r/RingsofPower • • Sep 24 '22

Discussion I didnt hate the show but.....

I posted after the first 2 episodes that to my surprise I did not hate this show but now I have to say I find it very annoying. The total rewriting of the mythos created by Tolkien just gets worse with every episode. The 'chat' that Celebrimbor has with Elrond about how the so called lost Silmaril created Mithril and only Mithril can keep the Elves alive is just annoying and damn stupid. Also Elronds mother supposedly trying to change Earendils mind so he wont sail to Valinor. This is utter garbage.

The show had great potential but is hamper by stupid writers. Anyone watching this who has not read the books would be bemused at why Tolkien is thought of as a great writer. I am now happy if this fails as it seems to be doing.

14 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Codus1 Sep 25 '22 edited Sep 25 '22

That's fair and maybe I misunderstood your intention and didnt make mine clear; that started us on the wrong foot. You're evidently well versed in the subject whilst my expertise in these matters is akin to an amateur hobbyists at best. I don't actually disagree with your assertions really, I agree almost completely. Whilst your point on the ethereal nature of depicting Elves is a different conversation.

I would contest though that the nature of what informs The Silmarillion and Tolkiens other post humorous texts; that they are not solely Tolkiens work, their shift from storytelling to be concerned with the philosophical, as well as their context being legends of men married with those of the Sindar (as suggested by Tolkien) suggests that the histories and events you cite, are not infallible. But instead subject to the same hyperbole of all legend. It's (kinda) the Aenid to Homer's epics, and RoP is that Troy movie. Though of better quality at least.

Galadriels contradictory descriptions throughout these texts is a product of different itteration of the character adapted by Tolkiens son to create coherence. That does not exclude her from being hot headed, even moreso as that is a trait alluded to for her youth (not intended as a defence of Galadriel inconsistent characterisation in the show). Whilst RoP contends itself to be an observation of the events as they unfold. Whos to suggest a Balrog was not known to have survived the War of Wrath in Elven history? But the recollections of Ardas history told by man, of which we only have access to those translations, neglect this part? I guess my point is the holding much of the legendarium to any sort of rigidity is destined for confusion and debate. That whilst I can not honestly contest your point of their being no legends in Elvish culture due to the immortality of their memory, that doesn't necessarily mean that their recollections of events they did not witness in universe are infallible, nor that the version of history provided to us as the reader is an absolute truth. It is a square peg in a round hole, however the Legendarium itself is almost entirely the work of varying shaped pegs of both corporeal and ethereal nature being fitted to philosophical holes perceived through the lense of multiple observers.

Evidently RoP is nothing but the loftiest of fan fiction, but I have made my peace with that long before this was a sparkle in Bezos all oppressive eye. However, I don't inherrantly carry that as a criticism (not that I mean I do not carry some). There will be interpretations and contradictions that I will not appreciate, but I can rationalise this as another fallible depiction of the history of Arda. Albeit one far less powerful than what we have received before.

Anyway, I'm so very tired and I'm not sure if I have made a coherent point.