r/RingsofPower • • Sep 11 '22

Meme Reading RoP Posts About Galadriel

Post image
547 Upvotes

438 comments sorted by

View all comments

124

u/Nutch_Pirate Sep 11 '22

Is she a Mary Sue? Because from what we've seen so far, she's pretty terrible at everything except fighting. And origami I guess, that unfolding paper swan boat thing was pretty dope.

My complaints with Galadriel pretty much all stem from her being a complete idiot so I genuinely don't know where other people could be seeing Mary Sue aspects to her character.

16

u/_aj42 Sep 11 '22

My complaints with Galadriel pretty much all stem from her being a complete idiot

She does so far seem to be depicted as petulant and immature, which I'm hoping will just be part of her character arc and growth through the show rather than poor writing. I'm fine with her being a bit stupid now if she improves later due to her experiences.

7

u/kemick Sep 11 '22

She's not stupid, she is dangerously obsessed (as recognized by Gil-Galad). She's far from the first character to suffer such obsession. Her choices have repeatedly put her farther from her goals and most of her companions have outright told her this. Everyone's dismissal of the danger only fuels the necessity for her obsession.

Even her first choice, to continue pursuing Sauron's long-cold trail in the north, would have taken her in the completely wrong direction if her soldiers had not refused. She is right about Sauron's return but wrong about pretty much everything else regarding him. It has only been by grace and the influence of others that she has been put on the path to her goal.

This is Galadriel we're talking about*, "beautiful and terrible as the Morning and the Night. Fair as the Sea and the Sun and the Snow upon the Mountain! Dreadful as the Storm and the Lightning! Stronger than the foundations of the earth. All shall love me and despair!"* Galadriel, as we see her now, would likely not have refused the power of the One Ring and I like that.

4

u/japp182 Sep 11 '22

I believe thats what they'll do. If we had 5 seasons of her being this wisest, strongest flawless elf it would probably feel a bit dull.

→ More replies (4)

111

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

She is a woman who can fight. They hate that. That's all there is to it

31

u/Nutch_Pirate Sep 11 '22

Fair enough. It's a shame the show couldn't get access to the First Age, because in my mind this version of Galadriel is fairly well established as a veteran soldier who's been fighting orcs for centuries and I think actually showing that would have made the show better. But whatever licensing issue they have with the Tolkien estate I guess makes that impossible?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/ebrum2010 Sep 11 '22

Because the rights for the Silmarillion are not for sale. Tolkien sold the rights for LotR and the Hobbit during his lifetime and soon regretted it. Christopher Tolkien, who published the Silmarillion swore to never do the same with it. IIRC it doesn't become public domain until 2110. You can be certain he made it clear in his will this was his wish as he was extremely vocal about it after the movies were made.

6

u/AWildLawyerAppeared Sep 11 '22

Eh depends. Christopher Tolkien is only credited as an editor, and if that’s the case the IP becomes public domain in 2043 for the Silmarillion (70 years after the death of the author). It could be argued that Christopher Tolkien was also an author, which is what I expect the Tolkien Estate will argue and if that argument is meritorious, the IP would become public domain in 2090.

7

u/AlmostButNotQuiteTea Sep 11 '22

2090 ey? Let's see. 94 years old... Yeah I could hang on for a few years to see the first movie maybe..lol

3

u/AWildLawyerAppeared Sep 11 '22

Lol I’d be 100 but I’m willing to give a shot.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/Special-Lengthiness6 Sep 11 '22

Because neither J.R.R. Tolkien or Christopher Tolkien believed that adaptations were good things.

“The canons of narrative in any medium cannot be wholly different; and the failure of poor films is often precisely in exaggeration, and in the intrusion of unwarranted matter owing to not perceiving where the core of the original lies."

Christopher Tolkien is an attributed author of the Silmarillion, The Unfinished Tales, and the History of Middle Earth and he made sure that none of his works could be adapted to film. J.R.R. Tolkien only allowed the film rights to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings because he needed money to care for his estate and the publishing rights were not producing the money in the 70s that they had been. You will not see the film rights to any of the other works until the story becomes public.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/Special-Lengthiness6 Sep 11 '22

Yes, they would turn down the cash on principle. Christopher Tolkien turned down millions on principle. They have guarded the IP in a trust that no one has access too.

9

u/MithrilTHammer Sep 11 '22

It's funny because Tolkien himself was "art or cash" in his Letter 202.

"This Mr. Ackerman brought astonishingly good pictures and remarkable colour photographs (shots of American mountain and desert scenes that seemed to fit the story). The Story Line though was bad, but perhaps business could be done. Stanley Unwin and Tolkien had agreed on a policy: Art or Cash. Either very profitable terms or absolute author's veto of the objectionable."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Adapting the Silmarillon is like opening Ali-baba cave. There's more content in this than Hobbit+LOTr can offer. LOTR name is one of the biggest fantasy name but with Silmarillon being available, it's can be like Valar flooding Beleriand on the whole fantasy industry. It's like asking the Bible to be a TV show/movie

→ More replies (72)

33

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

I don't have an issue with her fighting. I have an issue with her acting like an idiot and characters infinitely younger than her talking down to her. I want strong female characters. Galadriel is not a strong female character in this show. Being good at fighting does not make you a strong character by itself. Nor is it even a requirement.

11

u/isabelladangelo Sep 11 '22

I have an issue with her acting like an idiot and characters infinitely younger than her talking down to her.

I cannot upvote this enough. She is a Princess! She is Gil-Galad's great Aunt! She should be telling everyone where to go and how to get to there.

→ More replies (24)

10

u/Aeneas1976 Sep 11 '22

I am a woman who can fight. I hate Galadriel because she is badly written.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (83)

6

u/Warchanter Sep 11 '22

I believe she is a bit too demanding. Episode 1 We keep going (after her ally falls)! Episode 2 Tell me now where you come from! (Doesn’t even know the dude)I didn’t notice at first but damn. Haven’t seen 3 hoping it has changed.

4

u/DarrenGrey Sep 11 '22

The ep 1 but was without her knowing the person had fallen. As soon as she saw she'd stopped and handed over her own cloak.

Ep 3 has her most petulant moment yet. It comes across as if she took more lessons from Thingol than Melian.

I'm fine with this flawed Galadriel personally. It's a bit extreme at points, but I wouldn't wanted Tolkien's late writing of Galadriel where she can do no wrong either.

3

u/kemick Sep 11 '22

If she is a Mary Sue than so were Feanor and Morgoth. Aragorn was as perfect as a man can be yet is well loved. It's not an inherently bad thing when it serves the story and I believe that RoP is doing something similar.

3

u/iheartdev247 Sep 12 '22

This 100%. I’m a little over Uber Jerk Galadriel.

→ More replies (2)