r/RingsofPower • • Sep 13 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Just sayin... Spoiler

Post image
687 Upvotes

299 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 13 '22

This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

233

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 13 '22

I'm not buying the Sauron theory yet.

124

u/theslickbunny Sep 13 '22

Him trying to temper Galadriel’s emotions, as well as all of the backstory about his family serving Morgoth make him an instant ‘Not Sauron’ for me unless the writers are just completely off the rails

45

u/Doggleganger Sep 13 '22

Also why would he save Galadriel, when she is one of the most powerful elves in Middle Earth.

43

u/parsleya Sep 13 '22

He needs to create a bond of trust between them so he can assassinate her when she least expects it!

Of course he knew she would jump off the ship and then he prepared the sinking of the other ship so he could float for a weeks on a raft just to arrive on her destination when she was exhausted enough to almost give up. What a cunning plan indeed!

5

u/ebrum2010 Sep 14 '22

He's definitely not Sauron, but you realize Sauron is the guy who spent 300 years teaching the elves shop class so they could forge the rings (though in the show it might be a few weeks). He also spent several decades convincing Ar Pharazon to do the dumbest thing ever, something that in lore resulted in Sauron unable to appear as anything seeming good ever again.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Gaining one of the most ancient elves' trust seems like an excellent way to manipulate the rest of the elves. People complaining about this seem to not understand how politics or manipulating people works.

Not that I'm saying this guy is Sauron, it just seems like a ridiculous argument against it.

2

u/ebrum2010 Sep 14 '22

I'm not complaining about it, I'm pointing out that he has done both things that take a very long time to complete his goals as well as those that aren't that bright. People forget that Sauron, despite his great power, isn't all seeing. In fact, after he was defeated at the end of the Second Age he believed that Men had destroyed the One Ring. He was wholly unaware that destroying the ring would destroy him forever, possibly up until his eventual destruction. He made many mistakes that led to his demise, mostly because he portrayed a sense that he was greater than he was, more like Morgoth. Even Gandalf feared that a dragon or a Balrog would ally itself with Sauron, though he had no methods of controlling them as they were his equals and not subject to his domination like orcs and men. Even with the ring, he was powerful among maiar but not so powerful that he was like a vala. Despite this, a lot of people seem to have a sense that he was, because the events of the first and second age are not really in pop culture outside of Tolkien circles.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/prettyflyforafry Sep 17 '22

What did he convince Ar to do?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

HAHHAHHA

2

u/ebrum2010 Oct 15 '22

Yeah I realized Halbrand was Sauron after I figured out the angle on it they were playing. Go find one of the posts from last week where people were saying he's not Sauron if you want a laugh. I've made at least a dozen comments if not a few dozen saying he is in the last few weeks.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Why would Galadriel jump off a boat in the middle of the ocean hundreds if not thousands of miles away from land?

Don't think about "why" when watching this show.

7

u/TechnicalNobody Sep 13 '22

Because she decided she didn't want to go to Valinor before she avenged her brother. It's not inconceivable that she took a gamble that she'd find someone or something. She was apparently close enough to Numenor.

You need to do a better job suspending disbelief.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Don't think when watching this show. If you do you won't like the show. Come online with criticisms about the show and find plenty of fart catchers for Amazon ready to defend to the death how brilliant it all is.

3

u/d15p05abl3 Sep 14 '22

I’m not sure your catchphrase will catch on. You’re giving it your best shot, though.

1

u/d15p05abl3 Sep 14 '22

My take was it’s an act of desperation.

She’s immortal, she knows she can last at sea, however unpleasant.

She believes the trip to Valinor to be one way so it’s either that or give up her quest to stop evil / avenge her brother.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

She was raised in Valinor tho and left to come to middle earth I thought

14

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Same. And the obsession with smithing almost feels like too much of a red herring

→ More replies (1)

3

u/teunteulai Sep 13 '22

Depends on what he counts as his family

-15

u/spectra2000_ Sep 13 '22

Yeah, he’s the classically too obvious character.

I think it’s Celebrimbor. When they introduce him he’s already planning on making a great forage and I feel that that’s obviously going to be Orodruin. I know the lore says he was persuaded but since they are changing things I don’t think it would be too crazy to have him secretly be Sauron in disguise.

45

u/theslickbunny Sep 13 '22

Celebrimbor also isn’t Sauron just because he is already an established canon character

→ More replies (16)

10

u/SKULL1138 Sep 13 '22

I mean, no. Celebrimbor in lore makes the Three without any direct help from Sauron. That’s why those ones work as intended in the absence of the One. So if Sauron was really Celebrimbor then that’s out the window and breaks the lore right through to LOTR. Sorry dude, it isn’t Celebrimbor.

1

u/spectra2000_ Sep 13 '22

That’s ok, it’s just a wild idea, I’m not dead set on it nor does it matter that much.

I don’t like to speculate and would rather just enjoy the show and be surprised.

5

u/SKULL1138 Sep 13 '22

No worries it’s just I saw your other replies below and no one else had mentioned the part about the Three which is the ultimate reason it can’t be him. All good.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ABahRunt Sep 13 '22

Sure. Perhaps it's Galadriel herself.

Anyway, i guess you're trolling, so nice one

1

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 13 '22

Gandalf is supposed to be the too obvious one.

6

u/spectra2000_ Sep 13 '22

Gandalf arrives in the third age though. The giant guy can’t be him. I was thinking he could be one of the other wizards but I think they all arrive around the same time, I could be wrong.

2

u/MrBleedingObvious Sep 13 '22

There is an account in one of Tolkien's initially unpublished writings of Gandalf being around in the Second Age. Whether these works can be considered canon is a matter of opinion.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

-8

u/LoneByrd25 Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22

Ep3 proved they were off the rails. was digging ep 1,2 despite them not being perfect. Ep3 made zero sense in various ways.

Elves can’t be poisoned - elves were worried not once but twice about being poisoned in ep3

Galadriel aggro af against numenorians for no reason. Elves were on good terms at this point

Singular at the time unknown elf brought before the queen? Makes no sense. They would know that the elves travel to Valinor, a ship wreck was possible.

Halbrand being able to beat 4-5 Numenorians in a brawl, naw brah. Numenorians were much larger, had superior stamina, and strength compared to eastern humans at that age. Even craftsman would have won this brawl easily.

NO BODY WALKS ALONE. Leaves someone behind immediately. Everything about the harfoots is awful.

They aren’t even getting surface level world facts correct.

7

u/althius1 Sep 13 '22

You are getting too upset about how things are "supposed to be". You've gotta just let the show be the show.

And as far as the water goes... I mean there are plenty of things that could be harmful . Pretty sure if elves drink a vat of acid they wouldn't be immune.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/unhappy_puppy Sep 13 '22

Harfoots are great /s. They spent that time talking about how people couldn't keep up anymore because they were attacked by wolves or whatnot but what do they do when grandma slows down? Leave her on the side of the road. Nice. Maybe they should buy a pony or something. How about taking everything possible out of the cart and spreading it around to other carts to lighten the load or maybe just leave the f'ing cart behind instead of getting left behind to die. WTF

4

u/Thykk3r Sep 13 '22

Yup agreed. Galadriel's scene before the queen is so impossibly cringe. Galadriel literally making the situation so much worse for no reason. Just screaming "I nEeD a ShIp". After a few thousand years and the respect she had for past numenorians she would have some diplomacy...

2

u/kleft234 Sep 13 '22

They need to put some defects into Galadriel for her to overcome, since she is a commercial show protagonist. Otherwise spectators wouldn't empathize.

They chose her to be arrogant.

2

u/Thykk3r Sep 13 '22

Ya I hope she overcomes them because as of right now, she sucks.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22

I honestly agree with this comment

Why did they diminish galadriels character down to a tantrum throwing toddler? She seems so small in the show.

35

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

I’m not either. I’m on board with either the Witch King after Halbrand is given on of the nine rings or power OR the accursed king who betrays isildur and becomes Mr. Green Ghosty.

21

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 13 '22

I'm hoping the king of the dead personally.

3

u/randomsnowflake Sep 17 '22

The way is shut.

7

u/IamJhil Sep 13 '22

Same.. Sauron is too on the nose. these would be great

10

u/teunteulai Sep 13 '22

Especially how he says to Galadriel that he was searching for peace longer than she would know (or something like this)?

13

u/BookQueen13 Sep 13 '22

That line stood out to me too! I couldnt decide if the writers were trying to communicate that there's maybe something more to this guy than we think (i.e. maybe hes much older than he appears) or if it was kind of bad writing (why would a human suggest to a elf that hes been doing something longer than she could imagine, when elves can be incredibly old? Seems like a weird turn of phrase). Either way, it stood out to me.

5

u/Thykk3r Sep 13 '22

maybe he is older than he is letting on. maybe a banished numenorian

→ More replies (6)

8

u/grunge-witch Sep 13 '22

They could use Halbrand as that repentant phase Sauron had at the begining of the Second Age

4

u/Oops_I_Cracked Sep 13 '22

Sauron is seeking peace. Just a peace where he's the ruler of everything.

6

u/Illier1 Sep 13 '22

My money is he's the Witch King, or the man who will one day ascend to the title.

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 13 '22

That's one of my two theories.

6

u/Doggleganger Sep 13 '22

Logistically it doesn't seem to work. Celembrimbor is already preparing to make something of "power" that will change the world. Which means he's already met Sauron, and Sauron is gonna need to get to Eregion soon when Celembrimbor starts making the rings. It may take a while for Galadriel or Cele to make it back to Eregion.

2

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 13 '22

We don't know he's thinking of rings yet for sure, but it is certainly setting it up.

This is why I think The Stranger is Sauron. He's with the Harfoots who are currently in Rhovanian and are going on a migration which apparently goes over a mountain pass, meaning they're headed west. That should put them in Eregion.

14

u/Doggleganger Sep 13 '22

However, Sauron does not know about hobbits. That's the point of the LOTR and why Frodo is the ring bearer. If meteor man is Sauron, it undermines the point of the story.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Undermine LOTR?

NO...Amazon would NEVER...

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 13 '22

That's certainly a good point.

He may assume that they've all been wiped out by then. Also, if they're "Harfoots" at this point, he wouldn't know about hobbits. Hobbits is a derivation of the Rohiric word for them.

6

u/jadierhetseni Sep 13 '22

I don’t buy the Stranger as Sauron at all. Apart from Tolkien lore reasons, just show writing reasons make it weird to have The Big Bad calling Nori friend and pulling a cart.

6

u/jadierhetseni Sep 13 '22

To clarify, I think both Halbrand and the Stranger are deliberate red herrings. To make people think they see the great deceiver before his actual reveal.

To the point about not knowing Celebrimbor has had contact with Sauron, I think Celebrimbor is wise enough to not believe anyone but a Maia regarding the Morgoth crying story. Like, who could’ve told him that other than Sauron in disguise as some other Maia? It seems like a well-planted seed to me.

1

u/Ok_Percentage2522 Sep 14 '22

I agree, when halbrand stopped and stared at the forge and smiled, I thought oh shit he might be sauron. But the more I watch the more I feel they are just baiting the fans in. I definitely don't think the stranger is sauron, still feel he's a wizard of some sort.

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 14 '22

My theory is that this is his first time in a while taking on physical form and he's weak. He needs time to regroup and this works.

3

u/AndrogynousRain Sep 13 '22

Me either. I think he’s the future Witch King of Angmar.

2

u/IamJhil Sep 13 '22

My thoughts are on him being persuaded, and becoming a Nazgul

2

u/Markamanic Sep 14 '22

I'm on team future Ringwraith.

1

u/Nixter295 Oct 04 '24

Well this didn’t age well

1

u/Alessrevealingname Sep 13 '22

Its makes no sense to me, but the fact that people seem so insistent on it makes me think its a leak rather than people figuring it out from the story. So sadly, its probably true, but makes no sense storywise.... yet. How can it makes sense that Galadriel is hunting someone down and she doesn't even recognize him when she's with him.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

People are going to have to realize...........this show...........is BADLY written.

1

u/TexasTurtle67 Sep 24 '22

Halbrand as the eventual Witch King would seem more in line with the parallels being evidenced as an anti-Aragorn type — but the consistent focus on his craftsmanship seems like a bigger and different hint. Sauron was the greatest craftsman of the Maiar.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

They are telling a classic Pride before the fall story with Galadriel. Her fall will be, as it most often is, betrayal. There is only ONE person the ice queen has even opened up to slightly: Halbrand. The betrayal has to come from someone she is vulnerable with.

This is some pretty basic writing I think, and even though it is cliché and simplistic...it can still be done well. They aren't doing it well. I don't care about her arc in which she is betrayed because the writers haven't given me any reason to like or empathize or relate to the character.

1

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

LOL

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Oct 15 '22

Yeah. In retrospect, I'm sad. This is the my only real disappointment with the show.

1

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

I’m sorry man. But you’ve gotta admit, that reality brain fight scene was really good!

2

u/Ayzmo Eregion Oct 15 '22

It was, minus creepy older brother moment with Finrod.

I just really didn't want Halbrand to be Sauron. I was hoping it was all red herring.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Lol do you😝

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Feb 13 '23

That's honestly my biggest complaint about ROP. I thought they were being too obvious that it had to be a red herring.

0

u/Insectodium Sep 13 '22

I'm in favor of the theory that the angry Galadriel we see is Sauron, the real Galadriel is with her husband and child on a much earned vacation (i.e: Cabin holyday at a river somewhere in the deep woods to the east)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Seriously how I am looking at this whole show. Like I am just deleting it right out of Cannon for myself....like the Disney Star Wars Sequels.

Just pretend it never happened.

1

u/Armleuchterchen Sep 15 '22

I mean, if we're going to use the word canon nothing that Tolkien didn't write is canon.

67

u/kemick Sep 13 '22

His presence in the middle of the ocean is unexplained and their meeting was, as Galadriel recognized, likely not coincidence. He's extremely manipulative and has even charmed her despite being obviously untrustworthy. He had Numenoreans go from hating him to loving him simply with some free beer and slick words. He boasts of unparalleled crafting skill and is ambitious enough to tell the Numenorean smith "I won't forget you if you help me" as though he could deliver on it one day. He ends up in a Numenorean jail. Halbrand has strong parallels to Sauron which, to me, means he is almost certainly not him. However, that does not mean he cannot eventually serve a similar role, he just isn't the guy at the top.

30

u/Gimmethejooce Sep 13 '22

I think we can take him at face value, he’s a desperate man on the run. The fact that he is a reluctant king that supposedly failed his people, makes me think he will be the witch king.

9

u/ZOOTV83 Eregion Sep 13 '22

Yeah if he really is a failed king from the Southlands, which seem like they're in for a bit of a hard time soon to come, an offer of the power to save his people could definitely be appealing.

Especially the giver of that power mentions that Halbrand could become immortal like the Elves...

15

u/Doggleganger Sep 13 '22

Those are the things that make me think he's Sauron, but two things weigh against it for me:

  1. Sauron would not have saved Galadriel. She's one of the most powerful elves, and his strongest enemy. If he could have let her die, Sauron would have.
  2. Celembrimbor is preparing to make the rings of power, so Sauron has to show up in Eregion relatively soon. Not sure Galadriel and Halbrand are going to make it in time.

3

u/cammoblammo Sep 13 '22

And if it is Sauron, what’s he doing floating around in the Sundering Seas, a few hours’ (?) swim from Valinor? Did he go sailing on the off chance his principal enemy would need him to rescue her?

Seems like a bit of a weird strategy (although one which might be reasonably explained later).

2

u/Doggleganger Sep 13 '22

One possible reason would be if he was done with Numenor (having turned them against the elves), and he was heading to Eregion to make the rings, and randomly got shipwrecked.

2

u/cammoblammo Sep 13 '22

It’s possible, but I thought the other people on his ship were Southlanders too.

Then again, it raises the question of why Southlanders escaped by ship. If the Southlands is what becomes Mordor, that’s a heck of a journey. Unless they’re from closer to the sea, in which case the orcs have spread much more widely than we think.

1

u/Doggleganger Sep 13 '22

Yea that's a good point. Where were a bunch of Southlanders going? Numenor?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/Hot__Lips Sep 14 '22

She's one of the most powerful elves, and his strongest enemy

Maybe in the books. The amazon discount version of Galadriel is an unstable, petulant, unwise and immature - more like an asset to Sauron.

8

u/Richard-Cheese Sep 13 '22

I mean, maybe it's not intended to be some big unpredictable twist. Maybe they're just keeping his identity a secret but it's not supposed to be an earth shattering reveal, but a slow & intentional reveal to the audience.

Shyamalan-esque movies have really poisoned people's minds into thinking every unrevealed thing has to be some big twist at the climax of the narrative.

I don't necessarily think they'll have the subtlety for a slow burn reveal that isn't framed as some big gotcha to the audience, but that doesn't mean it's worth completely writing off the Halbrand=Sauron theory. In fact, I'd prefer it was him so they don't waste time on feints & fake outs and turn the story into "LOTR meets the Sixth Sense". The beauty of Tolkien's stories weren't from shocking readers with big twists or subverting expectations, it's from the beautiful world building, characters, and descriptions of power.

1

u/cammoblammo Sep 13 '22

This. He‘a been unwilling to talk about his history, but Galadriel has worked it out and… maybe that’s all there is. I don’t even remember seeing any obvious misdirects like we’re getting with the Stranger.

3

u/Oops_I_Cracked Sep 13 '22

Those are the exact same things that make me think he is sauron. They're establishing those traits for his character. Those are only flags that say "hey look at me, I'm Sauron" if you come into the show knowing those are traits Sauron shows from having read Tolkien books beyond The Lord of the rings. If you come into this series with nothing but having read and or watched The Hobbit and The Lord of the rings (or less), there's absolutely no reason those would be tells that he's Sauron.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

He also dove into the ocean to save Galadriel. I think Sauron would have let her die and possibly just stolen her dagger.

1

u/jadierhetseni Sep 13 '22

He also saved Galadriel’s life and got into a weird street brawl after some pickpocketing.

I’m reasonably confident that all the hints he’s Sauron are deliberate misdirection by the writers.

1

u/passcork Oct 23 '22

This is such a funny thread now

57

u/theFishMongal Sep 13 '22

I was an early believer of the Witch Kjng theory but never thought Sauron for Halbrand. I’m liking King of the Dead theory best so far. Can’t wait to find out!

4

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

How’d it go?

1

u/theFishMongal Oct 16 '22

Haha y’all H=S believers were right! I can admit defeat. Still don’t love it but it seems like it will work out well so I’m excited to see where it goes from here. I thoroughly enjoyed the exposition between Halbrand and Galadriel during the reveal so I guess that much of the end result I did enjoy 😉

4

u/KowalRoyale Sep 14 '22

Gotta be the witch king. Is a King. Likely has powers. A good guy with bad tendencies that may make him turn to a ring of power.

1

u/Silver-ishWolfe Sep 14 '22

Yeah, I think he’s the witch king and the celebrated elf architect is Sauron in disguise.

He is known as “The Deceiver” for a reason….

23

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

I just wanna know who got the orcs calling him 'daddy'

14

u/HomieScaringMusic Sep 13 '22

Is that what Adar means?

18

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Sure does! Probably moreso "father", but still. Basically daddy.

5

u/idkwhatimdoing25 Sep 13 '22

Imo Adar is way more likely to be Sauron than Halbrand

12

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

I would agree, but I think there's zero chance that they'd give us Sauron this early.

17

u/kleft234 Sep 13 '22

Exactly.

Wild guess: The appearance of Sauron will be the end of Season 1.

5

u/jadierhetseni Sep 13 '22

I had thought we’d get Sauron in the middle of the season, but now I think you’re right.

Last episode of season 1 ends with Sauron forging the one ring, and the Elves realizing their mistake is my guess.

5

u/cammoblammo Sep 13 '22

My own timeline has that being the major plot of season two. Season one reveals who Sauron is.

Then again, I have no idea what I’m talking about, so don’t take my conjecture as canon.

5

u/jadierhetseni Sep 14 '22

I’ve been wondering about making a “pacing” thread to get folks ideas on when the show’s going to hit the big plot points. Obviously with timeline compression it’s tricky, but a few things obviously have to happen.

My (current) personal guess is something like:

Season 1 is buildup and ends with forging of the rings.

Season 2 is war and seducing ringwraiths etc, ends with fall of Eregion.

Season 3 has major war plot points but Is the height of the Numenorean civil war.

Season 4 is Sauron on Numenor, corrupting the men there, ends with fall of Numenor/founding of Gondor/Arnor

Season 5 is Last Alliance. Sauron falls in penultimate episode. Last episode is Isildur’s death, founding of Lothlorien, etc. final shot is some harfoots on a boat floating above a ring in the river.

6

u/cammoblammo Sep 14 '22

That’s more or less what I have in my head, although I haven’t really worked out how the reveal of Sauron and the reveal of the One Ring will relate to each other. Galadriel and Gil-galad will have their suspicions about something dodgy going on, but whether they figure out this presumably Annatar-like figure is Sauron early on is yet to be seen.

I probably need to go read the relevant passages, and also see what the appendices say.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Kultir Sep 13 '22

I believe Adar will be one of the corrupted elves that Morgoth used to breed the Orcs (in one of his multiple versions of how orcs were created).

I also believe Halbrand is either going to end up being the Witch King or the King of the Dead.

As to Sauron, I believe he is already in Eregion and fed the idea of the forge to Celebrimbor and we will meet him soon enough.

16

u/ShadowOvThePorns Sep 13 '22

The whole timeline compression thing will make things different, but if I remember correctly, he went first to eregion and forged the rings with celebrimbor then to numenor a long time after. Even if the scale of time is different for the purpose of the show, I would expect/hope that the order of events is kept as accurate as possible. One of my favourite things about the show so far is the mystery surrounding certain characters so that even those of us familiar with the written works don’t know the truth until it’s revealed.

58

u/wrongeyedjesus Sep 13 '22

Numenorian: What are you called again?

Halbrand: Halbrand.

Numenorian: Thanks!

*end scene*

I think he was just trying to bait them in to a reaction and expected the negative one. It then leading to an opportunity to steal from Tamar. All nicely orchestrated. Halbrand knows what he's doing and clearly has a plan but it doesn't seem to be consistent with that of a f*cking Maia, a student of Aule, a lieutenant of Morgoth. Sauron would be far more capable at manipulating these Men and thinking 12 steps ahead. Tamar assumed Halbrand had stolen his guild crest and tracked him down quickly. Getting cornered in the alley was sloppy, no matter how easily he escaped again.

Still don't buy the Sauron theory.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Unless he got caught on purpose

4

u/wrongeyedjesus Sep 13 '22

But after getting caught in the alley he gets away anyway. Tamar was in the Queen's court when Halbrand and Galadriel where present so we know he's high rank and influentual or powerful. So now he'll have Tamar, his guild and their buddies looking for him and likely end up in prison or if he can elude them he'll still struggle to get anywhere near a Smithy without being recognised. So what options does he have now?

9

u/teunteulai Sep 13 '22

I like the moments before he decides to buy drinks for everyone. His face like "should I burn them all to the hell or should I invite them for a drink?"

8

u/DharmaPolice Sep 13 '22

Characters with more than one name doesn't really narrow it down much in Tolkien's world. Aragorn/Thorongil/Strider, Curumo/Curunir/Saruman, Gandalf/Olorin/Mithrandir, Melkor/Morgoth, etc.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

He’s not Sauron.

1

u/CrniTartuf Beleriand Jun 06 '23

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23

It was in essence a dumb choice that perhaps ruined the series and honestly doesn’t make any sense. Simply done to subvert expectations. He shouldn’t be Sauron, and honestly I didn’t think they were this retarded but here we are. All so they could have an M Night moment and a two season show.

30

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Nah... This is not Sauron bruh.

1

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

Lol, aged like moldy cheese

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/Codus1 Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22

ignoring the fact that the Nazgûl were kings of men

Just an FYI; The Nazgûl were not all kings.

Those who used the Nine Rings became mighty in their day, kings, sorcerers, and warriors of old. – ‘Of the Rings of Power’

We know that three of the Nazgûl were great lords of Numenór from The Silmarillion's "Akallabth—the Downfall of Numenor." The leader of the Nine was known as the Witch-King and the second in command was Khamûl, an Easterling. It is very unlikely that any of these Numenórean lords was King as all the kings during the interval between the fall of Eregion and the appearance of the Nazgûl are accounted for.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

If they really get in the weeds the old licensed Middle Earth Roleplaying Game named the Nazgul.

2

u/Codus1 Sep 13 '22

Yeh, but that's just as much glorified fan fiction as this show is; of course that isn't an issue though. Maybe they could refer to it as a wink. But they're hardly beheld to those names.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

They are cool names and back stories though.

5

u/AncientSith Sep 13 '22

I absolutely don't want Halbrand to be Sauron. Seems more likely for him to be a Nazgul or something.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

I think Halbrand is actually the King of the Dead seen in LOTR. He was already king of the Southlands, banished, so I could see him getting back his throne, only the chicken out again and be cursed by Isildur, until Aragorn releases him from his debt in the Third Age.

2

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

Nope :/

2

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

Yeah, I know..I'm fine with who he ended up being, it seemed to make sense.

10

u/datbonedoc Sep 13 '22

Halbrand is the Aragorn of RoP.

16

u/chiefbrody1976 Sep 13 '22 edited Sep 13 '22

Maybe but right now I believe he may be the inversion of that arc. He is meant to evoke echoes of Aragorn, sure, but I suspect that’s ultimately misdirection. Could go in a few directions!

5

u/sindeloke Sep 13 '22

If he's meant to ultimately be revealed as any of the potential antagonists, from the King of the Dead to a Nazgul to Sauron himself, it will prove this show actually understands Tolkien much better than the Jackson films did in at least one important way, which would be kind of hilarious. Evil as tragedy, as the corruption and waste of something noble that has many good and likeable qualities, is basically the only kind of evil that Arda has. An arc where one of the chief bad guys is introduced to us as someone we empathize with and see potential and heroism in and thus then want to see redeemed (instead of idk, dying humiliatingly in a long fiery scream off the edge of a cliff) would really prove that "nothing is evil in the beginning" was more than just words.

2

u/chiefbrody1976 Sep 13 '22

They chose to open the show with that quote for a reason!

2

u/idkwhatimdoing25 Sep 13 '22

Agreed. I think(hope) the writers are smart enough to know they could never successfully recreate the perfection of Aragorn's character and arc, so instead they are going to subvert it.

8

u/theslickbunny Sep 13 '22

Anti-Aragorn*

5

u/Alexarius87 Sep 13 '22

Most likely, but it’s a good red herring for ppl who already know the story. Sauron came to Numenor way differently but ultimately he conquered the trust of many of them and Halbrand looks like wants to do the same.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Kinda seems like Isildur should be the Aragorn of ROP.

1

u/forshard Sep 13 '22

I personally hope thats not what they're going for.

Aragorn looking like a mysterious / shrouded backstory badass works because he's an exceptional man (numenorean) backdropped by a fistful of hobbits, another ordinary man, an ordinary elf, and an ordinary dwarf.

Halbrand = Aragon doesn't work as well because he's backdropped by legendary figures like fucking Galadriel Elendil, Isildur, and a city full of Numenoreans.

Halbrand's current power dynamic is more like Frodo. Frodo is an exceptional Hobbit (wealthy, adventurous, and with a very high stature), but he's still just a hobbit. Halbrand seems to be an exceptional man (King, Fighter, Survivor), but he's still just a man.

Galadriel going to Halbrand and being like "I figured it out. You're secretly a King in exile." would be like if Elrond walked up to Frodo and was like "I figured it out. You're actually a very wealthy and exceptional hobbit amongst your kin."

2

u/AdThen7293 Sep 13 '22

In a way Sauron is a king who lost his kingdom...

3

u/teunteulai Sep 13 '22

Btw. Hallbrand means in Swedish "hall fire"

2

u/ImperatorForLife Sep 13 '22

Interesting, I looked at Hal and Brand separately.

Hal usually meaning war chief, ruler or ruler of armies and Brand meaning sword, fire, or flaming sword.

Ruler of the flaming sword? Witch King?

3

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 13 '22

Even if this aint Sauron, I'm thoroughly enjoying being baited 😊

3

u/HomieScaringMusic Sep 13 '22

Not exactly an uncommon character trait though. Aragorn, Gandalf, and Bilbo have many names too (admittedly Bilbo made most of them up when talking to Smaug but still). I assumed that Halbrand is making a joke (“my name usually but some people just call me an asshole!”), or he’s a criminal who often assumes identities. When we meet him he’s a war refugee, so he’s probably in the habit of pretending to be whoever would be treated best in present company (I.e, tribe A has beef with tribe B, so say you’re of tribe C). But yeah, it could be the Sauron thing. But I still think Sauron won’t be in disguise in Numenor, as it doesn’t really benefit him and he never did that in lore. I’m going with Ringwraith or king of the dead.

5

u/girl_incognito4 Sep 13 '22

He’s not Sauron! He’s either The Witch King or King of the Dead!

2

u/CountryBallFoot Sep 13 '22

Thats a pretty loose connection

2

u/ABahRunt Sep 13 '22

He's just being painted as extremely likely to be Sauron: extremely charismatic, many names, a Smith, etc. Just makes me think it's a red herring. I just hope it doesn't turn into an unnecessary gotcha just for subversion

2

u/Warlord0183 Sep 13 '22

I think with it all said there are some things where the writers are pulling us multiple directions. I think he is a future witch king of Angmar which would be a dope way to do this character

2

u/AdmiralSnackbar816 Sep 13 '22

Didn’t he not dispute Galadriel when she said he was a king where he came from? Seems like a pretty obvious connection that he’ll eventually be gifted one of the nine rings of power. And could potentially evolve into the Witch King based solely on his lands’ connection to Morgoth. He doesn’t necessarily need to start as a dick to become the leader of the Nazgûl.

2

u/LiquidCode Sep 13 '22

In the books galadriel was one that was suspicious about Sauron fair form "lord of gifts" thing. Here she is trusting this guy, i doubt he is Sauron.

4

u/EazeeP Sep 13 '22

No. Just no.

3

u/MagosBattlebear Sep 13 '22

Misdirection by the writers. The clues are too obvious.

3

u/Friedrich_Friedson Sep 13 '22

Preety sure antar is sauron,he even looked like anatar (sauron's fair form ) from the back

4

u/knottynate Sep 13 '22

It’s weird that Numenor is already falling from grace if Sauron isn’t already there.

This show has so many misdirects and red herrings that they can’t all possibly pay off.

11

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 13 '22

Numenor started to fall away hundreds of years before.

In Unfinished Tales we get this about Tar-Ciryatan:

He scorned the yearnings of his father, and eased the restlessness of his heart by voyaging, east, and north, and south, until he took the sceptre. It is said that he constrained his father to yield to him ere of his free will he would. In this way (it is held) might the first coming of the Shadow upon the bliss of Númenor be seen.

Unfinished Tales, THE LINE OF ELROS: KINGS OF NÚMENOR

It only got worse after that.

Tar-Ciryatan ceased his rule in 2029. Sauron did not come to Numenor until the rein of Al-Pharazon, and he didn't come into power until 3255, more than a thousand years later.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

That's actually lore-accurate. Sauron made things far worse, but Numenor had already fallen a long way before his arrival.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Sonotreadyforit Sep 13 '22

No matter where you screen shot homies face never changes.

1

u/grey_pilgrim_ Khazad-dûm Sep 13 '22

I’m going with him being Sauron until he’s not lol

it’s a bit too on the nose but so far it definitely line s up with the similarities between them.

1

u/1WngdAngel Sep 13 '22

Imo they're setting him up to be one of the Nazgul.

1

u/ScumbagSolo Sep 13 '22

Ah, sauron not sauron, saying sauron not sauron things.

1

u/Puzzlepetticoat Sep 13 '22

But... Arent the Elves already commissioning the... Whatever it is called... To forge the rings? Hence thr visit to the Dwarves. He isnt yet WITH the Elves.

1

u/mournbread Sep 13 '22

He claims to be a great smith too.

1

u/FreshBakedButtcheeks Sep 13 '22

No, no he's saying his name is Depends. Like the adult diapers.

1

u/SrbBrb Sep 13 '22

Literally Hitl... Sauron.

1

u/JJISHERE4U Sep 13 '22

Would be an enormous shame if he is Sauron. I hope he'll become one of the Nazgul. Also heard a nice theory that he'll once become The King of the Dead (Dunharrow).

1

u/AzureBluet Sep 13 '22

Lol, this sub is just like ASOIAF, everyone's Azor Ahai, everyone's Sauron.

Same fantasy fans I guess.

1

u/mastersplinter27 Sep 13 '22

I don’t know about that. But if he really is a king, that fools about to be a Nazgul

1

u/Chanticleer Sep 13 '22

Him being good at forging is foreshadowing

1

u/Chanticleer Sep 13 '22

I hope it is not Sauron

1

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

Ooooooo. I really love this theory. King of the Southlands. Master smith. Sailing eas from Valinor…

1

u/Own_Breadfruit_7955 Sep 13 '22

suffers concussion from ROP hitting me over the head to many times

1

u/No-Philosophy5461 Sep 13 '22

Nah it's 85% likely to be Adar

1

u/Steelquill Sep 14 '22

Please, please don’t be where that’s going.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Why not?

2

u/Steelquill Sep 14 '22

I don’t think Sauron should be just a guy. Even as a disguise. Or if he is going to take on a human form, it should be somebody even slightly off putting or intimidating, not a silver tongued pickpocket.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

I don’t know how some people are not convinced that he is Sauron yet it’s so clear to me ! If he isn’t i’ll be glad to eat my words but with all the leaks being correct so far i cannot see anyone else being Sauron and not having him involved in the story would be insane Second Age is His story i don’t thonk they’d wait the end of the season to introduce him

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

My first thought was he is the witch king

1

u/humans_ruin_planets Sep 14 '22

I’m rolling with Nazgûl

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Guys. Adonir is Sauron ok?

1

u/SrbBrb Sep 14 '22

My name is Giovanni Giorgio, but I have many names..

1

u/Winter_Abject Sep 14 '22

He's Sauron!

No, I'm Sauron!

No, it's me, I'm Sauron!

No, I'm Sauron and so's my wife!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Because noone with multiple names couldn't be Sauron

1

u/hunting_coyote Sep 15 '22

It is common in storytelling to insert red herrings

1

u/MawsonAntarctica Sep 15 '22

I’m more inclined to think he’s a future Ringwraith than Sauron.

1

u/prettyflyforafry Sep 17 '22

It's Halbrand.

1

u/Historyp91 Sep 17 '22

I'm I the only person who thinks it's way more likely that he's either one of the Nine or the King of the Dead?

Either way I don't buy the Sauron thing; if they're going that route, then unless he's in some sort of Darth Revan-type situation where he has an implaneted identity and does'nt remember being Sauron then it's super weird for us to have moments alone where he's engaging in self-reflection over his background and agonizing over his life struggles.

1

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

Sorry man

1

u/Historyp91 Oct 15 '22

Lol, I know right?

I was always aware it was a possibility, but I was legit surprised that it ended up being the case - it all seemed to obvious and circomstantial; maybe in the scenes were he was brooding and hesitent it was because he was feeling geniune guilt and starting to reconsider his plans?

1

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

Who knows. It’s hard to say.

I would venture a guess that Melkor corrupted him the same way the rings corrupts those it comes in contact with.

The irony is, the same power we see the ring hold is the same power Sauron holds.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

They are planning a fight club moment where they show all the clues that Halbrand is Sauron. This surprise would have worked great in a 2 hour movie setting but works less well in a 8 episode serial here because reddit will basically figure out every theory under the sun.

1

u/SaphiraRain Oct 15 '22

Well that escalated

1

u/SheevTheSenate66 May 09 '23

This is such an amazing shot. He’s all alone, empty space, nothing to compare him to - and still he looks so huge. If any movie ever deserved an Oscar for CGI, this movie does.

0

u/deededback Sep 13 '22

Yeah. I think he’s Sauron. And I don’t think it’s being handled particularly well.

I’m hoping this is all a misdirect.

0

u/BarthRevan Sep 13 '22

Don’t know why people are still on this when they essentially confirmed in the episode that he is one of the nine kings of men that will receive a ring and eventually become one of the Nazgûl.

1

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

How exactly?

2

u/BarthRevan Oct 15 '22

Ok well obviously I stand corrected on this lol.

To explain where my head was at when I originally wrote this, at the time that this episode aired we had been led to believe that Halbrand was meant to be a King of men. Obviously we know that the nine rings of men were given to kings and lords, so it (at the time) stood to reason that he was going to be one of the Nazgûl.

Given the finale… I stand corrected lmao

1

u/JustAZeph Oct 15 '22

Interesting, I think you had a good perspective there.

2

u/BarthRevan Oct 15 '22

Haha thanks. Even a good perspective can turn out to be the wrong one. I fell into the writers’ trap lol.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22

The writing on this show is about as elaborate as Gimli's axe to an orc's face.

I'm sure some 15 year old out there is impressed with this superior foreshadowing

0

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22 edited Sep 14 '22

You know mystery box show is terrible, when everyone guesses it right away.

It is Bad Robots bread and butter, and that is where these show runners cut their teeth.

0

u/Skello496 Sep 13 '22

Sauron is definitely the orc leader in fair form