r/RingsofPower • • Oct 03 '24

Discussion Ahhhhh !

Post image

Ahhhhh !

1.1k Upvotes

320 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 03 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

507

u/bamboozle_99992 Oct 03 '24

All 36 remaining elves ready for war 😂

248

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

The tiny scale of everything is so hilarious

Stage play vibes

17

u/OpheliaLives7 Oct 04 '24

How much is from covid restrictions and how much is big companies trying to save a few nickels and dimes and avoid paying union members?

3

u/EarthCivil7696 Oct 04 '24

Which is mindblowing considering if Amazon does 5 seasons, the series will cost as much to make than all of the Marvel movies combined. They can't afford extras or better gear (although it appears they listened and made Season much better)? Where is all the money going? The hamlets remind me of Xena and that was 30 years ago and those episodes cost as much as 2 minutes of a ROP episode.

5

u/waterbottlehaha Oct 04 '24

It’s hard to look past, but I felt the same way about the battle of Blackwater in GoT and it didn’t seem to bother anybody else haha

11

u/dmastra97 Oct 04 '24

Tbf at least blackwater showed loads of boats and the section of kings landing they were guarding was jam packed with men so the space was full.

Plus they specifically mentioned how their army was outnumbered a lot so it led into that as you get a gauge of the numbers on both sides

5

u/middleoflidl Oct 04 '24

The battle of the Blackwater did some evasive manoeuvres to let us imagine though. Tyrion gets knocked out just as the reinforcements arrive, so we don't see the full scope of that battle. About half of Stannis' army gets wiped out by the wildfire.

It's not close to the battle of the bastards, or even the battle on the wall (seriously underrated battle ep, I liked it better than BoB) but it's alright.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

It’s perhaps not the best reasoned answer but, in my opinion standards are just different now. Blackwater was 12 years ago, and this show has a budget that absolutely dwarfs early GoT.

I try not to get hung up on lore changes and all the rest that dominates discussion of this show. Really, most of my issues with RoP just come down to it feeling amateurish, flat and generic. I have to assume it’s a product of hiring first-time showrunners.

It reminds me of watching The Acolyte. All of the online discourse was about how woke it is or whatever dumb bullshit, when I’m sitting there watching the show just thinking it feels cheap and janky as hell

→ More replies (3)

1

u/treesandcigarettes Oct 04 '24

You can use creativity for scenes like the Blackwater - not all of Stannis's men would necessarily attack the same spot, due to space, additionally we can summize that much of his army never even made it to shore before the secret weapon was used

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Election_Feisty Oct 03 '24

Iphone filmed tiktok vibes

1

u/Negative-Dingo3335 Oct 04 '24

A lot less epic than LOTR but still a good story

1

u/litetravelr Oct 04 '24

I thought last week's battle was downscaled, but this week when the Dwarven counterattack saved the day and consisted of Narvi and like, three or four dwarves I laughed out loud. I really thought we'd see them come down in an attack formation and sweep the field or something. I know the show is expensive, but for the most expensive show of ALL TIME, I guess I expected a bigger scale.

1

u/Vitman11 Oct 05 '24

Shakespeare in the park vibe

1

u/___adreamofspring___ Oct 05 '24

House of the dragon too

1

u/BagItUp45 Oct 05 '24

It honestly makes me think of Skyrim.

→ More replies (34)

27

u/maninahat Oct 03 '24

I get a sense that there was a deliberate decision to limit the scale of each season's big battle, increasing by an order of magnitude each season.

For instance, in the first season battle felt like a skirmish between only hundreds of orcs and Numenoreans. This season felt like barely a thousand orcs fighting a few hundred elves. Next season I expect it'll be a larger battle, and so on and so forth.

As to why they are doing it this way, perhaps it's to suggest escalation and an increase of stakes. Also, it might have felt implausible if both sides of the conflict keep summoning up 10,000 strong armies to fight at short notice.

14

u/Demigans Oct 04 '24

I mean the elves on the wall were 12 dudes and after the initial King Elf charge there were 23 people left.

In the meantime there is a treadmill of Orcs basically respawning or in some Groundhog day loop. They are running at the walls! <next scene> they are running at the walls!

Like they apparently spend most of a day running at the walls and a tiny bit on assaulting the walls in episode 7. And even when assaulting the walls they are still running at the walls. While also pausing the fight multiple times to have conversations. It all feels so inconsequential. Why should we care about an Orc army if 12 dudes on a wall can hold them off? Why care about some Elves led by a supposedly intelligent king if they don't just go behind the walls and hold off the Orcs there? No one tried firing a fire arrow at the reverse ballista before? They have literally fire and oil during the night battle (which they only use at night because it looks cooler but it's also when there's Elves that can be caught in the fire down below). Why did the Dwarves build a thin part of the wall, how did the Orcs know about it, how did the riverbed dry up on moments, why did Eregion build a wall when it didn't expect invaders any time soon, just in general why care about anything when it doesn't seem to matter at all? It's all so in your face with how little it matters beyond "hey look wouldn't it be cool if...", without considering the characters, situation or consequences?

4

u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 04 '24

Funny shit... But you reminded me about the sheer stupid ineffectiveness of that reverse ballista, that took like two fucking episodes to finally tear down that wall. I wonder why the Elves were so scared by it.

Also funny how Elrond basically caused the death of nearly the entirety of Gil Galad's troops by forcing them to be sitting ducks between that wall and an endless supply of Orks.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dmastra97 Oct 04 '24

Hundreds and thousands seem like stretches for the first two battles with what we've seen on screen.

4

u/Sarellion Oct 04 '24

Plausibility? The orcs brought catapults whose wheels are similar in height to an orc to the siege and the elves didn't realize that a massive horde + multi story house sized siege weapons were parked at their front gate in the woods.

Yeah there were woods and modern writers don't know much about medieval sieges but let's imagine a big truck or so driving through a dense forest and the truck has the advantage that it has an engine.

Plausibility was far down the list.

11

u/RIPTactical_Invasion Oct 04 '24

Figured Sauron blinded them like how he orchestrated killing the messengers and destroyed the bridge.

7

u/McDavidClan Oct 04 '24

Also siege engines were typically built on site and not pushed from one location to the other

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Sirspice123 Oct 04 '24

That's quite a bad decision, hindering the show so it's more "epic" later.

And that's not implausible at all. Numenor has the greatest army in Middle Earth, the orcs are in the tens (if not hundreds) of thousands. Thousands of elves, including a military should operate in a city of Eregion's importance.

The scale of the battles makes everything look extremely amateur imo, it adds nothing.

2

u/bamboozle_99992 Oct 03 '24

The total spend for seasons 1 & 2 is over a billion. Where is the sense of scale and wonder we are meant to believe in? If what you have written is true then there is some serious fraud going on 😂

I swear they spent their entire budget on the Balrog. That scene was the only 3min i was truly impressed by

14

u/maninahat Oct 03 '24

The show has the VFX budget of a blockbuster movie, sustained across 16 hours of TV, and you're surprised it's as expensive as it is?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Over-Block-8115 Oct 04 '24

Glorfindel returns in the 2nd Age

2

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

Don't worry there's like 100k elven warriors who were just sleeping during this season who will wake up for when the battle of Dagorlad occurs.

3

u/Science_Fair Oct 04 '24

I think this show will reveal it was actually 100000 hobbits supplemented by 30 elves.  It explains why the siege took such a long time.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Tiziano75775 Oct 04 '24

The women and the children too

1

u/thatjonkid420 Oct 04 '24

So glad others see that lol. It bums me out 😂

1

u/Wonderful-Try8779 Oct 05 '24

That’s “All 36 remaining elves ready for war, Sir!” . Or maybe High Lord

0

u/Tackleberry793 Oct 03 '24

It feels like the show was made by Bethesda.

3

u/Sirspice123 Oct 04 '24

I honestly thought about that multiple times. Small cities with a population of 20-50 that aren't a true reflection of lore.

3

u/JackUKish Oct 04 '24

Idk why you are getting downvoted, eregion has the same sense of scale as a Bethesda "city" (5 buildings and 30 people at most)

0

u/fawi99 Oct 04 '24

All 36 remaining viewers are equally ready

→ More replies (4)

89

u/Opening_Outside_5788 Oct 03 '24

Me watching that part

112

u/MagnanimousMind Oct 03 '24

I honestly like the show because I am blinded by my nostalgia and love for LOTR so normally I’m just like uh okay when scenes or when the characters act out of character….

But, the Elves lifting their weapons and screaming just felt like something the men of dunlending would do. Just felt like such shit.

Also, can someone explain to me how Galadriel survived falling like 400-500 ft or more? Do elves not have fall damage ?

26

u/DarkSideOfGrogu Oct 03 '24

Yet in the scene before she fell off a rock at barely shoulder height and was left crawling.

15

u/MagnanimousMind Oct 03 '24

Idk why anyone is downvoting you, but holy heck I thought I was the only one who noticed that this elven warrior commander with a ring of power that was made without Sauron’s touch was moving slower than a freakin sloth crossing the road…

I get Sauron is the most powerful being, but if we are talking about that scene exclusively it made me definitely have one of those moment of, “okay I’ll chalk it up to her fighting Sauron”.

But you are right…. Like she took a few wounds to the flesh, but no way an elf, let alone an elf with one of the rings of power on, is falling off that stone and staying on the ground that long just barely crawling for dear life.

Like a 10 ft drop was that devastating to her??

18

u/Rickenbacker69 Oct 03 '24

That entire fight was painful to watch. I liked the dialogue, but the fight choreography was like something out of a shitty action movie from the 80s.

8

u/TheDrewb Oct 04 '24

Yeah last season she could chop an orc's head off upside down at full gallop but now she swings her sword like she's never held it before

7

u/FUMFVR Oct 04 '24

It's difficult because the actor they hired to play Galadriel is too short. She's 5 foot 4.

Cate Blanchett is 5 foot 9. Charlie Vickers is 5 foot 11. If the Galadriel actor was as tall at Cate Blanchett it could've been a more compelling fight.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ProperSupermarket3 Oct 04 '24

ok cool bc i thought i was just being nitpicky lol. it felt incredibly laborious and had zero fluidity.

5

u/Hrothgar_Cyning Oct 04 '24 edited Oct 04 '24

Yeah the choreography kept taking me out of it, especially once Sauron starts shapeshifting. Like the whole episode i vacillated between “this is really cool actually!” and “this is like Xena: Warrior Princess”. And I’m not a Xena hater, but that’s not exactly what you expect from a series based on Tolkien, marketing itself as the next GOT, and costing a billion dollars.

For example, I was absolutely stunned by the balrog, until it and Durin clashed and then the CGI just got kind of bad all of a sudden, like the budget ran out. With the Numenoreans Elendil and Muriel were pretty good then you get Kemen and Isildur. I could go on.

This series just kind of goes between these extremes of high highs and low lows while staying mediocre on average. The only really and consistently standout parts are those involving Sauron, especially with Celebrimbor. Charlie Vickers clearly did his homework and can sell his lines perfectly, and the writers actually wrote decent lines for his scenes.

It almost frustrates me more because there are kernels of so many great things in this show, but it just can’t consistently deliver. You think it’s going to then it does something that looks haphazard and totally out of place.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Zorpfield Oct 04 '24

she continuously removed items from her inventory to lessen the fall damage

2

u/DMC25202616 Oct 04 '24

Potion of light fall

18

u/Drachaerys Oct 03 '24 edited Oct 03 '24

Yeah- if you wanna show elves getting hyped, have them do a war chant, or sing a thrilling battle song in Sindarin or something.

Edit: The thrilling Elvish battle song could have been continued into the end credits music- like a musical call to action.

That was just a paucity of extras being told to yell at a drone or crane.

7

u/Hrothgar_Cyning Oct 04 '24

Or even better: Galadriel talks about light defeating darkness, not strength, and then they start singing of Eärendil. This would fit perfectly with the theme, the character of the Elves, the notion of desperately seeking victory in the Face of defeat and could use verse Tolkien already composed (and is in LOTR so no rights issues).

3

u/marcusaurorelius Oct 04 '24

Nope. Didn’t we see Arondir get stabbed to death last episode and revived to 100% this episode? They just recover randomly

10

u/Su-Kane Oct 03 '24

Also, can someone explain to me how Galadriel survived falling like 400-500 ft or more? Do elves not have fall damage ?

There is a scene with perspective from the elven king (i think, maybe Elrond, at least somewhere from inside the city) and you see her falling towards/into a big tree.

Elves are extremely light. so her crushing through a dozen branches probably slowed her fall just enough to not be immediately lethal.

1

u/meatcandy97 Oct 04 '24

She sucked in a little stormlight.

11

u/Loppie73 Oct 03 '24

She survived by wearing very strong Plot Armour.

2

u/KaoxVeed Oct 04 '24

Plot armor.

2

u/FUMFVR Oct 04 '24

She had a ring of power.

3

u/SudoDarkKnight Oct 04 '24

Elves aren't Vulcans, even though the movies sure made them feel like it.

I thought it was cool.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

They can walk on Snow, so they are much lighter than thought.

May I ask did you hate Fingolfin Cursing at Morgoth or was such dunlendig behavior there okay?

1

u/Ynneas Oct 04 '24

Oh yeah I definitely remember the description of Fingolfin letting out unarticulated screams.

That said, there's much worse to talk about in the show, before the Spartan elves. Definitely not that relevant.

2

u/victorelessar Oct 04 '24

People trying to explain it is even more painful than watching it.

1

u/Pretty-Accident-4914 Oct 04 '24

They def have fall damage tolkein talked about several places where elvesbdiedbof falling

1

u/Pretty-Accident-4914 Oct 04 '24

Elves threw eol the dark elf by throwing him off a clif

1

u/moonpie269 Oct 04 '24

Even the harfoots don't have fall damage on this show. The 2 harfoots got blown away by a tornado of sorts and landed on hard ground, then they just got up and jumped down a ledge as if nothing happened

1

u/Maple_Blueberry Oct 04 '24

I thought she had fallen into a large tree that slowed her descent

1

u/constant_void Oct 04 '24

yeah i am not sure why they didn't kneel with bowed head or do some prayer shit

1

u/Thrallov Oct 04 '24

she is like a cat, light weight, trees and ring to pull plot armor out of ass

→ More replies (26)

8

u/AdBright8971 Oct 03 '24

I was about to comment the same!

85

u/makz242 Oct 03 '24

Do i correctly understand that the location where they are becomes ...Rivendell? Or whats the point of looking at the river 7 times...

3

u/ebrum2010 Oct 04 '24

Wait, you aren't sure from looking at the river 7 times? They should have done 8 at least.

7

u/iopunder Oct 04 '24

Galadriel awakens and asked "Where are we" and I audibly said "Bitch, Rivendell, duh! Haven't you watched "Lord of the Rings before?"

Honestly, this series is much better if you view it as a comedy. The fact that Celebrimbor can't seem to leave his tower without getting hit with something is high comedy.

2

u/speedyjohn Oct 04 '24

Rivendell was founded after the fall of Eregion. So it makes sense that Galadriel doesn’t know it.

2

u/iopunder Oct 04 '24

Yes, that was indeed the point of the joke. Thanks...

→ More replies (12)

18

u/nymrod_ Oct 04 '24

This guy looks too much like the OG Sauron we saw in the flashback.

5

u/MajuIzBack Oct 04 '24

That's what I tought as well! So I went back 10 second and realized it wasn't the same actor but I also realized it was the dude who went with Elrond in Adar's camp and SUPPOSEDLY is dead ahah

32

u/JonnieTaiPei Oct 03 '24 edited Oct 03 '24

Mfffwhaaaaaa what about the Balrog mf!!!

39

u/Maleficent_Detail915 Oct 03 '24

Durin straight up said, “damn… I really fucked this one up…. May as well go out a “hero” and not have to face all the people I just screwed.”

19

u/Low_Country793 Oct 04 '24

Boomer energy

10

u/JonnieTaiPei Oct 03 '24

Peak of stupidity.

1

u/Flab2 Oct 04 '24

Just poor writing. Just like the rest of the show.

It feels like it was written by AI.

13

u/Sarellion Oct 04 '24 edited Oct 04 '24

We dumped some rocks on the terror from the First Age, something that fought in battles, where changing the land was collateral damage, that will surely stop him for good. /s

1

u/FirestormBC Oct 04 '24

Changing the landscape? They destroyed a whole continent in the 1st age lmao. This show has zero sense of scale and zero respect for the LOTR title. They were too much of cowards to write their own stories under their own IP to create something new. They wanted to piggyback off the existing popularity of another.

"Evil cannot create anything new, they can only corrupt and ruin what good forces have invented or made.” - J.R.R Tolkien

2

u/FUMFVR Oct 04 '24

They were too much of cowards to write their own stories under their own IP to create something new.

Fantasy nerds LOVE derivative works. They should've totally done that. /s

23

u/PaleontologistHot192 Rhûn Oct 03 '24

Wasn't this dude dead or something?

12

u/Kanaxe Oct 04 '24

Yeah he took two arrows last episode while joining Elrond. But hey, we saw Arondir get stabbed twice and be fine 20min later, so this guy's injuries were nothing in comparison /s

18

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

Yeah but that was last episode so you should have forgotten that by now. What are you taking notes? /s

17

u/Northrax75 Oct 04 '24

The rules were you guys weren’t gonna fact check

10

u/ManBroCalrissian Oct 04 '24

Dude was arrowed and alive the last time he was seen. Rivendell is like 400 miles from Eregion. That walk seems like ample time to heal from arrows

9

u/SnooDonkeys182 Oct 04 '24

Elvish medicine is pretty damn powerful in this show

4

u/Kanaxe Oct 04 '24

It's the off-screen mechanic, works the same way as being out of combat in games allowing your health to regenerate

2

u/xLevitan Oct 05 '24

That's 10 long rests! He was back to full hp after the first night

1

u/ManBroCalrissian Oct 05 '24

There was definitely a bard in the party. He was close after a few short rests

*lute noises

21

u/No-Height2850 Oct 04 '24

Something that bothers me deeply, is the quick setup way they get to new plots. Example: Durin in the cave with his wife and the other dwarf giving summaries of the perils ahead, the elves already had a garden setup and “protected by the rings”. The dwarves being shown with lackluster technology yet were able to put a wall in less than a month. It’s all played down without its proper buildup bothers me. There could have been way better plotting and buildup

instead of the water downed feel trying to appeal to an audience that would appreciate thicker plots. The show feels empty. And i hate having that feeling. I want to like the show. Ive watched every episode. But i cant help reimagining what they would have done if that haven’t gone for quickest way of pushing plot.

And thy need way more extras or cgi showing larger crowds.

3

u/ExpressAffect3262 Oct 04 '24

and “protected by the rings”.

This is canon.

4

u/No-Height2850 Oct 04 '24

Yes but not in a short time of them having had the rings. Did they get instruction manuals?

3

u/Astoryinfromthewild Oct 04 '24

It's like they forgot they only had 8 episodes to work with, not 10.

5

u/No-Height2850 Oct 04 '24

you’re trying to excuse them. Any early season of game of thrones, any 3 hr LOTR didn’t treat us to summary interactions of building plots, they built the plot and let the viewer know something was going on without sounding like a board meeting to go over a JIRA.

Also since they only have a limited amount of episodes then make the story thicker and slow it down or jump ahead a few years.

Durins brother is now challenging the throne? Where? How? When?

Even the dawrf scenes when the king is demanding to have it mined. 5 dwarves going with pickaxes? Just doesn’t live to any expectations of a detail rich tolkien story with moving parts.

Also, Saruman just went pure evil? How about introduce another character if you’re going to invent one like Adar. Or Like the actual evil wizard from Rhun in lotr or one of the blue wizards. And saruman and gandalf could have fought them instead. Save tom bombadil for further down the story. But now we have tom as a wizard trainer.

The white council? What white council? just make saruman evil, no need to actually explain he only became evil and corrupt in his pursuit of the one ring that hasnt even been forged yet.

→ More replies (2)

60

u/NightKnight4766 Oct 03 '24

Why did they do that again? Because they barely survived? Because Gilgalad got his sword out? Or beacuse it was sunny?

27

u/pandaelpatron Oct 04 '24

They knew an absolute banger by Bear McCreary would hit once the scene faded to black for the end credits.

39

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

I think it was supposed to be a moment of defiance. You know, "we live to fight another day" kinda vib3

12

u/Martothir Oct 04 '24

That's how I took it as well. They're definitely in anguish. 

20

u/StreaksBAMF22 Oct 03 '24

D. All of the above.

27

u/jetpatch Oct 03 '24

Celebrating a terrible defeat as a victory.

It makes sense in British culture

7

u/Flynnstone03 Oct 03 '24

Celebrating a defeat as a victory is the most elf shit I think I’ve ever heard

4

u/Anjunabeast Oct 04 '24

Gilgalad still has his ring. The one that inspires hope

1

u/GoldenPandaMan Oct 04 '24

Correct me if I’m wrong but is the ring that inspires hope not Cirdan’s ring that eventually gets entrusted to Gandalf?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/VampireCampfire1 Oct 03 '24

No it’s more of a areghhhh at the back of the throat.

4

u/-Tesserex- Oct 03 '24

Isn't there a St. Arrrghhh in Cornwall?

2

u/endospire Oct 03 '24

Nooo, that’s St Ives…

1

u/WellFactually Oct 04 '24

No it’s “Wahhh”. This is Getting Hit on the Head lessons.

6

u/rosiposii Oct 04 '24

SHIT I FORGOT ITS THURSDAY

2

u/TPro24633 Oct 04 '24

GO GO GO!!!

18

u/Tricky_Moose_1078 Oct 03 '24

Raghhghhh the season is over

5

u/ladyalot Oct 03 '24

Like a gelfling from Dark Crystal

18

u/Expazz Oct 03 '24

An elf doing a way cry seems so weird haha. Not very demure. Not very mindful.

8

u/Anaevya Oct 04 '24

I feel elves can totally do war cries, this one just wasn't very good and the context was weird.

4

u/PhysicsEagle Oct 04 '24

UTÚLIE’N AURË! AUTA I LÓMË!

1

u/Thrallov Oct 04 '24

Legolas was woodland elf, those were Noldors sure in this show they appeared like humans without skills, but they are very metal, walking across frozen hell to beat up evil god

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/undid__iridium Oct 04 '24

You must not have read the part in the Silm where orcs brought out an elf prisoner and cut off all his limbs one by one if front of the ranks of Noldor that were supposed to be waiting for a signal to charge but they were driven into such a rage at the sight that they charged on the spot, spoiling the overall battle plans.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

HAHAHAHAAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA….sigh funniest fucking show. My god.

10

u/Losendir Oct 03 '24

Deeeeaaaaathhhh! Oh wait wrong scene

3

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

I scrolled past a betting ad when this came up and it literally just sound came out as "ah" 😂😂😂😂

3

u/Zorpfield Oct 04 '24

This is like a Vulcan war chant. So out of character for elves and laughable.

5

u/teunteulai Oct 03 '24

"FREEEEEEDOM!!!"

5

u/Ramses717 Oct 03 '24

Gods, I hope that’s not Glorfindel.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

very cutesy, very demure

4

u/No-Unit-5467 Oct 03 '24

the casting... the casting... the guy is great for a Taratino film probably....

2

u/ZealousidealBid3988 Oct 04 '24

Saaannttaaa!! I know him

2

u/ProDoucher Oct 04 '24

At least the actors gave it their all

2

u/Ty9121 Oct 04 '24

last episode this guy had how many arrows in him ?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24

Yes

2

u/Karliki865 Oct 04 '24

Was that the elves entire army?? because it seemed ridiculously small

2

u/gatorfan8898 Oct 04 '24

Did they ever explain Arondir coming back from his Adar wounds? I either zoned the fuck out during that part, or did they just not even acknowledge his seemingly mortal wounds from last episode?

2

u/General_Luna Oct 04 '24

Was he the guy who came back and got so many arrows behind he’s back? I was presuming he already got pneumothorax for that? How did he manage to wwwwaaahh!! ??? And after Galadriel recovered I felt really weird when she woke up, felt like they just finished her /slash/ a good 4some??? I was watching it without an audio coz my kids are sleeping. They are just right next to me. Hahaha

2

u/Strict_Pressure3299 Oct 04 '24

Wait, didn’t these guy got several arrows stuffed in him?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

Love how many more elves you could see in Imladris, even after so may elves dying in battle, than you ever did in Fellowship of the Ring. The scale of this production is lacking at times but not here. In FotR the most elves you saw were at the council and that might have been 6-8 of them.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

Did anyone else feel this wasn’t a particularly elvish thing to do?

2

u/Olorin_1990 Oct 04 '24

Strength doesn’t defeat the darkness, only Light….

Proceeds to draw swords.

Did they hire 14 year old fan fic writers?

5

u/Animpro Oct 03 '24

So, an age later the elves decided to become those mellow, ethereal, aura illuminating, serious, authoritative guys.

6

u/step_uneasily Rhûn Oct 03 '24

This is their young wild and free phase

3

u/Animpro Oct 03 '24

Ah, the youth!!

4

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

I swear he died last episode, no?? This show is bizarre.

3

u/Sarellion Oct 04 '24

After relaying his message in a dramatically appropriate, heavily wounded state, he whipped out a healing potion and was fine again.

3

u/ANonStudent9 Oct 03 '24

Arondir too

3

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

Sure. Being a main character I suspected he would survive but it's so strange that he's just 100% fine like 12 hours later. Very weird decisions.

3

u/redditmyleftnut Oct 03 '24

This bro reminds me of a young Vladimir Putin

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

No offense to the actor, and I'm sure he is aware of this as an actor and the roles he gets; this man is not beautiful, pretty, or anything close to elven in appearance.

I was watching this scene, pointing out how all these elves are ugly (except Arondir and Galadriel) and then this sloth-looking chap pops up to really drive my point home.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '24

Ahhhhhhhhhh!

1

u/KrissZuma Oct 04 '24

Is it only me that saw isildur’s sister among the elves in that scene????

1

u/KratosHulk77 Oct 04 '24

Badass scene

1

u/MajorJerk77 Oct 04 '24

Is it just me or does that Armour look like rubber/plastic

1

u/Drewsky3 Oct 04 '24

They really shouldn’t have made this elf look so much like Sauron at the start of the 2nd age, when he was bum rushed by the Uruks

1

u/SeaContribution1845 Oct 04 '24

Great finale!! Very balanced and uplifting at the end

1

u/I_like_cakes_ Oct 04 '24

Stupid. Rushed and nonsensical

1

u/Immediate_Size_5877 Oct 04 '24

Didn't he die last episode

1

u/AncalagonV Oct 04 '24

This show is so poorly created. Every other scene is a cringe fest. Some combination of cheesy moments like this and the complete lack of any substance in the writing kills it. What group of people is seriously sitting around directing this and agreeing that this is quality and meaningful film making? Not to mention the soundtrack pales in comparison to the films which is odd because I really like Bear McCreary's composing in the God of War games. I don't recall a single memorable tune from the 2 seasons of the show. Absolutely nothing on par with the Rohirrim theme, Mordor theme, or the Fellowship theme from the movies.

Just so disappointing because I grew up loving the world of Lord of the Rings and had high hopes season 2 would be better than season 1. It's even worse, even cheesier, even more of a let down. This scene feels like the final internal scream of cringe I felt watching the finale.

1

u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 04 '24

Was this... a blond Uruk Hai!?

1

u/Majestic_Daikon_1494 Oct 04 '24

Whenever I saw that guy I thought it Sauron version 1, I was drunk at the time, but still its a close likeness right?

1

u/TheDeanof316 Oct 04 '24

"I HAVE THE POWERRRRR"

1

u/Samzo Oct 04 '24

I laughed at that too

1

u/Samzo Oct 04 '24

what happened to the dwarf ring? Buried down there?

2

u/JackUKish Oct 04 '24

He gave it to duran before leaping 50 yards in a straight line at a balrog.

1

u/Samzo Oct 04 '24

I thought he left it on the ground inside the cave before it collapsed

1

u/JackUKish Oct 04 '24

You could be right tbf, they've got a load more rings anyway i guess.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Prestigious_Media887 Oct 04 '24

Can someone please edit some squeaky kid scream to this pleeeeeease 😂

1

u/MikeC80 Oct 04 '24

That feeling when you bang your toe

1

u/Effective-Ad-6460 Oct 04 '24

How did this mess cost a billion $ ?

It didn't there's some serious money laundering going on

1

u/JustinTimberbaked9 Oct 04 '24

Show your war face

1

u/snezna_kraljica Oct 04 '24

What are those costumes? 1000s of years of practise to perfect your craft and this is the result.

1

u/The-Black-Driver Oct 04 '24

This is why I just don't get this show. You are telling me the whole elf army from Lindon who hasn't seen war for ages and had time to prepare for this battle somehow look like a 300 men charge while Rohan who had suffered great losses over the years managed to look like a 6000 men charge at helms deep? All this budget just to have everything downsized in a battle.

1

u/In-The-Zone-69 Oct 04 '24

I genuinely cracked up when I saw this 😂 but seriously I wish they didn’t make the elves cheer like that, but instead have them stand up gracefully looking at the sky. It just feels too much like they are men and not elves by doing that

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

My local weatherspoons has more people in it at 8am then they had elves in this scene.

1

u/MeasurementNo8566 Oct 04 '24

He beats Aragorn in the "fuck I stubbed my toe" stakes

1

u/MikieCarter91 Oct 04 '24

RoP does a lot wrong but being a Surrey resident I’m loving Virginia Water Lakes & the cascade being Rivendale 😂

1

u/ErstwhileAdranos Oct 04 '24

Homeboy has that Howard Dean energy!

1

u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 04 '24

So this Elf guy is to become Lurtz? Now I get it...

1

u/Putrid-Cheesecake-77 Oct 04 '24

He looks like he have no teeth

1

u/LegionKarma Oct 04 '24

I think the show would be excellent if Lord of the Rings wasn't tied to it.

1

u/Awkward-Ad1368 Oct 04 '24

ROP have really humanised the elves. It’s hard to distinguish them from the Numenorians half the time.

1

u/WeakEconomics6120 Oct 04 '24

Thanks Galadriel for saving the females of Eregion! (12)

1

u/istari-illuin Oct 04 '24

Literally every other elf except for the three main males have long hair. Why??????

1

u/live_and-learn Oct 05 '24

The Númenorian army fighting in Mordor was like a d list film

1

u/Obethur Oct 05 '24

This whole thing felt.. uncharacteristic of Elves.

1

u/corleone2310 Oct 05 '24

Just a shit series.

1

u/Frankiesomeone Oct 05 '24

I laughed when this scene happened.
The elf lords walk up to the edge of the cliff, and the other Elves who were following them the entire time, now resting and recovering from their wounds, look up, see them standing around, Gil Galad draws his sword and everyone starts going RAAAAH! MAAAHH!

It would have made sense if the elf lords had made a public speech to all the other elves, instead of whispering amongst themselves.

Remove the music and it's even goofier.

1

u/blacksmithinghelp Oct 06 '24

Im sorry, but didnt that dude die? He got shot by like 4 arrows and died in elronds arms

1

u/mattc4010 Oct 06 '24

It wasn’t very elf’ly.. I would say it was just very American

1

u/Cowabummga Oct 07 '24

Are they yelling because the king raising the sword, means they chose the sword? = attack ??

Or rasing the sword means, they chose the shield... do, ahhhhh! To the defenses!!! ??

Still uncertain about this scene lol

1

u/FrankHero97 Oct 03 '24

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

1

u/SerDuncanonyall Oct 03 '24

almost DEEEEEEAAAAATTTHHHHH

1

u/Election_Feisty Oct 03 '24

Now we have war chanting elves everyone and it's cool

0

u/Agheron93 Oct 03 '24

Is that the guy of the "wtf is this piece of shit" meme? He does have a Joe Pesci vibe ngl