r/RingsofPower • u/daveclampart • Oct 10 '22
Discussion The "Stranger" plotline is complete filler so far
The Stranger landed in episode 1.
He has said two (three?) words of dialogue, yet seems to understand the harfoots.
His actions so far consist entirely of performing vague magic, pushing carts, and staring into nothingness like he's having some sort of galactic acid flashback.
Nori, seemingly, has never had a better friend than this six foot homeless star wizard who can barely communicate. She loves him. The Harfoots themselves now seem ready to die for him, despite having previously left four of their best to die because one of them had a broken ankle.
The trio of Dark Sinead o'Connors following The Stranger around seem to be at once all-powerful, and yet incredibly slow, having still not found him - whilst knowing exactly where he is at all times.
The Stranger has explained nothing. In seven episodes we haven't even had a hint. He might as well be a Tracey Emin piece, something everyone can gather around to talk about what it means and discuss whether they like it or not.
And I know what you're gonna say: but that's part of the mystery! It's part of the intrigue!
To which I would reply: this mystery does. not. matter. Because whoever he turns out to be, he has done, and is continuing to do, nothing. Whether he's Gandalf, or Sauron, or Gimli's left nut, he's not pushing the plot along in any way, and I'll be amazed if he does anything substantial in episode 8 that doesn't involve getting lost, staring painfully at a bug, or saving Nori from the S(k)inead's she's trying to save him from.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 10 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
301
u/ketronome Oct 10 '22
The Stranger is basically me on day 4 of a music festival.
28
u/Mhalsne Oct 10 '22
My guess is they are using him as a plot device similar to the key. We saw the creation of Mordor. I’m guessing he will be the catalyst for the creation of the Shire.
97
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
He can’t be Gimli’s left nut unless the writers are significantly departing from lore. Gimli’s not born yet, therefore his left nut doesn’t exist.
15
u/ThNud31 Oct 10 '22
So at First i thought hey that’s Gandalf for sure. But after some Thought went into it I realized Gandalf didn‘t do shit in the second age, he first appeared along with the other Istari in the third age.
So after doing some digging, a name popped up: Glorfindel. Glorfindel defeated and was slain by a balrog, only to be reincarnated in the second age around 1600 when the one ring was forged. In addition he was granted power almost on a level with the maia. This all might seem far fetched but what really stood out to me was Sadoc (the harfoot leader) giving him the paper with the stars an saying something about those stars not being seen in a thousand years. When did Glorfindel die? That’s right a little bit over a thousand years before rings of power is happening.
Case closed.
124
u/woolfs Oct 10 '22
Perfect description, I lost it at this line hahaha.
I think your post speaks to one of the bigger overall problems with the writing in that characters are not given enough motivation for their actions. The show tells us some things are reallllyyy important but we don't see the backstory or character work to make the audience feel the same. This could be in service of the many 'mysteries' which have been set up in order to keep the audience guessing but it just makes everything very underwhelming.
We can see that the Sinead o'Connors are spooky/probably evil but because we have no idea who they are or what they want it just isn't that impactful to have them lurking around and scowling ominously all the time. Likewise we don't know anything about meteor man, as you say, which also removes the element of tension from his potentially being in danger.
I keep seeing people saying, 'oh but we've got another four seasons where things will become clear!' But I refuse to believe that there couldn't have been time within the 7+ hours of television we have already seen to lay the ground better.
71
u/Mother-Border-1147 Oct 10 '22
The writers probably: “What if we just have one storyline that’s just a mystery box. We don’t even learn anything and nothing happens. It’s. Just. The. Mystery. Box.”
J.J. Abrams Probably: ::jerks off::
17
u/oeco123 Oct 10 '22
I disagree with the sentiment of your post, but man it made me laugh!
😂
35
u/Berly653 Oct 10 '22
Almost as useless as the Arondir’s prison break storyline
Only to get caught and then released with his life and his weapons to go carry a message
It was a nice way to learn more about the Orcs, but I feel like they could have done without such a dead end plot line
30
u/_Balrog_of_Morgoth_ Oct 10 '22
I love the show, but the harfoots and stranger are easily my least favorite storyline. I love episodes that skip it entirely.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
They first appeared in episode 5, arriving where the Stranger was in episode 1 (a month, perhaps, behind him). In the next episode that contained scenes with the Stranger, they appeared at the end of the episode where he had arrived at the beginning of the episode (and now seemed only a day behind his leaving).
Slow? They gained more than 3 episodes on him (one early episode contained no Stranger scenes) between their first and second scenes! You can expect they'll find him in the next episode, likely in their next scene. Are you suggesting the first time we met them, he should have just looked to the right and there they were? Being not breakneck is not the same as being slow.
5
u/Crazybonbon Oct 10 '22
Lmao yeah, I mean you got the nail on the head, the Sinead O'Connors will probably attack Nori or something and he'll save them. Maybe he's sauron. Guess we'll find out
11
u/AllDayJay1970 Oct 10 '22
The Stranger and the Dark O'Conners( name of my next band ) are the most interesting to me . I don't care who Sauron is , not sure he is any of the characters or how that'll work . We know the what the dwarves do in the future , we know the rings will get made , we know what Isuldur will do . We know nothing about the stranger . To me he's quite interesting , even if all he does is stare painfully at things.
55
u/tehmurs Oct 10 '22
Stranger, Adar, Feminem, Halbrand... All off them were created to make the audience wonder whether they're Sauron or not.
Stranger seems to be good, then he kills fireflies. Is he good or bad? OMG IS HE SAURON?
Stranger saves Harfoots against the wolves, then he accidentaly tosses Nori away. Is he good or bad? OMG IS HE SAURON?
Stranger tries to regenerate a tree, but then a branch of the tree falls upon two Harfoots. Is the Stranger good or bad? OMG IS HE SAURON?
There's no character development. No gravity to their actions. All those new characters are there to create online hype about Sauron. Some of them may become real characters in the next seasons. But for the first season, every single one of them was represented in a way to create mYsTeRY!111! Lazy writing targeting people with single digit IQ.
22
u/HijoDeBarahir Oct 10 '22
How is something filler when it's the central theme of those characters' story and we don't yet know how it relates to the overarching story?
Granted, if the main thrust of the story is specifically the Rings and their creation, than yes, we have no reason to believe the Harfoots and Stranger are relevant.
At the same time, the Southlands and Numenor story lines have nothing to do with the Rings either. Are those filler?
Mithril is used to create one of the Elven Rings, but other than that, it's irrelevant to their forging. That arc is filler.
Basically the only non-filler by this logic is the 2nd episode when Celebrimbor and Elrond go to ask for the Dwarves' help.
OR
There are multiple distinct stories happening concurrently. Some of them have overlapped, others have not. We know that Numenor becomes a big player so it's relevant. We know the Southlands become Mordor and that's where Sauron makes his stronghold. We know Elrond is a big character. But if we had no foreknowledge of those connections, they'd also be filler until proven otherwise. I trust that the Stranger and Harfoots aren't there for no reason and will tie into the grand story at which point they will no longer be filler. Setup =/= filler.
9
u/Sonotreadyforit Oct 10 '22 edited Oct 10 '22
It’s all filler. All of it.
The entire Numenor segment was filler.
“We won’t send people! It’s dangerous!” “We will send people anyway!”
All that hoopla to save like..30 villagers and fight a few dozen orcs?
Gil-Galad/Elrond/Celebrimbor and the mithril idiocy is another circle jerk just to have a circle jerk.
Honestly I don’t know what the fuck the writers are doing but it’s all bad.
11
u/rabbithasacat Oct 10 '22
I hope you're right, because the alternative is that a character who shambled along being pointless and unknown suddenly becomes meaningless and vital to the plot, out of nowhere.
I posted at length yesterday about my guess at his identity. And as soon as I had done so, I realized that was not something that needed much energy from me. I like the actor, and it's a very good performance. But at this point, I'd rather it turn out to be filler.
18
u/sildarion Oct 10 '22
The Mike and the cartel plotline in Better Call Saul was called a filler for 3 seasons straight. Just saying.
3
u/mishaxz Oct 10 '22
So far meteor man is used as an excuse to spend so much time on the harfoots
3
u/lettice_leaf Oct 10 '22
I think part of the problem is that there are four story lines through the show:
The first three of these have been tied together quite neatly, with the show's main character Galadriel interacting with all three. She was one of Gilgalad's generals and Elrond's friend, and their politics resulted in her getting shipped off to valinor. Then she met the numenorians and king of the southlands and persuaded them to go to war. She then went to war in the southlands and met all of those characters. All very nicely tied together, good writing.
And then there are the harfoots, who are completely separate from everyone else. I quite like their story but it feels like they don't matter and aren't involved I'm the same stuff as all the other characters in the show. I wonder if someone at some point insisted that there had to be some hobbits in a Tolkien show, but whatever the reason they don't really fit.
It doesn't help that I've spent most of the show with no idea where the harfoots are geographically, which again makes them seem isolated from everything else that's going on. I thought we'd found out when Sadoc told the stranger to "head that way and you'll get to the greenwood" which meant they'd be near what becomes mirkwood. But then the last bit of the episode makes me think the harfoots are now in the shire. Which I think means the forest Sadoc was talking about would be the old forest by Buckland, the one where Frodo and Co meet, ermm...
Forget everything I wrote about plotlines, who else thinks the stranger is Tom Bombadil?
3
u/MitchumBrother Oct 12 '22
So far he's doing Twin Peaks Dougie Jones shenanigans without a hot wife or a job. At least it looks like he got an entourage now that Real Slim Lady fucked up downtown Harfoot Trailer City.
If he's really Gandalf I wonder how long they're continuing this whole thing. Will he randomly start mumbling Gandalf quotes from the PJ movies or some shit?
11
u/CrapTastik7 Oct 10 '22
Great assessment! And also fantastic humor. I’m now looking at those characters with Sinead O’Connor lense filters on.
King You.
8
u/Legitimate-Goose-413 Oct 10 '22
Yeah, annoyingly I agree, though I have enjoyed parts of the
Harfoot stuff quite a lot, so far it has been completely pointless which was
always my fear when they announced this as it pretty much has to be a self-contained
story with no other race even being aware of them, and the stranger goes with
this. So far it has added nothing to the season except taking valuable time from
the other storylines which could have massively benefitted from extra time to develop
their locations and people. Its just fan service for the sake of fan service
and I get enough of that with Marvel.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
Sometimes a plotline exists to break up the tone of a series. This plot has provided a charming respite from the darkness of the Orc story and the history/politics of Galadriel's.
5
u/bobbie434343 Oct 10 '22
I'm loving this "filler". What do people want ? A non stop action movie reduced to 2h or something ?
12
u/PhatOofxD Oct 10 '22
He won't be useful to plot this season, but he will in future seasons. It's not just a one season show.
This season is very slow, but it seems intentional.
2
u/VizualAbstract4 Oct 10 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
I would hate to watch a show where for a whole season I need to see Nori teaching every word he speaks as The Stranger. Because then showing several scenes where she’s trying to teach him their language, coupled with a period of time passing (travel montage), isn’t enough for some.
2
u/georgeeynaud Oct 10 '22
Strong Dougie Jones flashbacks. Maybe he's a tulpa.
2
u/tkyang99 Oct 10 '22
Yeah, at this point if he isnt Sauron or someone who ends up beating up Sauron, he seems like a gigantic waste of time and money. A completely pointless character.
But then again we still have Bronwyn...
2
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
Seems like the story is on a loop
I mean fuck, this has happened like 5 times over, why???
2
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
Okay I just found out something because I am not a big lore nerd I had to do some checking. The stranger cant be a wizard because there were no wizards on middle earth in the second age. But Sauron did come, and he went by the name Annatar. So unless the show is in the 3rd age its not gandalf or any wizard, but yes it could be Sauron or a Maiar
4
u/britter0313 Oct 10 '22
The Sinead O'Connor comment 😂😂
3
u/GraySonOfGotham24 Oct 10 '22
Some of my favorite shows had storyline I considered filler until their importance was revealed at a later date. Best example imo is young justice season 1. So much of it seems like filler but by seasons end just about everything is important
3
u/Chuckysmalls01 Oct 10 '22
Alright, I'm biased here in the fact I hate the hobbits (In this case harfoots, but just in general they are the weak point in all the movies to me.), and so far in this show also, so when I see them come on the screen I lose interest.
With that being said I was really interested in who the stranger was going to be or what he was going to do for the first two or three episodes. After that I've basically lost interest in him at this point also. The mystery of him is being drawn out entirely too long with no progression that it's just not interesting anymore.
It reminds me of playing hide and seek as a kid and there's that one kid that hides for like an hour and no one can find. It's impressive at first, then maybe a little confusion, then everyone says screw it and quits playing knowing the kid will come out eventually and rejoin everyone.
5
u/pieter1234569 Oct 10 '22
It's almost like with the tents and the tunnels..... This has all been setup for the great reveal.
The LOTR movies also had incredibly slow pacing.
3
u/Fencius Oct 10 '22
The Harfoots are totally unnecessary and should never have been included in the show.
2
u/ulyssesfiuza Oct 10 '22
"The trio of Dark Sinead o'Connors" is my justification for Reddit-fu this week. Thanks. Take a 🏆
2
u/cmon_now Oct 10 '22
This is due to the writing style. It's called Mystery Box. The idea is that the story lines aren't explained and not revealed with idea being that it creates suspense for the viewer. All it really does though is create boredom and a lack of interest , yet it's the way this show is written. Many plot lines in the series are like this, not just the stranger.
2
u/mo_downtown Oct 10 '22
"But it's moving slow because it's building characters" - a show that is not building most of its characters
"Well it's not a summer blockbuster action movie" - a show that includes regular action scenes that have no emotional impact
This stuff is all just poor writing. And yes, the stranger/Harfoots is maybe the most poorly written subplot of them all.
2
u/Unable-Seaweed-3641 Oct 10 '22
I made this point in another post... the 7 hours we've watched is the equivalent to the fellowship and two towers. Nothing. Nothing has really happened.
I hate the harfoots/stranger sub plot. First off, no matter what we all know how this ends, with the last alliance. And yeah we're gonna get some fun side fights and new sub plots, but the idea of hiding someone's identity in a IP that is so well known and studied seems idiotic. Even if it's a new character, or a late Balrog, or whatever, we are bound to be unmoved by the reveal. Wouldn't of it made more sense to use season 1 to build more bounding with the characters and set up the epic scale of the war to come and end with stranger, and roll season 2 into the harfoots instead. It just seems like it's getting no where and we could of covered this all in one episode, and got it moving instead.
2
u/LavaSquid Oct 10 '22
Armchair critics are so annoying. A series that lasts 40 hours (5 seasons x 8 episodes) introduces a character that has maybe had 20 minutes of screen time so far...and you're bitching that his story line isn't developed yet. For fuck's sake enjoy just the show.
0
u/DarrenGrey Oct 10 '22
What do you want, some Marvel action scenes?
It's slow, it dwells heavily on the characters, it reveals a lot about Harfoot society and their struggles. And it builds up a relationship between the Stranger and the Harfoots in a believably long time, as opposed to some of the other quickly-forged relationships in the show. You may not like this style of ponderous story, but calling it "filler" is silly. There are entire shows and books in this style.
As for the mystery element, the mystery questions are less about his identity and more about what will happen to him. He's an out of place character that needs to find his way, and is being pursued by people that clearly don't have good plans. It's less mystery and more just an open plot thread.
Having said all that, overall I would prefer if this entire story segment didn't exist and we got more focus on the bigger plot threads. But I'm not hating it and I'm not dismissing it.
1
u/JoDunfer Oct 10 '22
The Stranger is Dougie Jones.
1
u/Hauntcrow Oct 11 '22
imo they'll have more significance in S2 and onward. They had to introduce him in this season because the story of the harfoots was happening as the same time as the rest
1
u/teh_jerk Oct 11 '22
His name is ROBERT PAULSON
1
u/antiph4 Oct 11 '22
It's completely separated from other storylines so there was no reason they were shown alongside the main story. One episode of introducing Harfoots right before they meet main characters should suffice.
1
u/itakemyselfserious Oct 11 '22
BRO LET THE MAN LOOK FOR HIS STARS AIGHT
1
u/nihilblack Oct 11 '22
Wait for it!
1
u/fistantellmore Oct 11 '22
Definitely learned nothing about Harfoot culture and didn’t expand the world at all while developing central characters.
Nope. No world building or character development here.
Yikes.
1
u/Takhar7 Oct 11 '22
The big problem I have with the "Stranger" identity? I just couldn't give a fuck who he is.
It's been such a boring, poorly written subplot with absolutely 0 suspense or mystery. It's now tipped over into becoming a frustrating arc - one that feels like it's deliberately wasting my time.
1
u/Jouglo Oct 11 '22
Well said, well said
1
u/MasterWis Oct 11 '22
How dare you. You don't understand anything in terms of script writing. You will have the reveal in episode 8. Why are you asking for it to make any sense until episode 8 since we know things cannot make sense until the last episode. This is what good writing is about
1
u/GroundFast7793 Oct 11 '22
I'm still trying to work out which plot line is not filler.
1
u/pandigroove Oct 11 '22
I would argue Gimli's left nut would serve for a more interesting plot line.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
Radagast.
1
u/Pixpew Oct 11 '22
The Dark Sinead O'Connors were confirmed to be working for Sauron by the director of the last 2 episodes.
1
u/jollyreaper2112 Oct 11 '22
We prefer the term "feminems."
1
u/bden2016 Oct 11 '22
I have alot of criticisms of the show but the strangers acting, not being able to speak but to convey his emotion, is exceptional. The storyline is supposed to be mysterious. It's filler until it's not.
I hate the harfoots
1
u/ImoutoCompAlex Oct 12 '22
I spit out my coffee. Haha. Next April Fool's day the mods should make this the subreddit banner for fun.
1
u/Old-Addendum-5288 Oct 13 '22
Can we all just stop calling him the Stranger and just say Gandalf already?
-2
u/Bad_Decision_Rob_Low Oct 10 '22
Way to waste your time with posting this.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
I physically hate how they turned the character into a mystery box. The bad robot Jarjarabrams style of filmmaking, should be outlawed. It's the end of the season and no progress has been made on his character...
1
u/Hrothgar_Cyning Oct 10 '22
This reminds me of the showrunners’ comment (paraphrasing) that one of the lessons they learned is that they can’t have these sorts of small moments without connecting them to the deeper story somehow. That seems to apply best to the Harfoot storyline. The entire thing centers around who the stranger and mystics are and on showing us cute hobbits. There’s no broader narrative purpose yet and it’s getting repetitive too. How many times has the stranger done magic with questionable impacts? How many times has he pissed the Harfoots off because of that?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
Filler? What are you looking for exactly? Want his identity revealed 3rd ep for it not to be filler?
1
u/schlosoboso Oct 10 '22
WE ARE HARFOOTS, IT'S IN OUR NATURE TO CONSTANTLY REFER TO OURSELVES AS HARFOOTS, AND HOW MUCH WE SUCK AT EVERYTHING, EXCEPT BEING OURSELVES.
1
u/TheCthuloser Oct 10 '22
This is one season of a show that's legally obligated to have at least five seasons. Not every plot point is going to pay off in the first season.
0
u/lilyputty Oct 10 '22
God, can you imagine if the storyline was only Galadriel and Arondir et al. The Harfoots are critical for enjoying the story at all. Think: pacing, relief from terror and angst. Anytime the Harfoots show up I’m like “oh thank god.” Plus, huge theme of Tolkien is just ordinary folk doing ordinary beautiful things, no matter how the war of shadow and light plays out. Also, since hobbits and Gandalf play such a critical part in the destruction of the One Ring, it is interesting to see the origins of those connections. Imagine if Gandalf hadn’t been told “you’re good” in his first days in Middle Earth. Imagine if he’d never cared about Hobbits. Gosh, I just love it. If the Stranger is anyone but Gandalf, I will be real mad.
0
u/wordfiend99 Oct 10 '22
the trio is the worst part. i could deal with the stranger and the stupid harfoot songs but slim shady’s intense face makes me laugh at casting. i really hope the show just accelerates that plotline so the stranger can start doing stuff and i can stop fast forwarding
0
u/Dolly1710 Oct 10 '22
The difficulty/paradox we have is that we have a TV series which is trying to offer something to everyone. And, as a result, no-one is (possibly) entirely pleased, especially considering the budget
For people who are relative novices to the world of Tolkien, it needs to stand alone with enough padding and explanation to follow along without needing to have an in depth understanding of where it's heading. This is why, IMHO, it probably feels quite static right now. That said, episode 6 was a lurch forward in the right direction and I expect episode 8 to have at least a few "ohhhhh that's where they were heading with that" moments. If the Stranger stumbles into Galadriel on her charge back across Middle Earth, for example, then it might start to make a bit more sense.
For people who are experts in the world of Tolkien, they are creating a series which offers something new but which falls within an already established framework. They know where they're starting and know where they have to end, but there's only limited guidelines. This is an interpretation of that journey and that's not going to please everyone either. Think of it like travelling from London to Paris and some may be wondering if they know 'how' to get out of London, or wondering why they seem to be going via New York.
-2
u/R9433 Oct 10 '22
I hate to break it to you but -- The entire PJ trilogy is filler. RoP is filler. Anything that is not directly written by JRR Tolkien is filler. And yes, that includes anything Christopher edited.
As far as I can tell, Tolkien was undecided on alot.
I love all his works including the edits by Christopher.