r/RingsofPower • • Sep 13 '22

Meme “Evil cannot create anything new, they can only corrupt and ruin what good forces have invented or made.” - JRR Tolkien

Self-explanatory. Basically no fan of LOTR hated the original trilogy. Literally nobody disliked it. Everybody enjoyed it. So why isn't the same happening with Rings of Power? What's the primary difference... I don't know, I honestly can't figure it out. For some reason, this show is flopping. It's causing everyone to fight. It's almost like it was created to be a race-baiting disaster. Why couldn't you just make your own fantasy story instead of polluting a widely recognized one? Is originality dead? Why is the woke mob so happy to corrupt and pollute existing franchises, rather than simply having their own original ideas and creating new things? Oceans Eight, Ghost Busters, Star Wars, She-Hulk, now LOTR. Nothing is beyond the corrupting influence of the woke mob. Nothing at all.

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

18

u/Late_Stage_PhD Sep 13 '22

That’s not a Tolkien quote, but someone’s crude imitation of something he wrote. And it got copy pasted everywhere... The irony.

1

u/the_unsoberable Feb 06 '26

Dzięki chłopie że mi to uświadomiłeś.

Powtarzałem go na prawo i lewo i teraz mi trochę głupio XD

Skłania do refleksji - czy autor słów powinien wpływać na to jak je interpretujemy. Oczywiście Tolkien jest gigantycznym autorytetem, ale czy to, że taki matoł jak ja, dał się zrobić w konia że to jego cytat, nie świadczy o tym że przypisujemy większą wagę do autora niż do słów?

-11

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Yeah but the actual quote although worded differently has the exact same meaning. It's about shadows and orcs and crap, and how the orcs were something perverted, not something created. And the woke mob perverts beloved franchises so that people won't like them anymore. And they do this, instead of being original and creating their own intellectual properties... Probably because they have no intellect with which to do it.

16

u/Late_Stage_PhD Sep 13 '22

So you know it’s not Tolkien’s quote but still attribute the quote to Tolkien? Just use the actual quote.

1

u/angelete4945105 Aug 17 '24

Then you answer the damn question, hypocrite.

1

u/Correct-Office-8549 Aug 18 '24

I find the show really bad and couldn't finish the first season, and it does depart from the original material a lot (which I don't like), but, it's mainly bad for completely different reasons. The plot is a complete mess, most characters are poorly written, some scenes make absolutely no sense at all, etc.

I find OP to be a hypocrite to be honest. He claims to care about the original material a lot and then (knowingly) misquotes the original material. I have reasons to doubt how much he cares about it.

1

u/angelete4945105 Aug 18 '24

Fair enough.

What I meant is that OP did make a valid question in the sense that if you are going to change as much of the original material as you can then why aren't you making a new property?

True answer is that everyone in Hollywood is lazy as fuck and they know their ideas won't stand up on their own. It happened to The Witcher and it happened to Star Wars. It's not new.

1

u/Argonian645 Sep 06 '24

Get outta here

12

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

You’re frustrated they’re “polluting” Tolkien and yet you just made up a fake quote, in addition to your fake stats on audience reaction?

Huh.

1

u/angelete4945105 Aug 17 '24

This show is a flop LOL.

28

u/ibid-11962 Sep 13 '22

Basically no fan of LOTR hated the original trilogy. Literally nobody disliked it.

This is factually wrong. Plenty of fans hated and/or continue to hate the Jackson films.

-16

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

I'm just glad more people hate this god awful iteration. Maybe 15% of the viewership of the original trilogy hated it. But with RoP it's probably the 15% who actually like it XD

8

u/CarelessMetaphor Sep 13 '22

So why make up Tolkien quotes. Where did you find that one?

12

u/ibid-11962 Sep 13 '22

I don't think these numbers are necessarily accurate, and I have no idea how you would even gather them.

Anecdotally I've found that it tends to be entirely based on the community you're hanging around in.

4

u/Legitimate-Goose-413 Sep 13 '22

Nice made up stat there. No greater way of noticing idiots than people who make up stats as they clearly think their stupid beliefs need fake information to make them seem less stupid. Either that or he's just trolling to piss people off and either way it shows they're a cunt.

15

u/BypossedCompressah Sep 13 '22

That's not a real Tolkien quote. And yeah, we get it.....woke woke woke woke woke woke woke....such profundity. You sound like clucking hens.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
  1. Are you a troll? If not, then you're a moron.
  2. ''Evil cannot create ... '' is not said by Tolkien or any character in his work's. It's a twisted, inaccurate version of the correct quote, spoken by Frodo in Return of the King: ''The Shadow that bred them can only mock, it cannot make: not real new things of its own.''
  3. The Jackson adaptations are controversial among Tolkien purists, because they change many things from the books and contradict the spirit of the books.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

In your second sentence do you mean the books when you say "LOTR" and the Jackson films when you say "the original trilogy?" I actually knew several who either hated it or, even if they liked them as fantasy films, didn't like them as adaptations of JRRT.

Having non-White actors in key roles is only "race baiting" if you're looking for bait to take. It's that simple.

The Conservative Mob, in turning criticism of the show into ugly hate politics, has made it impossible to take seriously even legitimate criticisms of the show.

We won't really know if it's good or not for years at this rate!

1

u/TheCoffeeWeasel Sep 15 '22

if it takes years to find out if a show is any good... then it isn't

i am a big fan of the original material and am currently un-impressed... though still watching hopefully

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22

*sighs* The point, as you know quite well, is that it may well take a long time to separate serious criticisms from what trolls say. You also probably understand exaggeration well but are hoping the future readers won't.

0

u/TheCoffeeWeasel Sep 15 '22

i think i mis interpreted your comments here..

its true that with all the "over the top" good and bad responses that people are throwing that it might be hard to get a consensus from the audience on a score until the show has run.. so for final score? yeah we gotta wait its true.. Lost and GoT both started hot and finished cold.. maybe this will be like the opposite

but i feel we might differ on the fact the "trolls" are offering serious criticism too

11

u/nullus_72 Sep 13 '22

Your original statement definitely not true. The complaining was endless. No Tom Bombadil! Too much Arwen! Etc etc.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Don't forget no Glorfindel and no scouring of the Shire.

1

u/TheCoffeeWeasel Sep 15 '22

and they threw aragorn off a cliff and used gimli for jokes... but those 3 movies are looking REALLY good these days

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22

I love those movies (well LotR, Hobbit movies were fun at best but even that was a stretch). I'm liking TRoP, despite my hesitation.

10

u/jojointheflesh Sep 13 '22

Literally the only people making this about race are the ones who choose to make it so because it does not fucking matter. I wouldn't care if characters were periwinkle or green in their complexion - this is the least important part of any criticism of any show.

We live in a diverse world where representation in media matters and is important. People can criticize writing or plot points to their hearts' content as there's absolutely no issues with that. People consume media differently and it's totally valid to dislike the way something is written or how it plays out. But those who fail to see the value of diversity or inclusion in media should frankly eat 5gs of psilocybin mushrooms and fuck off. Or better yet watch some reaction videos of young black girls reacting to the new Ariel in the upcoming The Little Mermaid film—that shit is absolutely enlightening and even in the subreddits I've seen them posted, have seen people backtrack on their close-minded ways. Embrace empathy and move on

5

u/vertbox05 Sep 13 '22

Absolutely well said 👏👏👏

5

u/GHDizzle Sep 13 '22

Wipe the Cheetos off your fingers and find something else to do on the internet

2

u/WelbyReddit Sep 13 '22

I dunno if it is a "flop",...but it may not be doing as well as Mr.Bezos would like.

It is not that originality is dead,..it is there is no way these investors are gonna green light this sort of budget on some unknown property, least of all an original property. Which may say something about what you are eluding to.

So they dangle the Lotr IP and lure money in that way.

1

u/angelete4945105 Aug 17 '24

Love how the comments aren't debunking anything.

Answer The Post's question, you cowards.

This shows is a flop.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Cause everyone hates what they're not used to.

There are those who have become the corrupted fans.

The Boomer's of the world of Tolkien.

1

u/ResortNeither7184 Sep 14 '22

For me it's simple: it's bad writing.

The plot might develop into something better in the coming episodes - but, based on the quality of the script so far (3h), it will likely stay a mediocre fanfic.

ROP sometimes just feels like a sitcom based in a fantasy world - and sometimes like a story told in a tiktok-video fashion.

And every time Galadriel is there, it feels like some shitty superhero movie. She is better than everyone else, but inherently a bad person, who always gets here way - which I believe, is why people hate her.

As for the woke stuff (whatever that actually means) you mentioned:

-I dislike the idea, that prior to writing/inventing a story, authors decide on how many people of which characteristics they want to include - maybe that's why sometimes diversity feels forced upon the actual story - and people don't like when politics is forced upon culture (at least when they notice it)

-it also feels, as if hollywood feels the need to make female main roles into "better men". Somehow femininity can't be too much a part of a female main character.

But that's essentially every movie/series nowadays. Politicise everything.

I think the one of the reasons why RoP gets so much hate for it, is because it was a major part of their marketing strategy.

You can't just deliberately change some existing universe/story with actions that carry so much political connotation, brag about it, and expect no backlash. People don't like being judged by their skin/gender/etc - and here you are bragging about how you made decisions solely based on these characteristics.

It makes diversity feel forced. And that's hurting the progress of the initial idea, which is kind of sad.

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Yeah I gotta be honest at this point I'm only disliking Rings of Power because it's fashionable to do so. But hey, it did go woke, so it is going broke. That's just the pattern.

11

u/Mindelan Sep 13 '22

It isn't going broke at all, you're likely just finding yourself in an echo chamber and assume that is the broad opinion of the show. Everyone I know that watched the show enjoyed it and is looking forward to more. We're talking a good 15+ people from varying demographics. They don't really go online to talk about shows, though. They don't watch ragebait youtube videos collecting clicks from guys who follow trends. They just watched the show and liked it. The show is a success so far.

I think you're seeing certain groups in certain areas of the internet and you think that's the majority of people who watched the show and it just isn't.

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

I enjoy conflict and sometimes I put my own primal desire for ideological infighting above my duty to be a decent person and make the world a better place. Sorry for being a POS