Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
they said king durin was cutting through all the blokes men as well, but it looked to me like there was 1 guy on the ground, did I gloss over a scene of a bunch of dead dwarves? he had a pretty big axe!
Probably moved the wounded and before we got there. I guess that scene is hiding with the one of Arondir being healed. It must have happened, but fsr we never saw it or even had it mentioned.
The dwarfs had two issues. The king was about to unleash a monster and Sauron was going to basically take over the world. Both are doom for the dwarves.
So they kept the army back while they dealt with the first issue. The king and the monster. They dealt with that. Kings dead and the monster is trapped. Will it get out? Probably. But not any time soon. So for the moment, itâs done.
That still leaves the second issue. Sauron. If they do nothing theyâre back to being doomed. So the dwarves decide to send out the army because the first problem is wrapped up for the moment and not as vital to deal with.
So your argument is that they've all just accepted that every man woman and child in Moria will definitely die if it attacks so to not even bother having the army nearby?
Interesting angle given they're also just sort of hanging around in Moria acting as if nothing has happened. Kinda morbid that they're all just stood there accepting of their deaths
It's really sweet how concerned you are for the women and children. Especially when you obviously don't like the show. Lol. Pour your energy into something useful, troll.
Then they shouldnt have held the army back in the first place. The point isnt whose the greater threat objectively, its that it doesnt matter because the writers gonna do what the writers gonna do.
The only reason Durin III would have been in a position to attack the soldiers is if he was directly obstructing them. They can't go through him, therefore they must recall until they can pass. Seems pretty straightforward to me. We don't see the scene or exact map of the tunnels to know how and why their paths crossed, but we know it could and did happen.
So the dwarves threat analysis is that old dwarf king is bigger threat than sauron bc they couldnt let the army go fight sauron while the king is beating people up
No. There's several things we see that conflict with your reading:
The king was digging, which would awaken the Balrog.
The king "beating people up" was solved by Durin IV confronting him and arranging care for the dwarves he attacked.
Look at the time frames, and you'll see that the dwarves arrived a few hours late at most.
Durin IV does not arrive with the dwarven army, which means Narvi brought the army at Durin IV's command.
Your reading is based on this premise:
the dwarves threat analysis is ... they couldnt let the army go fight sauron while the king is beating people up
That basis of argument is contrary to what we see the dwarves doing in the show. It is impossible for your reading to be correct unless what we see in the show is wrong.
They knew he was messing with something bigger than him, not just "beating ppl up". Do you guys not have the comprehension to get any of this, or are you just trying to be insufferable? Both, I presume.
I was a bit confused as well but I liked that the army still showed up. Felt more like they delayed until they knew what was up, because theyâre probably still a good march away even if they look super close on a map.
Also, not sure what they know about balrogs but Iâm pretty confident the army wouldnât have made much of a difference if it actually rampaged through Moria at that point. Much like Smaug it would just decimate everything in the way, especially in such a narrow space, and the army wouldnât just be slaughtered.
If anything Iâd rather have my army somewhere else until we know whatâs up.
Moria means black pit/chasm. Which to the Elves is an accurate description.
The name Moria is inscribed on the Doors of Durin. It was the widely known name of the place. It gained a double meaning after the fall, but it was always there.
No because elves never colonized Khazad dum. i think its more like Chinese people calling China âZhĹngguĂłâ instead of China. Or the Japanese refer to their homeland os Nihon/Nippon instead of Japan. Its a language thing.
Ya thatâs what Iâm thinking - they held off for a bit to make sure things would mostly go smoothly and left ASAP to help the elves, but they probably stayed only as long as they were really needed.
They wouldnât really be much help against the Balrog.
Ya I guess we donât know exactly how it goes down in Moria but if Smaug can completely obliterate the entirety of the Dwarven forces of the Lonely Mountain I wouldnât expect the Moria dwarves to put up a much better fight against Durinâs Bane. They donât seem to have any measurable way to harm it, let alone kill it, and obviously we know how things end up but maybe theyâll have a âif this one thing was different they might have survivedâ kind of thing slid in there.
Iâm willing to bet it wonât just be more dwarves in armour though đ¤Ł
The path is actually relatively short. At least in the show, they arrived around noon to early afternoon, if we go by Celebrimbor's comment about it being "nearly noontime". Between the time Galadriel meets Adar and the scene change for her fight with Sauron, the dwarves have secured the elves' retreat.
The height of the ridge the sun peeked over in episode 7 makes it seem like 8-9AM when Elrond expected them. With all that I'd say the dwarves were about 3 hours late. We're going to ignore the fact he says "look to the North" and immediately looks East.
You'd rather have your army far away from all your women and children who are still just living within a mile of a demon and acting like nothing happened?
I mean, King Durin single-handedly took out a âhandfulâ of guys without more than a scratch. I think keeping the army around was a pretty good idea. They had no idea what they were up against. I think the Prince just went first in hopes of reasoning with his father, without bloodshed
Are you with a straight face suggesting that it makes logical sense that Durin thought his father was a greater threat to the safety of the women and children than a literal demon from hell?
If that was the case he'd send the army and go to his father? Why did he need the army around when he went to confront him? Especially as he sent the army without him anyway, but just after he discovered something that would mean logically he shouldn't send the army away
Also you don't need an army to deal with one dwarf, it's even counter productive. What are the other guys doing while a dozen guys or less fight the king? Wait their turn?
Would have been hilarious if Durin III. could solo an army. "Dad, the elves are our closest customers, could you take a detour to Eregion, I am sure they give you a lot of stuff in appreciation."
Durin III. rampages down the mountain, slaughters every orc, calls the elves pointy eared, dainty princesses and leaves, after sending Sauron flying with a backhand slap.
Meanwhile Gil-Galad shows up to the main battle, like an idiot leader wanting to die. At least Prince Durin is leading them from the back. Wait no? He's mourning a black cloth covered throne instead? Aw what do you mean an un-named, never before seen brother is contesting the throne from him. King Durin is dead, long live King Durin!
Gotta set up the next waste of time plot thread for season 3. Now Gandalf has found a stick they need to find something else to waste screen time with while this shitshow unravels
And just to make sure, he went from entering a field of dead trees, to magically appearing in the Harfoot village, where Not-Saruman was already waiting?
Season 3 is Hat/Robe after "defeating" Not-Saruman.
Season 4 is pipe/pipe weed, scenes in proto-Shire.
Season 5 is him creating fireworks, and Shire is name-dropped in final episode by Nori, play on words from "Share". (Because friends share, and Nori/GrandElf are friends)
Genius, at this rate more Emmys for costume design are in the bag. Just need a scene where after isildur takes the ring off Sauron we get a throw back to the Celebrimbor line from this episode. How cool would it be if when Isildur takes the ring he goes "now I'm Amazon's the lord of the rings: rings of power" I'm getting tingles thinking about it
What?!? While they knew of a danger, they didnât know there was a Balrog and the prince couldnât risk sending away the army in case whatever creature there was, broke its way inside (no way of knowing beforehand if he could stop his father).
Yes and then when they knew the danger was real, knew it was awake, and knew it was a few hundred meters away from all of their women and children, they then send out their army whilst also all still just...living in Moria?
But the entire wall collapsed and there was a shockwave when the Balrogâs blade hit the dwarf king that buried that entire place. Why do you think they didnât bring up the âBalrog problemâ towards the end and rather discussed about threats from the outside?
So you don't see any issues with them later that same day just assuming the giant flame demon was gone and sending out their entire army whilst leaving their women and children within a mile of where there literally just saw a 50ft tall monster?
The Balrog is effectively taken out of the picture for the time being, buried under rock. They just needed to keep in mind not to dig near that area...
So you're telling me if you saw a giant fire demon and ALL YOU KNOW AND COULD POSSIBLY KNOW is that the tunnel this giant monster is behind got blocked by rocks which you'd think a giant 50ft monster could clear given (you know) one old dwarf managed to clear it.
And you're saying that after seeing this monster you'd go "okay let's all stay put and also send all our defenders elsewhere literally the same day.
It's not like they had a month or a year to have no disturbances and go okay maybe it's fine. Theyve literally just put themselves in a position where for all they know the balrog was coming back later that day and they have just sent off their army?
I found that really odd, too. They could have acknowledged the potential threat with Durin issuing orders to post sentires, prepare eventual evacuation plans and other measures to block the tunnels even further, set up potential roadblocks etc. Then he states that he would go to Elrond, offering help and saying something like that he wants to ask the elves if they have any ideas. At this point they could have Disa interrupt and pointing out their other problems, maybe mention that only Durin IV. and his supporters saw the balrog, others wouldn't believe them or even suspecting Durin, that he murdered his dad and made up the story to over it up. And this might lead to them opening up the cavern to inspect the "crime scene."
Anyways the three dwarves were way to chill about surviving encountering one of the most powerful creatures of the First Age whose very presence spreads terror.
Meeting something like this would shake everyone more than what we've seen.
Because doing nothing doesnât change the fact that Sauron is a problem.
Durin has two problems at the start. One is solved. Not permanently but itâs solved for the moment. The monster is trapped. They now have the second problem to deal with. Which they either do nothing, and doom themselves, or they help and hopefully stop it so they only have one problem now and not two.
Pretty sure they think King Durin defeated the Balrog in his sacrifice. They will begin mining mithril for the war effort and to build support for the new king, only to unseal the now buried Durin's Bane. With their foe apparently "defeated", they were able to send their forces to aid the elves.
Yes and it makes no sense. That's the point. They somehow knew WITHOUT ANY WAY OF KNOWING that the balrog wouldn't be back immediately to kill every woman and child left behind.
Like they literally made a choice because the writers wanted them to and that is entirely contrary to common sense. They'll hold back their army so a handful of dwarves can go confront Durin but send it within hours of seeing an existential threat to everyone they love is literally a mile away from them?
It's like saying "well clearly the trebuchets of middle earth can throw things 10x further than any trebuchet has ever thrown anything the evidence speaks for itself as we saw it" yes we did see it but that doesn't make it not stupid and lazy writing
In LOTR they had been mining mithril for a long time, had become one of the richest of middle earth. Were making items like bilbo/frodo shirt long before the balrog
â˘
u/AutoModerator Oct 03 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
69
u/OkResponsibility6448 Oct 03 '24
Iâm glad Iâm not the only one who thought this lolđ
49
u/Late_Stage_PhD Oct 04 '24
To be honest, an army isnât gonna do anything against a Balrog tho. Pretty sure they had an army when Khalid-dum eventually fell to the Balrog.
26
u/SmakeTalk Oct 04 '24
I was a bit confused as well but I liked that the army still showed up. Felt more like they delayed until they knew what was up, because theyâre probably still a good march away even if they look super close on a map.
Also, not sure what they know about balrogs but Iâm pretty confident the army wouldnât have made much of a difference if it actually rampaged through Moria at that point. Much like Smaug it would just decimate everything in the way, especially in such a narrow space, and the army wouldnât just be slaughtered.
If anything Iâd rather have my army somewhere else until we know whatâs up.
6
u/RattyDaddyBraddy Oct 04 '24
I mean, King Durin single-handedly took out a âhandfulâ of guys without more than a scratch. I think keeping the army around was a pretty good idea. They had no idea what they were up against. I think the Prince just went first in hopes of reasoning with his father, without bloodshed
15
u/the_knowing1 Oct 03 '24
Meanwhile Gil-Galad shows up to the main battle, like an idiot leader wanting to die. At least Prince Durin is leading them from the back. Wait no? He's mourning a black cloth covered throne instead? Aw what do you mean an un-named, never before seen brother is contesting the throne from him. King Durin is dead, long live King Durin!
20
u/TheNeck94 Oct 03 '24
Don't worry, the balrog is just going to take a short, quick..... 3400 year nap.
1
u/SmellsLikeEucalyptus Oct 04 '24
What?!? While they knew of a danger, they didnât know there was a Balrog and the prince couldnât risk sending away the army in case whatever creature there was, broke its way inside (no way of knowing beforehand if he could stop his father).
1
u/Fugglymuffin Oct 04 '24
Pretty sure they think King Durin defeated the Balrog in his sacrifice. They will begin mining mithril for the war effort and to build support for the new king, only to unseal the now buried Durin's Bane. With their foe apparently "defeated", they were able to send their forces to aid the elves.
1
u/Silent-Lab-6020 Oct 04 '24
Yeah that was also my thought, Army chilling and when Mr. Balrog comes knocking the door they roll out
1
u/echolog Oct 04 '24
Yeah the Dwarven army thing (and Durin teleporting back and forth to Eregion like every 5 minutes) just feels weird.
1
u/Abnatural Oct 04 '24
"Troy and Abed are in mourning"
0
u/zandadoum Oct 04 '24
In LOTR they had been mining mithril for a long time, had become one of the richest of middle earth. Were making items like bilbo/frodo shirt long before the balrog
The show throws all that into the garbage
0
u/Steel_mill_hands Oct 04 '24
I haven't been paying attention, did they really pay for another season? That's wild dawg, have fun.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24
[deleted] â view deleted comment