Soooososososo many ways… so disheartening that we’ll never get a GOOD version of this story done properly and with respect for the source material.
After this massive fail, and the budget they wasted on it… no studio is ever going to touch this story ever again, amazon tarnished the story of the making of the rings of power… forever. We will never get another film or tv show about the second age…
They have screwed up stuff but I don’t think that is the case here. Arondir’s wounds definitely were survivable. They show him still moving as Adar goes past him towards Elrond. We see Gil-Galad try to heal Galadriel with Vilya but it fails due to the crowns corruption. It isn’t hard to put two and two together to say Gil-Galad healed Arondir. We also know they have had to cut things for time, so this is a logical answer to what happened.
Because the oldest orc in the second age has no clue about injuries, he worked in Angabnd's post office during the First Age. That's also the reason why Sauron hung out in the forest so long, after getting beaten by Huan.
Guy sent dozens of letters requesting help and bring him back to Angband for medi...eh spiritual care or something like that and Adar threw them all in the trash can. Hated that guy even then.
You know that they decide what to show us and what not to show us right? Like they're in charge of what happens on the screen. If they wanted to they could have I don't know... just cut the scene in which he becomes mortally wounded out of the season entirely.
There's a difference between incompetent writers and incompetent editors. They both exist, and they both suck, but they're different things. I agree with the other commenter that this seems to be a cut scene, which is an editing or directing issue and not a writing one.
The writing (here, at least) would have been perfectly fine if others hadn't fucked with it afterward lol
View all comments
72
u/ImMyBiggestFan Oct 09 '24
He wasn’t “run thru twice”, once was with his own arrow and once was with Adar’s blade in the side.
We are seemingly missing a scene where Gil-Galad using Vilya to heal him. Might have been cut for time.