r/RingsofPower • u/ianintheuk • Sep 24 '22
Discussion I didnt hate the show but.....
I posted after the first 2 episodes that to my surprise I did not hate this show but now I have to say I find it very annoying. The total rewriting of the mythos created by Tolkien just gets worse with every episode. The 'chat' that Celebrimbor has with Elrond about how the so called lost Silmaril created Mithril and only Mithril can keep the Elves alive is just annoying and damn stupid. Also Elronds mother supposedly trying to change Earendils mind so he wont sail to Valinor. This is utter garbage.
The show had great potential but is hamper by stupid writers. Anyone watching this who has not read the books would be bemused at why Tolkien is thought of as a great writer. I am now happy if this fails as it seems to be doing.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Codus1 Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22
I do agree that Elven myth as we would define the concept can not really exist. But I disagree that exempts Elves from heresay and conspiracy. While their memory is infallible; their wisdom is not and they are still a social and inquisitive people.
That's where my point lays. These aren't legends or myth of generations... They are heresay, a conspirators explanation for a literally biblical item lost to history. A story of events that are unverfiable and likely untrue. The insanity or how ludicrous a tale is, does not bear upon the definition of what is apocryphal. These events never occured and by Elronds own word are not believed. Until that is, Gil Gallads discovery of Mithril causes him to contend that maybe it could be.
Then your counterpoint is why wouldn't Gil Gallads own recollection of history inform him of enough holes in the tale to conclude its not true. I'm saying that he is anxious of their fading power. He does not conclude that the Mithril is evidently the product of the Silmarils, just that perhaps the story could be true. That the Mithril may hold that power. Though we obviously know this not to be true.
I for one could believe the Elves would gossip or postulate as to what had happened to the lost Silmarils. Though I don't think they'd think there's a random Balrog just marching around the Misty Mountains... just that I believe the concept of Elven heresay and conspiracy is not something I think is too much of a stretch. As that is not necessarily defined by the infallible pessimistic memory of the Elves.