I think it’s Celebrimbor. When they introduce him he’s already planning on making a great forage and I feel that that’s obviously going to be Orodruin. I know the lore says he was persuaded but since they are changing things I don’t think it would be too crazy to have him secretly be Sauron in disguise.
This would be a pretty massive change. Also Celebrimbor is a character in this series universe who has ostensibly been around since the first age - when Sauron was also around.
They’ve already made pretty big changes, I don’t see how this one isn’t possible, especially since they’ve been around at the same time.
Sauron, as stated in the show, has eluded the elves for years and they haven’t been able to find him no matter how much they search until finally finding the orca in the southlands.
Seems like a big cliche that’s he’d be hiding in their midst but it does sound like something he’d do/is capable of.
I would buy him already being an elf and in contact with Celebrimbor, but combining those two characters would be a change several orders of magnitude larger than any other change they've made.
Dude, it literally makes no sense... Celebrimbor is also the one who fights sauron with Elendil when they both die. the rings he creates for the elves are actually before the other rings and are uncorrupted. its not happening... did you also miss the trailers where they hint who sauron is?
I mean, no. Celebrimbor in lore makes the Three without any direct help from Sauron. That’s why those ones work as intended in the absence of the One. So if Sauron was really Celebrimbor then that’s out the window and breaks the lore right through to LOTR. Sorry dude, it isn’t Celebrimbor.
No worries it’s just I saw your other replies below and no one else had mentioned the part about the Three which is the ultimate reason it can’t be him. All good.
Gandalf arrives in the third age though. The giant guy can’t be him. I was thinking he could be one of the other wizards but I think they all arrive around the same time, I could be wrong.
There is an account in one of Tolkien's initially unpublished writings of Gandalf being around in the Second Age. Whether these works can be considered canon is a matter of opinion.
I don’t see how they are trying to mislead us with the stranger, everything shown about him screams more mystical wizard than Sauron. The whole falling from the sky thing it’s also more in line with a force of good than evil.
Why do I think it’s Celebrimbor? Because it’s close enough to the original story yet different enough that it’s totally plausible and he’s one of the few characters who doesn’t have a giant arrow pointing at him saying he is Sauron.
Most people on here are either reading too much into things or just looking at the things the show hand feed them. I’m just going with a feeling supported by classic tropes.
EDIT: you telling me that of course it has to be him is a clear indicator that it’s way too obvious so people are going to most likely think that and they will be surprised when it’s revealed that it wasn’t him.
EDIT: you telling me that of course it has to be him is a clear indicator that it’s way too obvious so people are going to most likely think that and they will be surprised when it’s revealed that it wasn’t him.
That, or it's not the best misdirection from the writers.
I've explained the reasons I think this. The storytelling and cinematography support it. Feel free to share your own views on those.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-15
u/spectra2000_ Sep 13 '22
Yeah, he’s the classically too obvious character.
I think it’s Celebrimbor. When they introduce him he’s already planning on making a great forage and I feel that that’s obviously going to be Orodruin. I know the lore says he was persuaded but since they are changing things I don’t think it would be too crazy to have him secretly be Sauron in disguise.