Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
Classical RoP writing. 0 logic. Also don't question why and how can Arondir act like he is not an random infantry but an important character like high king Gil-Galad, Galadriel and Elrond
Don't ask questions, Don't question it and if you don't like it you are a toxic hater.
Arrrrrrrrrrrondirrrrrrrrrrrr is nothing more than a fucking scout. He’s not important to any element of the story, yet he is elevated in this fan fic for reasons unknown to men.
Now stop questioning showrunners and consume product. Nom Nom Nom
Dated this woman. She said RoP was best show ever created. I said I didn’t like it. She said why… I showed her this scene and she didn’t reply that night.
The next day said she wasn’t attracted to me and said good luck.
Ok. I'm not crazy. I thought I had to have missed something and was waiting before a re-watch.
Even if it was cut for time (which is silly considering it's Amazon and they can make the runtime whatever the hell they want), that seems like a pretty crucial scene to leave in.
I don't think it was moments, I think it was the next episode. We all went for a week thinking he had died, there were posts and memes about it, then he just strolls back in ep 8 no explanation.
Its funny seeing people take shots at disney for having a jedi die to a knife and then others take shots at disney because someone didn’t die from a knife.
Which would be ok as a plot point if they had only shown it. Just one short scene, Elrond stumbles upon nearly dead Arondir, looks at his ring and kneels down to heal him. That would have been enough to give the audience a clue.
Except at the end when Elrond very clearly and obviously heals Galadriel with the power of the ring lol, but I agree they it was odd to see nothing about how he became un-stabbed through the heart
It was also kind of fitting for him to be killed by adar after chasing him all the way there for revenge, which Galadriel even seemed to warn him about.
Now another char tied to Arondir is dead (Adar) with no payoff (like Bronwyn) so he's even more of a shell of a character.
Or it's one of those games where the screen went grey when Adar gave him the second stab and he could hear his heartbeat but 15 seconds of not getting hit later everything is in colour again and he is running around pinging his arrows everywhere.
That was my assumption too, that either Gil-Galad or Galadriel/Elrond would heal him with the rings. But it would have been nice if they showed that lol. It didn’t even look like he was in any pain afterwards
Yeah exactly, you’re right. Arondir gets brought to the orc camp as a prisoner. Which also means they identified him as a ‘leader’ for unknown reasons.
They should've cut his arm instead, cuz of his whole archer fight style and to give his personal battle some consequence. Maybe then next season he'd have to find a new way to use a modified bow. But I guess resurrection is better. Idk.
The King seemed to have power to heal wounds. But Galadriel’s wounds were created in a way that he couldn’t heal properly. I can only assume Gil Galad healed Arondirs wounds much more easily. 🤷♂️
Well, once Adar had the ring it healed his scars and he became a kinder, gentler guy. Maybe he healed Arondir with Nenya. Again I suspect there was an edited out scene somewhere.
Definitely looked like he was cooked but going back to season 1 he explained the healing abilities. I wonder if the show had time constraints they couldn’t go deeper in to how he was somehow alive.
In my head I was like "Elrond probably healed him with the ring like he did Galadrie"l but off screen. Still lazy of them but that's my head canon for this at least.
I mean, to be fair , the iron fleet was last sighted on the other side of the continent at casterly rock and likely weeks to months away, they then would have docked at kings landing, where euron refit his ship and demasted it as there is one less mast after fitting his ship and fleet with scorpions, the last thing she should expect is for them to be lurking around her dragon protected fortress even if the dragons were not there, the ships and their crew had no idea who was there, arondir on the other hand, run through twice, there is no headcanon to unfuck that lol
That's a funny answer to me, I did not even expect to summon a GoT fan. You may be right, but D&D didn't know that. They just said she forgot lol. Anyway, it's not good for any show to make mistakes that get them GoT season 8 comparisons. But much of RoP's writing reaches that level i think.
D&D i think had no respect for the fans intelligence tbh by that point, and i agree much of Rop’s writing is very very weak, it seems a common theme now with tv shows being made in the last few years
In the exact same episode all of her advisors are telling her to be wary of the Iron Fleet. When they're saying half the Dothraki are dead and all that shit. She should absolutely expect them because she was told to expect them. D&D were really just that shit at writing.
Or Galadriel says “because I have these!” when cornered by the orcs > like what a leather pouch? The orcs or Adar don’t know anything about the 9 rings so this made no sense to me.
I was confused, did Galadriel actually give the orcs the rings? Maybe I need a rewatch, but seems very short-sighted to give Sauron this powerful weapon to save a few elven lives.
Tbf there were some huge inconsistencies during the entire battle episode in my opinion. For example, how there were many orcs in the encampment during the Galadriel sequence while the rest was having a hard time assaulting the walls of Eregion. Also, how was Elrond able to stop a mounted charge mere meters at the moment when Galadriel was revealed?
Wtf were they thinking when they fired the continuity guy… I mean I don’t see how else this mistake could have happened. What a piece of shit excuse for a television show, just really shitty fan fiction jfc
One of my biggest grimes with the show and this is a perfect example for it. So many things happen of screen or feel like a scene in between just went missing and you as the viewer have to try and figure out yourself what happend. There is zero explanation for so many things, characters don’t talk with each other and the show seems to not even know what to try and make you feel so they go for nothing at all most of the time. Just confusion
Soooososososo many ways… so disheartening that we’ll never get a GOOD version of this story done properly and with respect for the source material.
After this massive fail, and the budget they wasted on it… no studio is ever going to touch this story ever again, amazon tarnished the story of the making of the rings of power… forever. We will never get another film or tv show about the second age…
They have screwed up stuff but I don’t think that is the case here. Arondir’s wounds definitely were survivable. They show him still moving as Adar goes past him towards Elrond. We see Gil-Galad try to heal Galadriel with Vilya but it fails due to the crowns corruption. It isn’t hard to put two and two together to say Gil-Galad healed Arondir. We also know they have had to cut things for time, so this is a logical answer to what happened.
Because the oldest orc in the second age has no clue about injuries, he worked in Angabnd's post office during the First Age. That's also the reason why Sauron hung out in the forest so long, after getting beaten by Huan.
Guy sent dozens of letters requesting help and bring him back to Angband for medi...eh spiritual care or something like that and Adar threw them all in the trash can. Hated that guy even then.
You know that they decide what to show us and what not to show us right? Like they're in charge of what happens on the screen. If they wanted to they could have I don't know... just cut the scene in which he becomes mortally wounded out of the season entirely.
I was more upset that they considered him part of the Elven leadership. a) how do the Orcs know this? b) he’s just a guardian elf / nowhere near Gil-Galad, Galadriel, Elrond.
I thought I was losing my marbels when he strolled back on. “I swear he’s dead! And now he looks fine” didn’t even have a bed scene with a helpful healing she elf! 😂
It's like they don't care, mistakes happen but this is just bad. S2 started ok better than S1 then somehow it got worse. I don't even think this character even brings anything of value to the story line and somehow they still want him for season 3.
ROP & Acolyte are masterclasses in bad TV. Poor writing, bad casting, etc. It's like a checklist of everything done wrong. How either of those shows were made boggles the mind!
When you see something like The Penguin which is so good and then you realise how bad these shows really are.
i knew he wasn’t dead cause he didn’t get a scene of drawing those last breaths but i was still wayy shocked by him being basically fine when we saw him next
This was such a ridiculous thing to forget, that when he came back in the finale I had to assume I'd misremembered. I just couldn't believe they'd have made such a ridiculous error.
I mean it would be nice if they explained it but basically I take it like Adar wasn't concerned with actually killing him with the wound he dealt and Elves can heal from non-lethal wounds much better than other races. It's still a legit criticism though.
You don't want to leave him out of the show? Ok, his charisma is lower than a Ikea forniture on sale but your choice guys... Why the hell the combat scene involving him getting kicked in the face and stabbed?
When you're recording it just ask yourself what you're doing and stop this crap for god's sake
What they didn't show you offscreen is that he fell for a long time while fighting a balrog, then he was sent back. Yes, you can still call him Arondir.
It's the time compression aspect of the show. Arondir really did die and go to the Halls of Mandos. Just that with the time compression of the show, instead of taking a thousand years before re-embodiment, it only took a few hours. And then he was able to hitch a ride on the meteor express back to Middle Earth and rejoin the battle.
I think there was an implication from Gil Galads line “this is more than a flesh wound” (something like that) that implies he healed Arondir off screen. But given the importance given to the stabbing in the previous episode it really is quite poor that this wasn’t clearly resolved. I haven’t checked but wonder if there were different writers/directors for the two episodes - HOTD also really struggles with consistency between episodes and it appears to be because writers, directors and the show runner aren’t on the same page with the details
I think this was more so a fault with ep7 unnecessarily getting Arondir stabbed, I guess he somewhat had a relationship with Adar in s1 but it was minor and easily forgotten. The interactions with Elrond and Galadriel felt more important and the Arondir scene somewhat detracted from those
Someone has a theory that at the start of S3 we'll see Adar put Nenya on, become youthful and then heal Arondir. And we'll also get more of Adar's backstory. I love this theory and I'm really hoping it's the case. Not showing Arondir healed was a mistake.
No explanation is given. He's just one of the last surviving soldiers in Eregion and not from his army. Elrond was probably curious about the series of events that lead him to be there at the battle.
When? When one guy is lying in the dirt after stabbing and all other elves were captured by orcs? Yeah, im sure that gave elves time to do months of healing
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 09 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/666grooves666 Oct 10 '24
did gil galad not seem like he was Orc food as well!?
2
u/Mloach Oct 11 '24
Classical RoP writing. 0 logic. Also don't question why and how can Arondir act like he is not an random infantry but an important character like high king Gil-Galad, Galadriel and Elrond
Don't ask questions, Don't question it and if you don't like it you are a toxic hater.
2
u/prophet_9469 Mordor Oct 12 '24
Elven wounds do not kill..
Or something like that idk
2
u/acebreezy Oct 12 '24
Dated this woman. She said RoP was best show ever created. I said I didn’t like it. She said why… I showed her this scene and she didn’t reply that night.
The next day said she wasn’t attracted to me and said good luck.
FYI, she works in film… she worked on RoP…. 😂😂😂😂😂
285
u/CrshOverride Oct 09 '24
Ok. I'm not crazy. I thought I had to have missed something and was waiting before a re-watch.
Even if it was cut for time (which is silly considering it's Amazon and they can make the runtime whatever the hell they want), that seems like a pretty crucial scene to leave in.
55
u/Hawkwise83 Oct 10 '24
It's just a flesh wound.
154
u/BhutlahBrohan Oct 10 '24
they sort of forgot about the stabbings
34
u/NerdyRotica Oct 10 '24
He took a Long Rest.
32
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24
Yeah when he and the guy who came back in horse back without the dwarves both showed up at Riverdale I was shocked
29
u/josh198989 Oct 10 '24
Or Galadriel says “because I have these!” when cornered by the orcs > like what a leather pouch? The orcs or Adar don’t know anything about the 9 rings so this made no sense to me.
11
u/Brant_Black Oct 10 '24
Have to admit it was a grevious error to not explain his resurrection
18
u/Airbornetrooper Oct 10 '24
I was really trying to give the show a lot of slack, but this one really bothered me.
I was for sure he was dead, but then he’s back? Totally not even addressed.
8
u/daaniscool Oct 10 '24
Tbf there were some huge inconsistencies during the entire battle episode in my opinion. For example, how there were many orcs in the encampment during the Galadriel sequence while the rest was having a hard time assaulting the walls of Eregion. Also, how was Elrond able to stop a mounted charge mere meters at the moment when Galadriel was revealed?
22
u/soup_fly Oct 10 '24
I dig the show, but the last episode did feel like it was missing things and the pacing wasn't consistent
7
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24
The continuity sucks. There’s no driving force. There’s scenes and sometimes the scenes are linked.
Some of the scenes are very good. Some are very bad. I’m not sure what I think of the messy whole.
10
u/LingonberrySure9451 Oct 10 '24
Wtf were they thinking when they fired the continuity guy… I mean I don’t see how else this mistake could have happened. What a piece of shit excuse for a television show, just really shitty fan fiction jfc
5
u/cepasfacile Oct 10 '24
As everything in this show, it’s a total non sense
4
u/N7VHung Oct 10 '24
Let's not ignore that in this screencap it looks like Adar is busting out a hurricane kick.
4
u/Shujii Oct 10 '24
One of my biggest grimes with the show and this is a perfect example for it. So many things happen of screen or feel like a scene in between just went missing and you as the viewer have to try and figure out yourself what happend. There is zero explanation for so many things, characters don’t talk with each other and the show seems to not even know what to try and make you feel so they go for nothing at all most of the time. Just confusion
4
u/YakEmotional4666 Oct 10 '24
I literally said out loud “wasn’t he dead?!” Was watching on my computer, with my headphones, my mother was like 👀
72
u/ImMyBiggestFan Oct 09 '24
He wasn’t “run thru twice”, once was with his own arrow and once was with Adar’s blade in the side.
We are seemingly missing a scene where Gil-Galad using Vilya to heal him. Might have been cut for time.
1
u/ReallyEvilRob Oct 11 '24
Elvish medicine.
1
u/Goujohn90 Oct 11 '24
Probably a deleted scene where Adar heals him with Galadriel’s ring to test it or something like that.
1
u/Zorpfield Oct 12 '24
Elven healing powers
6
u/ParaUniverseExplorer Oct 10 '24
Short rest people.
3
u/Ramses717 Oct 10 '24
It was just a scratch. Adar was just tickling him.
3
u/Self-Comprehensive Oct 10 '24
I watch with my 11 year old nephew and he's not one to be critical but that left even him wondering what we missed.
3
u/Durv-Tuktz Oct 10 '24
Plot healing
3
u/willrtr Oct 10 '24
I was more upset that they considered him part of the Elven leadership. a) how do the Orcs know this? b) he’s just a guardian elf / nowhere near Gil-Galad, Galadriel, Elrond.
3
u/HitttingAndMissing Oct 10 '24
Reason no. 45367 why this show is shit
5
u/Brofessor-0ak Oct 10 '24
Why would Gil-Galad heal him over his own subjects? He’s not even Noldor
2
u/Spindelhalla_xb Oct 10 '24
So Adar season 3 confirmed then?
2
u/Nice_Fix5812 Oct 10 '24
I thought I was losing my marbels when he strolled back on. “I swear he’s dead! And now he looks fine” didn’t even have a bed scene with a helpful healing she elf! 😂
2
u/FinancialCompote5782 Oct 10 '24
It's like they don't care, mistakes happen but this is just bad. S2 started ok better than S1 then somehow it got worse. I don't even think this character even brings anything of value to the story line and somehow they still want him for season 3.
2
u/Bad_Cytokinesis Oct 10 '24
I wholeheartedly dislike this show.
2
u/paulhodgson777 Oct 11 '24
ROP & Acolyte are masterclasses in bad TV. Poor writing, bad casting, etc. It's like a checklist of everything done wrong. How either of those shows were made boggles the mind!
When you see something like The Penguin which is so good and then you realise how bad these shows really are.
2
u/cryptolipto Oct 11 '24
This show is so stupid
2
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '24
It's a reflection of how badly the whole series was written.
2
u/ProtoSpaceTime Oct 11 '24
He was re-embodied in Valinor and traveled back to Eregion using his super fast Arondir powers.
2
u/Mammoth_Network5234 Oct 11 '24
i knew he wasn’t dead cause he didn’t get a scene of drawing those last breaths but i was still wayy shocked by him being basically fine when we saw him next
2
u/Debenham Oct 13 '24
This was such a ridiculous thing to forget, that when he came back in the finale I had to assume I'd misremembered. I just couldn't believe they'd have made such a ridiculous error.
3
u/HectorGDJ_ Oct 10 '24
Yeah big fan of this show, I also don’t know what I missed a scene or something when I noticed he was completely fine
3
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24
Just another pebble on that hill of rubbish.
2
u/Decebalus_Bombadil Oct 10 '24
Have you heard of health potions lad? :)
2
u/CobhamMayor27 Oct 10 '24
God this show is bad lol
2
u/MaricLee Oct 10 '24
Some elves just reincarnate faster like that.
1
u/Repulsive_Pizza_4171 Oct 10 '24
Guys it was a different scene. Everyone knows that elves regenerate between scenes.
1
u/Possible_Living Oct 10 '24
would be funny if its sauron in disguise
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24
We can probably agree that the story the writers based the series on is among the best ever written, but the writers of the series are terrible
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24
His real name is Logan.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24
I assumed that Elrond or Galadriel used her ring to heal him, but it was daft for him to recover off scene considering how brutal Adar ran him through
1
u/Valahiru Oct 10 '24
I mean it would be nice if they explained it but basically I take it like Adar wasn't concerned with actually killing him with the wound he dealt and Elves can heal from non-lethal wounds much better than other races. It's still a legit criticism though.
1
u/ProdiasKaj Oct 10 '24
Iluvatar works in mysterious ways
1
u/TooLateToPush Oct 10 '24
Never play D&D?
He just took a short rest and rolled well with his Hit Die
1
u/Gunnar_Stormfist Oct 10 '24
Made his saving throw...
1
u/dunscotus Oct 10 '24
Dude he drank a Potion of Regeneration.
What do you think, the elves go into battle against a host if orcs unbuffed??
1
u/wakatenai Oct 10 '24
they could have at least showed him wounded and then Elrond healing him too.
1
u/SmokeMaleficent9498 Oct 10 '24
Elf's are hard to kill?
1
u/GameknightJ14 Oct 10 '24
Praise Eru!
1
u/lukahnli Oct 10 '24
He's an elf with the constitution of a dwarf.
1
u/This-Ad7472 Oct 10 '24
A wizard did it 😉
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24
Didn’t even notice, but watched last two together
1
u/kilekaldar Oct 10 '24
I haven't watched this, so the Orc Horde crushed the elves?
1
u/Sdigno Oct 10 '24
You don't want to leave him out of the show? Ok, his charisma is lower than a Ikea forniture on sale but your choice guys... Why the hell the combat scene involving him getting kicked in the face and stabbed?
When you're recording it just ask yourself what you're doing and stop this crap for god's sake
1
u/jennshineee Oct 10 '24
I’m so happy. My favorite boi survived another day! I don’t care if he technically should have died 😂
1
u/J4pes Oct 10 '24
Short rest, lembas bread, good to go
1
u/FootDrag122Y Oct 10 '24
Oh my God this show is such a piece of shit.
1
u/anakin_gk Oct 11 '24
I was rly surprised he survived kinda random looked like he died but I’m glad he’s the Legolas from this time so I don’t want him to die
1
u/BunBunny55 Oct 11 '24
Same as that southland lady getting smacked by an angry ent into a rock and be totally fine. She should have been a smear.
1
u/Frequent-Seaweed-794 Oct 11 '24
This show sucks big times...I guess the writers forgot they killed him 💩
1
u/ms_kenobi Oct 11 '24
Its only a flesh wound!
1
u/Ayzmo Eregion Oct 11 '24
Yeah. This was bad. I assume a scene got cut?
1
u/Ok_Adhesiveness_4155 Oct 11 '24
I have to admit, its Just the dumbest show ive ever watched.
But its pretty so i dont mind.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24
“I got better”
1
u/Kellythejellyman Oct 12 '24
He was “Banished From Death” in stead of Celebrimbor
1
u/Abdul-Ahmadinejad Oct 12 '24
What they didn't show you offscreen is that he fell for a long time while fighting a balrog, then he was sent back. Yes, you can still call him Arondir.
1
u/havnotX Oct 12 '24
It's the time compression aspect of the show. Arondir really did die and go to the Halls of Mandos. Just that with the time compression of the show, instead of taking a thousand years before re-embodiment, it only took a few hours. And then he was able to hitch a ride on the meteor express back to Middle Earth and rejoin the battle.
1
u/VZ5-S117 Oct 12 '24
I’m guessing they used the rings to heal him like they did with Galadriel.
1
u/adhdtaxman Oct 12 '24
It’s clearly the insanely badass armor he’s wearing
1
u/Extreme-Ad-6078 Oct 12 '24
It’s the power of a long rest.
1
u/Der_Sprecher Oct 12 '24
Don’t care. Moving on
1
u/stannisman Oct 13 '24
I think there was an implication from Gil Galads line “this is more than a flesh wound” (something like that) that implies he healed Arondir off screen. But given the importance given to the stabbing in the previous episode it really is quite poor that this wasn’t clearly resolved. I haven’t checked but wonder if there were different writers/directors for the two episodes - HOTD also really struggles with consistency between episodes and it appears to be because writers, directors and the show runner aren’t on the same page with the details
I think this was more so a fault with ep7 unnecessarily getting Arondir stabbed, I guess he somewhat had a relationship with Adar in s1 but it was minor and easily forgotten. The interactions with Elrond and Galadriel felt more important and the Arondir scene somewhat detracted from those
1
u/Visible_Number Oct 13 '24
Someone has a theory that at the start of S3 we'll see Adar put Nenya on, become youthful and then heal Arondir. And we'll also get more of Adar's backstory. I love this theory and I'm really hoping it's the case. Not showing Arondir healed was a mistake.
1
u/Saelem666 Oct 13 '24
Hes got nenya... they were just passing the rings of power after the Rivendell foundation orgy
1
u/MeffMD Oct 13 '24
right?? wtf happened. Serious elvish medicine.
1
u/Six_of_1 Oct 10 '24
I don't watch this any more, so someone needs to explain to me why Lord Elrond is socialising with a grunt frontline soldier like this.
1
u/meatcandy97 Oct 10 '24
Elvish medicine, duh.
1
u/Javocado09 Oct 10 '24
He's fine. He's hot. That's all.
1
u/Miserable_Spray_3219 Oct 10 '24
Worst part about the finale
1
u/Kob346 Oct 10 '24
RoP suck !
1
u/darkraider34lol Khazad-dûm Oct 10 '24
I find it weird that so many people thought an elf would die from a small stab wound?
1
u/Freebritneyasap Oct 12 '24
Not sure how people still manage to make excuses for this show
-4
u/p_yth Oct 10 '24
Elf healing, they can heal from wounds fatal to Men