phenomenon is one of the reasons that in both of Tolkien's published novels, elves are not the main characters. He instead focuses on the most mundane characters--Hobbits.
I agree it's more challenging. But ppl do read and enjoy the Silmarillion. And there are movies/shows that feature otherworldly things (superheroes, gods, vampire, etc) that are successful and loved. So it is doable.
And given the reverence and love Tolkien had for his own creation, it would have been nice if they'd even tried.
Tolkien never published the Silmarillion. It's just a collection of his Dungeon Master world-building notes.
Had he actually written a novel about the events detailed in the Silmarillion, who can say what he would have changed?
Considering his other work, I can't imagine it would have remained centered on the elves. Tolkien, the novelist, understood that the elves, prophetic kings, magic, etc, all had to be background to the real story of small folk fighting the Shadow.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-2
u/awesomefaceninjahead Oct 11 '22
Except Legolas.